HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

pknight

622 karma · joined January 9, 2011

submissionscomments
pknight··on The Batteriser Explained
Yep, voltage on the eneloops by comparison is 1.2V. Lots of battery operated toys work better with 1.5V batteries. There are rechargeable alkalines that provide 1.5V but they are very unreliable and the rest of the rechargeable AA market is lower voltage. So batteriser would be pretty neat if it works as advertised.
pknight··on WooThemes joins Automattic
The number one reason is because it is FOSS, easy to install, easy to use and easy to extend. The thriving themes and plugins ecosystem is the result of the platform becoming popular because of the aforementioned. If it wasn't FOSS WordPress wouldn't be where it is today.
pknight··on WooThemes joins Automattic
Usually an acquisition spells trouble for the product's users, but this is a different kind of situation. I think WooCommerce and Sensei will only get better as a result. The only folk who have to worry is the people building competing products.
pknight··on Another new era of WordPress
I think about the future of WordPress a lot. Like what would WP look like if it was mostly JS? When I look at all the front-end developments (React etc), it's really hard to gauge. On one level I'd love to see things become more framework agnostic and flexible. The json api in theory frees up a lot of restrictions in what devs can do with WP running as a backend. Even cooler if we can switch out Mysql with other kinds of databases.

But it's kind of interesting, for all PHP's warts, it has made it so easy to build things, allowing a huge amount of plugins and themes to develop. For all these years, devs didn't need to worry about the latest library, from backbone to angular, from react to mithril etc. It's the stability and ease of access that has been so important to growth.

Now that the web is so javascript oriented it's really compelling to just think about how WP can adapt to it. But a big push toward adopting new methodologies just strips away the number one reason to develop with WordPress: the huge ecosystem that has solutions coded with PHP. And if you are going to create that rift, you might as well start with some other platform.

But it's really hard to pick a winner now, React for example, could easily be overtaken by another lib in a years time. We're unsure how Nodejs is going to develop. The json API's current state is not superfast or fully developed yet.

I sometimes wonder that we're underestimating the advantages of having something stable like PHP continuing to run at least part of the show. For example, I have yet to see any kind of theme (A WP theme or otherwise) coded with some kind of front-end oriented mvc setup that results in a qualitatively superior site experience.

pknight··on The cold fusion race just heated up
The specifics of Rossi's contraptions may be kept private and shady, but the process involved is not something that only Rossi has been working on. Lenr itself is contentious still but there are so many groups working on it now, including Nasa. If some Russian scientist can independently reproduce an effect and he publicizes all the methods used it may be the start of acknowledging the effect as something that is no longer magical because more groups can start to replicate. That is newsworthy to me. Is that fair? I think so.

> This is a snake oil peddler with a secret black box

Perhaps, but you say that with no actual proof other than speculation and an a priori belief that it cannot be true. Is that much better than reporting on a phenomenon that is not yet understood.

Personally I think if there's a scam it may be that Rossi overstates how stable or viable his technology is. I think the phenomenon is probably real and not yet explained, just based on the number of groups that are working on this for considerable time now. Instead of blowing over, there are more and more groups starting work on it as the years have gone by.

pknight··on The cold fusion race just heated up
I'm merely responding the parent comment who is basically saying don't report anything that hasn't been fully understood yet. It's bizarre.

In this case, if the effect involved is real, it is real without being understood. Just like electricity was not understood. Just because all the answers aren't there doesn't make the effect any less valid or newsworthy. It's a narrow view to take.

And as far as what the inventor won't tell us, sure. But the story is that someone else has recreated similar measurements using what is known about the setup. Potentially a big deal.

pknight··on The cold fusion race just heated up
Any new discovery should not be mentioned in the press before it is fully understood then?
pknight··on The cold fusion race just heated up
On the face of it, it does sound really bad, yes. However, the E-Cat is a longstanding project and whatever the nature of the process behind the anomolous results, it is gaining an increased amount of attention from groups working around the world, including NASA. If the independent replication attempt is the real deal any group of scientists will be able to investigate and verify it now, because the details are provided out in the open.

And the implications are enormous. If the process is real and robust it will mark the start of a new era in energy generation. It's a total game changer.

I have been following the E-Cat for a while and it has all the hallmarks of a scam, an incredibly elaborate scam if it proves the case. But it also could be a real revolution in the making. I think that makes it worth reporting on. Especially if this replication turns out to be valid.

pknight··on "Open Source is awful in many ways, and people should be aware of this"
It's a shame that ones personal experiences result in generalizations that are then attached to Open Source. People can and will be assholes in any kind of project or group. That has not got a lot to do with Open Source. It would be fairer to say: "I had many bad experiences with the Open Source communities I was involved with".
pknight··on The economics of a web-based book
tldr; Author gives away work for free, navel gazes in detail about how many people didn't compensate the author, argues that they should because it is in their best interests. I hope I spared someone the bore. Also included, a rant about adblockers and how bad they are for the web.

My advice: if you want to see book sales, just put a price on your work. And it's not the only way to benefit from a book, financially or otherwise. Spare the world another boring rant how everybody should adapt to make it easier for content creators to get paid. If the ad industry had any kind of self control, people wouldn't have to go through the trouble of installing an adblocker. But we don't live in such world, so why not move on. Not only does an adblocker spare you from having to see ads you'd never engage with any way (and which would otherwise be wasting away precious seconds of your life) you get faster loading pages that are vastly safer. It's in content creators best interests to find ways to fund their work that are also in the best interests of the reader.

The real question is, how to make money providing content. There are many viable answers. Ranting about how people don't behave the desired way is a useless exercise.

pknight··on Ads work by cultural imprinting, not emotional inception
After 5 years of getting my degree in psychology the dirty little secret I have found is this: all of the persuasion studies are incredibly appealing to marketers and the general pop and also the researchers who are incentivized by money and reputation. Making deep insights is akin to crack for a scientist.

But the truth is most effects and mechanisms are overemphasized and exaggerated, because it makes a more compelling story. That is not to say that many of the mechanisms and factors that are reported aren't real or influential, it's just that they are over-hyped, over-appreciated or less understood than the academics reporting these studies back to the public care to admit.

You are putting far too much weight on the power of association in advertising. Much of the benefits of branding can be explained in a much more parsimonious manner. If given the choice between a and b, you will probably pick the one that is more familiar to you. Advertising works best if it gets people's attention. If you think people drink Dos Equis because people subconsciously think it will make them as cool as the Dos Equis man, you've been drinking the Koolaid. No, it works because it's funny, memorable and it gets a lot of exposure.

pknight··on Ads work by cultural imprinting, not emotional inception
> That's why if you want to reach a goal, you should tell as many of your friends and family about it as possible so you risk "losing face" if you fail.

If only that were the case, that would be grand. The opposite tends to be true more of the time. http://www.psych.nyu.edu/gollwitzer/09_Gollwitzer_Sheeran_Se...

pknight··on Your Treadmill Desk Is Over. Now It's All About the Hamster Wheel
I hope this is not meant to be serious.
pknight··on Fast, lightweight desktop manager written in AutoHotkey
The one hosted there is very limited. You can't move windows from one virtual desktop to the next for one. Mdesktop is pretty light weight.
pknight··on I disagree with Turing and Kahneman regarding the strength of statistical evidence
The fact is current day parapsychological research is far more scrutinised than regular research in the social sciences, because of the controversial implications and because there is a large group of people that simply won't entertain the possibility of positive results.

The most prominent paranormal researchers employ far more skeptical rigour than other skeptical commentators who dismiss any finding. Because it's called "paranormal" the default is "there must be something wrong with the methods" and so naturally people find fault with the methods. Hypothetically, even if real paranormal effects are surfacing in the data, the nature of the research works against persuading certain circles.

pknight··on Don’t do what you love
Author actually is doing what she loves and succeeding, by the way.

Any advice should not be taken in a vacuum. It doesn't make it bad advice because it doesn't solve all of life's problems. The point with the notion of doing what you love (and the money will follow) is that too many people are miserable in their jobs. That's an incredible waste. It's much easier to succeed if you love what you do. Of course that doesn't give anyone immunity to life's realities. But if you hate what you do, you've certainly got it all wrong.

I don't think too many people are that naive to think that all they need to do is to solely focus on what they love doing and everything else will line them up with success and wealth, just because.

But make no mistake, if you love what you do, if you are passionate, you are going to do better work than the other sucker who hates what he does (and only does it for the money/security).

pknight··on Decentralization: I Want to Believe
You make a lot of cynical, flawed assumptions. People do care about security and the increases to the degree of their awareness. But whether people care or not about security/decentralized implementations is irrelevant. People may not necessarily care how it's implemented, doesn't mean that the implementation is therefore any less important. That's developer's jobs to fix.

