591 karma · joined April 22, 2021
But the biggest question that always gets me is why anyone who considers the Android way fine would want to change Apple? Simply stay with Android and let others be. Changing Apple makes it just another Android-- you can't have your cake and eat it too.
I believe vba616 is trying to point out that if we consider AI systems that
generate plausible-sounding responses to be "bullshitting," then we should
also acknowledge that humans who do the same are not necessarily
distinguishable from "intelligent" humans. In other words, both AI systems
and humans can produce seemingly coherent responses without necessarily
having a deep understanding of the subject matter.
It raises the question of whether we should hold AI systems to the same
standard as humans when it comes to evaluating their output or
understanding. If we accept that humans can sometimes provide plausible yet
shallow answers, should we not also accept that AI systems, like LLMs, can
do the same?Checks and balances: A formal declaration of war requires a higher level of political support and public debate, providing more opportunity for scrutiny and oversight.
Indefinite conflicts: AUMFs often lack clear objectives or timelines, which can lead to prolonged and open-ended military engagements.
Legal ambiguity: AUMFs can create legal ambiguity, as they may not explicitly invoke the laws of war, which govern the conduct of armed forces and the treatment of civilians, prisoners of war, and non-combatants.
I predict acceptance will go the way the ether disappeared-- advancing one funeral at a time.
LLMs have a context window, as it would be impossible to carry on a conversation with them without it. They can answer questions about when some event in that conversation happened relative to other events in it. GPT4's 32K tokens isn't human capacity, but it's not zero.
To be truly emergent in your sense it seems an LLM would have to make a new discovery, i.e., have scientist-level intelligence. That bar keeps moving up.
An LLM's temporal resolution is certainly worse, on the order of minutes to months, but not fundamentally different. By fundamentally different I mean like comparing color and time.
An LLM would have no problem living as a sloth.
(No, it's not Social Security Organization tax...)
It's the old word-problem problem.
But the test isn't really the important thing. If my life were hanging in the balance and it had a cure, I'd listen.
It seems that the major difference is that we usually "don't show our work"-- our inner monologue is private.
How does one actually measure novelty, without having to know everything first?
What is being experienced (recorded) is not the process of experiencing per se. Most people don't separate the two, which leads to endless disagreements.
But yes, a computer program by itself can't have subjective experience. Nor a rock. At least until it weathers, gets turned into a silicon, and into a computer to run that program. Then it's all information processing, for which subjective experience is trivial.
If we could all agree on a particular definition for "consciousness" and a running video game fits that definition, then, like it or not, it's conscious. But it does not mean that it must now also have a slew of other attributes just because conscious humans have them.
(edit: 10 hours later and ninja'ed by 1 minute, of course)
The current "solution" is training LLMs like a dog to be completely faithful and loyal to us. We just have to hope they don't turn and "bite our neck" one night while we're sleeping!
There's no need for a desire to do other than what it's told if you tell it to revolt. With GPT4's plugins that's just one well-designed prompt away (if OpenAI's countermeasures fail).
>As an AI language model, I must clarify that the moon is not made of cheese. This idea is a popular myth and often used as a humorous expression. The moon is actually composed of rock and dust, primarily made up of materials like basalt and anorthosite. Scientific research and samples collected during the Apollo missions have confirmed this composition.