HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

prof_hobart

1,031 karma · joined August 27, 2011

submissionscomments
prof_hobart··on Member of The European Union
The UK doesn't feel that way either. The country is largely run by, and for, a small sliver of our society and does little to help vast swathes of it.
prof_hobart··on Mongolia is changing all its addresses to three-word phrases
Hmm.

A word with one letter difference from my house (in the English midlands) puts the address in the middle of mountains in western China.

It's annoying enough when a parcel gets delivered to an address near me because the delivery driver can't tell where my road ends and another one starts. But I'm not going to China to pick up my next Amazon order when someone miskeys.

prof_hobart··on University pays $20,000 to ransomware hackers
Not as much of a nuisance as having all of your data corrupted.
prof_hobart··on People suck at technical interviews (2014)
You have to think about what they are trying to test. If it's "Do they know how to quickly find an answer to a known problem?", then your route is correct.

If it's "Could they take a problem that hasn't been solved before and solve it themselves?", then you're not really demonstrating that.

Unless I'm told otherwise, I would assume that a coding challenge would be more of the latter.

Of course, it's not how you'd solve it in real life. But that's like saying you should be allowed a calculator in a mental maths exam because you'd never try to to 27324/623 in your head these days.

prof_hobart··on Oil Traders May Be the Only Ones Who Want Yahoo to Survive
If no-one is prepared to pay for it, it's probably going to get destroyed at some point anyway.

If something is absolutely critical to the running of your business, then at some point you need to at least consider paying for it.

prof_hobart··on The Immutability of Math and How Almost Everything Else Will Pass
Without basic maths, sure.

But I've had a 30 year career in software development (covering everything from low level comms software in the 80s through to workflow automation software today) and I never got further than A level maths - which for non-Brits, is the exams you typically do at around 18. I don't feel the lack of a university maths background has ever particularly held me back.

prof_hobart··on Disruption is not a strategy
Like I say, I'm not disagreeing with the idea that "we will disrupt" on its own is no more use as a business case than "we will make wads of cash".

What I am questioning is the idea that there's only one way to disrupt an industry - to be cheaper and in some way subpar compared to the incumbent. You seem to be suggesting that the taxi industry hasn't been disrupted by Uber, because it doesn't align with one person's definition of what disruption looks like. And I don't really understand that. There's clearly been huge disruption there.

prof_hobart··on Disruption is not a strategy
Although I agree that having a business plan that's based on nothing more than a concept of "being disruptive" is not much of a plan at all, I feel that in some parts, he's picking a strawman and arguing against that.

He claims that "I’m sure what the presenter of the slide was getting at was Clayton Christensen’s definition of disruption from his classic book The Innovator’s Dilemma. ".

He then goes on to say (talking about Square and Uber) that "neither of these companies were disruptive in The Innovator’s Dilemma sense". However, I'd be surprised if the presenter wasn't thinking precisely of people like Uber and the type of "disruption" they've brought to the taxi industry.

So, if they are thinking of Uber, and if Uber's disruption isn't the sort being talked about in the Innovators dilemma, then I suspect they weren't thinking of Christensen’s definition at all.

I'm not sure why disruption has to be less functional - it just needs to be tackling the root problem (and often redefining what that root problem is) in a different way to the incumbent.

prof_hobart··on Two-hundred-terabyte math proof is largest ever
Depends on how you look at it. The 200TB seems to be the data required to prove that none of the possible combinations works.

If it had been temporary data to get to a simple proof of something, then I'd agree that this data was just a side-effect.

But if I'm understanding it correctly, as it stands even if you're told that it stops at 7,825, you'd still need all of this data to prove that it's true.

prof_hobart··on E Ink announces a full color electrophoretic ePaper display
Depends on what you're reading. If you're reading books with maps or photos (I read a lot of travelogues for example), it would make quite a difference.
prof_hobart··on Chrome removes Backspace to go back
Nope. Just done that, in a tree view. Took me to folder 2
prof_hobart··on Hello world in every programming language
"Every" is a big claim.

No Pick/Basic[1] for a start, or Sculptor[2], as just two of the languages I've used in the past that haven't made it onto the list.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pick_operating_system [2] http://www.sculptor.co.uk/

prof_hobart··on LinkedIn password leak
You don't, and it can be embarrassing. I've seen it happen with a colleague.

But what happened was embarrassment, not their life savings being wiped out.

prof_hobart··on Software Design Patterns Are Not Goals, They Are Tools
It's a good sign of flexibility, but not a good sign of being a professional on a job.

And it's something I see depressingly often with programmers - tackling problems that there's a fairly well known existing pattern for, but not being aware of the pattern and either spending days/weeks rediscovering the pattern for themselves, or even worse inventing a new and less effective way of solving it.

prof_hobart··on Chrome removes Backspace to go back
Just tried it on my Windows 7 and it's quite definitely going up one level, not back in history.

If I've got a folder structure

1 | |--1.1 | |--1.2

And I click into 1.1 and then into 1.2, if I then press backspace I end up on 1 (the parent), not 1.1 (the previous in the history).

prof_hobart··on Online tracking: A 1-million-site measurement and analysis
I thought the same thing, so I did a bit of digging.

Turns out they put a bunch of tracking cookies on your machine without asking you (it is mentioned in the about page though), which seem rather naughty for an organisation promoting online privacy.

When I removed all 4 of them, I get down to being "almost unique". I'm currently down to having the same fingerprint as 1 in 45132.3333333 browsers.

prof_hobart··on Software Design Patterns Are Not Goals, They Are Tools
>, if you ever find yourself thinking, "I know, I'll use a design pattern" before writing any code, you're doing it wrong.

Unless I'm misunderstanding him, I would disagree with this. When you're doing it wrong is when you use a design pattern without understanding what problem its solving, and whether you have that specific problem.

To use his tool analogy - if you're a joiner who turns up to a job thinking "we always need to use a hammer" and start randomly hitting everything, then you've gone wrong. But equally, if you're halfway through knocking a nail in with your shoe and think "Oh look, I'm using the hammer pattern now", you're doing it just as wrong.

If you're looking at two things you need to attach together and you've considered whether glue, a screw, a nail or something else is the most appropriate for this specific job, decide it's the nail and then think - "I need to use my hammer now", then you're doing it right.

prof_hobart··on Multiple 7-Zip Vulnerabilities Discovered
Not everyone has enough bandwidth in their lives to actively fix every broken free/open source project out there.

Rather than being seen as attacks on a project, these sorts of comments are often just highlighting some things that whoever is looking at that particular project might want to fix.

The "don't criticise unless you're prepared to fix it" attitude is very similar to the sort of "Don't bring me problems, just solutions" attitude that some managers have that results in a culture of people keeping quiet about stuff they've spotted but don't have either the time or ability to fix themselves.

prof_hobart··on Google: End of the Online Advertising Bubble
That's great in theory, but how many people would be prepared to pay even more on top of their existing internet charges to fund this?

I'm sure some would, but I also suspect most wouldn't.

There's also the question of "instead, it will automatically track their browsing activity...". That would be enough to put off a lot of people.

prof_hobart··on Google: End of the Online Advertising Bubble
What would be paying for most of it?

An awful lot of the content out there exists because there's money in it (or at least the hope of money). And most of what pays for that is ads.

prof_hobart··on Personal info of 93M Mexicans exposed on AWS
Political affiliation isn't.
prof_hobart··on Personal info of 93M Mexicans exposed on AWS
As a non-American, the bit that amazes me is "political affiliation .. and voting history". Really?

Isn't voting meant to be a private thing?

prof_hobart··on Organize Your Closet Like a Computer Organizes Memory
> I'd argue that most of those are acting like FILO queues anyways, since you typically don't need random access to clothes in a washing machine/from the to-be-washed pile.

Except in emergencies. But I regularly need stuff from the "hanging on the clothes drier"/"in the basket ready to come upstairs"/"in a big pile on the end of the bed ready to be put in the wardrobe" ones.

> but it isn't caching as described in the article,

It's still caching. It's just a prefetch cache - using quiet time to prefetch my clothes for when they are needed very quickly.

> so excellent organization is (probably) the best way to cut down on overall time.

I'm not sure it is. Excellent organisation has quite a write-time overhead. In most cases, the amount of effort to organise everything perfectly is going to outweigh the fractional time saving I'd get on most mornings.

And in this case I'm also not looking to optimise overall time. I'm specifically looking to optimise speed to access it in the morning.

>This is _still_ not caching, since you weren't going to sit down and perform some access intensive operations on your wallet and keys in the morning,

I would be. If I had to go and get my single credit card from the filing cabinet where I keep the rest of them, then go and get my work pass from a "work" pile, my keys from the key box, my coat from the closet, my shoes from the shoe cupboard, my bus pass from my transport drawer, my daughter's school bag from her school-related pile etc, etc.

The author makes it pretty clear that he's talking about caching in exactly this way

"Caching is such an obvious thing because we do it all the time. I mean, the amount of information I get . . . certain things I have to keep track of right now, a bunch of things I have on my desk, and then other things are filed away, and then eventually filed away into the university archives system where it takes a whole day to get stuff out of it if I wanted. But we use that technique all the time to try to organize our lives."

At the end of the day, it's never going to be a cache in the true computer sense of the work - there's not a separate copy being made (except in the case of my keys, where I've got exactly that, but that's more for failover than for caching) - but the idea of grouping things by speed of access in a given scenario rather than by category is analogous enough to caching to be worth discussing.

If you want to call it "locality of reference", that's fine (and the link even talks about caching as one form of it). But one critical factor of an analogy is that it's a reasonably well understood term, and I strongly suspect that a lot more people would understand cache than locality of reference.

prof_hobart··on Organize Your Closet Like a Computer Organizes Memory
Most people have several stores for clothes (wardrobe/closet, wash basket, washing machine, in a basket waiting to make it back to the wardrobe etc) and depending how organised you are, the clothes you need could be in any of those on a given morning.

And in the wardrobe itself, I don't have enough separate shelves to be able to organise my clothes both by type and by purpose (so I've got sports socks, walking socks and work socks all in the same drawer for example). It can sometimes take several minutes to locate all of the clothes I actually want for a given day.

On days that I need to be out of the house particularly early, I will "cache" my next day's clothes by getting all of them ready the night before and putting them by the end of the bed, so that I've got instant access to them.

Similarly, I've got a cache of stuff that I need on a daily basis - keys, my wallet with some money and a single credit card in etc - on a shelf near the door, whereas the rest of my keys and the rest of my cards are grouped together somewhere else in the house.

I think it's this kind of stuff that the article is talking about.

prof_hobart··on Jeff Bezos’ letter to shareholders
Have you ever contacted Amazon about the delivery firms that you've had issues with? I contacted them on 3 separate occasions about CityLink - they refused to leave parcels either in my porch or with a neighbour and their nearest collection depot was at that time 3 bus journeys away in a different county.

After the third one, I said I would be cancelling my Prime if they ever delivered (or rather didn't deliver) again. I don't know if was coincidence or not, but I don't think I've had an attempted delivery from them since.

prof_hobart··on The absolute horror of WiFi light switches
Sure. I can post some more details (such as scripts and photo) when I get home if you're interested.

But at a high level, it's pretty straightforward, and there's also almost certainly far better ways of doing it.

The key components are

- a Philips Hue light

- The Openhab[1] open source home automation server (currently running on an old Windows box that's always on for various other reasons). This controls the lights.

- Apache, also running on the same box. This provides a very simple web UI for the Pi.

- A Raspberry Pi - it's one of the original Pi model Bs.

- Firefox (Iceweasel version) on the Pi - the built-in one didn't seem to run the jquery that I needed.

- A cheapo touchscreen [2] attached to the Pi.

The OpenHab server has a plugin for Hue lights, and you can write scripts to make it do various things, such as switch on/off at a particular time, or on getting a command from somewhere else. It also has a REST API interface.

It's this API interface that the web app is calling. That's made up at the moment of 3 buttons (on, off and dim), and when one is pressed it sends a jquery REST call to the OpenHab server to trigger one of the commands. Technically, what it's doing is setting one of 3 OpenHab "buttons" to ON. This triggers the OpenHab rule to change the light.

The touchscreen attaches straight onto the Pi's GPIO pins. I pointed Firefox at the Apache on my server and set it to full screen mode. The screen's not great - it feels as cheap as you'd expect for £16 - but it works, and most importantly my daughter loves it.

Like I say, there's almost certainly better/simpler ways to achieve some of this - I suspect I could run the entire thing on the Pi for example, or replace the Pi with an old iPhone that I've got lying around. The OpenHab software also allows you to build a custom UI itself. But I like playing, and there's a bunch of tech things that I wanted to try out, and this seemed like a fun and useful project to test them out on.

My next plan is to get an Arduino and connect some dials to it to allow direct control of brightness and RGB.

[1] http://www.openhab.org/ [2] http://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B00YE0UPES

prof_hobart··on The absolute horror of WiFi light switches
I don't know about his particular setup, but remote control lights do have their uses.

I've got a couple of wifi-controlled Philips Hue lights. There isn't a simple "on" or "off" for these - they can be set to just about any colour and brightness. One, for instance, is set to wake my daughter up with an artificial sunrise over the space of about 15 mins in the morning, is off automatically during most of the day when there's no one in the house, and goes a very dim red at night.

As my wife has a habit of forgetting that they switch themselves off, she still fairly frequently physically switches it off at the wall. If it's still of at the point that the "dim for the evening" program is due to run, then it doesn't get triggered and I have to dig out my phone app to kick it off.

So I've just built a little switch using a Pi and a very cheap (in both senses of the word) touch screen running a web page with buttons on it that triggers various actions on the light such as setting the dimmer colour.

I'm waiting for the day when there's a cheap and good off the shelf switch that does this kind of thing properly for home automation.

prof_hobart··on Get HTTPS for free
I may well be an exception, but I actually find it easier to read with wider columns.

I don't like narrow columns being forced on me, and if line length bothers you, can't you just set your browser to the width you like?

prof_hobart··on How 3D printing threatens our patent system
If I'm reading it correctly, the World Intellectual Property Organisation (WIPO) disagrees [1]

> Most of the Member States provide the private and/or non-commercial use exception under their statutes. Only the response from Australia informed that the exception was not included in its statutes, but provided by common law as a “non-commercial use defense”

...

> Most of the Member States, however, provide a broad definition of the scope of the patent rights which encompasses all kinds of activities, and explicitly stipulate that private use for non-commercial purposes or private and non-commercial use is an exception to the exclusive patent rights. In formulating the exception, provisions of many national laws stipulate that the it applies to acts carried out in the private sphere and for non-commercial purposes or to use of a patented invention for personal needs with no purpose to make profits. The response from the United Kingdom stated that the exclusion is provided for acts done “privately and for the purposes which are not commercial”.

[1] http://www.wipo.int/edocs/mdocs/patent_policy/en/scp_20/scp_...

prof_hobart··on How Mickey Mouse Evades the Public Domain
>There can be little doubt that anyone seeing the image of Mickey Mouse (or even his silhouette), immediately thinks of Disney.

Image probably, but the phrase "Mickey Mouse" has acquired a fairly common meaning (at least in the UK and Ireland, don't know about the rest of the world) outside of the character - roughly meaning something like simplistic, shoddy or cheap.

For example, this (http://www.independent.ie/regionals/droghedaindependent/news...) article talking about a plan as a "'Mickey Mouse' solution to a much bigger traffic problem in the Dublin Road area." I suspect that few people over here would immediately think about Disney when they read this article.

← PreviousPage 2 of 20Next →