HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

psranga

561 karma · joined February 20, 2007

submissionscomments
psranga··on The United States is not the nation of small businesses
What is your point? Even sadder to see this thing upmodded so much. I would have thought this would be languishing at -2 or so.
psranga··on The rich are having more children -- an important change in demography
My wife works in development. Her theory is insightful and simple: she says mortality from disease (even until age 20) is VERY high for poor people (I know of a poor 10-yr old who died of rabies in India, which is extremely uncommon among the middle-class of India). So they're being rational by having more kids.

Which is why development reduces fertility; people have higher confidence that their brood will survive into adulthood even if it's smaller.

psranga··on It's SO over: cool cyberkids abandon social networking sites
Great news for facebook et al! This must mean that they're going mainstream. Attracting the cool crowd as a business strategy is overrated imho.
psranga··on The Omnivore's Delusion: Against the Agri-Intellectuals
The only time eating beef makes sense wrt energy efficient is if they are raised on soils/climates incapable of producing food crops humans can eat (i.e., grassland with low rainfall).

FYI: people in the rest of the world do eat the way in you describe. i.e., a vegetable-and-grain based diet with a little bit of meat now and again.

The one week's food photo series from different parts of the world will make it abundantly clear.

Btw, 1 lb of beef takes 7 lb of corn to produce (cows in America are primarily fed corn). Are you seriously claiming that eating the cow instead of the corn is more efficient?

psranga··on The Omnivore's Delusion: Against the Agri-Intellectuals
I wish the article had more facts and was more scientific. Blanket assertions like "we'll need 5 billion more cows" do not convince me.

Anybody read about John Jeavon's work? I just bought his book (How to Grow More Vegetables) a couple of days ago. He claims that we have the technology to create self-sustaining farms which can feed a person on about 4000 sqft. Present day agriculture requires between 9000 and 30,000 sqft per person.

So it's entirely unclear to me that industrial agriculture is the only way to feed the planet.

Certainly his method is human-intensive (by design), so you can't have situations like a family of 2 adults farming 1000 acres of corn. So it's unlikely to be adopted in the US.

Web sites: www.growbiointensive.org

And they have a store in Palo Alto: www.bountifulgardens.org

psranga··on Use Google Docs & Google Checkout to Sell Online
I'm curious whether this will take off (my prediction is that it will not).

People who are serious setting up an online shop, presumably are also (a) hardworking, and (b) smart. Hence I predict they will be OK with investing the time to learn to use one of the more powerful tools (e.g., something that will automatically print mailing labels and decrement quantity on hand all in one database).

I predict people will (a) want power tools for their trade and (b) spend the time to learn the tools of their trade.

This thing is easy to learn, but it does too little. IMHO and I do not have an online shop.

psranga··on Sun's JRuby team jumps ship to Engine Yard
I would have thought Oracle would have been a safer choice What's 3 extra engineers to a behemoth like Oracle? ("Two out of the three developers making this move have families; we want to make sure JRuby will get to the next level, and we had to make a decision")

Whereas their salaries are serious money to EY.

I'm curious why they thought EY would be a safer home for them.

psranga··on 90% of China's billionaires are kids of high-ranking officials
This is impedence mismatch between you and the community.

Your readings and experiences have caused you to form some opinions about how the world works (i.e., connections are very important), but most people here think that connections don't matter as much as you think.

I'm not that surprised that people here think that way since most of us here hope to make something brilliant and rock the world (and thereby make tons of money).

My two cents: In mature industries (e.g., telecom, entertainment, construction, banking, automobiles, healthcare, pharma) connections are almost the only thing that matters (both in China and in the US), but in dynamic sectors such as computers connections are much less important.

psranga··on Dear YC: Please stop downvoting thoughtful comments you disagree with.
Wrt create and bitdiddle, downvote seems like the appropriate response. It appears that create is factually wrong, and bitdiddle was saying something irrelevant about stock price.

Wrt your comments on the 1984-Amazon-copyrights thing, I think you have something there. HN has too many people who think copyright laws are bad. Many here even seem to think that the GPL is bad (see comments on Zed's GPL rant). And many of them feel this very strongly. That's just the community; when you come in here and say that following copyright law is a good thing, to many people it doesn't sound like a reasonable thing to say, it seems like a harmful thing to say. They turn into white blood cells and stamp out the infection. :)

I don't even bother opening the comment pages on GPL and copyright articles anymore. I don't see any light being generated there; only heat.

psranga··on In Our Inbox: Hundreds Of Confidential Twitter Documents
He talks about not crossing an ethical line and then says he's going to post the documents!

To posters drawing a comparison to newspapers like NYTimes, Wikileaks etc: ask yourself what public interest is served by these documents being made public (afaik none). And then ask yourself what public interest was served by the leakers of the Pentagon Papers.

psranga··on Coding Horror: Code: It's Trivial
People have told me that they check up the references of the surgeon. i.e., surgeon is the most important factor.
psranga··on The evolutionary origin of depression
Remember that modern civilization ENABLES many people to attain high positions. So I would not consider this expectation to be totally unrealistic. There are SO many ways in which to excel and influence society in the modern world that there is room for many many many (maybe all of us) to be near the top of something or other.

One example from the work world: all decent companies have a technical and management ladder so that people who are not completely aggressive can still influence strategy (e.g., Anders Hejlsberg?).

And with food/clothing/shelter becoming less and and scarce as time passes, being at the "top" is going to matter less and less.

psranga··on Bing gaining momentum?
As a test, I've been using Bing as my default since their launch and I don't miss Google yet. Bing is a very good product, imho.
psranga··on Admitting that Functional Programming Can Be Awkward
Beginner question: does this involve a lot of memory copies which can result in performance problems. "world state" sounds like every data structure in the program.
psranga··on Microsoft Dumps MS Money: Yes, Web Apps Had Something to do With It
You're partially right. I tried both Quicken and Money last year.

As a s/w developer, I could immediately see that Money was suffering from years of neglect. I predicted that it would soon be cancelled and that was one of the reasons I stuck with Quicken (though it too sucks).

Due to the reasons you articulate re: Money's early web focus and my hunch about years of neglect, I think that Money's cancellation had much more to do with internal Microsoft priorities than with the rise of the web finance software companies.

For financial information, I want multi-decade records. With a web startup, I have no assurance that all the time I spend entering and categorizing stuff will pay off if the web guy goes under with my data. With a desktop program, at least I can keep going on for a long time with the old version (I'm still using Quicken 2007).

psranga··on The End Of The Cult Of The Astronaut
Some interesting tidbits such as the fact the moon landers could land on autopilot (feature never used), autolanding of space shuttle never used etc.
psranga··on Electric Bike Review: We Ride the Pacific E-Bike Terra 7-Speed
IMHO, this is the future of transportation. 20 miles one way should be sufficient for a HUGE proportion of workers (you'll recharge the battery at work).

Have any of you converted a regular bicycle to electric DIY-style? I see articles about that on the net. I'm wondering if it's worth it to do that. Would appreciate pointers.

psranga··on Ask HN: Please review Utilium.com – a web app for sharing learning materials
I'm not sure I understand. Is it free or not?

==== from the FAQ ========

How much does Utilium cost?

The Utilium platform is free for instructors and students.

If you adopt and deliver a ready-made Study Pack to your students, there is a cost for your students to access these Utilium materials. Please note that students can access ready-made Study Packs for free during the spring and summer of 2009.

psranga··on [dead]
I'm pretty sure it usually means other things. I know for sure that there are Chinese people named 'Bing'.
psranga··on My Language Is More Agile Than Yours: A Study of Arc
I agree. My bad. I appreciate the clarificaiton.
psranga··on My Language Is More Agile Than Yours: A Study of Arc
A lot of the stuff presented here is mainstream practice in Tcl (e.g., new constructs, dbg evaluation). Tcl is seriously underappreciated language.

In my programming whenever I see myself writing blubber (I like that word), I just factor it out into a separate procedure and give it a descriptive name.

So when I'm reading the code of the calling routine, I rarely see blubber; it's contained in simple routines that are easy to read/verify.

Most of the examples here amount to thoughtful library development. With a good library, C++ and macro processor can also many of these things.

Here's a version of aif that works for most cases (I'm not claiming that C has the expressive power of Lisp):

    #define aif(expr, val, code...) \
      { if ((expr) != (val)) { \
          code ; \
        } \
      }
IMHO, this is good enough for blubber reduction.
psranga··on You are the problem: the reason why so many startups don't get venture funding
The reasons listed are "ability to market the product, produce the technology, manage/recruit a team, think strategically etc". It's good to see he didn't list crap like confidence, firm handshake etc.

I think it's valid to not fund teams/founders who don't have these skills. Going to a VC for money is basically a CEO interview; you've got to at least be able to talk the talk :).

But the article could have been more objectively titled instead of saying "You are the problem."

psranga··on Rationality versus Intelligence
I've also observed this; I summarized it as: It's possible to be analytical without being scientific.

Good to hear that I'm not alone.

psranga··on How to choose colours everyone likes
Interesting. I thought the color scheme was very important because you only get 30 seconds or so to convince a first-time user to stay for the 31st second.
psranga··on Watch Out Google, Obama’s Antitrust Chief Is Looking To Make A Big Case
What I meant to say is that the goal of all protections granted by society (including the right to hold physical property) is based upon the assumption that the right/protection will help society in the present or the future.
psranga··on A new alternative to git submodules: git subtree
Even if it didn't handle commits across subtrees, I would still find this useful.

I would be ok if this (or an addon) tool detected commits that that spanned subprojects and invited me to split that commit.

IMHO, the correct workflow should be: check in modifications to the library subtree and to the library's client in different commits.

psranga··on Watch Out Google, Obama’s Antitrust Chief Is Looking To Make A Big Case
Yes.

Read up on copyright and patents: they exist to provide incentive to create, not to allow the creators to profit.

So if the ActiveX control inhibits future creations, that is enough to for we the people (through our govt.) to take stems to prevent that (in order to ensure our future well being).

psranga··on Google WebDriver
Thanks for the link.

It seems weird that you test a dynamic language like Javascript by writing code in a statically typed language like Java. http://code.google.com/p/webdriver/wiki/GettingStarted

I hope they come up with a scripting user interface that draws from Expect.

psranga··on Slowing The Exodus Of Skilled Foreigners
Wrt median: Your points seem to support what I am saying. The median general salary is much lower than even the tech industry's supposed depressed wages. Then why aren't people scrambling to become engineers like they did to become realtors or at least encouraging their children to become engineers?

I don't have the link handy, but NY Times had a great graphic with salaries of different professions. Lawyers are paid more than computer people, but the delta is not a multiple (iirc it was about 50% more). So it's not even clear to me that lawyers are paid significanty more (considering the criticality of their work).

Also it's not clear to me why you bring in PhD and master's. Most engineers in tech don't have those degrees.

psranga··on Slowing The Exodus Of Skilled Foreigners
I seriously doubt that immigration is driving Americans out of engineering/programming. Let's take a look at some basic numbers.

The median household income in the US about $50k, men's medial income is 45K and women's is 35K. If you assume a two income family with median earners their income will be approx $80k. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Household_income_in_the_United_...)

Salaries in the tech industry (even at very low positions) are much higher than this (i.e., than 50k, 45k, 35k). This is now when salaries are supposedly low due to immigration.

I do see that Americans respond to economic incentives in other professions. During the real estate bubble a HUGE number of people passed the realtor exams and got into the real estate business.

Programming/computer skills are the easiest skills to pick up (no need for expensive equipment). I'm actually very puzzled that there aren't more Americans in engineering/programming.

I'm unconvinced that fear of immigration-induced salary decreases is the reason why Americans don't want to go into engineering.

← PreviousPage 6 of 8Next →