HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

pipo234

860 karma · joined October 20, 2022

submissionscomments
pipo234··on Apple Confirms iOS 17.4 Disables Home Screen Web Apps in the European Union
Funny that Apple manages to pitch this change first and foremost as an (unfortunate, but necessary) change to users in the EU. That is not what this is, that is not the impact it has.

It's going nuclear, scorched earth, FUD on any viable alternative to native apps paid and served via the Apple app store.

Yes, it's a bit of a downgrade for European Apple users, but the impact for developers targeting "the world" is far bigger.

pipo234··on Is something bugging you?
Most of the software I've built doesn't have "a spec.", but let me zoom in on specs. around streaming media. MPEG DASH, CMAF or even the base media file format (ISO/IEC 14496-12) at times can be pretty vague. In practice, this frequently turns up in actual interoperability issues where it's pretty difficult to point out which of two products is according to spec and which one has a bug.

So yes, I totally agree with GP and would actually go further: a phrase like "we found all the bugs in the database" is nonsense and makes the article less credible.

pipo234··on Acoustic cameras can see sound (2023) [video]
Ah yes! You're right! I completely forgot about the deceleration exhaust.
pipo234··on Promoting Europe's Independence in Web Search
As a proud EU citizen, I'm embarrassed to admit this € 8.5M project looks like complete vapourware.
pipo234··on Acoustic cameras can see sound (2023) [video]
As a linguist, I liked the novel but I totally agree the "first contact" aspect is pretty shoddy. The microbes magic is like a necessary evil to explain why we suddenly can (and must) go interstellar.

The story also includes some "unaddressed magic", like how come Rocky find Grace "at" (orbiting) Tau Ceti? Like we would instantly detect an alien space ship entering "our solar system" because "we're there too".

pipo234··on Why doesn't Apple do servers?
> Apple laptops are widely popular amongst developers

I'm not so sure they are popular for the right reasons, though. When targeting anything server-like developers quickly grab something like docker desktop as a kind of poor-man's Linux. Apple has no OS or cloud platform presence. Also, so far it has shown little interest in supporting Linux community hacking away on apple silicon (Asahi).

pipo234··on RustPython
Yes, C++ definitely tends to rely more on binary dependencies, shared objects. Rust will probably have to as well, once frameworks and libraries get to size and maturity that you want your OS vendor to take over responsibility (and compile time!). And note that even MUSL doesn't help create a package that works seamlessly on any Linux OS/release — maybe WASM will (or more accurately: WASI).

But I think, the point GP is making is more about the dependencies Python ads to your C++ (or Rust). Ie.: build RustPython project to produce artifact that works on my machine, but relies on my python interpreter, my (which may have C dependencies) as well as a rust edition and cargo. How can I bundle this into a package for a different Linux? Preferably do it following the existing packages and lore of that distro, rather some python and some rustup version?

pipo234··on Mozilla's new service tries to wipe your data off the web
GOOGLE?! So... left hand cleaning up the mess created by the right hand? Isn't that called a Ponzi scheme, or something?
pipo234··on Mozilla's new service tries to wipe your data off the web
Maybe some EU country would like to step in and offer this as a basic service to all their citizens? (I'm sure Mozilla would be happy to give a discount.)
pipo234··on EU right to repair: Sellers liable for 1 year after products are fixed
I believe a German (?) court recently ruled that sending a do-not-track header in HTTP request is sufficient. So essentially, a website showing a cookie banner despite a visitor already expressing her/his preference using DNT, is a malfunctioning website.

Now all we need is some carrots or sticks to nudge companies to fix their websites. Like fines or decreased search ranking.

pipo234··on EU right to repair: Sellers liable for 1 year after products are fixed
Regulation "failures" are mostly about the wording, the how; less about what and why.

I guess rather than regulating cookies, they meant to regulate tracking. Or maybe even regulate targeting, rather than tracking.

