HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

pinkmuffinere

3,655 karma · joined August 8, 2021

I like engineering, finance, and tech. My biggest project (as part of a team) is stingray resistant booties: https://mydragonskin.com/
submissionscomments
pinkmuffinere··on BMW Is Showing Commercials on Their Car's Dash Screens as a Treat
> > At least in the USA, a new BMW is a high-end car.

> No they most definitely are not.

> They're marketed as high end, but their engineering is a tour de force of cost cutting behind the scenes.

Whether you personally like it or not has no impact on the product positioning. BMW is a luxury car brand [1].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BMW

pinkmuffinere··on A missing underscore sent innocent man to prison for 18 months
> I think we called every service qualified for providing such a testimony in Ontario, and a good portion of them across all of Canada. Some were even happy to work with us, until they found out we were testifying against the police. We ended up going international but without luck, and ended up with no expert testimony

This is absolutely horrible to hear!! I know you probably don't want homework, but would you ever consider taking this story to news outlets? I suspect there'd be no compensation, but the uproar might (eventually) result in change.

pinkmuffinere··on Kimi-K3 Technical Report [pdf]
Wow this is fascinating enough that I’m actually going to read tfa lol
pinkmuffinere··on Apple Will 'Watch Everything Burn' When the AI Bubble Bursts
I totally think the AI companies are very overvalued, I feel that's obvious. But I don't understand why apple should have such a high run in the last year. Sure, it avoided the pitfall of overinvesting in AI -- but what did it do for positive development? Avoiding waste isn't (imo) enough to warrant increased price. What's going on, what's the bull case for apple?
pinkmuffinere··on Clinical failure rates over the decades: yikes
tl;dr -- Boom's iterations are very similar to a phase III trial! Please prove me wrong!

Just to clarify, I think our numbers are in agreement here. From your numbers, phase I + II + III would be in the range $21-75M, all told. Let's double that to account for inflation (2012 is quite stale), to get $42-150M. In California, I'm going to estimate a "normal" engineer's compensation is $150-400k, and the company actually pays more than this because of benefits, HR, etc -- call it $250-600k. Let's say it's 350k fully loaded on average. Then the $42-150M number represents 120-430 engineer years. I'd totally believe that Boom has 120-400 engineers working full time, so if they make a major revision every year, then each major revision is like a full phase I-III progression!

I think there's some reverse-dunning-kruger going on in this thread, where because we're all engineers we think engineering is comparably easy. My claim is that it's actually pretty similar to medical testing, in terms of generic human effort (to the extent that can even be measured and quantified).

edit: According to wikipedia, Boom had 150 employees in 2021 [1]! I'm very proud of my estimate lol, it seems like it was right on the nose. Somebody give me a prize!

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boom_Technology

pinkmuffinere··on Clinical failure rates over the decades: yikes
That's fair, phase 3 testing isn't an early prototype, it's a prototype with many years of effort behind it. But I still think it is _more_ like a prototype than it is like a product coming off an assembly line. Perhaps phase 3 is like the latest prototype from boom (the company trying to bring back super-sonic jets). Those prototypes represent 100s of engineering-years put together, and are not much like the prototypes you'd encounter in consumer product development. I still think 90% failure rate is believable for that. How many significant design iterations has Boom gone through so far? I don't really know, but I could believe it's been 10 significant iterations.
pinkmuffinere··on Clinical failure rates over the decades: yikes
> But let’s think about that 91% failure rate for a moment. When I bring this up in presentations, I invite the audience to consider what the auto industry would look like of 91% of new car designs proved unable to roll out of the factory, or if 91% of new airliner models were unable to leave the ground - and if you only found that out after spending all the R&D money to build them at full size and trying to fly them. No cutting-edge restaurant could survive if 91% of its innovative dishes proved inedible or outright poisonous. What other industries operate under these bizarre conditions?

This is bizarre, bordering on stupid. Frist of all, there likely is ~90% failure rate of prototypes; I feel that roughly matches my experience in engineering. Of course the design that makes it through the process, testing, refinement, and into mass production is not going to have a 90% failure rate, but that's a _finished product_, whereas clinical tests are just that -- tests. Finished cars are more analogous to individual pills coming out of the factory. And I'm not even sure the analogy would be very meaningful anyways, because we have different requirements for things of different impact and importance. A 10% manufacturing defect rate is fine in forks, but not for fire extinguishers.

pinkmuffinere··on DeepSeek pause fundraise after comments on compute gap to US leaked (transcript) [pdf]
Wow, that is fascinating, I didn't realize China was now blocking foreign chips, lol. It's not a definitive indicator, but I feel that doesn't bode well for US dominance in this area -- when your competitor thinks they'd be helping _you_ by using your resources, that's not great.
pinkmuffinere··on AI Companies Are Trying to Hide a Staggering Amount of Debt
This is a common objection, "It's already priced in". I've believed it for a long time, but also been really interested in the claim, since it feels recursive in the kind of suspicious way. Recently I read / watched a lot of material about it, just out of personal interest. In short, this claim (the efficient market hypothesis, "It's already priced in") is very optimistic. It's not possible to prove definitively if it is or isn't true, and people will argue both ways. However, it seems very unlikely that _all_ effects are _always_ already priced in. Some evidence by way of contradiction:

1. It's widely known that Spacex is overvalued. How is it possible for it to be widely known, and yet still overvalued? Either it is fairly valued, or these issues are _not_ already priced in.

2. If people read Enron's filings, they could have been aware of the shady reporting, and should have seen the reduction in price coming. But clearly most did not! Enron persisted for a long time despite shady tactics, that essentially were happening "in the open" if you dug into the paperwork.

3. The same argument can be made about housing loans during 2008, the dot com boom in 2000, and the response to covid in 2020

If you're interested I have much more to say on the topic! It's fascinating and I've only recently been convinced that the efficient market hypothesis is untrue (or at least it is suspect). I also highly recommend any of patrick boyle's videos, he makes great content often touching on this topic.

disclaimer: I'm not an expert in this industry, or really in this industry at all. I just like learning about it.

pinkmuffinere··on Nobody knows what a used GPU cluster is worth
What are people going to do with all the GPUs? I guess we'll all have really good gaming rigs, lol.

Sincerely, perhaps there will be a new flood of crypto farms, which I suppose would drive the prices of crypto down. Other ideas for what changes are enabled by massive supply of cheap GPUs?

pinkmuffinere··on FDA approves new kind of cholesterol pill
> for the most part mass == weight on Earth.

The thread above us discusses neither mass nor weight. Here it is copied in full -- I encourage you to use ctrl-f

> mediumsmart 1 hour ago

> One could eat healthy instead of course but hey, the good life.

> shlant 1 hour ago

> you didn't read the article did you? Or are you actually here to claim that people with hypercholesterolemia just need to eat better?

> Do you have the same simplistic ideas about GLP-1's?

> moi2388 1 hour ago

> For all people? No. For the vast majority of people? Yes. Eat healthy and exercise more

I'm a bit upset that I put in effort to genuinely engage in your claims, and you're not willing to go back and read the thread to confirm claims that _you made_. In fact, you suckered me into re-reading the same thread _for the third time_ looking for some throwaway line I missed about mass or weight. I could just decide that internet discussion doesn't matter, and stop engaging on HN, but I'd rather not do that. Can you please try a bit more?

I'm not going to reply to the Triglycerides & HDL comment without a link. It was your claim initially, and I was nice enough to provide a link with evidence against it, so surely you can do the same in support.

pinkmuffinere··on FDA approves new kind of cholesterol pill
It’s possible the comments have changed, but I see nothing in the thread about mass loss. I do agree about weight though — losing weight is largely diet.

> Go from obese to not obese and the median person's cholesterol will drop quite a bit.

This is really interesting, I don’t think I’ve heard that before. Do you have a source you could share?

Edit: this doesn’t necessarily prove you wrong, but this paper argues there’s little correlation between bmi and cholesterol [1]

[1] https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11695-010-0170-7

pinkmuffinere··on FDA approves new kind of cholesterol pill
The dietary impact on cholesterol in the blood is surprisingly low. Looking it up, this source says diet can affect 20-30% of your blood levels [1]. I don’t have a great statistic about exercise, but I’d encourage you to question what you think you know — at the very least I’ll claim you’re mistaken about the importance of dietary impacts on cholesterol, which perhaps should give you pause about your other beliefs

[1] https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/articles/16867-cholest...

pinkmuffinere··on Goodbye, and Thanks for All the Bikesheds
To be clear, I'm not endorsing Amazon writ large, I'm just saying I like the framing (ha!) as "two-way doors". This is maybe equivalent to your concept of reversible decisions, just by another name.

While we are griping about Amazon, my main complaints are about the fulfillment centers/working conditions, the anti-union activity, building their own versions of products that sell well on their platform, and the penalizing of companies that price higher on-amazon than off-amazon.

pinkmuffinere··on SpaceX and the myth of independent Wall St research
> This creates a level of bias, even if banks didn't have incentives to write bullish projections.

I don't necessarily disagree with you, but I think this is misleading. The bad estimate of fair price is _overwhelmingly_ due to incentives for bullish projections. I have no source to back this up, aside from common sense. SPCX is supposedly an AI-company now, even though we all know this is a lie. It's AI-only revenue within 5 years[1] is projected to be larger than most SP500 companies' full revenue today[2]. On the face of it, this is silly, and I don't accept that all the analysts group-thought their way to believing it.

[1] https://finance.yahoo.com/sectors/technology/articles/goldma...

[2] https://stockanalysis.com/list/sp-500-stocks/

pinkmuffinere··on Goodbye, and Thanks for All the Bikesheds
+1! I've fallen in love with many of Amazon's in-group concepts, and maybe I'm just drinking the koolaide, but they have the concept of a "two-way door", which is exactly this -- a decision that can be made, unmade, remade, etc relatively cheaply. If you can identify that a choice isn't very dangerous, you can focus on the things that really are instead.
pinkmuffinere··on How Has Roman Concrete Lasted for Millennia? 1,900-Year-Old Latrine Offers Clues
> Wouldn't your beams start cracking at the bottom, where they are subject to traction?

You have a few mistakes here. I’m not trying to demean you, but I’m going to number them just for clarity, as it can get confusing when there are many misunderstandings.

1. You are intending to ask about tension (which the rebar helps with), not traction (the force your tires exert against a road).

2. Tension is not only experienced at the bottom of beams, the location with the most tension will depend on the geometry. For a vertical beam, I think tension will probably be pretty even through the whole beam in most “normal” designs and loading configurations. But it will really depend on the geometry and on the loads being applied.

3. I think when you say concrete beams you’re meaning columns (apologies if I’m wrong about this). Concrete columns are remarkably good at holding up without rebar, because they experience almost exclusively compression! And indeed, ancient Roman designs did not use rebar at all :). It’s certainly possible.

pinkmuffinere··on The infinite scroll may become endangered if controversial Calif. law passes
As somebody with not-enough self control, I would love this for myself. Self-locks help, but the temptation is always there.
pinkmuffinere··on Under federal rule, colleges must leave grads better off or lose financial aid
1. If you looked up the average tuition in the US and found the UC system is an outlier, then quoting CSU prices is a red herring — just tell us the average tuition and perhaps the standard deviation.

2. The question that started this thread was “does anyone really pay 250k for college?” Even as an outlier, the UC system price is relevant. It is an existence proof that many people _do_ pay close to that sum for undergrad.

pinkmuffinere··on Under federal rule, colleges must leave grads better off or lose financial aid
The discussion is about what the average person pays.... surely student body size _is_ the relevant metric? What else would you propose?
pinkmuffinere··on Under federal rule, colleges must leave grads better off or lose financial aid
That is very much a real sum of money people pay. The UC system is (I believe) 30k per year tuition if you’re in state. Add rent and you’re probably looking at 45k per year. Out of state is higher. And many systems are more expensive as well
pinkmuffinere··on FAANG Simulator
85k should definitely cover your expenses. You can rent out a bedroom instead of a house. Buy a cheap car. Eat canned beans. Even in SF, it’s doable on 85k.
pinkmuffinere··on 98% isn't much
This sounds very fun! I would love to hear more stories if you have 'em!
pinkmuffinere··on GAO: DOE Is Prematurely Excluding Less Expensive Options for Nuclear Cleanup
> The emissions from chinas coal burning plants is 10000000000000000000000000000000000000 times worse than chucking nuclear waste in the desert at random

I don't think you're wrong per-se, but I think your claim could be simplified to "the impact of the common alternatives are 1000000000000000 times worse than nuclear waste"

pinkmuffinere··on Building relationships with customers through support didn't turn out as hoped
> this is a glorified side project

Personally I'd guess this is a big part of the issue. If this is a glorified side project, you really don't / can't care _too_ much about everything. I don't mean that as a criticism, it's just if you have little time to give the product will improve little, and the customers will get a just-ok experience. It's not surprising that translates poorly to customers. People like devotion; luke-warm commitment is dissapointing.

pinkmuffinere··on Building relationships with customers through support didn't turn out as hoped
lol I like you, you can stay.
pinkmuffinere··on Building relationships with customers through support didn't turn out as hoped
One suggestion — when you have an unsatisfying answer for a customer like “I can’t reproduce that”, or “I won’t build that feature”, the customer may not appreciate the amount of effort you have invested in that decision. A 30 minute phone call/video call may communicate more effectively the depth of care you have. Even if you convey the same information, people _love_ talking to the owner/founder, it is a very strong indication that you care about their thoughts.
pinkmuffinere··on Building relationships with customers through support didn't turn out as hoped
I agree his responses could be more compassionate and show more effort, but i feel your characterization is over-critical. There _isnt time_ to chase bugs that aren’t reproducible. The software _cant_ have every form factor, _some things_ need to be set in stone as a North Star. These aren’t scummy practices, these are realities of a time-bounded existence.
pinkmuffinere··on The great blogging collapse: What happened to 100 successful blogs?
> I imagine that the top 100 of anything (that a lot of people do) that brings in income or fame will still be there in 5 years.

This sort of blanket assumption is exactly what the parent is arguing against. The mortality rate of top-n things is relatively easy to measure, and should be baselined first. Then we can compare recent performance vs historical performance, and actually say if something has changed. There's no need to start with the assumption "not much changes over 5 years" -- it can be measured instead.

pinkmuffinere··on President pardons 9 for Clean Air violations for 'fixing their car'
You’re right, that’s much worse. I should have read tfa before posting.
← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →