HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

pgeorgi

5,800 karma · joined October 4, 2011

submissionscomments
pgeorgi··on The first week of US v. Google – Defaults are everything and nobody likes Bing
I'm not sure if "outpay Google" is necessary for that. Apple and Google are competitors, in some aspects this seemed almost personal (Steve Jobs mentioned "thermonuclear war", see https://www.forbes.com/sites/ewanspence/2015/01/31/how-apple...)

Another search engine that is 90% there and can offer only 10% of payments might have been good enough (at least in a certain time frame) if it gave Apple an opportunity to snub Google.

pgeorgi··on Googlers told to avoid words like ‘share’ and ‘bundle,’ US says
The financial sector has a bunch of regulations on internal communication (mostly around retention and availability), but others don't really, so "explicitly told not to do this" seems like a misrepresentation.
pgeorgi··on Chromebooks will get 10 years of automatic updates
It's to ensure that you, the user, know when the boot process has changed substantially, and that you have a simple way to get back into familiar territory.

If you want to get rid of Chrome OS and all its user protection measures entirely, that's possible with official and relatively standardized means. The open source firmware community provides documentation and tested firmware images for that (of course: no warranty), most prominently https://mrchromebox.tech/

pgeorgi··on Chromebooks will get 10 years of automatic updates
The only one who can lock the boot process is the device owner: school/company laptops might be locked down and they might not bother resetting that.

By default it's locked-but-user-unlockable (presence test, user data removal), with various levels of trade-offs between "degrees of freedom to replace stuff" vs. "ability to recover without external hardware tools". When user and owner differ (e.g. schools or companies), the owner gets to decide.

As for source code, go wild: https://review.coreboot.org/plugins/gitiles/coreboot/+/refs/...

pgeorgi··on Chromebooks will get 10 years of automatic updates
"Certain behaviors of a corporation look very different from how they usually seem to behave" is most easily explained by:

{Google, Microsoft, Apple, Intel} is big enough so that {insert product here} operates a lot like an independent company, just with lots of automatic mind share (although that can backfire when the parent brand is devolving), access to top-tier lawyers, marketing, sales, etc people and practically infinite runway (as long as the bosses like what you do).

pgeorgi··on Oxford study proves heat pumps triumph over fossil fuels in the cold
No new nuclear power plants since 1989. Peak electricity grid contribution by nuclear power plants: ~30%, while oil and natural gas were used for heating (so replacing that with nuclear power means doubling NPP output, roughly). So Germany still would have had to increase its nuclear power plant capacity 6-fold to go all in.

Compared to France (70% from nuclear power, natural gas for heating in only ~1/3 of homes) this hardly looks like leadership.

As for the reasons: There has been a series of events where nuclear reactors weren't properly handled and where politics colluded with the operators to sweep it under the rug. No matter how safe the technology _could_ be, its management was horrendous.

One such example was a "passively safe" reactor that by now is a glowing mess for 40 years already, and will remain so for another 60-80 years before it can be dismantled: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AVR_reactor

Key quote from that Wikipedia article: "The report listed hidden or downplayed events and accidents and described serious concealed problems and wrongdoings. For example, in 1978 operators bypassed reactor shutdown controls to delay an emergency shutdown during an accident for six days."

As long as people argue about the merits of the technology, they miss the German discourse on nuclear power completely.

pgeorgi··on iPhone 15 and iPhone 15 Plus
"USB4" is really thunderbolt 3 with a few compatibility tweaks. As such, it's a very different beast from USB3 (which is much closer to the USBs that preceded it): more like "external PCIe" than "USB".
pgeorgi··on The new Polaroid I-2 instant camera
Also the 2 years mandatory warranty that needs to be priced in.
pgeorgi··on New LoRa RF distance record
It's the combination of company URL, posted by a company person, commented on by another company person pushing questions (i.e. generate engagement) that seemed weird, and feels orchestrated.

It's well possible that this was really an innocent accident, but it would have looked better if something like this engagement post was posted by the same account as the original link.

pgeorgi··on Digital Markets Act: Commission designates six gatekeepers
Dubai isn't exactly in the EU...
pgeorgi··on Internet-connected cars fail privacy and security tests conducted by Mozilla
> it wouldn't surprise me if the car refuses to operate correctly

I know of a car (Renault in EU) whose SIM access is broken somehow that still works fine, just can't call home. No guarantee that every car will handle it gracefully, but at least some regions don't seem to mandate any enforcement if that module happens to "break".

pgeorgi··on Internet-connected cars fail privacy and security tests conducted by Mozilla
I wonder if phones send out RDS (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radio_Data_System) information on the aux jack and your car happens to pick up on it.
pgeorgi··on Digital Markets Act: Commission designates six gatekeepers
Zalando objects that for everybody else users were counted, while for them it was visitors (a much looser association, they argue). The decision will sharpen DSA's profile, one way or the other.
pgeorgi··on On the 10th anniversary of the Snowden revelations
> We now know ...

