HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

pwdisswordfish2

936 karma · joined September 7, 2017

The HN rules still apply.

Please do not be disrespectful toward others.

Separate the commenter from the comment.

Smart commenters still make dumb comments now and then. And vice versa.

Consequently, the "identity" of the commenter is not a reliable predictor of the quality of the comment.

Shared accounts such as this one can address this problem.

Each comment must stand on its own, apart from identity and historical karma.

submissionscomments
pwdisswordfish2··on Mouthbreathing Machiavellis Dream of a Silicon Reich
What is the connection to mouthbreathing?
pwdisswordfish2··on Giant clams manipulate light to assist their symbiotic partner
When I read the parent comment I did not detect any suggestion that the squid communicates with the bacteria. It seems like you read this into the comment.
pwdisswordfish2··on Help Message for Shell Scripts
This will also work:

   sed '/^#\{3\}/!d'
pwdisswordfish2··on Help Message for Shell Scripts
sed -n '/^###/p' is cross-platform friendly.
pwdisswordfish2··on Help Message for Shell Scripts

    x=$(command -v $0 2>/dev/null)
    sed -rn 's/^### ?//;T;p' $x
Personally I would not use the author's chosen sed commands.

    exec sed -n '/^###/p' $x
would work fine.
pwdisswordfish2··on Why Can't I Reproduce Their Results?
What if I had said "pipetting"?

Semantics. Familiarirty with a piece of equipment versus familiarity proper technique when using it.

pwdisswordfish2··on Where Am I? NYTimes or Google?
Why is CCN not economically feasible?
pwdisswordfish2··on Why Can't I Reproduce Their Results?
How did you get a job in a lab if you were not familiar with a pipette?

"I still don't know how he did it."

Practice. Learning through mistakes. Tips from others.

pwdisswordfish2··on PurritoBin: Ultra fast, minimalistic, encrypted command line paste-bin
No, that is an incorrect assumption. The meow command does not decrypt data. The author is suggesting that users resort to using a web browser and Crypto-JS in order to decrypt.
pwdisswordfish2··on Pkg.jl telemetry should be opt-in
You are certainly entitled to your developer perspective.

What are the reasons users do not read the /legal/data page on the Julia website? What are the reasons users do not read 200+ posts from developers debating the use of opt-out telemetry? To ignore such reasons, assuming they exist, would also be disingenuous.

If you put the choice clearly before users and they knowingly, affirmatively choose to submit usage data, then no 200+ post thread is necessary. Instead, the choice is not left to users. It is made by developers, and the fact of the use of opt-out telemetry is found on a webpage that developers know users do not read.

pwdisswordfish2··on PurritoBin: Ultra fast, minimalistic, encrypted command line paste-bin
The author calls this "command line" pastebin. It uses curl and openssl to encrypt and submit. However it uses a Javascript-enabled web broswer to do the retrieval and decryption. Can we use the command line to do the retrieval and decryption?

This way, we are not restricted to the ciphers supported by the "Crypto-JS" NodeJS package. Not meaning to take anything away from the venerable Crypto-JS library of "standards" including RC4 and TripleDES.

pwdisswordfish2··on Pkg.jl telemetry should be opt-in
Edit: The issue of no download statistics is an issue for the developers, not an issue for users. Why is it an "issue" for developers of a "non-commercial" project in the first place? Because the developers actually have commercial ideas for the project. Users did not create this "issue", developers did. Instead of resolving the issue created by using a third party service for downloads by making a compromise, e.g., forgo using a third party to host downloads, or asking users to help them resolve it, e.g., by agreeing to submit usage stats, a new problem is passed on to users instead: opt-out, default telemetry. This is a user perspective. Compare and contrast this with a developer perspective.
pwdisswordfish2··on Internet mob justice can easily destroy innocent lives (2019)
"Humans love mobs."

I am a human and I don't love mobs. This article is all about incorrect assumptions. If I am not mistaken, the parent comment just made another one.

The part about the media amplifying what is on social media I absolutely agree with. I have always thought there is some strange irony in news outlets writing about something that is, at least in the case of newspapers, killing their own business.

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/columbus-statue-in-baltimore-to...

pwdisswordfish2··on Pkg.jl telemetry should be opt-in

   Moreover, at present, we have no idea how many people use each solver (and on which platform!). Knowing how many people installed which solver
   would allow us to prioritize support from our finite developer time.
Why not just let users vote on that? The support is for the users, no? Instead the developers want to minimise the amount of time they spend on maintenance based on the number of users who could potentially complain. The reason for this is (as we are about to be told) so they can spend more time working on platforms where they believe commercial solver developers could provide for-profit support services "(or $$)".

   This would also allow us to lobby the commercial solver developers to provide official support (or $$). To quote one company "We'll want to
   provide official support at some point, but it looks like the scales haven't tilted quite yet." It'd be nice to know whether 100, 1000, 10000, or
   100000 people per month use their software; that might change their mind.
The truth comes out. Collecting data via "frictionless" telemetry allows someone else, e.g., commercial solver developers, to make money. Nothing wrong with that if we let users know about these intentions, however when devlopers try to operate under the guise of "free", "non-profit", "open source", etc. while, truthfully, they have commercial motives, then it seems to me they are doing everything they can to avoid tipping users off that this aims to be a commercially-oriented project. Instead of just being transparent about their motives and letting users decide, they want to sneak something by (most) users. The issue raised here is not the collecting statistics (nothing wrong with that), it is the less transparent, opt-out nature of it: telemetry. Deceptiveness, stealth. The message coming from this discussion is "Don't tip (majority of) users off that we are collecting data." And why is that? Because the developers know this is something most users do not want.

   Finally, if it is opt-in, the vast majority of users will not opt-in. This leaves us no better off than we were before. Opt-out is a good
   compromise.
The discussion should have ended right here. If providing usage statistics is something that the Julia developers already know the vast majority of users do not want to do, then sneaking it by them via opt-out telemetry is wrong, and it tells us much about the people behind Julia. If users do not want it, and you know that, then why the heck are you doing it anyway? Anyone reading this will know why, but most users will probably never read what we are reading here.

The rest of this discussion devolves into "Everyone else is doing it". The lone dissenter finally gives in to peer pressure.

I remember when using download statistics was enough. Developers still maintained software. No "trade-offs" were needed.

pwdisswordfish2··on Where Am I? NYTimes or Google?
Do you mean to say that is the only difference?
pwdisswordfish2··on A look at the Gemini protocol: a brutally simple alternative to the web
I do not see the "incompatibility". There is a web-to-gemini gateway at https://portal.mozz.us which I think is an example to how easy it is to write one.

Big Browser is the cause of so many problems that people on HN complain about. Without the control over Big Browser that certain offending corporations have, their empires are considerably weaker.

Mom-and-Pop Browser is probably not an accurate caricature. Maybe something like End User Browser is more apropos.

If most HTTP is being sent over TLS these days, and Gemini is also over TLS, one could argue there is no "incompatibility". Gemini just doesn't need to all the extra ad-hoc functionality that has been built on top of HTTP. It is intended for data retrieval, not something that relies on help from the 20+ million lines of code in Big Browser to achieve.

pwdisswordfish2··on Where Am I? NYTimes or Google?
Funny how people can literally "forget" that Google is a third party. Probably people at Google believe they are not third parties. Not even asking or trust, just assuming it. No other alternatives. Trust relationship by default.
pwdisswordfish2··on Websites that look like desktop GUIs
That last sentence took an unexpected turn.
pwdisswordfish2··on Where Am I? NYTimes or Google?
By reading the source code?

    def divisors(n):
        for d in range(1, n):
            if n % d == 0:
                yield d

    n = 1
    while True:
        if n == sum(divisors(n)):
            break
        n += 2
    print(n)
I don’t know if this program halts. But I’m pretty sure it won’t steal my data and send it to third parties. Why? Because at no point does it read my data or communicate with third parties in any way: it would have to have those things programmed into it for that to be a possibility. At no point I had to solve the halting problem to know this.

Also, if I execute a program and it does exhibit that behaviour, that’s a proof right there.

The same kind of analysis can be applied to Google’s scripts: look what data it collects and where it pushes data to the outside world. If there are any undecidable problems along the way, then Google has no plausible deniability that some nefarious behaviour is possible. Now, whether that is a practical thing to do is another matter; but the halting problem is just a distraction.

pwdisswordfish2··on Where Am I? NYTimes or Google?
In what ways is this different/similar from "content centric networking"?

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=gqGEMQveoqg

(Google Tech Talk from Van Jacobsen on CCN many years ago)

pwdisswordfish2··on Court Rules Facebook Widgets Can Be Considered Wiretaps
"Also interesting that Facebook is the bad guy here instead of the actual side [sic] owner including the widget."

Facebook is doing the wiretapping, not the site owner.

Perhaps you are suggesting that the plaintiffs could allege a conspiracy to commit wiretapping?

These cases never succeed because the damages are too speculative. What injury/harm have the plaintiffs suffered as a result of the wiretapping? How can that be quantified?

pwdisswordfish2··on LinkedIn is copying the contents of my clipboard on every keystroke
Do not forget the hiQ Labs case where they have alleged CFAA violations against someone scraping public data.
pwdisswordfish2··on Invasive, secretive “bossware” tracking workers
Who forms a company that writes this corporate spyware and proudly sells it during a pandemic? Seems like that could be the "culture problem"? Is it the "incompetent managers" who are writing this code?
pwdisswordfish2··on Oppose the Earn IT Act
Understood.

Never trust tech companies about anything. Wise words.

pwdisswordfish2··on Zuckerberg: advertisers will be back to Facebook 'soon enough'
What I meant was not this particular instance but the future. Long term not short term. Is Facebook immortal? Companies, even the biggest ones, usually have a shelf life.
pwdisswordfish2··on Oppose the Earn IT Act
Seems like it is impossible to verify whether it is true because we cannot see exactly what they are doing. We are just taking their word for it. It can be nothing more than a "promise" because we are not the ones responsible for carrying out the encryption. We have to trust both (a) the encryption software, which we can examine, and (b) the third person doing the encryption, who is unfortunately operating outside our view. Even if the third person is trustworthy, if they make a mistake, they are not liable for anything. They are not even obligated to tell us they made a mistake. Usually when we trust people to do something important for us, we have some recourse against them if things go south. It is more than just a promise. They have skin in the game.
pwdisswordfish2··on Zuckerberg: advertisers will be back to Facebook 'soon enough'
A more interesting question is what if advertisers did not come back? Does Facebook have a "Plan B" for how they would sustain themselves?

What would happen if advertisers pulled out and Facebook fell on hard times? Would someone else acquire every detail of your life that you shared with Facebook? What happens if Facebook fails? Do they send your data back to you with a note saying "Thanks for the loan"?

pwdisswordfish2··on Go is boring, and that’s fantastic
I think the parent comment was sarcastic.
pwdisswordfish2··on DuckDuckGo browser seemingly sends domains a user visits to DDG servers
The settings page requires that the user enable Javascript.

I would not call haproxy "referer masking software". In any event, a proxy is not even needed.

Modern browsers are open source, right? Users can edit the source and remove the code that sends Referer header.

Even easier, I wrote my own http client. I can send any header I want, or none at all. According to DDG's privacy policy this is a good thing.

pwdisswordfish2··on DuckDuckGo browser seemingly sends domains a user visits to DDG servers
If you navigate to https://duckduckgo.com/lite/ or https://lite.duckduckgo.com/lite/, type your query in the form input field, you are using POST. If, OTOH, you were to type your query into the address bar, e.g., https://duckduckgo.com/lite/?q=xyz then you are using GET.

   curl -Huser-agent= https://duckduckgo.com/lite/?q=xyz|grep result-link

   curl -Huser-agent= -dq=xyz https://duckduckgo.com/lite/|grep result-link
← PreviousPage 3 of 16Next →