HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

piotrkaminski

731 karma · joined October 2, 2013

I run https://reviewable.io. You can reach me at piotr at ideanest dot com.
submissionscomments
piotrkaminski··on Golang Proposal: Just Use GitHub
This looks like a good spot to plug Reviewable (https://reviewable.io), which addresses the disappearing / untracked comments issues and more, while still integrating with GitHub rather more gracefully than something like Gerrit. While GitHub's PR review tooling has improved in the last year there's still a fundamental difference in philosophy such that Reviewable isn't lacking for customers. :) (Disclosure: I'm the founder.)
piotrkaminski··on Self-flying planes are now a marketing issue more than a technical one
> Many people have issues flying due the feeling of not being in control

You lack control whether it's a pilot or an AI in the cockpit, so rationally this shouldn't make much difference from this point of view. Of course, people are anything but rational. :)

I think it would be amusing to let an AI fly some commercial routes without telling people -- after all, I bet there's nothing in the carriage contract about having humans at the controls. I'm sure the FAA wouldn't approve, though.

piotrkaminski··on Self-flying planes are now a marketing issue more than a technical one
The article suggested that the price savings would be (relatively) most significant for private jets, which makes sense. I'm wondering if this might finally make for a viable small-jet-hire industry that caters to "normal" people? It seems that every few years we hear about a "jet taxi" startup that promises cheap(ish) flights between general aviation airports but they never seem to materialize...
piotrkaminski··on Building the next generation web
Hmm, Firebase does all of the above except custom build commands and preview websites for PRs. And while they're certainly focusing their marketing on mobile apps these days, they actually have a pretty good value proposition for web apps as well.

Sounds like Netlify is competing either on simplicity or on price, with a (likely temporary) advantage in developer tooling integration.

piotrkaminski··on Building the next generation web
At first glance this looks very much like Firebase, minus the real-time datastore. What's different/better about Netlify, and how are you supposed to use it for sites that need to persist data (i.e., pretty much anything non-trivial)?
piotrkaminski··on ES6 Generators Deliver Go Style Concurrency (2013)
Title needs a (2013) annotation.
piotrkaminski··on Building Searchable Encrypted Databases with PHP and SQL
I was specifically after a deterministic encryption scheme that would allow for exact-match comparisons and whose deployment was fairly foolproof (so a non-expert couldn't screw it up too badly), which AES-SIV appears to provide nicely. Another benefit in my case is that I'm using a NoSQL database where separating the encrypted value from its indexed value is not always practical, so having a single value that serves both purposes is highly desirable.

I'm not familiar with the other schemes you mentioned, but the practical reason for using AES-SIV is the converse of yours for not using it: there's an implementation for JavaScript. :) It's unlikely there are implementations for the other schemes you listed.

I agree that the Bloom filters are a nice natural outcome of your approach, though it would also be possible to combine AES-SIV for primary encryption with a truncated HMAC for partial match Bloom filters.

piotrkaminski··on Building Searchable Encrypted Databases with PHP and SQL
Why not just use AES-SIV instead of separate encrypted and HMAC fields?
piotrkaminski··on American Trees Are Moving West
So basically they're moving west because there's more space there? ;)
piotrkaminski··on American Trees Are Moving West
Actually, no, it doesn't. The subtitle (!) is:

> Climate change only explains at least 20 percent of the movement.

So what explains the other 80%?

piotrkaminski··on Badger – A fast key-value store written natively in Go
Very interesting, thanks for the answer! For the application and data structure I have in mind, I expect to need lots of range iteration over small values (<32 bytes?) and relatively infrequent writes, so Badger might not be a good fit. At a minimum sounds like I'd need to set up my own benchmarks.
piotrkaminski··on Badger – A fast key-value store written natively in Go
I'm curious if you have any more details here, or comparable benchmarks to share. BoltDB uses B+ trees and you say that a B+ tree approach is worth investigating due to improvements in SSD random write performance, so does BoltDB falsify that hypothesis or do you think it's just not well implemented and the idea still has potential?
piotrkaminski··on South Korean President Impeached
Thanks, that's some useful history to know. Any data points from other countries?
piotrkaminski··on South Korean President Impeached
> are we proposing education testing before casting a vote?

I'm curious, have there been any known attempts to condition the right to vote on passing some kind of IQ, education, or rational thinking test? If so, how did they work out?

piotrkaminski··on Electronic meters’ false readings up to six times higher than actual consumption
I believe https://getservice.com is the "deal-with-humans-as-a-service" you're looking for, taking a 30% cut of recovered money. I haven't personally used them, though.
piotrkaminski··on US Customs block Canadian man after reading his Scruff profile
I'm sure you'd be made to divulge the new passwords, but at least the passwords stored in their database -- that could be accessed by god-knows-who -- wouldn't be usable for the weeks or months between cross-border trips.
piotrkaminski··on US Customs block Canadian man after reading his Scruff profile
OTOH, not changing all your passwords after having to divulge them under duress is pretty careless, too.
piotrkaminski··on Codebrag – Daily code review tool
Reviewable supports per-file (and per-revision) check-offs. :) (Disclosure: I built it.)
piotrkaminski··on Announcing GVFS: Git Virtual File System
Check out Reviewable, it's influenced by my fond memories of Critique but designed specifically for git (and GitHub).
piotrkaminski··on In Marin, if you speed on your bicycle you're now going to get a ticket
I'm curious: since AFAIK one doesn't need a driver's license to ride a bike, what's the legal justification for the police demanding to see it?
piotrkaminski··on International Entrepreneur Rule
> However, the US does not recognize any other country's preferred retirement saving.

This is not completely true: Canadian RRSPs are recognized by the IRS at the federal level due to a tax treaty, though may not be recognized by all states. (For example, I had to figure the interest on the investments for my California return, until I decided to sell the RRSPs to simplify my life.) Other countries may get special treatment for their tax-deferred retirement accounts via a tax treaty too, though it can be tricky to ascertain -- you may end up actually having to read the treaty!

piotrkaminski··on People's underestimation of AI
You may well be right, but it's pretty common to initially overestimate the pace of progress ("it'll be ready in 15 years" for 100 years running) only to severely underestimate it later on ("it feels premature"). Given the recent evidence of unexpectedly early breakthroughs in AI ("it'll take another 10 years to beat humans at Go") I think it's not crazy to ask whether the inflection point has been reached.
piotrkaminski··on World Energy Hits a Turning Point: Solar That's Cheaper Than Wind
The article claims that today is that day, at least for new installations:

> That’s record-cheap electricity—roughly half the price of competing coal power.

piotrkaminski··on Introducing review requests
AFAICT the PR review REST API is still on their "near-term roadmap" (https://developer.github.com/early-access/platform-roadmap/).
piotrkaminski··on Introducing review requests
Heh, I never cease to wonder at the variety of -- often contradictory -- code review workflows. For me and many others automatically disappearing comments are a misfeature, since we _want_ to verify that a comment was correctly addressed. To each their own... :)
piotrkaminski··on Introducing review requests
FWIW https://reviewable.io supports arbitrarily complex review completion requirements, and the outcome gets fed into a PR status that you can make required as well. Right now the completion condition must be self-contained but I'm considering passing in designated metadata files so you could have, e.g., per-directory "owners" like Google does.

(Disclosure: I'm the founder.)

piotrkaminski··on Donald Trump’s Contract with the American Voter [pdf]
It'll definitely make it harder to buy (a meaningful number of) politicians. It'll also filter out bad ideas, but I'm afraid it'll also filter out the good ones. After all, there is research (which I'm too lazy to look up right now) that shows that as the size of a committee grows, their output tends towards mediocrity. But I dunno, perhaps mediocrity is what we actually want in government? (Not being sarcastic.)
piotrkaminski··on Donald Trump’s Contract with the American Voter [pdf]
I applaud the principle, but I think having 6400 (320M / 50K) members of the House of Representatives may be a little much to get actual work done.
piotrkaminski··on A list of headless web browsers
Yup, I'm seeing the same thing. Weird.
piotrkaminski··on Turning off syntax highlighting
Not true: https://www.gitkraken.com/download
← PreviousPage 6 of 9Next →