HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

plinkplonk

14,193 karma · joined February 20, 2007

Ravi Mohan

http://twitter.com/ravi_mohan , magicindian@gmail.com

Please feel free to email me about anything I can help you with! :)

submissionscomments
plinkplonk··on Google’s Shadow Work Force: Temps Who Outnumber Full-Time Employees
Why is this newsworthy? Genuine question. The article (I did read it!) doesn't seem to articulate why exactly this is a problem.

I think (happy to be convinced otherwise) it is ok for a company to have more temps than employees or vice versa. What does it matter? Is there a US cultural/social nuance that I'm missing?

plinkplonk··on Ask HN: Is the “The Art of Computer Programming” Worth the Investment?
These are awesome. Thanks for posting.
plinkplonk··on Ask HN: Which books teach mental models?
+ 100.

the idea that sustained practice till you become fluent in the use of specific mental models is missing in much of the literature.

Just like learning any other skillset, using mental models effectively takes a lot of work.

This is often the missing key to effective use. It is one thing to read about a mental model (say Donella Meadows's systems thinking), and be able to recall the material from memory and quote it and so on. It is quite another to be able to apply that model (here systems thinking) to real life situations and get useful results.

I know many people who can quote chapter and verse of literature about mental models, but their thinking remains confused and ad hoc when it comes to dealing with real life problems.

To practice, one can also apply mental models to case studies/situations from the past and compare to the outcome predicted by the model and the actual outcome.(To be fair, there is a risk of making mental models fit the known outcome here, so one has to be aware of that)

EDIT: (not the same as mental models, but since someone mentioned ARIZ/TRIZ above) Edward De Bono's "Serious Creativity" and "Lateral Thinking for Management" (yes terrible title) are full of thinking tools that can be practiced systematically. Most of his books are repetitive and have varying ratios of fluff to core material, but these two together have most of his useful ideas.

plinkplonk··on What Uber Left Behind in Asia
Uber still has a stake in Grab iirc. That might work out better than competing directly in SE Asia.
plinkplonk··on Learn more programming languages, even if you won't use them
" its because they know exactly 1 language ,"

which language is this? I'm guessing Python.

plinkplonk··on Rare Persian manuscripts dating back to 13th century now online
"Emperors Of The Peacock Throne" by Abraham Eraly

"Rebel Sultans" by Manu Pillai is a great complement, focusing on the Deccan, with a lot of material on how Iranian culture and politics influenced Indian history.

plinkplonk··on Twitter forces all new users to enter a valid phone number
fwiw, if you challenge this, twitter will restore your account.
plinkplonk··on How the Maker of TurboTax Fought Free, Simple Tax Filing (2013)
India doesn't do this yet, but it is set to be launched in a couple of years.
plinkplonk··on Google Employees Uncover Ongoing Work on Censored China Search
"I would consider India to be South Asia, not SE Asia"

ok. that's fair.

Do you consider Japan to be part of SE Asia? Taiwan? (Due disclosure, I've never lived either country - only transited through them - and don't follow their politics closely, but afaik they are both democracies with regular and fair elections).

In your opinion are these countries 'true' democracies? (fwiw, not trying to pick a fight, just trying to wrap my head around what you are really saying)

plinkplonk··on Google Employees Uncover Ongoing Work on Censored China Search
> There are no democracies in SE Asia.

I wonder if you consider India to be in SE Asia. If not, please ignore the following.

Last I looked there were regular elections happening there, with "strong leaders" being voted out of power with some regularity. They have problems (same as everywhere including the USA), but democracy / free elections aren't a problem (yet).

"Democracy has never worked in SE Asia" is an extremely strong statement, and in your comment, I find too many stereotypes about the region, and a shallow understanding. (paraphrasing -'some of them believe in karma and so democracy can't work there' is so ridiculous an argument that I wonder if you are doing it deliberately to provoke discussion. Makes about as much sense as saying that some catholics believe that a monarchy is the best form of government so elections won't work in Ireland)

plinkplonk··on As Uber Prepares to Go Public, Its Lead Lawyer Races to Clean It Up
yes, but the Ola app (last I checked) required access to all your emails and SMS messages and didn't function if these are not granted. When one of my friends contacted customer support he was told " but all your data is safe with us, why are you worried?"

(this was some time ago, I don't know what the status is today)

plinkplonk··on What I Learned at Activision
jasim is the person who posted the article to HN. Not the author of the article.
plinkplonk··on Interpreter for a simple Lisp, Written in Prolog
" they said that for those who use Prolog in production it is a real competitive advantage that they don't want to announce to the world;"

with due respect to prolog (which is a mindbending language), the proponents of every niche language say the same thing. "it is so powerful that users don't talk about it and that is why you don't hear about it"

I've heard many variants of this with respect to Forth, for example.

The reality is that devs can't stop talking about the languages, tools, and frameworks they use.

The simpler explanation is that next to no one actually uses prolog in productions, because it is, well, a niche language (which doesn't take away from its coolness)

Color me skeptical about "secret weapons".

plinkplonk··on Reflecting on My Failure to Build a Billion-Dollar Company
Sahil,

thanks for writing this article. very useful to me (as someone working on iteration 2 of a company).

(If you see this, could you please fix the paypal integration. In India, we don't have any protection if credit card data gets leaked, (and could end up paying off whatever the hacker charges the card) and I don't use my credit card online if I can help it

Thanks in advance)

plinkplonk··on India’s largest bank SBI leaked account data on millions of customers
Easy to be a fan when all the harm falls on other people on the other side of the world.
plinkplonk··on I'm going to work full-time on free software
Intuit (and others, I assume) lobbies strongly against this, and spends a lot of money to prevent this happening.
plinkplonk··on “In 2018 the blockchain/decentralization story fell apart”
"Stealth, space supremacy, global surveillance, carrier groups, strike wings, nuclear arsenals, reaper drones and all the other crazy battlefield robot tech in service or development can cut to pieces any obsolete nation state military, let alone some rebels armed with cheap 3d-printed guns. "

So why isn't the US (which has all this tech) winning in Afghanistan over some rebels with AK 47s? Likewise Vietnam after literally a decade of fighting.

Weapons superiority is one factor in winning wars. Likewise, to address the gp's point, the history of political organization is partly driven by military technology.

plinkplonk··on Why you should learn F#
>OCaml actually has excellent tooling — among the best

I don't think even the core OCaml devs would claim this. Rust (and Java and Microsoft) toolchains are examples of excellent tooling. OCaml, not so much.

That said, the tooling situation today in OCaml is much better than it was a few years ago, which is real progress.

plinkplonk··on Stop Learning Frameworks
I agree with everything you said.

I'd just like to add that the world is full of fascinating (yes, even tech/math/cs heavy) problems. If you find your problem (as distinct from the tech stack or whatever) boring, you could always find a different, cutting edge, problem to work on the next few years (or decades)

You might have to get a PhD/demonstrate extreme dev skills/build cutting edge software etc to get paid to work on such problems, but them's the breaks.

You don't have to 'settle' for boring domains/problems if you don't want to, but you do have to put yourself in a position to get paid to work on them, and some "soft skills" might come in handy (though I doubt the value of some books in that list. 'clean code'? bleh) .

plinkplonk··on Amazon’s Chips Threaten Intel
(Tangential) What I'd really like to see is a competitor to Google's TPU that I can actually buy (vs rent on the cloud)
plinkplonk··on What Happens When a Founder Is Fully Vested?
I have a question - Is founder vesting standard outside the valley/software startups?

If I and my partner set out to build (say) a restaurant franchise in Texas, do 4 year vesting schedules, cliffs, etc make their way into incorporation documents? How do things work in non-silicon-valley-startup businesses?

Either vesting is a part of standard business incorporation (in which case I don't see why it needs special discussion in a software startup context, we don't need to discuss whether a company should have annual or quarterly balance sheets, for example - such 'standard elements' are taken for granted) or it is highly software startup specific (in which case there might be interesting rationales for such provisions existing that are specific to software, software startups, or conventions of SV VCs)

plinkplonk··on Udacity lays off 125 people in global strategy shift
"all its incantations" - did you mean 'incarnations'? (though I like 'incantations'! )
plinkplonk··on Microsoft is Dead (2007)
Iirc (it's been a while since I read the article) I thought 'dead' was used to mean "they are not the dominant power in the world of software (in terms of tools, languages, leadership, driving change) etc, like they used to be in the nineties" not in the sense of "they are a declining company in terms of revenue or market value"

The present news just says Microsoft's market valuation is higher than apple's (today). Not sure if it really affects the central thesis of the article.

