HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

placebo

1,002 karma · joined October 7, 2014

submissionscomments
placebo··on Soti – A $1B firm built in a basement
Thank you for a great idea for my next startup - an application to micromanage remote workers. It will be even better than office micromanagement since the boss will have a large screen where all the remote desktops will be visible and under control simultaneously and the boss will be able to assist remote developers get back on track should they ever consider taking any initiative or heaven forbid be creative. It will also make it much easier to spot activities that do not seem to be directly work related. I feel I'm really on to something :-)
placebo··on Customer's 20-year-old email account shut down over unusual address
I don't know, to me this sounds like a perfect scenario to let them know he's getting a good lawyer and justifiably suing them for damages if they intend to go through with it and delete his account. Sadly, in most cases abusers of power only stop when there's a steep price tag on it.
placebo··on Dissolving the Fermi Paradox [pdf]
I honestly don't understand how this issue is even arguable - I mean given that: a) We haven't seen any evidence of life outside this planet b) We haven't been able to reproduce life from scratch in a lab so we don't know the odds needed for it to occur, then Isn't it obvious that: c) We have absolutely no evidence whatsoever on which to base any range of probability regarding the existence of life outside this planet ? I'm not saying I think there isn't life outside this planet nor that I think there is - what I'm saying is that so long as points a) and b) stand, any statement on the matter is just wishful thinking, personal faith etc. It has nothing to do with scientific thinking. If you think it isn't obvious, I'm interested (seriously) to understand where the flaw in my logic is.
placebo··on Betelgeuse captured by ALMA
I think you underestimate the creativity of conspiracy theorists to explain away any contradicting fact :)
placebo··on Betelgeuse captured by ALMA
At the risk of uncovering my ancientness, I remember reading astronomy books as a kid which specified that stars are so far away that they can't appear as anything more than dots of light even when viewed through the largest telescopes. Always makes me wonder what can be achieved in the future, especially since we're probably somewhere on an exponential progress curve. Of course, assuming a lot of optimism about not cutting off the branch we're sitting on before that happens...
placebo··on Consciousness and its Place in Nature (2002)
Perhaps investigate what physicality is beyond the awareness of it. The only reason something objective exists is that there's a separate subject to say so. And no, this doesn't mean that nothing existed prior to human beings, it does mean however that the division of the world into "physical" vs "mental", "objective" vs. "subjective", "me" vs. "not me" was created by the human mind.
placebo··on Consciousness and its Place in Nature (2002)
That's a good question and the answer is that both the sun and the number 15 are concepts created by the mind because creating concepts has great survival value. You are conscious of these concepts. "Consciousness" itself is also a concept you are conscious of. We tend to confuse the map with the territory - perhaps because believing the reality of the map makes us more real and gives a sense of control over things - I wouldn't know. What I am convinced of is that consciousness (and I'm not referring to the concept of it) is not a product of the mind, but vice versa.
placebo··on How I learned to live with multiple personalities
I asked a friend who said that in the decades he has practiced psychiatry not only did he never have a patient with this diagnosis, but he also never met a colleague who did, so his personal opinion is that this is more of something meant for Hollywood scripts or attention grabbing articles than something that actually exists in the way it is portrayed.
placebo··on AlphaGo's next move
I find it interesting that AlphaGo improves its play by playing against itself. I wonder what the limits of this are.
placebo··on Standing Up to a Dangerous New Breed of Patent Troll
I hate patent trolls with a passion, but these non-practicing entities are are just another negative by-product of what has devolved to be a negative system. Patents originally existed to protect inventors. Today, like in other legal systems, they have very little to do with justice and a lot to do with "whoever has the gold makes the rules". As such, while I definitely side with CloudFlare, it does seem like a complaint of "not fair, they are manipulating the rotten system better than us"
placebo··on A Theory of Consciousness Can Help Build a Theory of Everything
Decades of struggling with the question and scrutinizing what others came up with :) Nothing I've mentioned though is original or new - just took some time to filter out the noise, look carefully and honestly and connect the dots.
placebo··on A Theory of Consciousness Can Help Build a Theory of Everything
You are referring to the soft problem of consciousness, which is not what the argument is about. I too am convinced that the hard problem of consciousness is beyond the scope of science. It is beyond science not in the sense that it violates the laws of physics but because when you get right down to it, your consciousness is the only "real" thing that you can ever know about. Everything else you supposedly "know" - every concept, every derived "laws" of physics are thought models which you only know by being conscious of them. A very crude analogy would be to say that consciousness is like a camera that enables science to be done, but the camera can't take a picture of itself.
placebo··on LuaJIT 2.0.5 and 2.1.0-beta3 released
> LuaJIT is such an amazing piece of software - apparently to such an extent that only Mike Pall fully understands some of its internals