The cookie banners are mostly a tragedy, everyone agrees that modal, blocking cookie banners were never the intention. But the giants definitely had something to gain by suggesting they "were forced" to harass visitors.

pipo234··on YouTube and Spotify won't launch Apple Vision Pro apps, joining Netflix
I think the fact that apps are available for Meta's products show that (at the time) there was confidence into a potential growth category. And (currently) there is no confidence that Apple's product makes any commercial sense (in the near future). This is even emphasized by Apple clearly launching this in small quantities with excessive margins.
pipo234··on PeerTube v6
I don't have stats either, but working for a company that offers the shuffles for that kind of monetization for streaming media (jitm packaging and remix, drm, personalized ads, live2vod) and enthusiastic Podcast listener I tend to believe quite the opposite. (Jit ad insertion is popular in video (ie FAST) but we barely ever sell this to audio shops)

Dominant (tech) podcasts seem to favour focus on production, not distribution. Spotify went in guns ablaze and mostly failed. Personally targeting outside walled gardens often misses basic stuff like ads in a matching language. Content catalogue is billboard-irrelevant class. Nothing remotely near classic product placement or creator curated ads.

pipo234··on FBI director admits they rarely have probable cause for using NSA collections
Brilliant. I particularly liked the first comment (Anonymous Coward):

> Wray meant:

> Of course, we have probable cause.

> We always have probable cause for everything we do–well, mostly anyway.

> Well, I mean, we could maybe get probable cause, but it’s too complicated and it takes too long.

> You see, by the time we find an excuse that might double for probable cause, so much time will have passed, that we will all have died of old age.

> And that’s assuming we can really find an excuse in the first place.

pipo234··on Replacing HLS/Dash – Live Mass Fanout with Media over QUIC
Looks like a Will Law (of DASH fame) pet project. Interesting to see where it will lead. Seems to have sponsorship from some industry heavyweights Meta, Cisco, Twitch, Google, Akamai, Ericson. But notable absentee is of course: Apple (!)

https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-ietf-moq-transport/

pipo234··on Ubuntu Pro Shenanigans
It's nice that there is a work-around. This time. And the next time. I for one use System76' Pop!OS derivative (which is great!), but that might ultimately play out like a RHEL <-> CentOS/Rocky/Alma drama.

It will take another while, but it looks like Debian is our last hope for community linux (in apt ecosystem).

pipo234··on AOMedia Announces Royalty-Free IAMF Audio Container Specification
Interesting! Had a look at the spec [1] which looks a lot like AV1. Has the same OBU elementary stream concepts, ISO 14496-12 bindings, codec param string, the whole enchilada. What's missing so far is DRM (common encryption), but I'm sure they're already working on it.

[1] https://aomediacodec.github.io/iamf/

[EDIT] Compared to AC4, dts:X same stuff all done differently, as though you see them maneuvering around the patents minefields.

pipo234··on C++23: Removing garbage collection support
Good riddance!

So the proposal was sponsored by HP, Symantec and Intel. I was expecting something related to Microsoft and it's ill conceived idea of "Managed C++", but it all boils down to: Hans Boehm.

As surprised as the next guy to find this in C++ standard. ...Again: good riddance.

pipo234··on AV1 video codec gains broader hardware support
> Was it all but dead because people thought h264 was good enough, until 2.5 and 4k became more prominent in media consumption?

(Lack of) a compelling use case certainly played a role. Sure, reducing bandwidth is in itself a noble (and potentially profitable) goal but why fix it if it ain't broken? Ie.: the h264 infrastructure for HD was already there, working fine.

Another factor was that HEVC was full of new patents and the patent pool licensing costs hadn't yet settled.

pipo234··on AV1 video codec gains broader hardware support
+1 Indeed.

Compared to other standards in streaming media, I'd say that AOMedia has found adoption a lot quicker. h265 (HEVC) was all but DoA until years after it's introduction Apple finally decided to embrace it. It is still by no means ubiquitous, mostly due to patent licensing, which significantly drives up the price of hardware in single digit dollars price range.

Anecdotally, consider that Apple's HTTP Live Streaming protocol (till version 6) relied on MPEG2TS, even though Apple lay the groundwork for ISO/IEC 14496-12 Base Media File Format aka MP4. The reason was that chips in the initial Iphones had only support for h264 using mpeg2 transport streams, and even mp4 -> mp2 transmuxing was considered too resource intensive.

pipo234··on Sorry, Elon Musk but in Sweden we have a system
Quoting from the automated translation:

> In general, patience is a little too great with greedy employers. "Making a mistake" or "not knowing" is, in the eyes of too many, an okay excuse when an employer does not fulfill its part of an agreement or does not follow the law.

I wonder how this attitude relates to reports of extremely high injury rates in Tesla's German factories. Those high rates are (allegedly) not caused by lack of safety measures, but by legal obligation to report all incidents. Ie. working conditions might be / are probably worse in Tesla's Texas plant, China, ....

pipo234··on The risk of RISC-V: What's going on at SiFive?
You're absolutely right of course and I stand corrected.

I was thinking of the cool, companies (Silicon Graphics, Apple, NeXT, BeOS) and high end stuff (SUN, Hewlett Packard, DEC), of the pre-WinTel era. When CPUs had one core, integrated memory and periphery controllers and even floating point co-processors weren't ubiquitous and "graphics cards" did not include a "GPU".

Acorn worked with a single company (VLSI) to produce the first ARM chips. When ARM came of age, there wasn't a complex "foundry ecosystem" where dozens of companies specialize in different stages of what results in a SoC.

pipo234··on I face investigation for terrorism
I see why that sentence is considered over the line, but in context it does not sound like he's endorsing another holocaust.

> To be entirely plain.

> I have always viscerally opposed war. I have dedicated my life to conflict resolution and reconciliation.

> But in the coming Gaza genocide, every act of armed resistance by Hamas and Hezbollah will have my support.

> If that is a crime, send me back to jail.

https://twitter.com/CraigMurrayOrg/status/171333500612114051...

I think he's clearly very angry and upset about the violence inflicted upon Gaza population and it's difficult to keep heads clear and calm.

But let's not jump from "armed resistance" to "another holocaust".

pipo234··on The risk of RISC-V: What's going on at SiFive?
> I think it's an example of a company suited for venture capital.

I guess it makes sense from the investment angle. Ie. need to grow, and need to grow fast, therefore need for lots of cash, therefore need for risk takers.

But at the same time not so much so for the angle of is growth realistically possible for this type of company? It took ARM over 30 years to organically grow with ups and downs to what it is today, in an age where the foundry landscape was much less complex wand wild chip design innovations were much more common. (We had SPARC, PowerPC, MIPS, PA-RISC, Alpha AXP, i960, 68k, Itanium, Transmeta in the nineties.)

From what I read, SiFive had broad ambitions and wasn't very focused. Not sure if it is viable, but expecting it to turn $$$ into competitive chip designs in a couple of years was a bit of a stretch.

pipo234··on The risk of RISC-V: What's going on at SiFive?
Sounds like they were basically a victim of venture capital. First the pressure to grow (too) rapidly, then the gutting for failure to deliver. Growing a company with wild ambitions sustainably is hard. I feel sorry for the employees that tried.

And of course 9 women can't deliver a baby in one month.

pipo234··on DRM-free e-books are a big deal (2019)
> Problem with this is it means you are giving money to providers that sell with DRM

Indeed. And also do not underestimate the cost of adding DRM to media. Don't know about ebooks, but for streaming media I would estimate about half the engineering time spent designing, building and maintaining video work flows is somehow related to CENC, CBCS, Widevine, Playready, Fairplay and the whole ecosystem of third party consultancy around this.

For larger platforms these investments are worthwhile, but I don't think it's a coincidence that smaller audio shops and podcasts generally avoid DRM for streaming audio (where margins are smaller than Live/On demand video streaming).

pipo234··on [dead]
Lack of specifics and context and utter absence of links to sources indeed strongly suggests this was a GPT-generated click bait.
pipo234··on How to Download and Install Linux
> The overhead of booting windows maybe once a year?

No way!

If you were to boot into Windows only once a year, I'm sure there will be a couple of updates waiting to be installed, forcing you to boot into Windows at least twice a year ;-)

pipo234··on GPSJam: Daily maps of possible GPS interference
Some serious interference around areas of military tension: East Mediterranean, Black Sea South-West, Baltic Sea. Scary.
pipo234··on Metric Time
To quote yet another time format: NTP 64-bit timestamp format (rfc8877), which is 32 bits seconds since epoch + 32 bits fixed point second fractions. (Outside of Network Time Protocol, you'll find this baby for instance in ISOBMFF ProducerReferenceTimeBox(prft)).

Here seconds are just 1/(24*60*60) of a day as expected, but the base 2 fixed point part, where a tick "is roughly equal to 233 picoseconds" makes you want to pull your hairs out if you just want to accurately express milliseconds. (Similarly for other timescales frequently used in media processing, like 90kHz, 25, 60 or 29.97)

The answer to all this is of course: hand waving — "you don't need that". Your time can be perfectly accurate in itself (ie. an accurate discrete sample of continuous time), even if no accurate conversion exists to some other time system.

← PreviousPage 4 of 14Next →