58,606 karma · joined May 4, 2014
-- RochefoucauldAI creations are going to be enjoyed or not, used or not, given attention or not, just like human creations, regardless of what we call them.
More and more I'm leaning towards seeing the whole category of "art" as nothing more than gatekeeping.
Some people just can't deal with that.
If genuine, unaided human creativity is so great then AI generated creations should not be much of a challenge.
The sad fact, though, is that a lot of human creation is really not that good in comparison, or at the least is slow and expensive, while AI creations are often cheap, fast, and good -- you can have all three.
I search for "how to do X", and instead of just showing me how to do it, which might take 30 seconds, they put a ton of fluff and filler in to the video to make it last 5 minutes.
Typical video goes something like:
0 - Ads, if you're not using an ad blocker
1 - Intro graphics/animation
2 - "Hi, I'm ___, and in this video I'm going to show you how to do X"
3 - "Before I get in to that, I want to tell you about my channel and all the great things I do."
4 - "Like and subscribe."
5 - "Now let's get in to it..."
6 - "What is X?"
7 - "What's the history of X?"
8 - "Why X is so great."
9 - finally... "How to do X"
Fortunately you can skip around, but it's still a bunch of useless fluff and garbage content to get to the maybe 30 seconds of useful information.
Vimscript's dominance in vim is one of the things that got me to switch to emacs when I got interested in Lisp and Scheme more than a decade ago.
Sure, even then I could write scripts for vim using Vim's scheme compatibility mode, but I'd probably be one of the only ones doing so. Pretty much everyone else was using vimscript.
In Emacs the whole ecosystem is in eLisp, so I'd feel right at home there, could naturally integrate other eLisp codebases/projects, could easily get help on anything related to working with eLisp in emacs.
If I'd written scheme scripts in vim my work would always be a second-class citizen in the vim ecosystem.
How's the vim ecosystem now? Is vimscript still dominant?
They would rather be entertaining themselves, being with their families, relaxing, etc.
Yet they have to work, and do things they don't want to do day after day, month after month, and year after year. On top of that they often have to pretend to like it, and to spend time with people they don't want to be with.
It's even worse if they have to commute or not get enough sleep, or if they're not valued at work or don't feel they can make a difference.
After a while, that takes its toll. Some can handle it, but some can't.
So there isn't even a phone number to trace.
This goes double for government-funded research, which the overwhelming majority of basic science research is.
I also recently came back to Crime and Punishment, and found that while it has some of the greatest passages I've ever read in any book, passages that are full of keen psychological penetration and empathy for deeply flawed people, there's also a lot of corny, cliche material in it: the murderer with a heart of gold, the prostitute with a heart of gold, the consumption poor mother sacrifices everything for her chldren, etc...
These sorts of characters might not have been cliche in the 19th Century, but they certainly are today.
I go on the assumption that anything I ever reveal on the internet will become public knowledge at some point.
But, yeah, I understand this is beyond the capabilities of your typical user, and not something most users even know exists.
This is really a UI/UX deficiency of IRC, not a functional deficiency.
Discord's logging is shitty because:
1 - The logs aren't yours, they're Discord's. If you get banned from the server, your server shuts down, or Discord bans you altogether your access to those logs is gone forever.
2 - Unlike the logs of some IRC channels, Discord's logs aren't available on the web anywhere, so they can't be indexed or searched outside of Discord.
3 - Paging through hours or days of Discord logs is so incredibly painful, because every few screenfuls or so Discord has to load the previous/next logs and that is super slow compared to paging through text logs offline. If you have a lot of logs to page through, this experience is absolutely atrocious.
4 - There's no easy way to export the logs to be processed with standard/powerful text manipulation tools, like text editors, sed, etc..
Discord's search is painful because:
1 - There's no regex search.
2 - No ability to search via web search engines, because the logs aren't available on any website (see above).
3 - No way to search through the logs of multiple servers at once.
I have IRC logs going back decades, from servers I haven't been on in decades, but they're all instantly searchable, and the text in them is easily manipulable.
My Discord logs are trapped in Discord and I'm forced to use Discord's pretty but otherwise horrible UI to search them.
No, the reason Discord is popular has nothing to do with logging, but everything to do with how easy it is to sign up, join, and get a server running. Inline images and not having to learn obscure IRC commands or figure out obtuse IRC clients are also huge plusses for your average user. Discord's client is also visually pleasing -- something that most IRC client developers still haven't figured out. Aesthetics matter to users, as Apple has proved.
But Discord is an information black hole where data goes to die.
Are you saying doing science is so hard the only way to succeed is to cheat?
This is a slap in the face to scientists doing honest work.
What you are measuring with an ohm meter is not visible to the naked eye. Electricity is not visible to the naked eye. Neither is heat. Neither are x-rays. Neither is math. Their effects might be, but they themselves aren't.
It's easy to come up with more examples of things not visible to the naked eye which are very useful.
Can you comment on Google's[1] and IBM's[2] announcements of 70 and 433 qubit quantum computers?
Is this just marketing hype? Are the qubits not fault tolerant? Is fault tolerance really necessary to get useful results?
[1] - https://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2023/07/02/google-quant...
[2] - https://www.technologyreview.com/2023/05/25/1073606/ibm-want...
I also much prefer to use Claude for explanations (I haven't experimented much with Claude+, but limited experiments have shown it to be even better) over the GPT's and other LLMs. It gives much more thorough and natural-sounding explanations than the competition, without extra prompting.
That said, the Claude variants don't seem to be as good at logic-puzzly sort of stuff that most people love to test LLMs with. So if you're in to that, you're probably better off with GPT4.
I also haven't tested it much with programming.. but I've been very disappointed with every LLM as far as my limited testing in that realm has gone.
Claude deserves to get more attention, and I eagerly await Claude 3.
By some definition of "worked". If we define "worked" as "made money for", who it worked mostly for are the middlemen and a minority of writers... a minority that with the advent of LLMs is likely to shrink even further.
Offline text processing tools are infinitely better than online ones, and archiving one's own conversations offline should be an option so as not to be forced to rely on websites which could die at any minute.
Then imagine you've taken something that infinitely transforms your world and makes you feel amazing to such a degree that's absolutely unimaginable to someone who hasn't tried some of these substances ("better than sex" is an extreme understatement). All your pain is gone, all your misery forgotten, amazing vistas open before you, all is good.
After that brief stay in paradise, you come crashing down and back in to your miserable life. Everything is as before, your passion is back, only you now know it's possible for you to get back to that exalted state, to escape that prison of a life you've been living in, even if for a moment.
Is it evidence of a disease for someone who's gone through this to desperately want to experience that escape again? To be free and feel great?
Is the cause of such a desire -- the misery, the poverty, the hopelessness, the fantastic way these substances make you feel and the escape they offer -- can all that be justly summed up in the word "disease", or is there something else going on?
Not only that, but most drug users aren't addicts.
To the general public, when they hear the words "drug user" they immediately equate that with "addict", and many can't even imagine that people could use drugs and not get addicted.
But that's not true, as addicts are a small minority of drug users.
Drug policy affects far more than just addicts. Lots of non-addicted users are affected too.