HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

poof131

2,305 karma · joined November 30, 2012

submissionscomments
poof131··on Pinterest pays $89.5M to terminate San Francisco office lease
The commercial property aspect of Prop 13 is actually up for a vote in Prop 15, to repeal these tax breaks for commercial property over $3M. It’s interesting to see people come out of the woodwork railing against it for all sorts of reasons from how the money is distributed to claiming it will cost the state hundreds of thousands of jobs. Would be nice to see this archaic tax relic go away. It’s like the state has granted feudal land rights to certain property owners.
poof131··on Navy F/A-18 squadron commander's take on AI repeatedly beating real pilot
Too funny, I went through flight school with Colin. Great guy and glad to see he picked up command but disagree with him on the benefits of BFM and the true value of manned fighter jets over the coming decades. The US military is caught between two wars. One, against opponents who can’t really hit back where fighter jets are overkill. Better off with AC-130s and the like. The other against opponents who can hit back, where the battle will be won or lost in space, cyber, economically, and possibly through nuclear warfare. Even with regards to fighters, the amount of money spent on BFM is really a boondoggle. It’s like spending billions training the infantry to knife fight. It’s not Vietnam and the last gunfighter with regards to missiles and targeting. Is not the AIM-9X targeting AI itself?

A great book that rings more true than ever talks about the obsolescence of weapons systems. I believe it was Freedman[1] A key thesis is that as a predominant weapon system becomes more vulnerable, it becomes more expensive, as it’s burdened with more defensive measures to survive from cheaper more expendable systems. In World War 2 the canonical example was the battle ship and the aircraft. Now it’s the fighter jet and the missile (or drone) etc. Just look at the ridiculous state of the JSF.

Manned missile trucks are valuable for countering electronic attack, but not dogfighting. Still, practice dogfighting is one of the most fun things you can do, too bad it hasn’t really been applicable since Vietnam. This post from the other day reminded me how fun it is and seems like a great fit for VR.[2] Onward last Samurais! Just try not to spend all the taxpayers money on the way out.

[1] https://www.amazon.com/Future-War-History-Lawrence-Freedman-... [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24255191

poof131··on The evidence which suggests that Covid-19 is not a naturally evolved virus [pdf]
It strikes me as reducing virulence would be a responsible first step before conducting research on increasing transmissivity of a deadly virus.
poof131··on The evidence which suggests that Covid-19 is not a naturally evolved virus [pdf]
Is this actually the case? This paper [1] seems to indicate that there are multiple types of gain-of-function research, not just an increase in virulence. In fact, the paper specifically discusses “transmissibility”, which would seem to support the argument of the paper under discussion: “In short, SARS-CoV-2 is possessed of dual action capability. In this paper we argue that the likelihood of this being the result of natural processes is very small”

[1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK285579/

poof131··on Limitations and pitfalls of the job interview
I think it’s a fantastic idea and applaud you for your work. The major hurdle is leading companies only want to hire senior devs. Why spend money and implement a training program when you can outsource it. There seems to be 3 paths in. One, go to a top 10 CS college. As a hiring manager, our internship choices were broken down by school with less than a dozen choices: Stanford, Harvard, MIT, Berkeley, CMU, etc. and a few diversity conferences. The candidates resumes where literally partitioned in folders for each school or “diversity”, so to peruse through hundreds of candidates you had to go by school or conference, with no way to see who had interests or experience in distributed systems, front-end, AI, etc. without choosing a school or conference to look through. I couldn’t believe how biased it was. Two, go work at a startup or small company for below market wages to get experience and try to work your way up to better and better companies. Three, work overseas for a couple years, pay full price for a masters in the US, and then work the H1B masters recruiting pipelines.

While there are exceptions the bootcamps seem to be geared toward path two. I wish bigger companies had training programs. I was working with a veteran who recently graduated from a local college and helping him with interview prep. He couldn’t pass the phone screen for the role I had available and ended up working for a small local consultant which seemed to be more IT focused than dev. I couldn’t in good faith just hire him without support from the team. I wish companies had training programs to hire local people into these jobs, but there really isn’t a shortage of talent that requires them to set these programs up. The shortage is in quality senior devs who could get into a top company but are willing to work for less elsewhere. Anyone who sets up one of these training programs and doesn’t pay FAANG salaries, is just training up candidates to move to FAANG. I guess in a way path two and three really are the training programs you are talking about.

And the stuff you are talking about regarding documentation, testing, etc. also sounds like other tangential roles like TPM or quality, which unfortunately are just being put on developers themselves at many places. I think most companies should have more people in these roles with the aspiration of moving into dev. Maybe a “training” role focused on this could help, but you may also run into resistance from people who are in these roles in organizations.

poof131··on U.S. arrests former Green Beret, son, in connection with Ghosn escape from Japan
The privatization of the military is one of the most corrupt and corrosive things our country has done in a while. I flew F-18s for the Navy and did a ground tour in Iraq with Special Forces. Look at the pay grades in 2020.[1] E3-E6 are making about $25-40k in salary. With some hazard pay and Basic Allowance for Housing (BAH) and Subsistence (BAS), depending on where you live (if not in the barracks) maybe you are making $50k. A decade ago, the contractors who took none of the risks of going on ops and were just training Iraqis were clearing $1k a day. I also saw contract pilots clearing $20k+ a month. This pay differential is morale destroying and trains people to think in market terms regarding skills that shouldn’t have a market outside of government. Now we have private armies going on offensive operations (Venezuela). But this is what the owners of the contracting firms always wanted. Privatizing a military is dumb but I guess so is outsourcing your medical supply chain, an overabundance of short-term bottomlinism the past few decades.

1. https://militarybenefits.info/2020-military-pay-charts/

poof131··on Tesla factory is still open for business
Ordered to close now.

[1] https://www.sfchronicle.com/business/article/Tesla-s-Fremont...

poof131··on U.S. Seeks to Heighten Scrutiny of Foreign Investment in Tech, Infra, Data
People were hoping that closer ties would open up China to democracy, that capitalism and democracy would go hand in hand. But it hasn’t happened and in fact, is going in reverse. The trend has been obvious for a long time. I remember reading books about the threat in the 90s.[1] In the military, China was the major adversary we trained against in the 2000s, not Russia. But the business opportunities helped mask the growing divide. It’s easy to hope for the best when profit is at stake and the outcome of cooperation (peace and trade) is so much better than the alternatives. But now people are being forced to choose between profits and values, the NBA is just one example.[2] It will take time but the tide has turned and many people will not be looked upon favorably by history, similarly to the Nazi sympathizers prior to WW2.[3] And it’s important to differentiate China and the Chinese people from the CCP. Both the CCP and their apologists in America would like to conflate the two. But Americans and the Chinese have fought together before and can hopefully (and peacefully) overcome the tyranny that currently afflicts the country.[4]

[1] https://www.amazon.com/Year-Rat-Clinton-Compromised-Security... [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-14-aUXlEac [3] https://time.com/5414055/american-nazi-sympathy-book/ [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flying_Tigers

poof131··on Ask HN: Who is hiring? (October 2019)
Salesforce | Distributed Systems / Backend | Multiple Levels | San Francisco, Palo Alto, Remote | $150k+ | Full Time | Visas

Come help Sales Cloud find Insights from its activity data. The Activity Insights team is responsible for running machine learning and heuristic models on top of the massive data set that is Salesforce. We not only generate Insights but are also building the alerting engine for the new High Velocity Sales product. Work closely with data science, product management, user interface, and infrastructure teams to build the scalable and intelligent future of CRM software. Tech: Kotlin, Scala, Storm, Spark, Cassandra, Postgres, Kafka, GraphQL, TensorFlow Serving, Docker, and more, all running in Amazon Web Services. Contact: s.young@salesforce.com

poof131··on No call for simulators in new Boeing 737 Max training proposals
Great video, thanks for sharing. That simulator work at the end was a fantastic demonstration of team work. Crew Resource Management.[1] I still remember DAM CLAS from the Navy.[2] Numerous examples in the video. Sad and terrifying thinking about what it must have been like for the pilots and passengers of the crashed airlines. If the issue was MCAS, the slowly worsening situation, never disabling the trim, just one step to remedy the situation that’s never taken, and the intuitive solution of pulling back hard on the yoke not working, because Boeing removed it in the latest version--a sad example of awful decision making on the ground.[3]

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crew_resource_management

2. https://quizlet.com/45297265/crew-resource-management-crm-th...

3. https://www.seattletimes.com/business/boeing-aerospace/u-s-p...

poof131··on F-35: What The Pilots Say
“Find targets to shoot at.” The man is hardly involved at all. It’s a battle of sensors. It’s a battle over the electromagnetic spectrum and the man in the loop in the aircraft isn’t the critical part. Unless, you lose the battle of the EM spectrum and can’t communicate with a drone. Then a man in the loop could be critical but you’ve probably already lost at that point and would be better off with the “cruise missiles” you deride using ground mapping to find the way to the area and AI for specific target selection. I’m talking more about what aircraft are these days in BVR air-to-air: missile trucks, carrying AAMRAM, which is the real weapon. I’ve flown against F-22s, seen their weaknesses, and wouldn’t base our defense strategy on planes that have become too expensive compared to missiles.
poof131··on F-35: What The Pilots Say
I've posted about this a couple times here in the past (though misspelled Tucano), and saw exactly what you are talking about in Iraq.[1] This article and the F-35 make me sad. It's the last of the samurai. For close air support in a low threat environment the Super Tucano and other aircraft are much better at the task and cheaper. For a high threat environment (i.e. China or Russia), expendable, stealthy drones acting as missile trucks are much better assuming somehow the war doesn't go nuclear and we don't lose in space and cyber first. The F-35 is too expensive and epitomizes the trajectory of the battle ship, where more and more money is put into defense of the platform, and it eventually succumbs to cheaper threats. I think the Future of War delves into this concept well.[2] The F-35 is probably more boondoggle then defense.

1. https://hn.algolia.com/?query=super%20tacano&sort=byPopulari...

2. https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/470769.The_Future_of_War

poof131··on Can Boeing Trust Pilots?
> the system rejected the data as invalid and temporarily stopped the stall warnings. However, "this led to a perverse reversal that lasted nearly to the impact: each time Bonin happened to lower the nose, rendering the angle of attack marginally less severe, the stall warning sounded again—a negative reinforcement that may have locked him into his pattern of pitching up", which increased the angle of attack and thus prevented the aircraft from getting out of its stall

From your link. In my mind that is the critical piece. The pilot did the right thing, pushed the nose down, heard the stall warning again, and did the wrong thing, pulled the nose up, because that made the stall warning go away. Having been in a plane upside down at night pointed toward the ground I can imagine the stress on the crew. It’s easy to say dump the nose when the stall warning goes off, but what if they had been upside down, then he would have been doing the right thing by listening to the warning. The fact the stall warning cut off was the final critical link in the accident, not pilot error.

poof131··on Boeing 737 Max pilots complained to feds for months about suspected safety flaw
I think you are on the right track about one of the underlying problems. From another comment on a different thread.

> My company's error rates have increased on the "common fleet" by almost triple. [1]

The aircraft manufacturers and carriers want to get the most change with the least impact: updated jets with better gas mileage that don’t require pilots to retrain. It seems the FAA and other regulators have become too lenient in letting the manufacturers put significant changes into aircraft without requiring them to have different type ratings or at least add new training requirements.[2] Not communicating the MCAS changes seems to indicate a broken process at Boeing too.[3]

But you are also observing the Swiss cheese model of safety.[4] As the easier individual issues are fixed (mechanical) more difficult compound issues cause the accident, where multiple things (pilot training, bad communication, new system) all need to line up.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19376565

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Type_rating

[3] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19377220

[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swiss_cheese_model

poof131··on US refuses to ground Boeing 737 Max
As someone who flew a Boeing plane for a long time, if it’s true they released a stick pusher (automatic trim) that would dump the nose,[1] couldn’t be overridden by pulling back on the stick as in previous versions of the aircraft,[2] but only by disconnecting the automatic trim then manually trimming the aircraft, was tied to only one AOA sensor, and then felt this was too much information for “pilots”.[3] Wow. Seems like engineers on the ground and business leaders making decisions that ended up costing lives. Pilot error seems like a scapegoat here. Even a well trained pilot on a bad day might not handle a nose down situation after takeoff well, especially when the intuitive solution of pulling back on the stick had been disabled.

While this may not be the cause of the most recent crash, the Lion crash alone seems to indicate a problem with Boeing and the FAA’s relationship. This probably extends to Airbus and other regulators as indicated in another comment about his or her carriers safety incidents tripling due to flying two aircraft of the same “type” but not really.[4] At a minimum the MCAS changes should have been communicated to pilots and indicates a process problem at Boeing with insufficient pilot involvement and too much engineering and business input. And the FAA probably needs to be much stricter in the training and documentation requirements between models.

[1] https://www.seattletimes.com/business/boeing-aerospace/u-s-p...

[2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19077371

[3] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18438607

[4] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19376565

poof131··on US refuses to ground Boeing 737 Max
> My company's error rates have increased on the "common fleet" by almost triple.

That is Terrifying. It seems like the FAA has optimized for allowing the Manufacturers and Airlines to streamline changes and operations while slowly letting safety deteriorate. Perhaps these accidents will force what seems like a needed change in type ratings.

poof131··on Ethiopian Airlines plane crash: No survivors among 157 on board
If this accident is a second trim related incident due to their MCAS system, it is damn near criminal negligence at this point and they probably need to ground the fleet. From an earlier article, pulling back on the yoke would disable the system.[1] They removed that functionality. Not easy to teach people new habits or proper procedures when the intuitive solution worked. And if the intuitive solution worked is that not really the proper procedure despite what engineers on the ground think.

If MCAS is the culprit here, Boeing clearly released this functionality without proper vetting and testing. It’s a sad day for safety and for automation. These accidents will likely slow the advance of BVR for drones[2] and more autonomous flight for cargo.[3] The fact these accidents are occurring overseas where the pilots have less training will also buttress the decision for the 1500 hour rule.[4] Like I said, if MCAS is suspected here, probably time to ground the new 737 despite what it will do to Boeing, because right now it looks like they cut some corners, the FAA let them, and families are mourning. Pilot error isn’t really the issue, it’s engineering, process, and training.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19077371

[2] https://www.altiuas.com/bvlos-mean-commercial-drone-users/

[3] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-10-10/will-you-...

[4] https://www.forbes.com/sites/marisagarcia/2018/07/27/a-perfe...

poof131··on Boeing acquires flight-planning app maker ForeFlight
What are the hard parts and what does ForeFlight get right?
poof131··on Amazon cargo plane crashes in Texas
Zipline is doing good work. I think we will get there, it’s just going to take time. Acting FAA administrator Dan Elwell gave a great speech at InterDrone last year about the safety aspect.[1] Personally, I think in some ways parts of industry are slowing down progress. State and local will be key players, the FAA knows this, but industry seems to believe they shouldn’t be involved and below 400’ should be like class e & g airspace with no rights for property owners. If the Uniform Law Commission settles on 200’ that could be a good thing. [2] Then assuming the FAA authorizes a system as safe, private property owners could conduct BVLOS flights over their property (i.e. ranches, mines). Or assuming state and local are involved, they could authorize flights over public routes. The airspace below 400’ will more likely resemble class A airspace than anything else and will have to involve state and local for planning. No magical UTM solution will solve it alone. [3] It will be a combination of technology and operations.

[1] https://www.interdrone.com/news/dan-elwell-speaks-to-audienc...

[2] https://unmanned-aerial.com/drone-industry-responds-to-draft...

[3] https://www.utm.arc.nasa.gov/upp-industry-workshop/UTM%20PP%...

poof131··on Amazon cargo plane crashes in Texas
Thanks for the reminder, three investigations. It’s been awhile and FNAEB was always a terrifying word that imprinted on my brain. Accepting responsibility was definitely a key part of Naval aviation.
poof131··on Amazon cargo plane crashes in Texas
The Navy likes to keep things simple and called it the Swiss cheese model.[1] It’s usually never a single factor, but a combination of factors. The holes line up and an accident happens.

I think it’s also important to emphasize that getting to this level of safety is so much more cultural than technical. The ability to be open about failure and for people to feel safe in communicating to investigators is critical. The Navy would run two parallel investigations into an incident, one focused on Safety, where anything said was confidential and couldn’t be used in the administrative investigation (FNAEB) that could result in career ending consequences.[2]

Though I worry a bit with the constant wars and punishing deployments this culture may be heading in the wrong direction. [3] One of my XOs said, “One generation of Admirals will make their names breaking the Navy, and the next will make their names putting it back together.”

I have immense respect for the FAA and NTSB. They are trying to infuse this safety ethos into the fledgling drone industry. No easy task.

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swiss_cheese_model 2. https://www.airwarriors.com/community/threads/my-fnaeb-exper... 3. https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2018/10/the-n...

poof131··on America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Miserable
Those numbers don’t remotely reflect the cost of living for people moving to the area now. Prop 13 has distorted things dramatically. In Palo Alto, there are numerous retired people living in houses paying property tax rates essentially set in the 1970s. In fact, Palo Alto has the lowest tax rate in the country by percent since the houses are so expensive but the people pay so little compared to the value.[1] You could definitely live off $500k, but $137 would be really tough to near impossible with a family. Prop 13 has really broken the California housing market.

https://www.bizjournals.com/sanfrancisco/news/2016/12/01/pro...

poof131··on Behind the Lion Air Crash, a Trail of Decisions Kept Pilots in the Dark
> Take it up with the FAA and the airlines?

Sure. It's not just Boeings fault. I believe the FAA will course correct from this and probably all changes to flight controls will need to be reported to pilots. More lessons written in blood.

poof131··on Behind the Lion Air Crash, a Trail of Decisions Kept Pilots in the Dark
From the article:

"Older 737s had another way of addressing certain problems with the stabilizers: Pulling back on the yoke, or control column, one of which sits immediately in front of both the captain and the first officer, would cut off electronic control of the stabilizers, allowing the pilots to control them manually.

That feature was disabled on the Max when M.C.A.S. was activated — another change that pilots were unlikely to have been aware of. After the crash, Boeing told airlines that when M.C.A.S. is activated, as it appeared to have been on the Lion Air flight, pulling back on the control column will not stop so-called stabilizer runaway."

If the above is true, it's near criminal that Boeing didn't notify pilots about the change. It's also not just about following checklists but understanding the systems of the aircraft.

poof131··on Flying High Unpressurized (2016)
Reminded me of the two times I’ve been hypoxic. One was in the altitude chamber. The Navy was great about training and had all pilots experience hypoxia so they could understand how the symptoms effect them in particular. My first indications was tingling fingers. The second time was flying into Iraq. I had skimped on the preflight checklist and missed the cabin pressure switch, which was always in the on position, but had somehow been set to off. Took my mask off at 20k heading in country and started to feel light headed with tingling fingers. Told my commanding officer / flight lead something was wrong. We started to return to the carrier. During the emergency procedure checklist hit the step to check the cabin pressure switch. Oops. “Sir, we don’t have to abort the mission!” The Navy had some great training that saved my life on more than one occasion.
poof131··on Reasons to Fear Another ‘Great War’
A puppet government? Hardly. We simply replaced Sunni for Shiite and slightly shifted things in a millennial old civil war. It was naive optimism of the Potomac chess players that we could reshape a country by invading it.[1] Others have mentioned the US supporting heinous countries like Saudi Arabia. This is sadly true and should stop, despite what the referenced article says about “staying engaged”. Ceasing support of tyrants and ending overtly militaristic policies is not disengaging, but reevaluating failed policies.

But the US also acts through a democracy, while the countries mentioned above do not. I can criticize the stupid policies of the US in a public forum. The citizens of the countries listed above can not. Democracy is not the equivalent of an oligarchy or tyranny. The people of a country are different from the government that represents them. Unelected governments are illegitimate and a danger to the free world despite what their minions of propaganda post.

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imperial_Life_in_the_Emerald_C...

poof131··on You’re Not Managing a Team of Software Engineers, You’re Managing Writers
The problem is the architecture is intertwined with the product is intertwined with the people. Believing that these things can easily be broken apart is an illusion. It’s how product believes one thing and engineers believe another, resulting in quick hacks, missed deadlines, and a mediocre product, if it’s released at all. Meanwhile the manager is a “people person”.

Teams need leadership, not three leaders. Dev managers should be able to understand the architecture, and the product, and the team. Product advises on the direction. Tech leads argue for the implementation. But the dev manager needs to bring these things together and provide direction. Otherwise all three people will just point fingers when the results suck—diffusion of responsibility. Teams need leaders and leaders need to be accountable for results.

poof131··on Belgian Air Force F-16 destroyed by fire during maintenance
There is an “arm” switch.[1] This certainly shouldn’t have happened and indicates a break down in safety procedures. Significant maintenance should not be performed on an aircraft with ordnance. The plane never should have been armed. The maintainer should have been careful around the trigger. And a plane loaded with forward firing ordnance should not be pointed at another plane. This seems like a Commanding Officer gets fired type accident.

[1] https://www.google.com/search?q=f+16+master+arm+switch

poof131··on DOD Just Beginning to Grapple with Scale of Weapon Systems Vulnerabilities
I agree that the comment came across as from some one without skin in the game themselves. But I also believe the current procurement process is broken and after spending time using these systems I don’t hold the people building them responsible, but the Admirals, Generals, Executives, and Politicians who smooze at places like Tailhook and shoot down opposition to the status quo. The parent may be right that we won’t course correct until a catastrophe happens. All industries have issues, but the military isn’t an industry and deserves better for $1.6 Trillion. This report is terrifying and exemplifies the sad state of the military’s conventional weapons systems. But agree that most those in defense are often trying their best to do good.
poof131··on FAA Moves Toward Treating Drones and Planes as Equals
By establishing property rights you make a stronger case for the right to fly a drone on your property. Certainly the FAA will have a safety say, but property rights will also be important. In the end, much of this may be decided by the courts.
← PreviousPage 2 of 10Next →