1,968 karma · joined February 9, 2010
Just curious, but what in particular? Their profile page, logs of forum conversations? And how does he/she generate the guesses? It seems like optimally you'd have some kind of tool which constructs permutations of likely words (sun, 5un, sun!, etc).
...Honestly just curious, promise I'm not planning anything evil.
That is, let's not be so quick to patch the problem with the first thing that isn't a chair.
But it's also possible that artists (and especially designers) tend to use it a lot just because they've heard that it's beautiful, when really it's nothing special. In this case, it would just tend to crop up in beautiful works because a) it crops up in all kinds of works anyway (base rate) and b) there's a whole lot of looking for it in hindsight (especially in works acknowledged as beautiful, while nobody goes looking for it in ugly works).
Some kind of A-B study would be nice. I found one (http://www.livescience.com/7389-sense-beauty-partly-innate-s...), but the methodology seems a bit lacking, I'd say it's far from conclusive.
And when I say "vast majority", I'm referring to the fact that even ripping a mix CD a friend made you or copying an album or 2 off a thumb drive constitutes piracy.
Of course, none of this matters because it's completely impossible for Apple to compile this data reliably.
If Apple has not earnestly dug into and improved on this software, users will be completely mystified and the whole thing will be a big embarrassment for Apple.
The significance of this is offset by the base rate though: unlike Windows PCs, blondes don't constitute 90% of the sample group.
As was pointed out by another commenter, if the game had been "everyone who knows the answer write it down and get credit", Watson probably wouldn't have won, and absolutely not by so much.
So I think Jennings is just cautioning us not to assume that AI has achieved human level language and information capabilities when really a totally unrelated and unimpressive other dimension of the game is the culprit.
This is false, in fact they specifically mentioned Watson learning from the answers of the other players.
In the game, Watson answers "The 1920s" after Jennings answers incorrectly with "the 20s". Basically, it didn't write off its own answer because it thought Jennings' was different enough that it might have been incorrect for the way it was phrased. The same way you might correctly answer "inner ear" after someone else incorrectly answers "ear".
Not that this can't be taken care of with a little careful coding, just saying that user-agent sniffing is still troublesome, and separating desktop from mobile can be tricker than expected.
So it's a cool accomplishment, but it's never going to be "like Mac, but totally unhackable!" or anything like that.
Surprised he didn't want to clarify that...
Active use of the "Hide from news feed" option makes facebook a much happier place.