> ... was likely ...

That would be "suspect", not "know"

pgeorgi··on Ask HN: I’m an FCC Commissioner proposing regulation of IoT security updates
The main issue these days is the 5GHz band that might interfere with radar. That's mostly an issue outside near an airport, that is, it affects practically nobody, so the solution is to snoop the problematic bands and disable them when detecting radar signals, and use them otherwise for a bandwidth boost.

These days this seems to be mostly done in wifi chip firmware (that is then signed and under lock and wrap to make it tamper proof), but back in the day it was too easy to circumvent the mechanism.

pgeorgi··on Build Your Own Flight Sim in C++ (1996)
C++ of 1996 predates the first ISO standard (1998) and the Boost library (1999). Back then, c++ code was still relatively readable...
pgeorgi··on UPI Payments: 10B transactions a month done, next stop 100B
> like the public blockchain

Since this thread is about an article celebrating UPI's 10B transactions/month: That means between 4133 (28 days/month) and 3733 (31 days/month) transactions per second on average.

Bitcoin is at 7 transactions per second.

The bitcoin blockchain takes ~500GB these days. At UPI's transaction volume, it'd take 250TB by now, replicated at various sites.

Whatever you think of blockchain, it has some serious work ahead.

pgeorgi··on Cesium-soaked truffles may keep fallout in an environment’s food web
> Anyway, what about the truffles and other mushrooms of that region ? For logic deduction, they should be unsafe, too.

They are: https://www.bfs.de/SharedDocs/Pressemitteilungen/BfS/DE/2023...

pgeorgi··on WAPO: Fatal Force DB
Everybody can upload a big csv to archive.org, or distribute it through Tor or BitTorrent.

None of that works for your solutions without converting to something like... CSV.

pgeorgi··on Cesium-soaked truffles may keep fallout in an environment’s food web
Green energy industries were hampered (or outright killed, like German photovoltaics, just 10 years ago), so I wouldn't say they're all alike.
pgeorgi··on Cesium-soaked truffles may keep fallout in an environment’s food web
> Anything modern simply wouldn't have.

That was the claim for the technology they developed at Jülich, too. And it does look good on paper.

Seriously, as long as you try to argue on technical merit, you're missing the point of the debate on nuclear power in Germany. It all came down to having to trust people who have demonstrated that they're not at all trustworthy.

pgeorgi··on Cesium-soaked truffles may keep fallout in an environment’s food web
The issue isn't as much as the realized damage, it's the way it's been handled. Ask the people in charge at the time and Jülich never had any issue: it's deny, deflect, deter all the way.

So we're dealing with an industry that cuts corners whenever it feels like it, and received unlimited backing of politics by sweeping incidents under the nearest rug, and trampling over communities at will (see how the Wentland region was chosen to become a permanent storage site for nuclear waste).

In such an environment at some point any statistics are meaningless, even harmful: they drive home the point that in face of the nuclear industry and its political handling, the people are just a statistic. Why should the people put up with that?

Nuclear power in Germany wasn't a technical failing (for the most part), it was politics colluding with the industry in a way that evaporated any trust.

Nuclear technology is highly regulated for good reason (enriched uranium 235 isn't simply available "over the counter", for example), which increases the amount of trust required. It wasn't any particular incident that killed nuclear power in Germany, it was the inability to act responsibly.

pgeorgi··on Cesium-soaked truffles may keep fallout in an environment’s food web
Emission limits for incinerators for waste: https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/bimschv_17_2013/BJNR10440...

Emission limits for coal power plants: https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/bimschv_13_2021/__5.html (and a few other places in that ordinance)

Some are higher, some are lower. I don't understand the rationale either, but "much stronger controls" isn't universally true.

pgeorgi··on ARM wrestles assembly language guru's domains away, citing trademark issues
> A trademark comes with legal implications.

Those would have been satisfied by a friendly "You know, we need to keep track of uses of our trademark and see that they're in line. You keynoted our conferences, your sites are valuable for our ecosystem. How about you put a trademark notice somewhere and we call it a day?"

pgeorgi··on Cesium-soaked truffles may keep fallout in an environment’s food web
The source for Germany's CO2 emissions is a pro-coal-miner stance, not an anti-nuclear position: Germany happily threw away a 120k workers strong photovoltaics industry while protecting a 40k workers strong coal mining industry.

The anti-nuclear position comes from radioactive boars and even more-so from the fuck up that is the Jülich experimental reactor, a "safe by design" system that by now took 40 years of maintenance while taking another 80 before it can be dismantled.

Politics and industry have demonstrated that they can't ensure safe nuclear operation in Germany. USSR (1986) and Japan (2011) just drove the point home that it's not a specific German failing.

(Case in point: the anti-nuclear movement in Germany started in the 1970s. Unless you believe in time travel, those big incidents at most fueled the flames)

pgeorgi··on uBlock Origin Lite now available on Firefox
At that point it would request the global "read and modify all sites" permission, which makes it kinda obvious.
pgeorgi··on Critical hearing looms in battle over California’s last nuclear power plant
At the price of continuing tensions in society and politics. NPP weren't taken down just for fun, that was a long time coming. An NPP based energy policy wouldn't have stopped building new nuclear power plants in 1989: nuclear power never provided more than 1/3 of the electricity consumption of the country and unlike France, there was never a push to go all in, e.g. by promoting electrically powered domestic heating.

The real issue is that, even though renewables saw a pretty good growth, the renewables side of the plan was to push it even harder (and expand the transmission network, and establish storage) and that fell through once a government took over which didn't care for that all.

Those plans are 25 years old now (the Social-Democrat/Green coalition was formed in 1998 and set out to implement the transition from the start) and the south is still not properly connected to the wind power resources in the north.

Germany would have had to go all-in with nuclear (and build it out by a factor of 6 or so, to also replace avoidable uses of fossils like domestic heating) or it would have had to go all-in with renewables. Instead it stumbled around indecisively.

pgeorgi··on Critical hearing looms in battle over California’s last nuclear power plant
Net exporter since 2003. Increasing renewables since 2003. If we go by cherry-picking what kind of power plant creates whose power, Germany is busy reducing everybody else's CO2 emissions, too.
pgeorgi··on Critical hearing looms in battle over California’s last nuclear power plant
Germany replaced its nuclear power plants with all kinds of things, predominantly renewables. The first NPP going offline under the "Atomausstieg" went offline in 2003.

https://www.energie.de/et/news-detailansicht/nsctrl/detail/N... has a chart showing the energy sources for electricity production in Germany (up to 2021).

During the period in which nuclear (Kernenergie) went down from ~160bn kWh (2003) to ~60bn kWh (2021), lignite (Braunkohle) went down from a bit over 150bn kWh to ~110bn kWh. Hard coal (Steinkohle) went down from ~140bn kWh to ~50bn kWh.

There has been an uptick in natural gas (Erdgas) from ~60bn kWh to ~90bn kWh, but most of it was covered by renewables (Erneuerbare), going from ~55bn kWh to ~240bn kWh.

So no, nuclear power wasn't replaced with coal.

There has been an increase in coal to replace natural gas in 2022 (not on this chart) when the gas market imploded following russia's full-scale invasion in Ukraine, but that was more of a temporary measure. With the LNG terminals going online, that will be sorted out soon enough, and measures to increase the build out of renewables to get rid of all fossils (_and_ nuclear) were planned even before 2022.

Germany just had the problem that after a coalition government including the Greens until 2005, the conservative-led coalitions for the next 16 years didn't dare to reopen the snake pit that is nuclear power (it was a conservative government that ended new build out of nuclear power plants in 1989, too) but at the same time hampered the renewables build out - apparently they have some weird infatuation with burning fossils.

pgeorgi··on Critical hearing looms in battle over California’s last nuclear power plant
> If not for the decision of German public to shut down their nuclear reactors, Putin would have never had that much money to start the war.

55% of natural gas that circulated in Germany in 2021 came from russia. 48% of natural gas that circulated in Germany in 2021 was exported to other countries. ~13% of natural gas in Germany that year was used for electricity production.

But go on and tell us how keeping nuclear power on in Germany would have cut those natural gas exports, heated the 14 million domestic gas boilers, or produced fertilizer.

← PreviousPage 8 of 34Next →