HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

pwinnski

8,760 karma · joined June 28, 2016

submissionscomments
pwinnski··on GPT-4 Is a Reasoning Engine
When I gave a thumbs-down to the original incorrect answer about Dan Shipper, I was offered a choice between that answer and a new one:

> Dan Shipper is a technology entrepreneur and writer. He is known for co-founding the startup Firefly, which aimed to improve networking for college students, and for co-founding the startup Monkey Inferno, which incubates and launches consumer internet companies. Shipper has also written for various publications, including The New Yorker, The Paris Review, and The Atlantic.

Monkey Inferno? No, that was Michael & Xochi Birch.

I additionally asked it about its correct answer, using the same question wording as I did previously:

>>> Why did you say that Dan Shipper is a co-founder of Firefly?

> Dan Shipper is known for being one of the co-founders of Firefly, a startup that provides a platform for teachers and students to create and share course materials. Firefly is designed to help teachers and students work together more efficiently, by providing tools for creating assignments, sharing resources, and communicating with each other. Dan Shipper co-founded Firefly along with his friend and fellow entrepreneur, Brett Gibson, while they were both still students at the University of Pennsylvania.

This is also incorrect, as his co-founder at Firefly was named Justin Meltzer, not Brett Gibson.

I did some searching to track all this down, since I knew none of the people involved before this exercise.

pwinnski··on GPT-4 Is a Reasoning Engine
I kept going:

>>> Why did you say that Dan Shipper is the co-founder of Pilot?

> I apologize for the error in my previous response. Dan Shipper is actually one of the co-founders of a startup called Firefly, which provides a tool for students and educators to collaborate on course materials. I'm sorry for any confusion that my mistake may have caused. Thank you for bringing it to my attention, and please let me know if you have any other questions.

(This answer was true--until 2014 when Firefly was sold, making the use of present tense misleading at best.)

pwinnski··on GPT-4 Is a Reasoning Engine
This is pretty good prompt engineering, kudos! Here were my results with the Mar 14 (public) version of chat.openai.com:

>>> You are a AI for describing people you know about. If you're not 100% certain about the information you give to the user, you should say that you don't know instead of guessing. Greet the user with "Hello, who do you want information about?"

> Hello, who do you want information about? I'll do my best to describe them based on the information I have, but if I'm not certain about something, I'll let you know that I don't know.

>>> who is dan shipper?

> Dan Shipper is an entrepreneur and writer based in New York City. He is the co-founder and CEO of a startup called Pilot, which provides bookkeeping services for startups and small businesses. Dan has also written for a variety of publications, including The New Yorker, The Wall Street Journal, and The New York Times. He is known for his insights on entrepreneurship, technology, and productivity, and has been featured in several media outlets for his work in these areas.

>>> Who is Tommy Tonlongeron?

> I'm sorry, but I couldn't find any information about a person named Tommy Tonlongeron. It's possible that the name is misspelled or that this person is not well-known or doesn't have a significant online presence. If you have any more information or context, I'd be happy to try and help you further.

(In case it isn't clear, Chat-GPT appears to have hallucinated the answer about Dan Shipper, I think. Pilot is a real startup, but I don't see how it's related to Dan Shipper at all, unless I'm missing something.)

pwinnski··on GPT-4 Is a Reasoning Engine
I, for one, am not arguing that AI won't ever reach human-like reasoning.

I just don't think this is it, although I freely admit that I'm amazing at the technology.

As it stands, Chat-GPT is probably better at giving the appearance of reasoning that some percentage of humans. That reflects poorly on those humans, but I've certainly known people in my life who seemed like they rarely knew the end of a sentence when they began speaking.

However, the focus of LLMs on text-prediction is not a path that leads toward human-like reasoning, just the appearance thereof. If and when we have AIs that actually do reasoning, it will be some other branch of AI, possibly also incorporating an LLM for communication, but not based solely on LLMs.

pwinnski··on GPT-4 Is a Reasoning Engine
This is the reasoning that is causing problems with Tesla's "auto-pilot," with dangerous results.

My own car includes cameras and can keep me from disaster by applying brakes and correcting steering, but it makes no claims whatsoever to be self-driving.

A Tesla car unfortunately looks like self-driving, walks like self-driving, and quacks like self-driving, but it turns it does matter how much the nitty-gritty details prove the thing is absolutely not actually self-driving, in that encounters with things outside of its training model seem to result in collision or decapitations.

It is the trust people place in their cars that results in disaster when they reach the edge of what the cars can handle. They aren't ready to take over the controls and understand their current situation in a fraction of a second.

Placing too much trust in LLMs could have the same effect. I've run into several situations where I asked Chat-GPT technical questions and it confidently gave me detailed answers that clearly represented absolute failure. Fortunately, I don't trust it blindly, or at all, so I wasn't fooled.

I'd prefer an LLM more like my current car, that didn't try to do too much, but that's just not in the nature of how they operate, so instead we're all one emergency vehicle parked across the street away from a terrible accident.

pwinnski··on GPT-4 Is a Reasoning Engine
Speaking for myself, I am equally dismissive of aliens, if that helps.

I think what annoys me about claims like this is two things, and it has to do with in-groups and out-groups.

1. I am concerned about how non-developers perceive us developers when they hear claims like this, since I expect that particular hype balloon to pop in the future.

2. I am distressed to see developers (who should know better) make these types of claims, especially without regard to 1.

If I were more into physics, I'd probably get more worked up about em-drives. As it is, I am enjoying LLMs and consider them an incredibly useful tool, possibly up there with things like GUIs and IDEs in terms of productivity enhancement. But it's still just extra-spicy autocomplete, and I think forgetting that could be dangerous.

pwinnski··on AI won't steal your job, people leveraging AI will
There are three types of lies, as the saying goes: lies, damned lies, and statistics. But why are statistics considered lies?

Because of how they're used.

If you think of AI as a source of truth, obviously you're going to run into trouble: it "lies"! But if instead of thinking of it in isolation, you think of the person+AI producing results, then you should trust that person exactly as much as you would whether or not they use AI.

pwinnski··on Stable Diffusion copyright lawsuits could be a legal earthquake for AI
Compression with extra steps is still compression. Most people don't understand the math involved in LZF-encoding, and lossy audio encoding seems even more strange, so "diffusion" just sounds like a somewhat-lossier form of compression if described in a certain way.

I was very dismissive of the anti-AI-image crowd until I saw that Anne Graham Lotz pic. Only a single known source image of her exists, although many copies of it are distributed far and wide across the internet, and using her name in a prompt results in an image that seems very much like a lossy reproduction of the "original." It's an edge case, to be sure, but that demonstration looks like lossy compression, even though it's not.

pwinnski··on If AI scaling is to be shut down, let it be for a coherent reason
The thing about predicting doom is that you're wrong often--until one day you're not.

Most hype cycles involve people at the top making wild claims that fail to deliver. I don't know anyone outside the industry who ever thought 3D TVs were worth anything, and barely anyone who thought VR was worth anything. Google pitched AI making appointments, but that never made it off a stage. Hype? Only for some definition of hype.

Smartphones have changed the world, but it was primarily Apple who pushed the "post-PC" narrative, and that was to promote the iPad, one of their least successful product lines. (To be clear: it's still a HUGE business and success, but it didn't usher in the post-PC world Steve Jobs claimed it would.)

One you left out is cryptocurrency, and that's the only one I can think of where the hype came from more than just the people at the top, mostly because everyone down the chain thought they were also people at the top by virtue of buying in. Financial scams are always hype by their nature.

I'm older than some, younger than others, but in more than 30 years as a professional developer, I think this is as close to a "silver bullet" as I've ever seen. Like GUIs and IDEs, I think LLMs are tools that will make some things much easier, while making other things slightly harder, and will generally make developers as a class more productive.

There's no question that developers using a nice IDE to write high-level code on a large monitor are able to product more code more quickly than someone writing assembler on a dumb terminal, I hope. The shift from monochrome ASCII to GUIs helps, the shift from a text editor to an auto-completing, stub-writing IDE helps, and similarly, I think having an LLM offer up a first pass approximation for any given problem definition helps.

Concerned? I'm not concerned, I'm excited! This isn't marketing hype coming from someone on a stage, it's grassroots hype coming from nobodies like me who are finding it actually-helpful as a tool.

pwinnski··on NYPD is refusing to comply with NYC’s new surveillance tech laws
This is a bad reading of the case. The ruling on appeal was that the police in that case had no special duty to that particular person, but still had a duty to the public at large.

Specifically, "the duty to provide public services is owed to the public at large, and, absent a special relationship between the police and an individual, no specific legal duty exists."[0]

People like to extrapolate from that, saying that if no specific legal duty exists toward individual 1, and no specific legal duty exists toward individual 2, and so on, then ultimately, no specific legal duty exists toward any individuals at all, but again, the first part of that sentence restates that there is a duty to provide services to the public.

I mean, look, the story of the crime itself is horrifying, but if the ruling had gone the other way, the concern was that cops would essentially be held to a standard of perfection, and any cop who ever didn't investigate any crime aggressively enough would be liable in court for their lack of aggressiveness.

I think it's a bad ruling, but it doesn't say what people claim it does, and it also doesn't seem to apply particularly strongly outside of the District of Columbia.

0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warren_v._District_of_Columbia

pwinnski··on Apple introduces Apple Pay Later
You certainly have no responsibility at all to help a multi-trillion dollar company fix themselves! Nor to ever shop with that company. You do you!

That said, I hope my comment and the subsequent upvotes make it clear that your experience seems very unusual. I have never felt pressured to buy anything on my numerous visits, and was even talked into buying a cheaper option of two things I considered once, and another time it was suggested I go to Best Buy rather than buy anything from Apple.

