HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

parodysbird

201 karma · joined September 25, 2024

submissionscomments
parodysbird··on Interactive map of Paul's first century travels in Roman world
> His main privilege was that petty local rulers were more reluctant to persecute him than they would a non-citizen

It's more than that. Basically everywhere he went local commoners wanted to kill him and it was the elite local rulers that safeguarded him

parodysbird··on Interactive map of Paul's first century travels in Roman world
I chose the words carefully for that reason. The prophet of the nascent religion was a human being who was born, lived and died as a human being. Paul did not encounter this man. In his story, he encounters a divine being, and receives a private revelation (gospel) and mission that is distinct from the revelation and mission that the prophet in question gave as a human to his chosen students (apostles).

Paul is, in this terminology, also a prophet. He explicitly says the revelation he tells is not of human origin, and so not passed down to him through e.g. the ministry of one of the students (apostles) of the prophet in question.

It strikes me as unusual to have so much of the theology coming from someone who simply claims private revelation but is not the prophet in question and when the prophet explicitly chose disciples and set a ministry for them.

parodysbird··on The McPhee method for writing deeply reported nonfiction
> Even back when every household received a morning paper I cannot fathom how a single article could command such a high pay.

He wrote for the New Yorker, which is a magazine rather than a newspaper. The number of long-form literary nonfiction pieces that the New Yorker runs every year is drastically fewer than the number of news articles produced to fill a daily newspaper in just a couple weeks.

parodysbird··on Interactive map of Paul's first century travels in Roman world
I'd recommend looking into adding a speculative final journey he might have taken to Spain. He mentions plans to go there in Romans, and other sources like 1 Clement and Jerome suggest he actually went there. The city of Tarragona has a tradition that he visited, as a speculative destination to map.
parodysbird··on Interactive map of Paul's first century travels in Roman world
It is very strange the amount of theology that comes solely from Paul's idiosyncratic writings, given that he neither met the prophet in question (Jesus), nor was taught by any of his students (apostles), nor even got along particularly well with any of his students.
parodysbird··on Interactive map of Paul's first century travels in Roman world
He was also a Roman citizen, so he could pull some privileges for free rides like getting to Rome through exercising his right to appeal directly to the Emperor
parodysbird··on Measuring the environmental impact of AI inference
AGI is made-up nonsense, so it's better to phrase the hardware overhang (and anything else that is meant to refer to reality) without reference to it.
parodysbird··on GPT-4o is gone and I feel like I lost my soulmate
I think I might value a society where there are fewer people like this
parodysbird··on GPT-4o is gone and I feel like I lost my soulmate
Or that these people are not suitable to have been judges in the setup of the Turing Test... People also fall for email spam with blatant misspellings, that doesn't mean email spam passes a Turing test, it means the people falling for it are marks.
parodysbird··on The new literalism plaguing today’s movies
> movies that aspire to win academy awards, are meant to be played to the world wide lowest common denominator

That's not the kind of films that tend to win the major Oscar awards. Those tend to be either a bit artsy (e.g. Anora this year) or "serious" biopics/history movies (e.g. Oppenheimer last year).

parodysbird··on Grok is making AI companions, including a goth anime girl
That's a wild impression of what living in a city is like
parodysbird··on Why Claude's Comment Paper Is a Poor Rebuttal
The original Turing Test was one of the more interesting standards... An expert judge talks with two subjects in order to determine which is the human: one is a human who knows the point of the test, and one is machine trying to fool the judge into being no better than a coin flip at correctly choosing who was human. Allow for many judges and experience in each etc.

The brilliance of the test, which was strangely lost on Turing, is that the test is doubtful to be passed with any enduring consistency. Intelligence is actually more of a social description. Solving puzzles, playing tricky games, etc is only intelligent if we agree that the actor involved faces normal human constraints or more. We don't actually think machines fulfill that (they obviously do not, that's why we build them: to overcome our own constraints), and so this is why calculating logarithms or playing chess ultimately do not end up counting as actual intelligence when a machine does them.

parodysbird··on Claude 4
You can be inspired by anything, that's fine. Gell-mann was amusing himself and getting inspiration from Buddhism for quantum physics. It's the process of the inquiry that generates the knowledge as a discipline, rather than the personal spark for discovery.
parodysbird··on Claude 4
The thing with alchemy was not that their hypotheses were wrong (they eventually created chemistry), but that their method of secret esoteric mysticism over open inquiry was wrong.

Newton is the great example of this: he led a dual life, where in one he did science openly to a community to scrutinize, in the other he did secret alchemy in search of the philosopher's stone. History has empirically shown us which of his lives actually led to the discovery and accumulation of knowledge, and which did not.

parodysbird··on AI in my plasma physics research didn’t go the way I expected
> It’s called Quantum Mechanics.

Nobody is suggesting anything entails a possible violation of quantum mechanics, so yes, obviously any system under inquiry is assumed to abide by QM.

parodysbird··on Thoughts on thinking
How is what the same thing? Fabric production vs social communication? I don't really see what is the relation here.
parodysbird··on AI in my plasma physics research didn’t go the way I expected
> Alphafold made a breakthrough in protein folding.

Sort of. Alphafold is a prediction tool, or, alternatively framed, a hypothesis generation tool. Then you run an experiment to compare.

It doesn't represent a scientific theory, not in the sense that humans use them. It does not have anywhere near something like the accuracy rate for hypotheses to qualify as akin to the typical scientific testing paradigm. It's an incredibly powerful and efficient tool in certain contexts and used correctly in the discovery phase, but not the understanding or confirmation phase.

It's also got the usual pitfalls with differentiable neural nets. E.g. you flip one amino acid and it doesn't really provide a proper measure of impact.

Ultimately, one major prediction breakthrough is not that crazy. If we compare that to e.g. Random Forest and similar models, the impact in science is infinitely more with them.

parodysbird··on Thoughts on thinking
Oh yeah this is exactly how my group chats went. We still can post some good (in our context) memes and have fun, but not like an avalanche of poorly filtered slop. A joke for a group can still be crafted via an LLM when used judiciously and as intentionally as part of the bit. But by judicious it's important that the human is the one doing the sending and in the right moment, and so the human is still the one communicating.

When WhatsApp originally inserted their AI bot in the chats, it got very annoying very quickly and we agreed to all never invoke it again. It's just a generative spam machine without the curation.

parodysbird··on Thoughts on thinking
This is basically a contemporary reframing of the core purpose of Renaissance magic. I suppose aspiring to be a 21st century John Dee from talking to some powerful chatbot of the future, rather than angels or elemental beings, does sound a bit exciting, but it is ultimately mysticism all the same.
parodysbird··on Thoughts on thinking
To emphasize again part of the post above: "The aim of our creation is communication and mutual-transformation".

When I write a poem in a birthday card for my wife to give her on her birthday, very little of the "meaning" that will be communicated to (and more importantly with) her is really from some generic semantic interpretation of the tokens. Instead, almost all of the meaning will come from it being an actual personal expression in a shared social context.

If I didn't grasp that second part, I might actually think that asking ChatGPT to write the poem and then copying it in my handwriting to give to her is about the same thing as if the same tokens written but from genuine personal creation. Over prolonged interaction, it could lead to a shared social context in which she generally treats certain things I say as little different than if ChatGPT returned them as output. Thus the shared social context and relationship is then degenerated and fairly inhuman (or "robotic" as the above post calls it).

