HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

pserwylo

1,053 karma · joined June 20, 2012

Developer. Free software enthusiast.

Some of my open source android apps:

https://github.com/lexica/lexica https://github.com/retrowars/retrowars https://github.com/babydots/babydots https://github.com/beat-feet/beat-feet

submissionscomments
pserwylo··on Stop Australia's Data Retention Bill
With this particular legislation, it is very clear to me why it is bad. I am able to articulate to people that regardless of who proposed or supported the idea, it is not a good idea to keep information on my family and friends, such as where they move, who is in their social networks, what topics they search the web for in the privacy of their own home. I feel that it is empowering to explain why it is not a necessary or proportionate response to place the entire country under surveillance on the off chance one of us was to plan a terrorist related offence. I can also explain clearly why this is something which will result in all lay people being monitored, but none of the technical savvy people who actively try and circumvent the retention scheme using a mix of offshore VPS + VPN + tor + whatever other technology helps them.

As beefsac said, this is a policy which will likely have support from the two major parties. I encourage all people who oppose this particular legislation to explain to their friends, families, co-workers, etc the ramifications of mandatory data retention - without mentioning a particular party. I'm aware that discussions about legislation such as this often end up in name slanging and partisan comments. However I think it is very important to debate these things with a clear head. As much as possible when discussing politics and legislation, I try to refrain from referring to any specific party or politician. I fear that if I do, I'm allowing people to attack my argument by saying "of course you'd say that, you leftist greenie" or "of course you'd say that, you right winged conservatist". Lets play the ball, not the man.

FYI - I've already contacted my local MP - the first time I've felt the need to do so. I await his reply.

Edit: grammar

pserwylo··on Australian Government Scrambles to Authorize Mass Surveillance
I find it greatly concerning that laws are passed with such haste, and then justified by very recent events. To clarify, the two recent events which seem to be frequently cited by the law makers is:

* An anti-terrorism raid across two states, which charged one person and questioned several others. This happened a couple of weeks ago.

* A tragic incident in which an 18yo stabbed two police officers and then was shot dead. This happened a few days ago.

I fail to see how any of the provisions in the new laws are able to be justified by either of these events.

Firstly, the anti-terrorism raids worked seemingly well without the yet-to-be-passed-laws. They successfully used existing laws to thwart a plan that allegedly involved the beheading of random members of the public.

Secondly, no amount of surveillance or detaining will stop a determined individual from being able to stab somebody who is standing right in front of them.

So as troubling as these two events were, it is also troubling that they are being used in this manner by politicians of both major persuasions.

pserwylo··on Remote code execution on Android devices
For internet blocking, AFWall+[0] is a fork of DroidWall which seems to be under active development.

Unfortunately, XPrivacy is not available on F-Droid, but anyone who is able to get it building and submitted to F-Droid would have my gratitude.

[0] - https://f-droid.org/repository/browse/?fdfilter=droidwall&fd...

pserwylo··on Obama's Secret Terrorist-Tracking System, by the Numbers
And yesterday Australia announced that it will be pushing ahead with an ISP level data retention scheme in the name of fighting terrorism [0]. This is after last year explicitly asking for feedback on the proposal to retain Australian's internet history, and receiving countless concerned letters from the community (along with security agencies who were pushing for data retention) [1].

I suspect in a decade or so that we will also have a similar chart as this post [2].

[0] - http://www.zdnet.com/abbott-brings-on-mandatory-data-retenti...

[1] - http://www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Committees/Hous...

[2] - Only an order of magnitude smaller due to our population difference.

pserwylo··on The seL4 microkernel
It's great to see more and more stuff come out of NICTA. For those who are unaware, it is a government funded research institution in Australia. A big difference from other research institutions is that they are especially focussed on commercially viable research (rather than purely theoretical stiff - although I'm sure they do some work on that too). It is a model that has been used for quite some time on Aus, with the CSIRO doing the same thing for more general (I.e. not specifically ICT) research. The CSIRO has done some beautifull research which forms the backbones of technology such as WiFi. So, putting aside recent budgetry and financial issues, it is great to see stuff like this being released by them. Here's to many more years of fruitful research.
pserwylo··on JSON Resume – a JSON-based open source standard for resumes
I would just like to say that I think that this is a great idea(despite agreeing with others here that XML + XSLT would seem like a more logical choice). I hope it gets some traction in the long run.

I've posted an issue on github [0][1] mentioning that "firstName" and "lastName" is probably not a good representation of names. I don't actually know what the solution is, but this article [2] gives some great reasons why we tend to make incorrect assumptions about peoples names, which have the possibility of excluding some people form our tools based on their name alone.

[0] - https://github.com/jsonresume/resume-schema/issues/4 [1] - It seemed like an appropriate place to comment. Please let me know if there is somewhere else you'd prefer such comments. [2] - http://www.kalzumeus.com/2010/06/17/falsehoods-programmers-b...

pserwylo··on Tailspotting: Identifying and profiting from CEO vacation trips
One of the best pieces of advice I heard from our resident stats/machine learning researcher at Uni was this: If a paper is published which claims to show a technique for profiting on the share market, then it doesn't work. If it did, they wouldn't have published it.

Having said that, there is plenty of interesting papers in this area, and from the abstract, this paper seems to take an interesting approach too.

pserwylo··on OpenTX is open source firmware for RC radio transmitters
For those of you interested in what might be a slightly lower level approach: I saw a talk from Andrew Trigell (of Samba/rsync fame) at linux.conf.au. In it, he was bemoaning the lack of Open Source firmware for radio transmitters, while pondering a UAV project hey were working on.

So, in typical tridge fashion, he and his friends created some, and given it is relatively simplistic, and the transmitters are quite tiny, the feature set seems pretty impressive (though I haven't had a need to use it... yet):

https://code.google.com/p/ardupilot-mega/wiki/3DRadio

pserwylo··on A group of 3,000 citizens is making better forecasts than CIA analysts
This is a common factor which is considered when researching approaches to crowd sourcing. The article at [0] shows how their approach deals with anti-forcasters ("adversarial answers") by doing exactly as you say - inverting their answer and calling them good.

[0] - http://scholar.google.com/scholar?cluster=144091158652582285...

pserwylo··on A group of 3,000 citizens is making better forecasts than CIA analysts
The issue of crowd sourcing answers to questions is a very interesting one. I've recently been reading research in this area with a colleague, and it is far more involved than the article makes it sound.

If you are interested, one of the first people to work on the problem were Dawid & Skene [0] back in 1979. They were trying to solve the issue of clinicians talking to patients and asking how they are. Each time they asked, the patient may give a slightly different answer. The goal was to estimate the "true" answer from the number of various "noisy" answers (sound familiar after reading the OP?)

The general intuition for most future research into the topic is that if you tend to agree with others more often than not, your score goes up. If your score is higher, your answers are trusted more.

Then there are a whole bunch of interesting additions to this principle, such as factoring in question difficulty [1] (e.g. questions which have the most disagreement can be considered more difficult, and hence you may want to ask more people about these questions to get a clearer picture). It is also helpful to seed certain questions for which the answer is "known" (may or may not be possible, depending on the project). Then you can use the answers to these questions to help score people even more accurately.

An even more interesting approach is to take into account people who answer adversarially, that is, they always answer incorrectly (either due to malicious intent, or they consistently misinterpret the questions in a backward fasion). If you have somebody who answers incorrectly 90% of the time, then they provide almost exactly the same information as someone who answers correctly 90% of the time. All you need to do is flip their vote once you've identified this.

The whole field is very facinating, and there seems to be more and more publications coming out with interesting approaches to the problem.

[0] http://scholar.google.com/scholar?cites=15953840037809938294...

[1] http://scholar.google.com/scholar?cluster=144091158652582285...

pserwylo··on Coffee and its Effects on Feature Creep (2011)
Well, if I order a large Meat Lovers, it is far too easy for somebody else to change it to half a small vegetarian. Then add 15 people, all wanting to screw with eachother, and it is far too easy to stuff up the whole thing.

Perhaps "gaming the system" was not the right choice of words, but I wanted to note that the author of the article seems to go to great lengths to stop this sort of abuse.

pserwylo··on 8.0 earthquake strikes northern Chile
> And I hope ad-hoc/mesh wireless networking technology takes off sooner rather than later

Are you familiar with the Serval Project [0]? These guys are working on exactly this solution, for exactly this (and other similar problems).

[0] http://www.servalproject.org/

pserwylo··on Coffee and its Effects on Feature Creep (2011)
I love this. Although it is a bit more advanced than what we had, we suffered a similar problem:

On Friday when the boss shouted us pizza, we had a problem with everybody trying to order various pizza's, various half pizza's, and various sized pizzas over email. Then the orderer had to collate all of these into a coherent order for the pizza shop.

In the end, we wrote a new module for our internal project management system called "The Pizza Module".

The Pizza Module would be pre-populated with the menu of our favourite pizza shop, so that you couldn't place an order for something that didn't exist. It would then allow people to enter orders via intranet, and then resolve things like four people ordering "half a mexicana" into two mexicana's. It also came with the "fat graph" report, which always had the orderer with the fattest amount (due to people who didn't have access to the intranet ordering through him).

Finally, it was fitted with a feature that prevented ordering, unless your timesheet was complete for the past two months. For a long time, it was very successful, and worked perfectly as intended).

However, in the end, it broke down when we moved away from it as we shifted to a different project management system. Nobody could be bothered writing a new pizza module (or refactoring the old pizza module to work with various project management systems), so we now use a collaborative Google doc with a table that people can place orders in. This is a Bad Idea™, and is far more open to gaming than the system described in the article. However, it is good for 5 minutes of entertainment on a Friday morning, watching people going back and forth on the shared doc.

pserwylo··on Textbooks Prices: Out of Control
Firstly, thanks for doing what you're doing. Even if it is a hassle to get it all together, I hope that the more people engaging in this type of effort can only be a good thing.

I agree that the coherency of the text book would be poor if everything was written by different authors. In fact, it is often so jarring when I read a journal article with different writing styles, that it is one of the easiest ways for me to identify plagiarism in student work or when reviewing for journals.

I guess the answer would be to have particularly committed and experienced editors like you mentioned in your attempt.

Perhaps if the book started of as quite a basic book, with key concepts, written by one person. Then, over time, that person (or small group of people) could accept pull requests from the community, and modify them to fit the style of the original book.

This could work quite similarly to most open source software projects:

1) Start of with one or a few people

2) Build only enough functionality for a working/useful piece of software

3) Over time, build up functionality via community contributions (and further contributions from the original contributors)

4) The direction of the project is steered by a group of people with its best interest in heart

Note how in the example of software, there is a fully working thing (even if it doesn't have all the bells and whistles attached) quite early in the process. Also, the overall vision for the project is kept in line by the original maintainer, who runs an eye over each pull requests and is free to make suggestions for changes. If there is any major disagreements, people from the community are free to fork the software and make it suit their needs.

I don't know how practical this is, in that a text book without huge amounts of detail may have less usefullness than a piece of software without huge amounts of functionality. Perhaps there are some fields which would benefit from such an approach, while others really do need to have a comprehensive, "finished" book to be of any use to anyone.

pserwylo··on Textbooks Prices: Out of Control
You are absolutely correct. I guess the answer would be that if such books were, e.g. CC licensed, then hard copies would be able to be printed. Given the prevailence of self publishing firms available, one would hope there is a market for text book publishers who compete on the printing price alone. Such companies needn't even be publishers themselves, but rather a middleman which makes use of self publishing services.
pserwylo··on Textbooks Prices: Out of Control
I'm genuinely astounded that there is not more of a movement towards open source style text books, that accept contributions (e.g. chapters) from reputable academics from around the world.

I understand that there is a huge amount of money involved, but surely the only stakeholders who benefit are:

1) The publishers, for obvious reasons

2) The authors, as they may get a healthy sum of money for writing a given text book.

3) (possibly) the teachers, if they get bribed into using a particular book in their curriculum.

Lets forget about the publishers, because they are for-profit businesses who do not have the students best interest at heart. We'll also forget about the teachers, because this type of bribing is not common in my experience (teachers I know tend to go for what they already know, rather than the new shiny book which came to them in the mail). Also, we can presume that teachers are not in the business of squeezing every last dollar out of their students.

As for the authors, I don't have an issue with people making money by writing text books. I know a few academics and industry people who are able to pursue more interesting goals because they have money coming in from books they've written. BUT THIS IS THE TINY MINORITY. Of all of the academics who would be capable of writing a chapter for, e.g. an introductory programming book, I would randomly estimate that only 0.1% of them have written a text book that is used in universities. If another 5% of them got together and contributed to an open source text book on the topic, that was liberally licensed and free for students to obtain and distribute, then why should we not embrace that?

I understand that "getting your name out there" is not motivation enough for doing such things [0]. However, surely just doing it for the good of education and teaching is motive enough?

Every now and again I see books come up on hacker news which seem like quite good resources (recently it was a cryptography book, another time it was a link to a github repo for a specific field of mathematics). It would be great if these projects could take off, and become the bibles for their relevant areas. And if a particular academic institution disagrees with the teaching of the book, don't go out and prescribe expensive text books to your students. Rather, fork the (e.g. CC-licensed) book that they are not happy with, and change it. Or better yet, submit a pull request, discuss the issues with the maintainers, and hopefully resolve the issue amicably.

It just astounds me that this is not a thing.

[0] - This occurs a lot in discussions about how companies such as Google try to get artwork from people at zero cost, citing that the artist will get "exposure".

pserwylo··on Push for Australians' web browsing histories to be stored
Yeah, go for it. That is indeed the correct link.

It's funny, because I was happy to read the coverage about the overwhelming amount of letters they received regarding data retention. However I was really dumbfounded when they mailed my a physical book with the contents of the report in it, rather than just emailing a link to the PDF or something. Lo and behold, it actually turned out to be useful for me to sit down on the couch this morning and thumb through after reading this new headline about the topic.

pserwylo··on Push for Australians' web browsing histories to be stored
For those interested, this was also brought up in 2012 [0]. Among 44 different things that were requesting comment, was this, tucked away in section 15c [1]:

"tailored data retention periods for up to 2 years for parts of a data set, with specific timeframes taking into account agency priorities, and privacy and cost impacts"

One of the main reasons it didn't end up going further was likely due to the fact so many Australians wrote to the inquiry expressing their concerns [1]:

"The Committee received 240 submissions and 29 exhibits. Three submissions were received in largely identical terms from some 5,300 individual members of the public. These submitter's expressed opposition to the reform proposals, particularly the proposed mandatory data retention proposal."

The part you will be interested in is "Chapter 5 - Data Retention" [2]. In it, the committee came to the conclusion that there wan't enough information provided in the terms of reference to make a proper judgement. However they talk about how it is of obvious interest to the law enforcement agencies, and obvious problem to civil libertarians. They commented on how it is up to the government to choose how to make a decision and take into account these two opposing views.

This is actually the first time I participated in a democratic process, beyond voting, and was pleasantly surprised to find out (only this morning during a more detailed read through the report) that they quoted my submission! [2 (Box 1)].

It is sort of the opposite to voting, where you feel "how can I make a difference". If you take the time to write in to such an inquiry, then it is highly likely that your opinion will get taken seriously.

[0] http://www.aph.gov.au/parliamentary_business/committees/hous...

[1] http://www.aph.gov.au/parliamentary_business/committees/hous...

[2] http://www.aph.gov.au/parliamentary_business/committees/hous...

pserwylo··on College considers basing president’s salary off that of cleaning staff
Well there you go. Now that you've mentioned The Invisible Hook, it occurs to me that this is what they were talking about on the radio. Thanks for the link.
pserwylo··on College considers basing president’s salary off that of cleaning staff
This sounds like a discussion of pirates I heard on the radio the other morning. It was about how pirates of a few hundred years ago had a very good idea of democracy, and how to ensure that the captain didn't become too far removed from the crew (though like all such systems, it was far from perfect).

It went something like this:

Captains get elected, and they get elected on cycles. At any point, if people are dissatisfied with the captain, they can overthrow them and reelect a new one (though not during chases or battles).

The bit that rings home with this article though, is that the captain generally had to eat with the crew members. If any one of the crew members decided they liked the captains meal better then theirs, the captain would have to swap.

Apparently, this helped to ensure some humbleness in the captain. Even though they called the shots, they were not this mystical being that nobody saw, interacted with, or felt out of touch with.

I think the tying of the presidents salary to that of his cleaners is a good example of this. He still gets to be the boss man, but can do it without being too far removed from the rest of the population of workers.

pserwylo··on I don't know, Timmy, being God is a big responsibility
This was a very well written discourse on the existence of different universes, and a bit of an intuition about how to think about them.

It reminds me a lot (though it is quite different) of "Flatland: A Romance of Many Dimensions" [0]. This book gave me the best intuition yet about what it would be like to experience a fourth spatial dimension.

Having said that, I still don't quite know what to think about it. I definitely don't have a mental picture of what it would be like. All I know is that when I was reading the book, I had a part of my brain clicking along, which felt like it understood what it is to experience an additional spatial dimension. Yet there is still very little actual comprehension going on in there.

[A bit of a spoiler alert follows]

It starts by explaining in meticulous detail what it is like to live in and experience fictional 2D world instead of the 3D one we are used to.

Then, the main character transcends into a 1D world. The book explains to the 2D inhabitant what it is like to live in a 1D world. Explaining this to the 2D inhabitant is the same as explaining the 2D world to us (and our 3D world).

Finally, the character moves up to a 3D world, which they cannot comprehend. However the explanations which are given to the character are quite intuitive and satisfying, and help to explain what it might be like for us to move up one dimension and experience it.

[0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flatland

p.s. The book is also a hilarious parody on victorian era attitudes towards women.

pserwylo··on Tell HN: My Brother Died Last Week. His Death Will Not Be In Vain
I'm not sure why you've been down voted. I didn't intend for my post to say that talking to friends or colleagues is a replacement for professional help, just that any extra help is a positive, especially when people might have a tendency to feel isolated.
pserwylo··on Tell HN: My Brother Died Last Week. His Death Will Not Be In Vain
Traditionally, they are handed out for free at conferences. I'm quite confident that if you are going to a conference or a user group, they'd be happy to post some to you (I'm not part of the organisation, just like what they do).

If you just want something for your laptop, I suggest printing out on a piece of paper and sticky taping it to your machine[0]. Although a license is not specified, I'm quite confident that from speaking to these people (and their philosophy on open source) they'd be more than happy for people to print and share them.

[0] http://bluehackers.org/logos

pserwylo··on Tell HN: My Brother Died Last Week. His Death Will Not Be In Vain
There is an organisation called BlueHackers.org [0] which was started at the Open Source Developers Conference. It has a strong presence at linux.conf.au as well.

The organisation started from a very brief lightning talk that went something along the lines of (me paraphrasing from memory):

"Who here in this room has experienced depression?" (for which the person asking the question put their hand up. After a few seconds, quite a few people in the crowd had their hands up. "Look around, I want you to know that you are not the only ones who experience this, and there are always people willing to talk."

One of the ideas they have is, for anybody who is willing, to put a BlueHackers sticker on their laptop. This little gesture is more than just a decal though, because it informs other hackers that you understand that if they are feeling depressed, they don't need to deal with it on their own. You are telling them that you are willing to discuss anything with them, especially if they are feeling down.

I have had the sticker on my laptop for over two years now. Although I haven't had anybody recognise it, or comment on it, or indeed discuss any issues with me as a consequence of it, and although I myself have been lucky enough not to have to experience depression, I am absolutely, 100% willing to respond to anybody who wishes to chat to me about such issues (on the off chance they recognise the BlueHackers sticker). I would love if this idea took off, so that people all around the world could see that there are so many people who are willing to talk.

[0] - http://bluehackers.org/

pserwylo··on Android Support vs iOS Support
If you split end users into tech people and lay people, then I don't think it matters as much.

Most of my lay friends tend not to even realise they are not on the latest version. Their maps app gives them directions and the camera takes photos.

As for more techie people... that's why I much prefer Android. The ROM scene is amazing, and allows my original Samsung Galaxy S 1 to run the latest version of Android. I also get to experiment with different ROMs that take different approaches to mobile OSes.

pserwylo··on AutoDesk Releases An Electronics Simulator Called 123D Circuits
As somebody who is learning electronics using Arduino right now, I almost agree with you.

WARNING: The first time I accidentally forgot to put a resistor in front of an LED and sent 50mA to one which was rated at 20mA, I expected it to fizzle and cut out like a regular incandescent light bulb does in my house.

When it literally exploded and the plastic covering went flying through the room, I was very very glad it didn't hit me in the eye, or I'd probably have done some fairly serious damage.

pserwylo··on Poll: Would you vote online if you could?
Ah, that's good to know. Must be my inferior and incorrect pop culture references that told me "Yard sale".

FWIW: Google Fight has "Garage sale" smashing "Yard sale" [0] while Urban Dictionary has almost twice as many definitions of "Yard sale" to "Garage sale"

[0] http://www.googlefight.com/index.php?lang=en_GB&word1=%22gar...

pserwylo··on Poll: Would you vote online if you could?
[This may come across as tounge-in-cheek, but I'm quite serious]

I voted yes, but I hope that there will always be people in the community who desire physical polling stations. The reason is that as much as I am disillusioned about politics here in Australia, I am looking forward to the upcoming federal election for one reason:

Garage Sales (Yard Sales if you're from the U.S.)

A couple of elections ago my brother and I (who both love garage sales) realised that if you drive around each of the local polling stations, then there is a huge number of garage sales. As it happens, if you live near a polling station - mostly primary schools around our area - and you want to hold a garage sale when the greatest number of people are going to walk past your house, people tend to pick polling day.

Therefore, we've made a bit of an election pilgrimage to various garage sales. We've affectionately dubbed the term "Garage sailing".

pserwylo··on Isaac Asimov's predictions for what the world will be like in 2014
I recently read an interesting New Scientist article in an old (2009) magazine[0] which explains how to use moving sidewalks for mass public transit. Spoiler alert - it has actually been done before!

[0] - http://web.archive.org/web/20090809091201/http://www.newscie...

(using wayback machine because new site is behind paywal)

pserwylo··on LinuxMint 15 delivers smooth alternative to Ubuntu
> it's not like searching the desktop will send results to Amazon et al.

But it is similar - if you use web applications in your every day life, then a misspelling may well send your misspelled info to Amazon, if they advertise through OpenDNS (though I'm unfamiliar with how OpenDNS works).

← PreviousPage 3 of 8Next →