EDIT: literally the first paragraph of the article

"I was talking to a young startup founder about how Google was different from Yahoo. I said that Yahoo had been warped from the start by their fear of Microsoft. That was why they'd positioned themselves as a "media company" instead of a technology company. Then I looked at his face and realized he didn't understand. It was as if I'd told him how much girls liked Barry Manilow in the mid 80s. Barry who?

Microsoft? He didn't say anything, but I could tell he didn't quite believe anyone would be frightened of them."

People fear Facebook and Google and Amazon, if only for the immense amounts of damage they do to societies and polities. Who is afraid of MS (or IBM)? Do startup founders even think of MS as a factor in their plans (which seems to be what the article is about)

plinkplonk··on Perchance to Scheme (2016)
"Implementing a language that resembles Scheme is quite easy. Implementing call-with-current-continuation and hygienic macros AND getting the tricky little details correct is not."

(tangential) and this is where most "build your own compiler" style books fall down.

They teach you to implement ultra simple languages, but don't tackle memory management/garbage collection, concurrency, production grade typecheckers, and for lisplikes, macro systems, etc.

plinkplonk··on OCaml for the Masses (2011)
"For good or for bad, Javascript is the lingua-franca of computing today "

a very strong claim. There is a lot of 'computing' outside the browser.

lingua franca of front end web dev, I grant you, (almost by definition 'front end web dev' is mostly javascript).

plinkplonk··on The World, Built by China
"I wouldn't be surprised if India became the dominant power in the second half of the 21st century"

I would (Fwiw, I am in Indian, lived for years in the USA, now live in India). Aside from climate change, India has tremendous problems with respect to literacy, religious intolerance, lack of engineering/manufacturing skills (outside the space program) , emigration of its brightest young people etc etc.

Any nation can progress only when it has competent leadership for a few decades. In India, across political parties, we have utterly terrible leaders with little education and less common sense. If anything I (personally) predict India will decline as the century progresses. (imo ime, ymmv, etc, saying this before the super patriots of India(n origin) accuse me of being some kind of traitor to our glorious destiny)

plinkplonk··on OCaml for the Masses (2011)
"you didn't mention Scala"

my hypothesis (and it is only that) is that trying to unite FP and OO, as Scala tries to do, leads to unnecessary complexity in learning and usage. Also see 'tooling'.

That said, many impressive + widely deployed systems have been built with Scala, which is more than other typed FP languages can claim.

plinkplonk··on OCaml for the Masses (2011)
"The killer app for OCaml is front-end webdev with Reason."

I'll make a 1000$, 10 year bet with you that in 2028, if browsers still exist, ReasonML (or its successors) will be nowhere near mainstream status (which is the point we are discussing here). I like Reason, or at least the idea of it.

Javascript itself might incorporate more static typing in 2028 than today's version does, but I suggest the 'advances' will be relatively miniscule.

plinkplonk··on OCaml for the Masses (2011)
"I for one can't wait for Typed FP to become mainstream as soon as possible."

This will never happen till there is a typed FP language that has solid tooling, documentation, solid libraries for most common programmer tasks, a welcoming and active community and at least one of a killer app, or framework (Rails for ruby), killer platform (objective c/swift for AppStore dev) or targets an underserved domain (Julia for Scientific Computing).

The existing typed FP language implementations (OCaml, Haskell, SML, not sure of F#) are full of cruft and/or are just lacking with respect to one or more of the above.

Haskell comes the closest I think, but that maybe because I've been using Haskell for decades, and so I am biased in its favor (and I'd still hesitate before using it on a large team + long timescale project).

Try writing a 'mainstream' application in any of the above, and you'll see what I mean. Yes you can write a typical web app /CRUD app/mobile app in (say) Haskell, but to be honest, Yesod (say) is no Rails.

Reason might be 'the one' I guess, at least in bringing TypedFP to the javascript ecosystem, especially with FB's corporate backing.

Rust gets/is getting most of the above right, but it isn't really an FP language.

OCaml or Haskell being the mainstream will never happen imho. If there is a TypedFP mainstream language in the future, it is yet to be invented (or is being invented right now! touch wood).

What is more likely to happen is some FP features moving into mainstream languages. Not sure if that counts as "typed FP becoming mainstream", but it likely to be a long wait ;-)

I honestly don't see any typed FP language ever having the success of say, Python, for at least a few decades yet.

(all imho, ymmv, as it should)

plinkplonk··on Clojure at Netflix (2013) [slides]
which implementaions of SML are the production ready ones?
← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →