HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

poof131

2,305 karma · joined November 30, 2012

submissionscomments
poof131··on Is productivity the victim of its own success?
An example I can think of is healthcare. I’ve seen plenty of dogs in Silicon Valley with better healthcare than many people on the planet. The market is allocating resources to train vets to take care of animals better than people because that’s what people with money want. It’s easily justified as a sacrifice, “I’m spending $8k on Fido’s surgery instead of putting it toward a Tesla like my neighbor.” But this really still hides the ridiculousness of the fact that an animal is receiving better care then many people. The only way to deal with this in my opinion is to enact policies that strengthen the middle class, so more people have enough money for the things that really matter and fewer people have enough money for the things that don’t.
poof131··on Is productivity the victim of its own success?
Your analogy of the pipes seems spot on. I’m currently selling an underwater condo in Norfolk, VA for 40% less than I bought it ten yours ago while I was in the military. Now, I’m working in Silicon Valley where no one can afford a house, where friends and family’s houses have doubled in price over the same period. It is two different worlds. One has Trump bumper stickers, the other Hillary. One never recovered from 2008, the other is doing great.

More than broken pipes though, I feel this is the natural tendency of easy money. As the central banks hand out money, they hand it to the well connected. This money is then misallocated since it wasn’t distributed by the market but by fiat and this is the underlying cause of the decline in productivity. Raising rates, paying off debt, and less government micromanaging, while painful in the short term, is required in the long term for stable, efficient markets.

poof131··on Ask HN: Is gun purchase data available?
I think you may be going into precog territory while looking for a needle in a haystack. Some of the common patterns seem fairly well documented: disaffected male, mental issues, history of abuse, affiliation with radical islam. But most experts seem to believe finding a key indicator before hand is really impossible since you will also label so many people who will actually resist the urge to violence. The Orlando killer popped on the FBIs radar twice and they couldn’t make the call with all the expertise and experience the organization has. Machine learning a data model to predict violence will have so many false positives as to be either useless or used as a totalitarian hammer. [1, 2, 3, 4]

[1] http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/12/19/mass-shooting-psych...

[2] http://www.livescience.com/21787-predicting-mass-shootings.h...

[3] http://andrewgelman.com/2016/02/25/probability-paradox-kills...

[4] https://bayesianbiologist.com/2013/06/06/how-likely-is-the-n...

poof131··on Ask HN: Should I quit my highly paid startup job at a failing startup?
Most SaaS startups take time to get going, about two years according to saastr, so it might take awhile. [1]

But a lot of really bad founders have raised money during this bubble cycle. The VCs are screaming about the market changing behind closed doors. The founder where I work was recently pressured to fire the team and sell the company.

Make sure you look after yourself. Get your interview skills up and have a list of opportunities. Don’t overcommit to 50+ hour weeks. If they want to pay you 25% more than sure, but don’t fall for the overwork peer pressure by founders who have a 20-100x equity win over you.

Make your own personal assessment of the team, product, and market, and the likelihood of success. Recognize that founders “sell” their belief and my not be honest about issues. I’d probably try to stay to the one year mark and move if you don’t have a strong belief in the company, but be ready to be dropped at a moments notice.

[1] https://www.saastr.com/if-youre-going-to-do-a-saas-start-up-...

poof131··on Buffer Layoffs
It was a sacrifice for themselves and their equity. What does the cap table look like? Not laying off employees prevents a morale issue and gives more resources to keep building product. Don’t confuse other employees by trying to say it was a sacrifice for them, that is misleading, it wasn’t, but I’m sure the founders would love to sell it that way: “We’re doing this for you!”
poof131··on The U.S. Navy’s Big Mistake: Building Tons of Supercarriers
As a former Navy F/A-18 pilot, I have strong opinions on this and generally agree with the analysis. A few thoughts:

1. The services are building what the defense contractors want to build more than what the war fighters want. Knew a lot of pilots who didn’t like the F-35 and would have preferred more, cheaper planes specialized for specific roles. This defense contractor capture is a big problem.

2. The services waste these ‘big war’ resources on our insurgency campaigns. F/A-18s were about 10k per flight hour and perform worse than platforms such as the Super Tacono[1] when supporting war fighters on the ground. We spent hundreds of billions more than we needed to on the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan because when the game starts everyone wants to play to justify their budgets. Programs such as the Super Tacano were shut down to protect and justify the massive expenditure on fighter jets. Funding for different types of wars needs to go through different sources to prevent this enormous waste of money.

3. I’d be for a submersible carrier that could surface to launch and retrieve drones that act as missile trucks for both air-to-air and strike missions. I wouldn’t go all in on unmanned aircraft though, since I would also assume the possibility of totally denied electronic environment where signals are jammed and space assets are unavailable.

4. To force military leaders to focus on the services and not themselves, I’d support a ban on senior level leadership (O-7 and above) from accepting board seats or contractor / full-time positions with defense contractors. Too many leaders make decisions while in service influenced by their personal outcomes when they get out. This behavior reinforces a system that supports the status quo. Senior leaders have great retirement packages and can do things other than maintain an incestuous relationship with the military-industrial complex. Although sometimes other jobs seem to result in more bad behavior such as pressure to look the other way on Theranos and its questionable product.[2, 3] Does look like their board has gotten a bit better with the only remaining military / diplomat being General Mattis. Glad to see Admiral Roughead and Secretary of State Kissinger are no longer there.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Embraer_EMB_314_Super_Tucano [2] http://www.techinsider.io/emails-theranos-elizabeth-holmes-u... [3] https://www.theranos.com/leadership

poof131··on Secret Service Employees Punished For Illegally Accessing Congressman's Data
Another sad day for government and its inability to maintain any sense of accountability. As others have stated, I don’t understand how this isn’t a criminal matter. Beyond just privacy issues, this seems to fit the definition of blackmail in D.C.

“Blackmail also has two elements. The first relates to criminal intent. That is, the person needs to intend to obtain property from someone else or to cause the other person to do or refrain from doing something. Second, in order to achieve the intended goal, the person needs to threaten either: (1) to accuse the other person of a crime, (2) to expose a secret or asserted fact that could subject the other person to “hatred, contempt, or ridicule,” or (3) to damage the other person’s reputation.” [1]

They exposed the congressman’s secrets with the intent to cause him to refrain from critiquing the agency. How isn't this a crime?

[1] http://koehlerlaw.net/assault-theft/extortionblackmail/

poof131··on Jessica Livingston’s Pretty Complete List on How Not to Fail
Not sure I agree about advisors. Getting smart people who have experience in places the team is lacking seems pretty critical to me. Perhaps it’s different at YC where you have advisors built into the program and getting ‘boards of advisors’ is extraneous, but for other teams without those resources behind them this seems like bad advice. Find people who’ve done it before and learn from them.
poof131··on Planned GPS outages in southern California
You are right. The military relies on INS and GPS. Most systems such as the navigation in an F/A-18 are INS with GPS to maintain accuracy like you described. I thought JDAM was entirely GPS, but apparently it is only an INS supplement to.[1] Cruise missiles use both plus terrain mapping.[2] Military could probably handle total GPS denial, but it would be ugly, especially since it may mean no SATCOM either. I ponder what WW3 looks like and total space denial seems like a strong possibility. Spoofing is probably worse than denial since it isn't just no information but bad information that could throw off the INS.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joint_Direct_Attack_Munition [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tomahawk_(missile)

poof131··on The man who seduced the 7th Fleet
I wouldn’t say there is title inflation as much as command inflation. The services fight over how many commands they have. This controls how many officers they can promote and how much budget they can request. Like other government agencies, the goal is the expansion of the bureaucracy’s influence and power. This is indirectly correlated to the number of commands.

Although I’m not a fan of the current batch of senior leadership based upon my experience in the Navy and further illustrated by the evidence uncovered in the article, I wouldn’t say the people who are Admirals haven’t worked their way up to that title. The military is definitely top heavy due to the pension system, but not, in my opinion, due to title inflation as you would think of it in the civilian world.

poof131··on Steve Blank: 'VCs Won't Admit They're in a Ponzi Scheme'
There’s little downside protection from bankruptcy or from a fire sale to strategic investors who are waiting for bankruptcy. A friend recently left a startup that had raised over $100M where the whole executive team was celebrating an $800 revenue deal. He didn’t even wait to vest. Lots of mid to late stage startups are in big trouble, and it will take time to flush it out and see who’s all hype, who’s unit economics are upside down, and who are the real companies.
poof131··on Startup Employees Invoke Obscure Law to Open Up Books
You make a great point. I probably wouldn't work for a startup that doesn't extend the exercise period. Fortunately, people are pushing for this and I think it is great for employees. [1, 2] Strong signal that the company thinks about you.

1. http://blog.triplebyte.com/extending-stock-option-exercise-w... 2. http://blog.samaltman.com/employee-equity

poof131··on China’s scary lesson to the world: Censoring the Internet works
But what if we could lift 100's of millions more if the american upper class contributed more. It's not that the task isn't worth doing but if that is the point, we should all be choosing to do it together.
poof131··on Startup Employees Invoke Obscure Law to Open Up Books
Options are your right to equity or ownership of the company. So you experience some of the upside as well as risk some of the downside.

The problem is equity is serving two purposes. On one hand, it represents ownership of the company, the ‘capital’. On the other hand, due to it’s favorable tax treatment, it has become a key component of compensation.[1] Marisa Meyer didn’t start or invest in Yahoo, but she is compensated almost $40m a year in equity, over 90% of her pay package.[2]

When you are evaluating an offer between a startup and a larger company, regarding compensation you need to evaluate the whole package: salary, equity, and bonuses. Startups want to compare only salary and over value their equity. “You’re taking a 50% pay cut from Google, but we are giving you XXX in equity at our last valuation.”

Look at the total pay packages with more realistic valuations such as a 409a for startups, and then examine the probability of different exits and how much you will make. There’s a reason people say employees are learning while founders are earning.[3] An honest assessment of the paydays doesn’t usually bode well for employees at startups. If founders can’t talk to you about this, you probably don’t want to follow them. Most hope you don’t ask the questions and then say things like “What, you don’t believe in the company!” They should be able to sell you on the probability of success, the learning, and everything that will make up for less comp. But don’t let them mislead you about the comp.

[1] https://medium.com/the-wtf-economy/what-paul-graham-is-missi...

[2] https://www.google.com/search?q=marissa%20mayer%20compensati...

[3] https://bothsidesofthetable.com/is-it-time-for-you-to-earn-o...

poof131··on Startup Employees Invoke Obscure Law to Open Up Books
It’s fairly disingenuous to use the fundraising valuation. Investors have a ton of preferences that make their shares more valuable. Probably cut that by a third or ask to see the most recent 409a valuation. Walk through possible exits with dilution, assess the likelihood of those exits, and try to make a calculated guess at the payoff. In all likelihood it is less then working for 4 years at a big company and founders saying it isn’t are selling their book. If they can’t make the follow on valuation gates and see an exit, you probably won’t make anything. Even if they exit at the valuation when you joined, your shares will likely be worthless as senior preference holders get their guaranteed returns.
poof131··on China’s scary lesson to the world: Censoring the Internet works
Sure. A good thing. Or possibly a bad thing if we strengthen a tyranny that can’t find a path to freedom for its people. History will tell.

What I find most upsetting though is that much of this comes at the expense of the american middle class while the american upper class benefits. So less unrest in one country leads to more in another.

Personally, I wish values drove foreign policy more than business. And trade doesn’t equal peace. Connections lead to conflict. The USSR and US never fought despite the tensions of the cold war, while Europe, with all it’s interconnections and trade has blown apart in a world war twice in the last century.

poof131··on Looking into the eyes of failure
Agree with your first point, but somewhat disagree with the inspiration quote. After a decade in the military and seeing some great leaders in fighter aviation and special forces, competency and empathy are the critical traits, not false bravado.

Is your leader good at their job? Do they see the reality of the situation at hand? Will they make decisions and take actions that are required by the mission but also in your best interests too?

As a leader (or pilot/operator) you don’t want to dwell on all the little things that could go wrong or linger on the fact you could die on your mission, but you don’t want to ignore the reality of the challenges you will face.

No one believes in the person who puts their head in the sand. A leader shouldn’t share all the burdens they cary, that’s part of their job, but they also shouldn’t delude themselves into thinking a smile and confident attitude will cary the day.

Think about your team. Be honest with your people. Be as good as you can. Do your best at the task at hand. And then try to smile at whatever comes and say ‘fuck it’. Perhaps the quote is trying to describe that last part, but too many leaders forget the competency and empathy parts, the parts that enable the whole team to say ‘fuck it’ and run into the breach.

poof131··on Medical error in hospitals is the third leading cause of death in the U.S.
Disappointing, sad, and scary, but not unexpected. You can’t expect matters of life and death that effect liability, public relations, and profitability to be properly investigated and resolved by the entities directly involved. When an airplane crashes, the airlines, manufacturers, and pilots union don’t get to run the investigation and choose the results. Sure they are involved and try to influence the outcome, but an external agency heads the investigation.

Medicine needs some sort of non-punitive external investigative agency. With the scope so much larger than aviation and death often being a normal outcome, how to structure such an agency would be challenging, but I still think it’s the only way to really address the problem. The same applies for law enforcement and the use of deadly force. While many of the people involved have the best intentions, the pressures of the organization put undue bias on any internal investigation.

It looks like an agency along these lines may have been formed [1], but the ‘At the invitation of healthcare providers’ isn’t good enough. A quick google search found others pushing along these lines [3], and it’s interesting that they are talking about error being the ‘third leading cause of death’ in 2014.

While critics point out that the study may have an overly broad definition of error, it still seems that there is an issue here from anecdotal experience, and that error shouldn’t even be in the top 10.

[1] http://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/pso-services-group-l... [2] http://www.ntsb.gov/Pages/default.aspx [3] http://safepatientproject.org/press_release/patient-safety-a...

poof131··on Ask HN: How do I deal with the first sexual harassment complaint at my startup?
1. While you need a lawyer for advice and to cover your ass, lawyers can’t lead. Lawyers offer advice and dot i’s. Weak leaders delegate their responsibilities to lawyers.

2. You need to assess your culture. Is this one bad apple or is this something larger. The work hard, party hard, live in the office startup culture can be a breeding ground for this. Not that you can’t have this environment and succeed, but you need to understand it and put checks and safeguards in place. One option is to designate a sexual harassment rep and make sure everybody knows this person’s roll and that they can talk to them, possibly anonymously.

3. Talk to your female employee and let her know you have to do something. You can’t ignore it as that effects the company and thus everyone. Get her opinion about how much of a problem his continued presence in the office will be. She may not want him to be fired as she may feel partially responsible (not saying she is in any way, but we don’t know how she’ll feel).

4. Talk to the bizdev employee. Document the meeting and any outcomes or remediation. Is this a problem of just being junior and not yet having the ability to separate barroom behavior from the work place. Why did you hire this person? Are those qualities still there and does this person have potential? Only you know.

Talk to a lawyer, but remember, you are the leader, they are not. Walk through the steps and make the tough decision about what is best for everyone. Reactionary firings can be almost as negative on your culture (not your liability though) as doing nothing. Be the type of leader who talks to their people and tries to come to a decision that is best for everyone. Don’t be the leader who makes reactionary decisions behind closed doors.

Also, don’t talk about ‘kicking someones ass’. As a leader, this is almost as bad as calling someone a MILF. Step back from your emotions. After a decade in the military, part of it working in legal, I’ve seen a lot worse: rape, child porn, attempted murder, grand theft, fraud. While obnoxious, calling someone MILF is pretty far down on the scale. This makes it tougher in some ways since firing isn’t automatically the only response.

poof131··on Is the U.S. Ready for Post-Middle-Class Politics?
Totally disagree. We’re sitting at almost zero percent interest rates because the fed can’t take their foot off the pedal. More isn’t going to help bring back the middle class. Volker broke the stagflation of the 70s and is probably the only decent chairman. Bad trade deals, runaway education and health costs, regressive taxes, foreign wars, etc. have done more to decimate the middle class than interest rates being too high. If anything, the fed has helped accelerate / fund much of this mess with ridiculously low interest rates for decades. Certainly it will hurt when rates go up, but it hurts to pay off your credit cards too. Cheap money funds malinvestment, flows to the politically connected, and aggravates income inequality. It’s just tough to notice. You may get a raise at work but don’t realize the bosses mansion/stock just appreciated 100 times more than your raise. You feel good but your ability to purchase things decreased.
poof131··on Is the U.S. Ready for Post-Middle-Class Politics?
nostrademons, love your name and comments but disagree with a few points.

>>> That's not the Silicon Valley mindset

Having grown up in the heart of the valley, Palo Alto, traveled the country and the world in the military, and now back working in tech, my observation is that this mindset is more SV than people give it credit for. It’s better packaged as meritocracy and innovation but the results are fairly apparent in the disparity of economic outcomes. I like a lot of aspects of the SV mindset (engineer focused, innovation focused, risk and failure tolerant) and know a lot of good people in SV, but I wouldn’t imbue it a purity above Wall Street, or Hollywood, or D.C. or any other power center. All are fairly dismissive of flyover country and self-assured in their wealth, power, and status.

>>> skeptical of any politician… They’re using you;

I got used by the military for a decade and assume everyone is using me. Haven’t seen much change in SV. But I’m also a sucker for trusting people. Life ain’t easy.

>>> Economically frustrated masses are a very good way to gain power.

Yes, but they are also the primary internal way to change power structures. And democracy allows us to do this in a controlled fashion through law.

>>> thinking locally… opting out of the national conversation

While I agree with the ethos of thinking locally, to the extreme it can also be taken as, "Don’t worry about the big things, leave that too other people. Don’t worry about what the hirer-ups are doing, just do your job. Don’t worry about the country, you can’t change anything” As a Veteran, I disagree with the attitude of total disengagement. I got sent to war by politicians. Only two presidential candidates are saying the Iraq war was stupid. That gets my vote. These decisions are life and death for people.

poof131··on Is the U.S. Ready for Post-Middle-Class Politics?
Corporate profits have benefited greatly which thus benefits all who own stocks (top 20%). Wages have been crushed which negatively impacts the other 80%. [1] Personally, on a whole I feel we’ve lost as Americans and disagree with the parent. You can argue about cheaper goods or more competition, but most these trade deals seem fairly lopsided with the main beneficiaries being other countries getting jobs and corporations getting cheaper labor.

1. http://www.cnbc.com/2016/03/29/hillary-clinton-cannot-win-us...

poof131··on Is the U.S. Ready for Post-Middle-Class Politics?
The problem is you can exit silicon valley, but you can’t exit the silicon valley mindset. Where can you go work where you can believe that your employer has your best interests at heart, where you don’t have to worry about them outsourcing your job to increase profits by a couple percent. In the quest for ‘shareholder value’, business leaders have taken an overly cut-throat and self-centered approach to employees and their obligations to the country. Politics is the only way to reign this in and that is exactly what’s happening.
poof131··on Ask HN: How Much Reliance on 3rd Party Tech Is Too Much?
Congratulations. What a great way to prove out the usefulness of your service. Minimal effort to fulfill a need.

1. Try to form a relationship with the companies whose APIs you depend upon. Try to find out their plans for the APIs, if they’ll keep them up, if the terms of service will stay okay for you, and if they are likely to become a competitor.

2. Depending upon one, either put your resources into expanding into new areas or replacing the APIs. Expanding would be preferred, but you may need to do both if one of the companies may become a competitor.

Again, sounds like you are in a great spot. More value provided with less effort is always a good thing. Sounds like an eloquent solution. There’s risk, but you recognize it which is important. Focus on growth if you can rather than de-risking the API usage since there are probably a bunch of other unseen risks and growth will help you find these and deal with them. Then gradually de-risk the API usage as you grow.

poof131··on Bank of Japan Is an Estimated Top 10 Holder in 90% of the Nikkei 225
I believe some of them do and that’s a major reason populist politicians are becoming in favor. Would be interesting to see the average asset ownership between supporters of the traditional candidates Clinton/Cruz and outside candidates Sanders/Trump. My guess is that the bases for the latter candidates (young/working-class) have a lot less ‘ownership’ and wouldn’t care too much if the stock market and home prices where cut in half.
poof131··on Bank of Japan Is an Estimated Top 10 Holder in 90% of the Nikkei 225
This is ridiculous. It illustrates that most central banks’ primary mission has become asset price inflation (primarily the stock market) more than anything else. Pension funds, retirement savings, the top 1%’s majority of assets, and so on are all in the market so governments of the world have decided that the market shouldn’t go down, at least not very much.

So we are stuck at zero percent interest rates going negative. Give out the money to keep the party going. Any hiccup in the markets and banks cut rates. Our economies will continue to struggle with malinvestments until interest rates are in a more reasonable long-term range and all the zombie businesses can die and free up resources for stronger players. Amazing how supposed proponents of ‘free markets’ try to micromanage entire economies.

poof131··on For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant Nightmare
Office romances are fine. Even in the military, relationships between coworkers are accepted. It’s part of life. What’s not accepted is hitting on or dating your subordinates. One, it’s inappropriate since the subordinate may feel forced to comply with the advances for the sake of his or her career. And two, even when it works out and isn’t harassment, team dynamics are about to go into the toilet. Who gets the next promotion? Who gets the next good deal assignment? When the boss is dating one of the team members, any decision will be suspect. The whole thing is entirely unprofessional. An office romance between consenting coworkers is different from harassing/dating people you have power over.
poof131··on A C.I.A. Grunt’s Tale of the Fog of Secret War
I agree. Follow the money. I think all war profit should be nationalized. No corporate gain from killing people in foreign countries. Then at least greed won’t be a motivation.

Are we safer? I’m not sure, probably not. We did deal with Al-Queda and it’s roots existed before ’96. ISIS became the new idiot on the block, but was that from the mishandling of Iraq or Syria, likely a bit of both. And I blame regional issues more than any US actions for the lack of safety. Safer is a tough term to define specifically but war doesn't generally make people safer, I'd agree with that.

poof131··on A C.I.A. Grunt’s Tale of the Fog of Secret War
I agree on governance, but disagree on how to get there.

One, I wouldn’t say SOCOM was the problem and call the operators assassins. The military started off stupid, dropping a bomb on every person planting an IED. Then people got smarter and realized that understanding a network and finding the leaders was more important than just killing low level people trying to feed their family. SOCOM did a good job of finding those leaders.

Two, I would focus on Army SF. Training locals to operate themselves is more important than direct action. I’d just move FID directly under SOCOM. The Navy and Air Force spent way more then they should have in these wars, costing the country trillions. The Army and Marines weren’t much better. Green Berets were built to work with the locals. And with an air power supplement they can prevent places from getting over run.

Three, governance requires other agencies. Start with a minimal footprint of SF and Airpower. Then try to bring in state and aid and other agencies quickly. Only bring in more mainline military units as needed and get them out as quick as you can. This will never happen with the budget flowing directly through the military.

I think SOCOM focusing on FID with a more limited budget then the entire military and getting in other agencies quickly would be a much better approach to governance. When the “big” military comes in, they come in for total war. You get fighter jets, bombs, and battalions.

Whether you need it or not, the military will find a place for everything to keep it’s spot in the budget. Sometimes you do need tanks and bombers, but not where you are trying to govern.

We need to differentiate between total war and governance with people getting shot at and always strive for the latter. I don’t think the military will ever be able to effectively govern, it’s not its job. So less ground troops and more SF and Airpower and more State Department please and get rid of SOCOM as soon as State is comfortable. That's the approach I'd vote for.

poof131··on A C.I.A. Grunt’s Tale of the Fog of Secret War
Appreciate your service and your viewpoint but disagree.

How do we win in Iraq? We supported the Shia backed government and they used their power to oppress Sunni political opponents. Now the Sunni regions are in revolt with ISIS ruling large swathes on the ground and the Iraqi government is incapable of stopping them even with support from Iran. I saw first hand SF officers having to deal with political target packs from the Iraqi government while our senior military leaders would turn a blind eye.

How do we win in Afghanistan? The place seems more tribal than Iraq. Do we stop the drug trade or support it? We can’t seem to figure that out ourselves. We payed ex-DEA agents outrageous money to run around and destroy poppy fields while Marines I know where happy to ignore the fields if the tribal leaders stopped the roadside bombs. If we can’t figure out our own objectives how can we ever ‘win’.

Personally, I’m all for using SF/Airpower to help a side we believe to be the best and letting the naturally lines form: Shia, Sunni, Kurd, etc. The region is beset with fake boundaries dictated by foreign powers and our foray hasn’t helped. We can’t allow ISIS to exist, but ground troops aren’t the answer. I’d begin by funding all limited wars through SOCOM, otherwise big military will stomp-in, take as much money as it can, and create havoc. Let the units trained in FID working with the locals dictate the support assets they need.

And I’d hardly say we conducted these wars on the cheap. Could have been a lot cheaper regarding money if big military had stayed out and we focused only on routing out Al-Qaeda and not on some fantasy of nation building. And cheap regarding KIAs, well I’m glad about that one since more people killed doesn’t necessarily mean a better outcome. I don’t believe more troops, more force, and more governance imposed by an external entity would have solved the problems of either Iraq or Afghanistan. The problem wasn’t a lack of political will but a lack of political reality and an inability to actually figure out realistic goals that could be accomplished based upon the situation on the ground and the assets we have as a country.

← PreviousPage 5 of 10Next →