HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

prof-dr-ir

1,862 karma · joined June 19, 2020

submissionscomments
prof-dr-ir··on A new way to make quadratic equations easy (2019)
From 2019.

And, dare I say it, still a waste of time. In my not-so-humble opinion you either know enough algebra to understand that, for non-zero a, 0 = a x^2 + b x + c <=> 0 = x^2 + b/a x + c/a <=> 0 = (x + b/2a)^2 - b^2/4a^2 + c/a <=> (x + b/2a)^2 = (b^2 - 4 a c) / 4a^2 or you need to improve your basic algebra skills - not search for a better derivation of this particular formula.

prof-dr-ir··on In major shift, EU says vaccine boosters should be considered for all adults
I do not think this is an example of the (real) problem you are highlighting. First, the ECDC is not a government. Second, their previous standpoint was not inconsistent or wrong: in particular, there was no urgent need for boosters (for healthy youngsters) in September since the vaccines appeared to be working well.

Did you read the ECDC guidance, in September and now? Can you point out the passage that exemplifies your point? Or do you have another example of a government saying that young people will never get boosters? Since naturally you did not write your comment based solely on the tone implied by the words 'major shift' in the headline of the Reuters article...

There are certainly people, journalists, and government ministers guilty of what you say. But throwing a catchall accusation around is a bit cheap, in my opinion.

prof-dr-ir··on Tesla displaces Mercedes-Benz as third-most-popular luxury brand in U.S.
This is an outdated view. It is better to view Tesla stock as a "store of value", like we do with so many other expensive things nowadays.

/s, of course

prof-dr-ir··on Stop Making Students Use Eclipse (2020)
I just would like to add that I think this was an outstandingly written post.

For example, look at the first sentence: it promptly sets the stage ('first introduction programming for computer science students') and confers the main point (about using a professional IDE), all while remaining straightforward to understand. The reader knows exactly what is coming! I thought the remainder of the article was equally sharp, well-argued, and stylistically quite pleasant.

Sadly, the main points of the article seem to be sorely misrepresented in this comment thread. I do not know why, but I really would not want this to discourage the author from writing more.

prof-dr-ir··on C³: A "cool" route to the Higgs boson and beyond
Stating that such a project is worth doing only if it produces other technological advances is not something I would like to be accused of, but fortunately your question does not have to be interpreted in that way.

Here is an exchange between physicist Robert Wilson and senator John Pastore in 1969, about establishing Fermilab.

Pastore: Is there anything connected with the hopes of this accelerator that in any way involves the security of the country?

Wilson: No sir, I don't believe so.

P: Nothing at all?

W: Nothing at all.

P: It has no value in that respect?

W: It has only to do with the respect with which we regard one another, the dignity of man, our love of culture. It has to do with: Are we good painters, good sculptors, great poets? I mean all the things we really venerate in our country and are patriotic about. It has nothing to do directly with defending our country except to make it worth defending.

prof-dr-ir··on C³: A "cool" route to the Higgs boson and beyond
Good question, and the answer is not easy.

It looks like the proposed accelerator smashes electrons and positrons together which are nice and clean elementary particles (as far as we know), so much of the collision energy is directly usable to create, say, Higgs bosons with a mass of 125GeV.

At the LHC they smash protons into each other which at this scale are a bit like a soupy mess of quarks and gluons. So its 13 TeV c.o.m. energy actually gets spread out over multiple elementary particles, which might not even hit each other straight on. Because of this the number of high-energy collisions between elementary particles is significantly lower.

This is just my lay-physicist perspective by the way; an accelerator specialist can probably provide more details.

prof-dr-ir··on EU Chatcontrol 2.0 [video]
IT companies warn in open letter: EU wants to ban encryption - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26825653 - April 2021 (217 comments)
prof-dr-ir··on EU Chatcontrol 2.0 [video]
Thank you for this clarification. This topic has been previously discussed on HN and sadly the top comments seem to always result in poorly informed pitchfork parties against the EU and its institutions.

I would urge people to read the linked texts in your comment. I think they will see that it is entirely possible to follow the (imperfect) thought process of the EU Commission from these primary sources, since they are quite readable.

prof-dr-ir··on Theorem demonstrates that CNNs can always be trained on quantum computers
Suggested background music: "if I were a rich man" https://youtu.be/j5fCqKbSC7M

If I had a quantum computer, I could do all these wonderful things... it's interesting theoretical research but we do not have the machines yet.

prof-dr-ir··on The big alcohol study that didn't happen
Of course we 'know' nothing for sure - which is a truism that applies both to the original comment and to yours... but my point is that you should rarely be convinced by a single study.

That said, I have no specific criticism on the paper you refer to. It might be that the lower risk of heart disease is outweighed by an elevated risk for e.g. cancer? In that way both results can be true.

prof-dr-ir··on Pumps run dry at gas stations in Britain
Your claim that "there is no shortage of drivers" according to "everyone in the industry" is incorrect. From [0]:

BP blamed the restrictions on “delays in the supply change which has been impact by the industry-wide driver shortages across the UK”.

Tesco said it had “experienced temporary supply issues caused by driver absences in recent days”, adding: “We expect the situation to improve in the next week and apologise to our customers for any inconvenience caused.”

[0] https://inews.co.uk/news/hgv-driver-shortage-bp-to-start-rat...

prof-dr-ir··on Conversations on Quantum Gravity
The blog post itself quotes Edward Witten, a Fields medal winner, as saying "String theory is the only idea about quantum gravity with any substance". It quotes David Gross, Nobel prize winner, as saying "Loop quantum gravity is total BS". Then it seems to shrug and say, well, too bad they're all so wrong.

What am I missing? What are the priors for trusting the author of this blog more than the seemingly universal voice of these authorities?

prof-dr-ir··on UK to overhaul privacy rules in post-Brexit departure from GDPR
If UK privacy law starts to deviate significantly from GDPR then the EU commission will not hesitate to withdraw its 'equivalence' decision on UK privacy rights [0]. This will hamper the flow of data from the EU to the UK, the costs of which to UK businesses will more than offset any "Brexit dividend for individuals and businesses across the UK" that the culture secretary is seemingly so keen on obtaining.

Of course, these kind of nuances tend to get forgotten by those who think they can secure better trade deals by spending £200M on a boat [1].

[0] https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2021/jun/28/eu-rules-...

[1] https://www.ft.com/content/c77b7aa1-cebc-47c6-a04a-d21eef2d1...

prof-dr-ir··on UK to overhaul privacy rules in post-Brexit departure from GDPR
Also, the cookie popups are not an immediate consequence of GDPR, but rather of its interplay with another directive from 2002 [0]. The EU has of course taken notice of the irritation of the public and is trying to improve on the state of affairs with the proposed ePrivacy Regulation [1].

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Privacy_and_Electronic_Communi...

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EPrivacy_Regulation

prof-dr-ir··on Physicist discovered an escape from Hawking’s black hole paradox
That is an unrelated result, although the confusion is understandable.

You refer to a theorem, named after Hawking, that states that in classical general relativity the area of black hole horizons must always increase. The experimental confirmation of this theorem refers to the fact that the total area indeed appears to have increased for the black hole merger event observed by LIGO (which should indeed fall well within the realm of classical general relativity).

However, once quantum gravitational effects are taken into account this black hole theorem no longer holds. Indeed, since the real world should be quantum, it is expected that the area of black holes eventually does decrease: they evaporate by emitting Hawking radiation. This is however purely a theoretical expectation, since these evaporation effects are a loooong way from being observable; evaporation probably only becomes a significant effect on time scales far beyond the current age of the universe.

In quantum gravity there are nevertheless plenty of theoretical paradoxes and open questions, and the above article describes some recent progress by the theoreticians in this area.

prof-dr-ir··on One does not simply calculate the absolute value
"1e-3"
prof-dr-ir··on A Programmer’s Introduction to Mathematics
I have no specific comment to make on the (first two chapters of the) book recommended by this blog. However I have become wary of people recommending a textbook because it finally helped them understand something they had tried to wrap their head around for years.

I heard a conjecture once that the best textbook you'll find on any given topic is your third. The point, of course, is that it simply takes about three serious attempts to make it click - but it is a fallacy to give all the credit to the third book.

prof-dr-ir··on Messaging and chat control
If you have been following this site for a while then you know that it is a truth universally acknowledged (well - on HN), that the EU wants to "ban encryption".

I keep having the same question as you, and will refrain from joining the pitchfork party until I see actual proof.

prof-dr-ir··on Embarrassed by your Olympic javelin: did cavemen do it better? (2012)
There are also clear safety advantages to recumbents, like harder breaking without flipping over and an unobstructed view without sacrificing aerodynamics, so I do not think they should automatically be considered less safe.

I am also pretty confident that the 'manoeuvrability' disadvantage is completely irrelevant for any individual track event. And do you think that it would be an important factor for time trials?

prof-dr-ir··on Embarrassed by your Olympic javelin: did cavemen do it better? (2012)
Cycling is actually another notorious example of a sport where the rules are holding back significant innovation:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Recumbent_bicycle

prof-dr-ir··on Testing quantum mechanics in space
If you (and the cited wikipedia article a few comments up) mean i d/dt | psi > = H | psi > then sure, that might refer to a relativistic theory and in that sense my comment was imprecise. But showing that a given Hamiltonian is relativistic generally requires work, and I still think there is merit to my point that these theories seem to start 'at the wrong end'.
prof-dr-ir··on Testing quantum mechanics in space
I often see the argument 'we should check because you never know' being used for supporting exotic science experiments. But I think it is too dogmatic.

Indeed, we have not tested experimentally whether launching andi999 into space will affect the muon g-2 anomalous magnetic moment. Although you might be very supportive of testing that hypothesis, I would sincerely doubt that it would lead to a discovery of new physics.

In the end this boils down to funding decisions for the sciences, which are invariably nuanced, difficult and political. Simply saying 'we should try because nobody else has' would convince only the most naive of funders.

prof-dr-ir··on Testing quantum mechanics in space
It appears that these theories are not relativistic and claim that energy is not conserved. Therefore they will have significant trouble explaining almost all particle physics experiments.

From the perspective of a theoretical particle physicist these theories are also awkward because they try to fiddle with non-relativistic quantum mechanics like the Schrodinger equation. But that equation merely arises in the non-relativistic limit of the more fundamental relativistic quantum mechanics, more commonly known as quantum field theory. Therefore, if you want to probe the foundations of quantum theory then quantum field theory seems like a much better place to start.

As an analogy, these attempts sound like a nineteenth-century person trying to understand gravity starting from F = m g h rather than F = - G m1 m2 / r^2.

For these reasons I would not be supportive of significant funding for theoretical or experimental research in these collapse theories.

prof-dr-ir··on Why extraterrestrial life may not seem alien
An intelligent being in a 'state' of decreasing entropy seems a little difficult to imagine.

Much more realistic, IMO, would be a civilization that was made entirely of dark matter. Perhaps they might be able to infer our existence if we built some insanely powerful particle accelerator (and vice versa). If not then we would presumable only be able to communicate through gravitational effects...

prof-dr-ir··on France Gave Teenagers $350 for Culture. They’re Buying Comic Books
The second reference you gave lists four opinion pieces, one culinary review whose tongue-in-cheek comment it misinterprets, and one actual news article about the impact of austerity in Britain.

That one news article was a subject of intense discussion at the time which quickly became politicized. A decent overview of the discussion can be found at

https://www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/news/business/prescot-makes-...

For what it's worth, I wholly subscribe to the OP's viewpoint that the NY times' reports from France have been subpar in recent months - in my view they have been too Americo-Centric and do not sufficiently recognize the different value system in France. But I have often been positively surprised by the paper's reporting on UK issues (and on Brexit in particular).

prof-dr-ir··on Disinformation for hire, a shadow industry, is quietly booming
I missed this earlier, sorry and thank you for the well-researched post.

Among other things, I will happily agree with you that the Snopes page is simply not correct. I will not hold the NY times responsible for that, however.

As you have surely seen, in his twitter thread the senator does list "the engineered-bioweapon hypothesis" as a possible option, and also says that "the so-called experts" do not really know any better.

So I can see the viewpoint of the NY times: it is newsworthy if a senator lends credence to a possibility that scientists widely dismissed. As an analogy, a senator who believes that the earth is flat might be equally interesting for a news publication - even if it is masked by phrases like 'we need to keep an open mind', 'the experts might be wrong', etc -- 'the earth might be flat' is simply not a reasonable position for a senator to hold.

But I can also see your point. It was early days of the pandemic and there were lots of unknowns. The general gist of the argument was one of caution and keeping an open mind towards all possibilities, which was healthy. And for a senator it would have been hard at those times to distinguish between something that scientists almost universally dismissed and something that they were still debating about.

Perhaps we can agree that the newsworthiness of the content of the NY times article was not entirely obvious, and the reasons it was published anyway could have been political (even if this was not consciously done). Based on your research it seems that the resulting storm of negative publicity by other outlets was not justified.

prof-dr-ir··on Disinformation for hire, a shadow industry, is quietly booming
The first of these is a stub and might be unclear on the meaning of "originated in". Again, if you read it as "engineered" I do not think I can disagree with its content. The second is the one I referred to and seems to have appeared at most a day later.

Also - what exactly is your point? Like the other readers here I could probably be convinced that my example is bad, and you might even be able to make us adjust our opinion of the NY times. But right now I only see a suggestion of criticism rather than the raising of an actual issue. Would it be too much to ask you elaborate?

prof-dr-ir··on Disinformation for hire, a shadow industry, is quietly booming
If you are on the fence then it might be worth re-reading what the NY times wrote about it back then.

For example, I could not find much wrong with this from February 2020:

https://www.nytimes.com/2020/02/17/business/media/coronaviru...

It does (correctly, IMO) focus on the 'bioweapon' conspiracies rather than the 'lab leak' theory and mentions how the senator ended up distancing himself from the former.

And actually, the original letter in The Lancet might also not be entirely unreasonable? I cannot find fault with it, provided one interprets the phrase 'not have a natural origin' as 'engineered' (rather than 'leaked'). See here:

https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6...

You should of course feel free to disagree, but it might be worth reading these sources before continuing the discussion? And maybe there are other articles I missed?

prof-dr-ir··on Quantum computing hype is bad for science
I am not incredulous and neither, I believe, is the article's author. You are arguing besides the point.

This is not about you or D-wave. Instead it is like there is a shop with so little supervision that every customer has to be trusted to not steal things. So if a customer asks: "What can I do to convince the world that I am not stealing?" then the answer is clear: you either show your shopping bag to everyone in the world, or we need an entirely different kind of shop.

The point of this part of the article is that, for quantum computing, there is an equivalent structural problem. Until it is absolutely manifest that quantum computers do useful things that classical computers cannot, the potential for fraud remains real.

prof-dr-ir··on Quantum computing hype is bad for science
If all you can offer is your "personal assurance" then that seems to exactly confirms the author's point.

From my reading the article's point was really to note the risk of fraud. It did not claim that this kind of fraud is actually happening now.

I also think that the article is more nuanced on the topic of brain drain than you make it out to be. Is your argument not just whataboutery? And what do you think of the article's claim that "it may not be a zero-sum game"?

← PreviousPage 7 of 11Next →