The challenge remains to create something that is simple and convenient to use and is at the very least on par with popular alternatives. Nothing more than that. Counting all the ways a decentralized implementation in principle is going to supposedly struggle without mentioning a longer list of problems with centralized systems is being excessively negative and cynical and for what purpose?

pknight··on Evidence of massive-scale emotional contagion through social networks
The physics measurements are interesting for different reasons. Those are measuring very objective things, even if measurements vary, they vary for ways we can conceivably calculate. Some physicists even raise the idea that certain constants aren't that constant.

But it's still vastly different to appreciate statistical data coming from those kinds of experiments and those that touch on psychology and social effects. Your height/nutrition example is convenient because we all can appreciate an effect expressed in objective units such as cm that we can see with our eyes. It's much harder to weight the effect that, say emotional states, have in pure numbers.

I could continue this discussion endlessly, probably not going to get anywhere with it.

pknight··on Evidence of massive-scale emotional contagion through social networks
I think you continue to miss both my points. If you're measuring apples falling to the ground, of course you wouldn't expect effect size to diminish with higher N. But social/psychological studies are not like a physics study, you have far less control over variables. This is especially true with a large N, where there is a noisier environment with more variables coalescing, typically, you get less precision over what you can say about impacted individual datapoints.

I wouldn't argue that a larger effect size here wouldn't be more impressive, of course it would. I'm just saying that a small effect size for a study of this kind does not diminish it's meaningfulness and that it's to be expected for these kinds of studies. There's an effect, that we're very confident is real, works in both directions and has real world implications.

pknight··on Evidence of massive-scale emotional contagion through social networks
> These do in fact get smaller with increasing sample size, whereas an effect size that diminishes with increasing sample size is solid evidence that the effect is not real

The realness of an effect is not just judged by the effect size. If you have more confidence over the result (lower P and/or higher N). You can run most accepted psychological effects done with smaller sample sizes over a much greater sample size and expect to see a smaller effect size. If the effect size dissipates and the P increases, that's where you have the biggest problem. If your confidence grows bigger in proportion to the lowering of the effect size, you still should have greater trust in the realness of the effect.

The core of my point though is that looking at effect size and thinking it is not meaningful can be distorting things a bit here. A smaller numerical expression that involves a large data set does not capture the actual meaningfulness of the impact the effect has on a single person to person interaction.

pknight··on Evidence of massive-scale emotional contagion through social networks
No, what is meaningful is not what the effect size (a number) is measuring, it's just a statistical metric. So in this case, I think it's clearly meaningful if humans have the power to impact other humans inner-state non-verbally. For example, if one smile to a stranger makes their inner-state more positive, that's impactful and they then have the same power for their emotional state to impact others. A trivial encounter can, in such, make a significant positive or negative impact. This study proves that the effect is extremely robust in both directions.

Effect size tends to get smaller the bigger the sample size for any kind of psychological/sociological study. This was a study of over half a million N, most studies use < 1000. In other words, the effect size is impressive despite looking small.

Side note: It's interesting to note that paranormal researchers often get criticized for finding small effect sizes in their studies. (Part of that is thinking that it's more likely due to chance or noise) For all intents and purposes, if you believe the effect to be real but small, it would still have paradigm changing consequences on how we view the way brains work, a radical departure from what mainstream science currently believes. It's another example of why a small effect size can be incredibly interesting, course altering even.

pknight··on Evidence of massive-scale emotional contagion through social networks
A "small" effect size doesn't make it any less interesting or less impressive. If anything it underlines how even the most trivial human interactions can make a meaningful impact, positively or negatively.
pknight··on WordPress for app development
By own admission, I'm a bit of a WP fan boy, but this was a stellar example of putting forth a constructive criticism about WP (in this case, for App usage). Almost all WP sentiments here tend to have obnoxious/negative/histrionic/elitist/brash/shortsighted qualities, so it's refreshing to see a balanced perspective padded with actual reasoning.
pknight··on Scoop: A Glimpse Into the NYTimes CMS
Do you have any data that actually indicates a move away from off the shelf cms-es?

There is always a case for building a custom CMS and some companies go that route. That has been case since the WP/Joomla/Drupals off the world came into existence. I don't see a trend though, in fact I think all 3 of those are growing.

For some companies a custom CMS just makes the most sense. It doesn't really reflect anything on the off-the-shelf cms-es.

And static site generators are not exactly taking off like crazy either, in terms of growth.

Choice is always good though. In that respect, I agree that there is a renaissance There are lots of great ways to run a site now. There are some nice looking CMS platforms and the popular platforms continue to mature as well. It's good stuff all around.

pknight··on VersionPress – Version Control Plugin for WordPress
I am also skeptical of this plugin but I think almost all of your points are moot.

There is big market for a solution that lets users backup and restore the filesystem and a database on a more granular level. Not being able to easily and conveniently revert changes that are made easily is one of the biggest pain points in managing a WordPress site. If you update WordPress and find that a critical plugin doesn't work, there is no convenient way to undo the update. Of course, ideally, these kinds of things are tested on a staging server first, but the truth is only a minority of sites utilize a staging server in this manner.

A lot of pain around websites is dealing with changes to the filesytem and database. To have a simple way of tracking changes and reverting changes is a boon. Both normal end-users and developers will jump for joy with a unified tool for this.

You can't compare this with many of the existing backup solutions either. You get far more detail (which helps with debugging) and far more incremental control when you have something git-like managing it all.

I'm pretty sure the solution would not be dependent on being accessible from a site's WP backend. But then, I don't know the specifics yet.

I don't see the problem raising money through crowdfunding for this either, from their point of view. It's a sound business strategy that validates a market and provides some investment.

My hesitation is this, we have no idea if they even have the skills to pull something like this off. Because it's not going to be easy. The WP environment can really vary from one site to the next (different server setups/different plugins/themes etc) and you have to make it work on them all. That's just a huge undertaking. I think you'd need a pretty big team with a ton of experience and a lot more than 30k to get close to pulling it off.

pknight··on Lego Ideas (Kickstarter for Lego sets)
I think at one point they had plans to do this and anybody would have been able to create and sell sets. This would have been amazing. I think they have changed their mind since, years have past and they now use a kickstarterish system for electing user-created models that are made available to the mass market. Not quite as exciting, but still forward thinking.

Of course you can use their designer tool to create models and order them yourself, but it works with a limited range of parts.

pknight··on Thoughts on Privacy: The right way forward
I think it's a flaw to bring in village life in pre-modern time in the context of the meaning of privacy. For one, in that context what information one shares is apparent and the impact of the information is more readily understood. This is not the case when large volumes of data are shared with unknowable powerful parties, used in unmonitored ways with effects that one cannot predict or control.

Secondly, we do not live in a small community, we have an incredibly interconnected world. Democracy does not function well when people lose the capacity to moderate access of information about ourselves, our thoughts and communications to some degree, when other parties may use that information against the individual. It stunts individual expression and that is pretty fundamental to living a modern society.

It's incredibly naive to undervalue the need and importance of privacy. Nightmare scenarios are not hypothetical to a lot of people, they are acting out right now, each and every day.

pknight··on Making Your Writing Work Harder For You
Well, pre-internet our family only ever had 1 set and they retain a very high base value even as they age, never felt a need to update to a newer set continually.

Point still stands though, are PG's essays devalued because he puts a year date on them? I don't think so.

pknight··on Making Your Writing Work Harder For You
The type of content does not matter, can you think of any significant written work pre-internet that purposely obfuscates when it was written? Even an encyclopedia isn't shy about when it's written.

If you want your content to appear valuable vs less valuable, write the hell out of your content. Make it impossible to discount the content by making it stand out.

In science, researchers don't cherry pick and refer studies written in the last 5 years. They go back as far is relevant. They will refer back to hallmark papers regardless how old. Same with nonfiction books. Same with well written blog posts, because good blog authors often cite references to give the proper context. That's kind of the point of blogging, the power of linking and building upon what has already written. But making a piece of content float in some unspecified time vortex disrupts that.

What's more is that a clear date indicates that the author wrote it at a certain time. It makes it harder to distinguish people that copy content or write about similar copycat ideas from their more original authors.

For what it's worth, I'm not against the idea of situating your content in the best way possible. I think using categorization like tutorials/articles/essays is a better way of framing certain types of content. That can help the reader. Hiding the date meta is an attempt to help the author, while hampering the reader. It doesn't even add up.

pknight··on Making Your Writing Work Harder For You
Care to provide some logic instead of downvoting all my comments?
← PreviousPage 5 of 11Next →