HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

piannucci

342 karma · joined October 3, 2014

submissionscomments
piannucci··on Scientists create their own GPS by spying on internet satellites
1. Dunno, but they’re working in MATLAB.

2. I would not expect that to work very well without an IMU, but you can do some pretty remarkably good odometry using wheel rotations, vision, and/or automotive radar if you’re dead set against using an IMU.

3. I think they were measuring instantaneous Doppler and integrating to get phase. They only looked in a 1 MHz passband, and they didn’t have a very directional antenna, so they must have been acquiring something pretty narrow-band compared to the full downlink packets.

piannucci··on Scientists create their own GPS by spying on internet satellites
Yeah, I think they said they used the TLEs. There are better ephemerides posted by SpaceX on space-track.org under contract w/ the govt, who doesn’t really want to be responsible for tracking all those objects.
piannucci··on Scientists create their own GPS by spying on internet satellites
I was in the audience for these presentations last week, and I sat down with Neinavaie and Khalife for a couple hours to discuss their work. I’m also engaged in very similar research myself, which I presented at the same conference.

So... not directly affiliated with the original authors, but very familiar with the work. Can I answer any questions people might have?

piannucci··on MIT CSAIL network design principles
No kidding. My potted Schlumbergera got nibbled by a mouse on the 9th floor. :-( I'd been nursing that plant back to health for years.

This wasn't a regular occurrence up that high, but still.

piannucci··on Electromagnetism is a property of spacetime itself, study finds
Yeah, I think so too. While the authors might attempt to counter that they are only describing EM in vacuum, the fact is that GR is nonlinear. You can’t just add an EM sector by a rank-1 metric component and expect linearity to apply.

At some level, this feels like a vacuous result. If you start with a rank-2 massless field theory, and constrain it to act on rank-1 fields, is it surprising that you get a rank-1 massless field theory? Is this not just an elaborate form of completing the square?

piannucci··on Electromagnetism is a property of spacetime itself, study finds
Assuming that every paper is reviewed at least once, Markov’s inequality implies that every paper is reviewed exactly once!
piannucci··on Steve Finberg, W1GSL, SK
We crossed paths. Steve was always recruiting volunteers to help staple up announcement posters for swapfest. If you didn't decline strongly enough, you'd never walk away from a conversation with him without a small stack of posters. My impression was of a man with so much history that I knew nothing about: as if I could meet him a hundred times and never be a blip on his radar, he'd been doing this for so long. When you visited the radio society's storage room and saw decade upon decade of dusty and inscrutable equipment, lifetimes' worth of projects, of disassembly and re-assembly--- well, what do I know. Keith can tell you much better than I. But it seems to me that Steve was the kind of person who could start a million things, finish half, and still sleep well at night, comfortable that he'd get to it eventually.
piannucci··on Basic Music Theory in ~200 Lines of Python
Shtaaap, you’re headed for the Totient Function! Collision immanent, abort, abort!
piannucci··on USB 3.0* Radio Frequency Interference on 2.4 GHz Devices (2012)
I work at a lab where this is a major nuisance.

I’ve been wondering whether the clock spreading in the USB standard could be manipulated to notch out certain frequencies, like in noise shaping for ADCs.

piannucci··on Nuclear power must be well regulated, not ditched
Wouldn’t the plant have been located where demand and cooling capacity were co-located?
piannucci··on How Uber Deals with Large iOS App Size
Interesting. I have had bad cell connectivity in unfamiliar airports, though, where I could barely keep a connection to e.g. the Lyft servers. What if I can’t download the module when I need it? I don’t think requiring the user to download it in advance of their flight is viable, either. If we lived in a world of universal, homogeneous, inexpensive connectivity, I’d be satisfied with the solution you mention. I guess if they had location/policy micro-modules small enough to fit in a single MTU, then anybody who could connect to Uber at all could be served.

It still boggles my mind that there could be ~100M meaningful instructions in a program.

piannucci··on Web Spectrogram using your Mic
To add to what others have said--

The spectrogram image contains amplitude, but not phase information. (There are partial exceptions in special cases involving oversampling.) Conveniently, the human auditory system is primarily sensitive to the same information present in the spectrogram.

piannucci··on Arecibo Observatory Collapsed
Whoa, cool. Could you make a .wav file or something so we can hear it?
piannucci··on AlphaFold: a solution to a 50-year-old grand challenge in biology
This is so cool. I hope they will also tackle the problem of predicting RNA structures and catalytic activity.
piannucci··on Missing Covid-19 test data was caused by the ill-thought-out use of Excel
Oh, my God. "On Error Resume Next" is one of my earliest memories of learning to program for Windows. It never occurred to me that it might result in deaths.
piannucci··on Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Preliminary Thoughts
You might get an answer by reading about Hausdorff dimension.
piannucci··on Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Preliminary Thoughts
The mainstream theory is that whatever reality is, its consequences on measurable length-scales are as-yet indistinguishable from an almost-everywhere-continuous medium. (I.e. away from black hole singularities.). Until we have the ability to measure not just deviations of reality from theory, but deviations from what any continuum theory might predict, the question of whether hypergraphs have the correct asymptotic continuum behavior is largely moot. Wolfram has been pushing an atomistic program of cellular automata as models of physical systems for many years. They are beautiful, but so far they are only useful insofar as they approximate continuum mechanics-- which is to say, they are of limited application.

The thing about continuous media is that they involve dynamics on all length scales: .1 meters, .1 nanometers, 1e-10 nm, etc. Because of wave-particle duality, length scales and energy scales run inversely: a low energy experiment just does not exhibit any measurable dependence on extremely short-range behavior of the universe. Only high-energy experiments have a wavelength short enough to be sensitive to this unknown sector. Low energy physics is “well understood” in the sense that any experiment with a modest number of component particles can be totally predicted from theory, to the limits of experimental accuracy. Granted that many real-world problems involve stupendous numbers of particles, and exhibit challenging-to-explain emergent behavior: but this is not evidence of unexplained fundamental phenomena, just of the limits of our mathematical insight into finding good abstractions for many-body problems, and evidence of the limits of our computational power to try and work around the lack of good abstractions.

It is known that the most generous interpretation of current theories is that they are self-consistent to arbitrary high energies (renormalizable is the term). That does not mean they are consistent with actual reality, just with themselves.

So... hypergraphs are a big lift, an unneeded multiplication of entities. Until an experiment reveals non-continuum behavior of space-time, what we have here is a solution to a non-issue.

piannucci··on Small nuclear reactors: tiny NuScale reactor gets safety approval
1. Don’t let that happen.

2. There have been proposals before for core dilution buckets: a wide shallow dish under the reactor full of something like gallium for the hot core to dissolve into. As it spreads out into the dish, the heat and radiation fluxes become less unmanageable, and the core material becomes less critical.

3. Don’t let that happen. :-P

piannucci··on Ammonia as a fuel for compression ignition engines
Knowing nothing about this, broadly speaking, the enthalpy of formation of the diatomic nitrogen molecule is very high, and you might expect to achieve high energy density. Also it does not produce any CO2.
piannucci··on Astronomers solve the missing baryon problem
Blackbody radiation describes an electromagnetic field in thermal equilibrium. Typically, we associate this radiation with a particular source, or boundary; but the blackbody spectrum itself is a Maxwell fact, not a matter fact. Real systems have many degrees of freedom, some matter, some Maxwell. In this particular example, the Maxwell degrees of freedom have a temperature of 3K, while the matter degrees of freedom have a much higher temperature.

Clearly, then, the matter is not in equilibrium with the electromagnetic field. How can this be?

Equilibration is a process that proceeds through a large number of interactions that each exchange energy between two thermal systems (or subsystems). If energy transfer is prevented, for instance by the conservation of mass and momentum, or because no post- states of an appropriate energy are available for one subsystem to evolve into, then the systems may remain far from equilibrium relative to each other.

I’d have to do some homework to verify this, but I think a correct statement is that free massive charged particles don’t gain or lose energy in net from passing radiation; and conversely, they cannot radiate. This is guaranteed by Lorentz symmetry, btw: if you examine a million-kelvin electron in a frame of reference moving alongside it, you’d agree there’s no way it can be radiating: there’s a frame in which it is stationary, and stationary charges don’t radiate. If it isn’t radiating in one inertial frame, it isn’t radiating in any inertial frame.

Only during collisions between charged particles is there a possibility for the matter and Maxwell degrees of freedom to exchange energy: and these are very rare in tenuous plasma. (We would call these “three-body interactions” because the photon counts as one.)

[edit to add] Now one might object that charged particles are always interacting, because their fields fall off like 1/r^2; they don’t just end. Indeed! But one of the effects of being in a plasma is that charges are “screened”. You can think of that as meaning the net effect of many-body interactions can be described as altering the “effective” field of each particle to fall off much faster, like e^-r.

piannucci··on CERN makes push to build €21B super-collider
This! To my understanding, as a dilettante in the science of fluids, turbulence is an open problem mostly only in subfields pretty far removed from everyday engineering:

The mathematicians question whether the Navier-Stokes continuum fluid model can be trusted to remain mathematically well-posed in all scenarios; but Navier-Stokes is just a second-order approximation to Boltzmann transport, and higher-order approximations are well known. If N-S were to blow up, it would merely indicate that the second-order approximation breaks down in some regime, necessarily involving shocks. But... I don’t think any experts in transport theory would be surprised by that. It would be more be like solving the mystery of rogue waves, and less like finding bigfoot.

The other group I’m aware of are those who study large-scale turbulence. The goal there is to summarize or coarse-grain the turbulence that goes on within a small computational volume, as a cost-saving measure versus using a more finely-resolved mesh in space and time. That’s valuable work with true social impact, such as in atmospheric forecasting and erosion studies. But... it’s kinda phenomenological. Not as much fun for many scientists.

piannucci··on UChicago doctors see ‘remarkable’ success using ventilator alternatives
First-- and I'm sure you weren't suggesting this, but I feel I need to mention-- it's extremely dangerous to pressurize a person's lungs above the surrounding environment[1]. Not to mention that pressurizing the inside of the throat could pressurize the middle ear and blow out your eardrums.

Second, I'm not a physician, I'm a physicist. What follows is for curiosity's sake.

I suspect that the goal is to maximally enrich the patient's airstream in oxygen, whenever it is that they happen to breathe in. In a patient with fluid-filled alveoli, the surface area available for diffusion of oxygen into the bloodstream is greatly diminished. Additionally, the distance that oxygen needs to diffuse before it reaches hemoglobin is increased: rather than just the lining of alveoli and capillaries, it has to first dissolve into the fluid gunk filling the space, then diffuse through the fluid, then pass through the lining of the alveolus and capillary. To top it off, water doesn't have great solubility for oxygen, and atmospheric air is mostly nitrogen anyways.

Each of these passive transport phenomena occurs at a rate that depends on the gradient (roughly...) of available O2. This concentration is greatest in the air, and lowest in the bloodstream adjacent to the alveoli, where hemoglobin binds up oxygen. One way to increase the rate of dissolution and diffusion is to increase the concentration gradient. That means enriching the airstream in O2.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barotrauma#Pulmonary_barotraum...

piannucci··on MIT moves all classes online for the rest of the semester
I think the idea is you leave stuff in your dorm room that you don't need right away, but yeah. Wow.

(btw some of the MIT dorms have storage space in the basement)

piannucci··on Proposed FAA Rule Would Kickstart New Economy for IDing Drones
Can we have a bounty program for capturing and turning in transponderless drones? :]
piannucci··on The Czochralski method for growing single-crystal semiconductors
Wow!!! What a great lab exercise!

Tell me, please: how were the students supposed to reach the melting point of the salt? It seems... too high for me to try this at home.

piannucci··on Hubble Observes First Confirmed Interstellar Comet
That’s a great question, and it’s (relatively) feasible to answer. The object is coming in towards the center the solar system, so its past trajectory lies outwards. If it has been disturbed into this path from a hypothetical sun-centered orbit, it would have to have happened very recently: otherwise it would be long gone, never to return. So it would be necessary for the back-projected trajectory to pass very close to a compact, massive object. Dare I say that the vast majority of all such massive objects in the solar system are well known; so if the trajectory doesn’t indicate a close encounter with a planet within the past decade or so, then this possibility is essentially eliminated.
piannucci··on Home 3D metal printing: first results
Could the flame be acetylene gas?
piannucci··on The geometry of an electron determined for the first time
The scale of this experiment is pretty big in quantum terms, so a semi-classical explanation is not inaccurate. The electron is behaving like water filling a bowl. The height of the bowl floor represents how much potential energy the electron needs to reach that point in space.

Suppose that the bowl is invisible, and detailed knowledge of its shape is of scientific interest for one reason or another. Here, it's interesting because they want to fine-tune their ability to spatially and electromagnetically control individual electrons so that they can explore "spintronics".

One way to measure the shape of the bowl is to measure the shape of the electron "fluid" filling the bowl. They've developed some technique for doing that. I haven't read the details.

That only gives you information about the bottommost part of the bowl, where the fluid lies. By applying voltages to the electrodes, the authors can raise the potential energy needed for the electron to hang out at one end of the bowl relative to the other. This effectively tips the bowl, and the electron "fluid" re-distributes itself, allowing them to measure the shape of the bowl at locations other than the bottom.

That's all I get from the article. You'd have to read the linked original paper to learn more. A traditional undergraduate series in classical mechanics, electromagnetics, waves, and quantum mechanics is very helpful, but cutting-edge research is never communicated in the same terms that are used in undergraduate teaching. There are going to be some jargon barriers no matter what. Happy reading!

piannucci··on GPS Flaw: Security Expert Says He Won't Fly April 6
The GPS broadcast navigation message includes the offset between GPS system time and UTC, which is specified to be an integer number of seconds plus or minus a microsecond. The integers are the running total number of leap seconds since 1980. GPS system time doesn't perform leap seconds, but the clock offsets are calculated so that the system tracks UTC. So I am not certain what you mean.
piannucci··on JIT-Less V8
How bad of an idea would it be to create a ROP-based JIT engine for these platforms? You could hand-craft the gadgets and use the stack to reduce interpreter dispatch overhead.
← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →