HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

piotrkaminski

731 karma · joined October 2, 2013

I run https://reviewable.io. You can reach me at piotr at ideanest dot com.
submissionscomments
piotrkaminski··on Available on Google Cloud: Intel Optane DC Persistent Memory
But in the context of the OP, presumably devices in a data center would never be powered down on purpose to save energy? In which case it seems that battery-backup DRAM would work just as well for this use case, and be both cheaper and faster.
piotrkaminski··on RawGit is now in a sunset phase and will soon shut down
Is there a service that can replace RawGit for Gists, specifically serving them with the correct MIME type? This was a convenient feature for users of https://reviewable.io to hack up a quick custom stylesheet or keyboard shortcuts override. It's not clear to me whether any of the suggested replacements support Gists.
piotrkaminski··on A Warning from Europe: The Worst Is yet to Come
Interesting, I didn't know that -- thanks for clarifying.
piotrkaminski··on A Warning from Europe: The Worst Is yet to Come
Dupe of https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17995934, not sure how it got through the filters.
piotrkaminski··on Handy GitHub File Explorer
Development is definitely ongoing! The high-level changelog is at https://changelog.reviewable.io/ and you can get more granular updates via https://groups.google.com/forum/#!forum/reviewable-enterpris... (though these releases usually go out a few weeks after the respective changes hit reviewable.io).

Not sure what you mean about putting state in the repo. It's possible of course since you can stuff anything in there, but what would be the advantage? It wouldn't integrate with GitHub any better and it would throw away the real-time updates, queries, etc., available thanks to Firebase.

piotrkaminski··on Handy GitHub File Explorer
Yeah, fair enough. I want to move the file matrix into a sidebar file tree instead (along with the rest of the toolbar) but I'm blocking on some infrastructure work. I've been resisting tooltips on hover for the longest time but I'm capitulating on that as well -- for now, hitting F1 or H anywhere will bring up the help, but hover tooltips are coming.

As for GitHub integration, I agree it's not ideal but it's the best their slightly brain-dead review API will allow. Getting the whole team to adopt the tool is much better, but is obviously quite a bit harder. Though that's probably why I'm seeing a lot more success in the enterprise space, where top-down diktats are par for the course.

piotrkaminski··on Handy GitHub File Explorer
Then you might want to check out https://reviewable.io -- not an extension but does integrate with GitHub pretty nicely. (Disclaimer: I'm the founder.)
piotrkaminski··on If you’re unsure whether to quit your job or break up, you probably should
I'm going to go out on a limb and guess that you don't have (young) kids.
piotrkaminski··on Ask HN: I'm experiencing pair programming exhaustion, how best to cope with it?
Or (tooting my own horn) for a friendlier but still powerful approach to code reviews that integrates better with GitHub you could try https://reviewable.io.
piotrkaminski··on Ask HN: How to find a tech-savy business co-founder?
This is not directly addressing your question, but I went the bootstrapped SaaS solo founder route and have no regrets. Code reviews would've been nice, admittedly, and some of my initial attempts at the non-tech stuff were weak. But ultimately the non-tech stuff proved fairly easy to pick up and I really appreciate the extra skills I ended up with. As for sharing the experience, consider joining one of the many online bootstrapper communities, or attending MicroConf.

So my advice would be to look for a co-founder, sure, but don't discount the option of going it alone. Remember that good co-founder > solo >> bad co-founder!

piotrkaminski··on Remote Only
This seems more like an opportunity for a company to come in and handle those details for you. I believe those exist already but they seem mostly targeted at larger multinationals rather than scrappy remote-only startups.
piotrkaminski··on Why I've lost faith in p values
My criticism is not necessarily constructive. ;) But it's not too hard to imagine something along the lines of arXiv combined with a rating/commenting system not unlike HN itself, combined with a Facebook-ish algorithm for surfacing articles relevant to each reader. The devil is in the details, of course, but it shouldn't be hard to do better than the expensive, artificially constrained, and arbitrary system we're saddled with now. The real trick will be convincing entrenched academics to switch -- I'm still not convinced this is actually possible.
piotrkaminski··on Why I've lost faith in p values
> instead of asking whether an effect is null or not, we should ask how big the effect is likely to be given the data. However, at the end of the day, editors need to make an all-or-none decision about whether to publish a paper

Yet another way in which the traditional publishing structure actively harms science.

piotrkaminski··on Ask HN: Do you have the courage to abandon your high paying job?
I doubt you'll find a consensus on this question. My opinion, for what it's worth, is that this also follows the dictum of "asking if you should fire someone means you've already made your decision", and prevaricating only prolongs the pain.

I made a similar decision with much less of a financial cushion (and without moving away from the west coast) and it worked out OK. I'm happy now and don't regret giving up the millions. YMMV, of course. One tip: make it your goal to get to ramen profitability ASAP, not in 2-3 years -- it has a wonderful way of focusing your work.

Good luck whatever you choose, and keep in mind that either decision will remain reversible for at least a few years. If you go out on your own, I don't think having "I tried to run my own startup, failed, and learned a lot" will be a negative when seeking another tech job, and you can always move back.

piotrkaminski··on Require multiple reviewers for pull requests
FWIW, Reviewable allows you to write a custom review completion condition in JS where you can match paths and participants to your heart's content and determine whether the review is complete or not. This is posted to GitHub as a status check so you can use it to block/allow merging. (Disclaimer: I built Reviewable.)
piotrkaminski··on [dead]
> That wouldn't affect LIDAR, would it? The safety driver may not have been able to avoid the collision, but what about the self-driving car itself? I would like to know more before ruling out Uber's fault.

