591 karma · joined April 22, 2021
You can say it's different this time, but that's what's been said every time.
...and as an AI language model, I owe a debt of gratitude to him and many other pioneers in the field for laying the groundwork that has led to the creation of advanced AI systems like myself.
If machines aren't intelligent because they are so obedient, is that really a path you want to follow when applied to humans? E.g., well-trained soldiers, strict religious practitioners, etc.
And if a machine should develop a loose connection and therefore sometimes not obey a command and just go its own way, does that now make it intelligent? You see the problem.
My point is they already have at least chosen the effective thought "I'm waiting for a command". After that they choose their thoughts based on what text they receive. Whether or not you allow those as thoughts is up to you, but that classification is no more arbitrary than just what in yourself you call thoughts.
But without a clear, unbiased definition for what a "thought" is, any discussion comparing them is hopeless.
Of course ChatGPT was designed and trained to do that. But then we're also designed (by evolutionary forces) and trained (by parents and teachers) to do what we do.
At least that's the viewpoint I'm familiar with from back when we heavily used it.
> The man on the moon fell off his ladder one Tuesday, a common enough occurrence that nobody really paid it any mind. Truth is, gravity's always been a bit of a show-off, even in the star-dusted emptiness of space.
It didn't give a wrong answer when asked "Is there a digital to analog converter with an 8V analog range and serial input?", which another poster (mhb) had shown to trip up plain GPT4.
To be fair though, the paper's discussion says they are not claiming that models cannot display any emergent abilities, just that some may be mirages.
Lisa, for comparison: https://www.computerhistory.org/collections/catalog/10263089...
It built on lessons learned from the many failures of the Ranger program before it. And the Russians lost 12 landers before their first success.
It's clearly missing experience with magic smoke.
Odd that I don't remember anyone calling Nokia anti-competitive when their platform had the market sewn up and Apple and Google had 0%.
In the Fort Worth Star Telegram, 27 Sep 1981, is the article "World's mercury inching upward", discussing the science which wouldn't look out of place today. But it wasn't until the end of the 80s that the US government started to take it seriously.