Fully agree about the awesomeness of LuaJIT and incredible capabilities of Mike Pall, but also the reason I've stopped considering using LuaJIT for projects that should be "future proof". I think that depending on technology which can only be maintained by one genius is too much of a risk.

placebo··on Earth is a ‘dwarf planet’ because it has not cleared its orbit
I completely agree. It's so silly that I chuckle every time this argument comes up. Then again, people are so attached to their definitions and classifications in a way that it becomes part of how they define themselves, and therefore any suggested change is considered a personal threat. This of course is not limited to planets...
placebo··on Text Editor Performance Comparison
My experience has been the exact opposite. The latest version of UltraEdit easily handles large files that Notepad++ and Sublime Text 2 choke on. Didn't purchase Sublime Text 3 yet so the situation might be different there.
placebo··on We will no longer use the phrase “zero knowledge” to describe our software
>But I still must, ultimately, trust you, your competence, and your motivations.

This is true about any entity that has access to your data, including your bank, health insurance, or any other organisation which you have an account with. It is true that they don't say they can't access your data though...

Regarding their motivation - having developed a system with end to end encryption for sensitive information, I can tell you that the worst thing from both a business and professional perspective would be a data security breach - that gives quite a lot of motivation to get things right...

placebo··on We will no longer use the phrase “zero knowledge” to describe our software
I think in terms of catchy marketing phrases, its a good switch, considering they wanted one that sounds as good as the previous one yet does not clash with existing professional terminology. I remember thinking for a few seconds about what I would change it to back when reading criticism about them using the term "Zero Knowledge" and couldn't off the top of my head think of something different but still catchy. Seems obvious once it's thought of...
placebo··on The no excuses culture
While I agree with everything you wrote about "no excuses" being a side effect of a healthy frame of mind, and that in an ideal situation things should be motivated by passion and not by fear, I wonder if perhaps sometimes the amount of damage created from long exposure to a bad environment is not something that can be easily undone and one has to revert to the stick to achieve results. I wouldn't want to manage or be managed in such an organisation, , but I can imagine there are situations where discipline needs to be enforced when the culture is too far gone due to past mistakes. Using the analogy to human personality, you probably won't fix deep rooted pathologies or self destructive habits overnight by motivation talks. Maybe sometimes things have to be artificially straightened out because the time for a natural fix would just take too long.
placebo··on SJCL – Stanford JavaScript Crypto Library
If the goal was just end to end encryption, why was there a need for asymmetric keys? Couldn't the medical data have been directly encrypted via the password-derived AES key and stored on the server?
placebo··on Why Do Americans Refrigerate Their Eggs?
in Israel every egg carton has a stamp stating an expiry date if refrigerated and an expiry date if not.
placebo··on On Loneliness
> They say they're free from suffering, maybe they are, maybe they aren't, but they can't tell me how to repeat that in a way I can reproduce for myself.

If that were true, I'd take the same position as you do, but the good ones never tell you to trust them. In fact they insist that you look for yourself with brutal honesty and never trust any guru on their word. In fact, I see their conduct as the epitome of the scientific method, only directed at understanding what's at the core of the subjective experience. What experiments have you tried so far to claim that these are bizarre and baseless claims?

placebo··on On Loneliness
I assume you trust logic and empirical tests. Here's something that is both repeatable, and as empirical as it gets. Consider every instance of knowing anything "objectively". You will notice that consistently it is always first and foremost a subjective experience. You can't get around it. Thought is very quick to dissect, categorise, extrapolate etc. and then you create a division of the thinker, which you take to be yourself, and the things "out there" which are separate from you. You take your understanding of the world as absolute truth, while spiritual giants, dared to dig much deeper in a manner no less scientific than the greatest scientists the west has known, only directed it inwards instead of outwards and arrived at understandings which are no less remarkable than what scientists have. The difference is that they can't demonstrate it by getting a rover to mars, but by becoming totally free of any form of suffering caused by an incorrect understanding of reality, which I dare say is at least as impressive.
placebo··on Raymond Smullyan has died
My favorite too, and also my first encounter with his writings. Read it back in the eighties as it was one of the writings discussed in "The Mind's I". It was exactly the type of initial clarification I needed to read at the time and definitely shaped my understanding on what the term "God" might point to at a time when all the other options seemed petty and infantile to a curious and perplexed teenager.

Wow. Sad to hear about his passing. He set the initial path for much of my subsequent interests.

placebo··on Against Willpower
I once conveyed this belief to someone who had been through a path that is equivalent in difficulty to what the US nave SEALs have to go through. I told him that perhaps willpower is an illusion and it's basically has to do whether the net total of motivation is above or below zero given a set of circumstances. He answered that from his experience, motivation takes you up to a certain point but beyond it something else comes into play which he called willpower.

I don't take the personal experience and interpretation of a single person to be much evidence for the existence of this vaguely defined concept called willpower, but just thought this anecdote would be of interest

placebo··on Chrome Widevine DRM can no longer be disabled
I'd argue that companies don't care about anything as they are not sentient. The culture and morals of a company is an aggregate of the morals of the people that operate and make up these companies, so this "companies care for shareholders" being a free ticket to doing immoral things does not get anyone off the hook (morally speaking). Of course life is complex, things aren't black and white, etc. etc. but I still believe business can be successful without being evil (whether it was originally intended as marketing message or not)
placebo··on Python 2.8?
Back when python 3 was introduced and after learning of breaking backward compatibility my first thought was, "good luck with that"...

Wanting to create something better is not surprising. What was surprising (to me at least) is not seeing that people don't like change unless they see a really dramatic benefit to what they already have, and clearly see that the advantages to making that change far outweigh the discomfort of the process.

Most people have a really hard time changing from something they know, even if it's less than perfect. Actually, even if it sucks. Ask any marketer, salesman, social worker or psychologist and you will see this is not limited to programming languages, and beyond the psychology, change has an economic price that needs to be justified.

So, years later, the only thing I'm surprised at is that Python 3 actually caught on to the extent it did. I don't know whether to attribute this more to the quality of the language or the energy that went into promoting migration to it, but its current adoption rate to me is a mark of success when one tries to compare it with other attempts to reeducate a well established market.

placebo··on Calling bullshit
The fact that you are right about the possibility of taking other interpretations as non truth, does not mean that no opinions are simply misguided and not based on truth. In addition, there have been many articles that are simply made up, which has nothing to do with difference of opinion.
placebo··on Calling bullshit
You need to want to know what is true first, to care enough to take the trouble of knowing how to detect bullshit. I think the reason why bullshit is flourishing is because those that actually give a damn are the minority. The majority is composed of the useful idiots and those that manipulate them. Of course reality is never black and white, and it is much more nuanced than I've stated here, but I think that's the general gist of things
placebo··on Stanford Unsupervised Deep Learning Tutorial (2014)
Good to know, thanks. Guess I'm a bit of a dinosaur for not following social networks :-)
placebo··on Stanford Unsupervised Deep Learning Tutorial (2014)
I've also been following this book and it seems as if progress has stalled. The last sent chapter is incomplete and half baked, there is no response from the author in the book forum and errors in previous chapters remain unchanged.
← PreviousPage 9 of 14Next →