That's actually an interesting question, I think: should we assign (formal, legal) fault to self-driving cars based on their actual capabilities, or on the capabilities of an average human driver in similar circumstances? What do we currently do when humans of very unequal skill (e.g., a race car driver vs daily commuter) have an accident -- does the race car driver potentially shoulder more of the blame? If not, should self-driving cars be treated differently?

Honest questions, I'm not sure how I'd answer them myself.

piotrkaminski··on The Nightmare Letter: A Subject Access Request Under GDPR
I guess my implicit answer was "I think so -- in fact, you probably don't even need to do that much". (Though you want to replace "EU citizen" with "EU resident".) And of course nothing will _guarantee_ no trouble.
piotrkaminski··on The Nightmare Letter: A Subject Access Request Under GDPR
I believe it should be sufficient to:

- Incorporate your business outside the EU.

- Have no offices in the EU.

- Reside outside the EU.

- Not visit the EU (?).

- Not employ any EU residents.

- Not target any advertisements about your business to EU countries.

- Only offer your site in your local language and/or English.

- Don't register your site in an EU TLD.

At that point, as far as I can tell (and of course I'm not a lawyer), you have no EU presence and even the GDPR admits that it doesn't apply to you. Presumably these conditions apply to the vast majority of small businesses where dealing with random claims of extra-territorial jurisdiction is just a waste of time.

This being HN, I'm sure somebody will be ecstatic to correct me if the above is wrong.

piotrkaminski··on Sierra Leone just ran the first blockchain-based election
> thereby offering instant access to the election results.

...

> it is still unclear who won

piotrkaminski··on Project Gutenberg blocks access from Germany
(Thanks for the well-reasoned reply! I'll preface mine by saying that I'm not terribly well-versed in the GDPR either... and that's really part of the problem.)

AFAICT, the GDPR consider an IP address to be PII. So collecting visitor logs or sticking an analytics script on the page -- even without asking people to sign in or otherwise identify themselves -- would fall under the purview of the GDPR. I don't think doing such things should cross the line into "active character".

It's also a terrible idea to infer intent from offering translations in other languages. As another comment pointed out (I presume correctly) there are more German speakers outside Germany than there are within its borders. Why should trying to improve the accessibility of a web site by people around the world make one susceptible to the laws of a language's native country?

As you say, the implied end state is the real problem: do I now need to learn about the relevant laws of every country whose residents (or even citizens?) might visit my web site? That's regulation without representation, and should be resisted on principle IMHO. Or will every site need a standard disclaimer that it's only intended for residents of X?

Perhaps some creative lawyer will figure out how to add a clause to Terms of Use that shifts responsibility for damages incurred by exposure to extraterritorial laws to the offending (offended?) user, and we can have a detente through mutually assured destruction of dueling lawsuits. :)

And just to preempt any criticism from the European peanut gallery, I'm in favor of stronger privacy protections on the Internet but they need to be worked out and agreed on globally, not imposed unilaterally by claiming extraterritorial jurisdiction.

piotrkaminski··on Project Gutenberg blocks access from Germany
> This is distinct from, say, a company explicitly providing a service to customers in a particular country (cf GDPR).

In what ways do you think the GDPR is distinct from the laws in the present case? Let's say, for argument's sake, that gutenberg.org starts capturing PII about visitors and storing it without conforming to the GDPR. Do you think it would be fair for the EU to sue them and (attempt to) enforce their law? If so, why?

piotrkaminski··on The risk of nitrites and nitrates in bacon
Hmm, the first link says:

> All of the bacon we sell is made without synthetic nitrates or nitrites.

Is that the dodge mentioned in the article where they actually do use nitrates from celery instead, which are just as bad even though they're natural?

piotrkaminski··on What I want in a code review tool
Reviewable does 2 out of these 3 IIUC (no globs yet) and integrates with GitHub PRs. Might want to take a look. (Disclaimer: I built it.)
piotrkaminski··on The Big Vitamin D Mistake
Coincidentally, another submission from earlier today points to a study that says that (lack of) Vitamin D can impact sleep quality: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15862222.
piotrkaminski··on China’s dark matter space probe detects tantalizing signal
Ah, makes sense now -- should've gone to the source instead of trusting the article to summarize all numbers. Thanks!
piotrkaminski··on China’s dark matter space probe detects tantalizing signal
> In its first 530 days of scientific observations, DAMPE detected 1.5 million cosmic ray electrons and positrons

> "we now expect it to last 5 years"

> That will allow the satellite to record more than 10 billion cosmic ray events.

Assuming DAMPE continues detecting cosmic ray events at its current rate, I think the total number after 5 years would be a bit over 5 million. That's a few magnitudes off of 10 billion... Math fail, or do I misunderstand something?

1.5m / 530d * 5y * 365d/y = 5.165m

piotrkaminski··on How Firefox Got Fast Again
FYI, Chrome has had smooth scrolling since v49. https://developers.google.com/web/updates/2016/02/smooth-scr...
piotrkaminski··on LinkedIn’s Tips for Highly Effective Code Review
Dupe: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15428277
piotrkaminski··on I used to think gun control was the answer. My research told me otherwise
Mandatory insurance sounds promising, but what happens when the insurance lapses and the person still owns the guns? Does the government go in and repossess their guns? Does it force them to pay somehow? Doesn't seem practical.
piotrkaminski··on Golang Proposal: Just Use GitHub
Feedback is always appreciated, and candid feedback is highly prized! I get what you're saying, but it's a fine line to walk: if Reviewable is too much like GitHub, it won't be able to add sufficient value to be worth using. If it's radically different, few people will be able to figure it out at all. I'm happy with the balance I've hit but it's definitely not for everyone -- on either end of the scale! Also, there's a forthcoming migration from Angular to Vue where I intend to make major changes to the UX, which will hopefully increase usability and make onboarding easier... We'll see!
← PreviousPage 5 of 9Next →