parodysbird··on The unusual mathematics that gives rose petals their shape
It's not pedantic, it's true, and it actually is deeply important because misunderstanding this can lead to very different beliefs about the world, science, and technology.
parodysbird··on Wikipedia: Database Download
You have bad politics. This is bad politics.
parodysbird··on AI assisted search-based research works now
Biologists, mathematicians, physicists, and philosophers are already the experts who produce the text in their domain that the LLMs might have been trained on...
parodysbird··on Jagged AGI: o3, Gemini 2.5, and everything after
And based on the actual Imitation Game in Turing's paper, we are no where close and I don't think we will be close for quite some time.
parodysbird··on A Realistic AI Timeline
It is fantasy (or more specifically, science fiction). And it's astonishing how uncritically it gets taken at face value through so much of the industry.
parodysbird··on Trump's Tariffs Wipe Out over $6T on Wall Street in Epic Two-Day Rout
Extreme combat superiority does not mean you are fighting a combat where that achieves your objectives. The reason the Taliban did not have to reckon with the full potential of the US military is because the US unleashing it's full power on them would be stupid. Your power is actually limited by the boundaries of rationality. The US (and to a lesser degree Russia) could in theory vaporize every city in any country, and kill everyone there. That's not actually a coherent goal (unless you like fantasizing about how powerful you are), and so it doesn't actually happen.

The development of nukes greatly reduced the possibilities of war between major nation states, and in the conflicts with minor states, nukes are not under consideration for use. Russia has never actually done any move with their nuclear weapon regiments to indicate using them, even though they are actively locked in a dumb war they underestimating that is costing hundreds of thousands of Russian lives. America kicked the Taliban out of power but could not keep the Taliban out of power, whether you left immediately or after 20 years. Your combat superiority doesn't mean you can defeat foreign militancies. Time and time again you have not defeated them. That is the reality. Fantasizing about unleashing the full combat superiority of the US military (nuking the entire landscape petulantly) to show that you are powerful is not a credible or coherent outcome... and lo it does not happen.

Finally, the US has waged total war since the end of WW2. Almost every substantial building in North Korea was destroyed in the Korean War. All of the dams and civilian infrastructure were entirely destroyed by US bombs. US bombers couldn't even find targets to indiscriminately bomb toward the end. And yet the US did not defeat the North Koreans.

(As a final note, DPRK started that war, not the US or its allies, so the primary objectives were inherently different and more defensive. Nonetheless, the use of total war did not achieve ultimate the victory it was aimed at.)

parodysbird··on Trump's Tariffs Wipe Out over $6T on Wall Street in Epic Two-Day Rout
America didn't lose the Iraq War to Saddam, it lost to disparate groups of Islamic jihadis who read some Mao.

Losing a war is not body counts, it's a military withdrawal after a failure to achieve objectives. It doesn't mean there are winners.

America went into Afghanistan to destroy Al-qaeda and remove the Taliban from power. At the end of the war, the Taliban were back in power and global jihadism is even stronger and more pervasive than before. That is losing a war.

Pax Americana shows that big militarized states like the US and Russia (before that USSR) do not wield the operational war power they imagine. They lose every war they start (which, again, is not to say there is a triumphant winner).

parodysbird··on Trump's Tariffs Wipe Out over $6T on Wall Street in Epic Two-Day Rout
The Dutch and Swiss are very powerful, relative to their size. You can say fantasy things like "if they were invaded tomorrow", but that's not reality.

The US has atomic weapons, but has lost almost every war it has started since having nukes. Having weapons doesn't mean you will be faced with contexts to actually use them. "Genome-targeted bioweapons" is just made up nonsense. Just making up "if" statements of fantastical capabilities that do not have grounding in reality is just that: fantasy. Living in fantasy land is how the richest nation the world has ever seen could lose a war to teenagers in Afghanistan.

parodysbird··on Dow plunges 2,200 points, Nasdaq enters bear market
> Vietnam already coming to the negotiating table, time will tell.

Oh wow you got a developing country to agree to lower their tariffs on their fairly minor import capacity from the US.

parodysbird··on Claude 3.7 Sonnet and Claude Code
So you're just doing Delphic oracle prophecy. Mysticism is not actually that helpful or useful in most discussions, even if some mystical prediction accidently ends up correct.
← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →