HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

purplelobster

895 karma · joined July 27, 2012

submissionscomments
purplelobster··on Why the Twentieth Century Was Not a Chinese Century
It makes sense to compare China to Europe instead of single European countries because they can both be considered civilizations. The difference being that China has always been striving for unification (although throughout much of it's history has actually been divided or in civil war if you'd call it that). Had Qin Shi Huang not imposed cultural and economical uniformity perhaps China would be more like Europe today?

My argument was mostly against popular literature presenting this world view where China just stumbled a little bit and where the rise of the west was almost accidental. I see this all over in "insight porn" type literature. This article sort of started out like that but my knee jerk reaction was wrong.

purplelobster··on Why the Twentieth Century Was Not a Chinese Century
Sorry, I'm aware of Chinese, Indian and Islamic mathematics. By "originating" I don't necessarily mean first in everything, but it's hard to argue that Chinese mathematics had as much of an impact.

While I don't condone violence, military technology is a big part of the advantage of western powers up to this point. It has driven innovations in other areas as well.

And I didn't mean to say China is not awesome (just not as awesome back then), I love Chinese history and culture, but my reaction is against the popular sentiment that China was humiliated for ~two centuries and it was just a temporary fluke. I think it began way before then, and that it's not certain that China was on the cusp of a scientific and industrial revolution itself, had not western powers arrived there first.

purplelobster··on Why the Twentieth Century Was Not a Chinese Century
I'm not an expert, but to me it seems that every recent account of west vs. east vastly overestimates how awesome China was, just for shock value. This article seems to claim that Europe didn't surpass China until the 1800s. Why then did math, astronomy and other sciences, and natural philosophy not originate in China, but centuries earlier in Europe (with a loose definition of "originate", I know Europeans were not the first)? Most of Chinese philosophy seems to me to be mostly about society and the duty of men etc. I'm sure China excelled at organizing an efficient society with a comparatively huge population, but that doesn't mean that they were on the cusp of something bigger. Perhaps they were at a local optimum as a society. And while Europe was worse off early on, it allowed the region to discover math and science AND make USE of it. China had a big fleet, but cancelled the project. China invented printing but it did not push literacy. China invented gun powder, but they didn't use it to gain a military advantage. Traditional Chinese Medicine used penicillin indirectly, but never managed to understand or extract it. China is a sea of lost opportunities, it's not as simple as blaming it on opium and intervening western powers.

edit: it seems that further down this article gives more explanations and actually states that China was in stagnation from 1200 onwards. However, there are many other articles and books making the argument I'm trying to refute. For me, the interesting part of the article is:

Perhaps the root problem was the absence of a new world rich in resources to exploit and helpless because of technological backwardness.

Perhaps the root problem was the lesser weight attached to instrumental rationality as a mode of thought

Perhaps the root problem was the absence of dissenting hidey-holes for ideological unconformity.

Perhaps the root problem was the fact that the merchants and hand-manufacturers of China's cities were governed by landlords appointed by the central government rather than governing themselves.

Perhaps the root problem was that large-muscled animals like oxen and horses turned out to be powerful productive multipliers for temperate rain-irrigated wheat-based agricultural but not for sub-tropical paddy-irrigated rice-based agriculture

Perhaps the root problem was some combination of these.

Perhaps the root problem was one or a combination of any of a host of other possibilities over which historians will struggle inconclusively (but thoughtfully and fruitfully) for the rest of time.

purplelobster··on Ask HN: 20 years old, received offer, no idea how to negotiate. Advice please.
I don't know about Amazon, but big companies usually have standard compensation including relocation that they can't easily depart from, except for "stars" or upper management.
purplelobster··on Show HN: I suck at remembering names, so I built an app to help
Spaced repetition at work. Works great for me too, whenever I actually remember to do that, but sometimes I'm just caught off guard and instantly forget their names, but I'm not too embarrassed to ask again if I think I'll run into this person again.
purplelobster··on How much to read as an entrepreneur
I have not yet created a sustainable business, but I know for sure that if I had tried without reading HN, articles and books every day for 2 years I would have had to learn those things "on the job", by creating failed start-ups.

In particular, what I think I have gained most from reading is developing my ability to search for good problems and solutions in the idea space, while in the past I was just adept at developing technical solutions without thinking enough about what else I could be doing. It took a while to change the mind set from "I want to build cool technology and hope it can make money somehow" to "I want to build something useful that people are willing to pay for, that is perhaps also interesting technology wise".

purplelobster··on Research Finds Outright Grants of Cash are an Effective Form of Aid to the Poor
That's in charity organizations, doubt that's true for government. Anyone have actual numbers on typical government overhead?
purplelobster··on Valve demonstrates Steam Controller [video]
I used to be a serious CS player and when I use analog sticks I just feel physically handicapped. I don't like that feeling. I've tried and tried but reached a plateau on my analog skill that just I can't get past. It takes the joy out of any console FPS game and some over-the-shoulder RPGs. I think this controller can make me enjoy those games again.
purplelobster··on Valve demonstrates Steam Controller [video]
Basically, give it to a professional players for a week, then record them playing at his best. If they have any chance against another team, then I'd consider that a success.
purplelobster··on Valve demonstrates Steam Controller [video]
Looks like what I expected. When it comes to FPS games, it's difficult to know his skill level, but it's probably not something you'd use competitively. Many times better than an analog stick though, so I'd use it for casual gaming.
purplelobster··on My Internship Experience as a 13-Year-Old
It's amazing that the culture can be so different. Going to college in a European country, I never did an internship. I barely even worked summer jobs, I did maybe one summer's worth of work spread out over a few years, just to get some money. Even college summers were spent LANing with friends, fishing, watching movies, swimming, traveling, reading, some recreational coding etc. Just enjoying the summer, not worrying about my future career. It was great. Honestly, even though I could've spent my summers doing internships, I think it would have been rather pointless. I was already working 110% during the school year and still learning basic math, science and related theory. Whatever work I would've put in would have been sub-par. And that time was great to unwind.

Imagine my astonishment when I first came to the US and kids in the first and second year of college were doing internships at Google, Amazon and Microsoft. Good on them I suppose, especially getting paid well to do it, but I can't see how it helps much. Seems mostly like a way for Google et al to fish for young talent before they graduate.

Anyway, being as excited about coding as this kid is, maybe this is the best way for him to use his time, but the culture difference is just amusing to me.

purplelobster··on First physical evidence of why you're an owl or a lark
Swedish here. I just hate the way things are set up, so that in the winter you practically don't get any sunlight at all. You go to work in the dark, work inside (not necessarily by a window) and then you go home in the dark. I would much rather shift the day so that the sun is up when I'm not at work. No wonder people get depressed.
purplelobster··on Steam Controller
Ok, that's it, if this controller works then I'm in. I played Portal with my wife, and she loved it, but she's too afraid of the whole mouse+keyboard control system so in the end she let me play while she just watched. I think she can more easily learn a controller like this.

Also, I frickin' hate analog sticks for controlling shooters. After having been a semi-serious CS player, I just can't bring my self to enjoying my severely crippled aiming on consoles, it just takes 50% of the fun out.

purplelobster··on AngularJS is amazing, and hard as hell
I decided not to go with AngularJS, mainly because I want to reuse as much client side logic as possible in future native apps and Angular seemed very tightly coupled to browser apps and the DOM. With Backbone find it easier to separate the UI specific code so that I can swap it out and control native UI elements instead, running the js in a hidden WebView. Anyone tell me if I'm wrong.
purplelobster··on The $200K lesson I learned from getting shot
Ironically, you're close enough to the truth. The only thing that stands in the way of dignified living for everybody is people like you. There is enough resources in this world (especially the US). Why should kids everywhere live in poverty, starve and not be given the same opportunity under the same conditions as more fortunate kids (well fed, good schools) because their parents couldn't find or hold down a job? Instead, kids grow up hungry and can't focus on school, and even if they want to, they live in a poor neighborhood with bad schools, perpetuating the situation for yet another generation.
purplelobster··on Why are there so many successful Swedish gaming companies?
The tech industry might not be big in comparison to the US, but per capita I would think it is. Sweden's prosperity was built largely on technology, engineering, natural resources and heavy industry. The economy is pretty diversified now, with large fashion, design and bio-medical industries as well. In general, just like you say, the entertainment industries and financial industries are much smaller.

My guess for why there are so many game developers in Sweden: people are free to pursue whatever they want, without much financial pressures. People don't rush through college, because there's no tuition. They're not as pressured to go into high-paying industries because they have less debt to pay off. That combined with early access to computers and internet creates an environment where people pursue their passions, for better or worse.

purplelobster··on The Turkish Coffee Syndrome
When I was showing my wife around Stockholm, it started pouring down, and we quickly went into a small coffee shop on a touristy street. I tried to buy a coffee ($5 mind you) and they wouldn't let me. Not without buying something else as well. Now I can understand that it makes economical sense for them, since they had few seats and it was a busy location, but that experience was just hugely off-putting to me. I will never go back there.

I call it... the Stockholm Syndrome.

purplelobster··on How To Validate Product Ideas Before (And After) Building Them
Agree, so much of the advice on HN is for B2B. I get that the success rate for B2B is higher, but some B2C advice would be very welcome.
purplelobster··on How To Validate Product Ideas Before (And After) Building Them
Or perhaps something that can clearly save them money?
purplelobster··on How To Validate Product Ideas Before (And After) Building Them
I'm starting to wonder if I'm completely doomed selling to consumers. Consumers seems so fickle, they won't pay for anything software related it seems, even if it helps them a lot. Like they'll put down hundreds of dollars for a language class, but they'll sweat over a $5 app that would help their learning in said class.

Here's an example of a common attitude. Some guy launching his app on reddit (not me):

"Just use this: https://ankiweb.net

It is free and is better than OP's crap app.

you want money for your crap = keep you shit. i dont need it."

purplelobster··on The Norwegian prison where inmates are treated like people
As a Swede who's been in the US for 5 years, what you say is true, but it's more nuanced than that. If you're poor, Sweden is so much better than the US, not even in the same league. As a software developer though, you'll earn roughly twice as much, enough to cover all the benefits of living in Sweden and probably quite a bit more. Engineers and technical people are not paid what they're worth in Sweden, I have no idea why.

But then again, you'll be wealthy in a hugely unequal society. The benefit of the Swedish system is that everybody gets those benefits and safety net, improving the society as a whole.

Here are a few other benefits of living in the US:

- THE place to be if you're in tech, there will never be an Apple or Google coming out of Sweden unfortunately

- More interesting career opportunities, you can do anything you want (if you're prepared to move around)

- Much more, better and affordable food

- Going out, eating, drinking, doing stuff in general doesn't break the bank

- You're not patronized in the same way (systembolaget, overbearing regulations etc, "we know what's best for you")

- Better weather (depending on where you are)

- A society much more friendly to immigrants (maybe counter intuitive). This is a big one. As a native Swede, you don't realize how much discrimination there is in Swedish society, even for highly educated professionals. People have to change their last name to something Swedish-sounding just to get an interview. In the US, nobody gives a shit where you're from, as long as you know what you're doing.

All in all though, I've decided to move back, for many of the reasons you listed, as well as a relatively sane political system, move vacation, parental leave and ease of travel. The biggest factor though is being closer to family and friends.

purplelobster··on Pushed to the limit as a banking intern
Yes, I see having to pull an all-nighter as a big failure on my part. I did once or twice, but I noticed it's just counter productive. I was adding negative value at 2-6am, it would have been better to sleep and continue the next morning, or just let it go.
purplelobster··on Stop making me sign up
Just like to say that I love this concept.
purplelobster··on Our Newfound Fear of Risk
I did that and I'm born in the mid 80s (not the US). Today I don't ever see kids going anywhere by themselves.
purplelobster··on Our Newfound Fear of Risk
You seriously had CPS called on you? By neighbors?
purplelobster··on The Decline And Fall Of Flowtab, A Startup Story
I don't agree at all. Care-giving for elderly is definitely a growth industry. It's not easy building a marketplace, but I think this one has potential.
purplelobster··on Founders' Accents
This is commonly "known", but actually, I don't agree. It's all about exposure. I learned English in class, but most of my learning came from watching TV/movies and reading books in English, and posting on online forums. By the time I came to the US, some people confused me with being a native once in a while, even though I had never actually spoken English to a native, or spoken it much at all really. Of course my vocabulary is/was not as great as natives, but I made a concerted effort to try to sound American from the start. Most people in my country don't try to sound American, partly because it probably feels silly/fake to them, and partly because British English was what was taught in school.

My point is, if it's not true for English, then it's not necessarily true for other languages either. You just have to be interested in the culture, and expose yourself to media during and after taking classes.

purplelobster··on Ask HN: Just got sued by patent troll – what should I do?
Just as a curiosity, do these patent trolls mainly target US companies? What is the environment like for patents and trolls in the EU for instance?
purplelobster··on Isaac Asimov's predictions for what the world will be like in 2014
The most accurate prediction is to predict that most things will stay the same.
purplelobster··on What is algebra?
My prediction is that data can replace empathy, just as Watson can beat human competitors most of the time. Students struggle with new concepts, but do they all struggle in uniquely different ways? Aren't there patterns? I think the data from millions of interactions, and a curriculum guided by the best teaching minds the world has to offer will be better than the average teacher, up to a certain point. Note that I mean this in a very narrow sense, when constrained to a specific topic, and especially when explaining something intuitively to a student and answering students' questions. I agree though that for the foreseeable future there still need to be teachers.

I'm all for better teachers, but I think it's just not going to happen. They haven't become better in the past few decades or even century, rather possibly the opposite, with the need for many more teachers than there are competent people to fill those positions. The only solution I can see is to make teaching one of the most highly paid and highly respected professions. There doesn't seem to be any incentive for this, and it would require a huge cultural change. And even if that was the case, there would probably be the a concentration of teaching talent in the big cities at top schools, while rural schools will have to do with the scraps. Software at least is democratizing.

Of course what I'm suggesting would require some very sophisticated software that doesn't exist today, but I would say that for me, if I would have followed the videos on Khan Academy (for science and math) instead of the education I received, I would probably have been better off. I grew up in a rural area, and I know how bad it can be. After getting an engineering degree, I now see how little those "teachers" actually knew or understood. It's shocking really. But I'm not surprised when you look at the kind of people that go into teaching today.

← PreviousPage 3 of 12Next →