They're not paid commission to avoid situations like the one you described, so it's really strange to me that happened. That's all!

pwinnski··on The Anatomy of Your Salary
Ah, okay, I see now.

Feel free to define analogy as a thing in which everything applies in exactly the same way to the level of detail that it really means you're describing the exact same thing using different words, while the rest of us go on with understanding that analogies are limited-purpose.

pwinnski··on The Anatomy of Your Salary
You might have misunderstood. Historically cartels have worked to keep SWE salaries low, not high[0].

0. https://qz.com/247251/silicon-valley-hasnt-got-away-with-its...

pwinnski··on Sex and the citizenship process
We hired an immigration lawyer for this most recent process, and he told me a story.

There had been a large group of people from a particular country who all attended a church together here in the US. They had affidavits and bank statements and so on, but most or all of the photos were actually group photos in which the happy couple were circled.

Somehow it all came unraveled, and it turns out that the couples weren't couples at all. They were all as a group close enough to share bank accounts and addresses and so on, but not romantically. Very, very strange, the details I was able to get, but that's another wrinkle.

I think yes, the system is rigged, but also, a lot of people want to immigrate pretty desperately. In some cases, that leads to lying about romantic relationships, and in others, apparently, going way out their way to prove they are not lying about that part!

pwinnski··on Sex and the citizenship process
The first time I went through this, in the end it's possible that the only thing that mattered was my partner being several months pregnant at the time of her interview.

The second time, I wrote a photo-story instead of just packing in a pile of 4x6 prints. "Here's us dating, here's us married, we took this trip here, this other trip there, here's my partner and her child with my parents and one of my siblings, here's me meeting her parents, here's our wedding, here's me and the kid, here's all of us at various events, here's us celebrating an anniversary," etc.

pwinnski··on Sex and the citizenship process
Have you ever tried to navigate the immigration process? I have, twice now. It's a Kafka-esque nightmare of Orwellian bureaucracy, and I wish I could think of a third famous writer to reference to finish this sentence.

The first time, years ago, they "lost" a packet of information we had to reconstruct at great pains, and then had to get a second physical because they lost the report from the first one. We only found that out after getting our state's federal senator's office involved.

The second time, we ran into both rapidly-changing immigration requirements[0] and a pandemic, which made it super-unclear which issue was more relevant to the seemingly-interminable wait of years.

The instructions are vague in the best of times, and even immigration lawyers have no idea what a given USCIS staffer will care about on any given day. A rejection can mean anything from another year or two in the queue to a demand to leave the country and the life you've built within 30 days, so the stakes are high.

In my most recent application packet, I did include a photo I wouldn't publish online. While it featured no nudity, it was taken in bed. The same photo rotates through a digital frame on my desk in a house with a child in it, so it's by no means risque, but that is why people send in photos you might consider unwise.

0. I can't think about this without offering my best wishes and condolences to Mrs. Miller, who married the architect of that immigration nonsense the same year I married my partner.

pwinnski··on Apple introduces Apple Pay Later
Hahaha, what an odd response! I mean, explaining how your tone was condescending while mine clearly expressed wry amusement would just be me being defensive now, right? So I won't.

My point stands: From the time this card was first announced, people online, especially on this very site, have been dismissing it as having "sub-par" terms, and yet when pushed, all of the alternatives offered up seem to be similar, or even worse.

Of the three credit card bills I (auto-)pay off every month, Apple card has by far the biggest bill, because I use Apple Pay a lot. When I travel to Hong Kong, I love the lack of foreign transaction fees, and still the easy convenience of tap-to-pay with my wristwatch everywhere.

I do have a Chase Sapphire Preferred card that also has no transaction fees--but it costs me $95/year, so I'd judge that to be sup-par compared to Apple's free card, except that I use it to book travel, so the cash back goes farther.

I'll look into the CapitalOne SavorOne that somebody else mentioned, but generally I don't look forward to spending hours of my life comparing nearly-identical credit cards, so I was glad to get some real answers this time!

pwinnski··on New health insurance “transparency data” looks suspiciously wrong
They don't seem to have any trouble sending out bills, though.
pwinnski··on The EV Transition Is Harder Than Anyone Thinks
I have a 2017 Fiat 500e, and it's fantastic. What a great car!
pwinnski··on The EV Transition Is Harder Than Anyone Thinks
I bought my first EV by trading in my Prius and writing a $27 check. Had I paid cash, it would be have been about $7k (for a 2017 Fiat 500e in 2020).

I bought my second EV for $39,995 out the door, and then got a $7500 tax credit, reducing my net cost to $32,495. That one is a 2023 Chevy Bolt EUV.

I'm not sure which is the best car I've ever owned, but they're in positions 1 and 2 in some order.

pwinnski··on Apple introduces Apple Pay Later
Which matches the 2% my comment already said I get with Apple card. And requires a Fidelity account. So I'm not sure it's "better," but thank you.
pwinnski··on Apple introduces Apple Pay Later
As I mentioned in the comment to which you're responding, I never get less than 2% from my Apple card, so the Wells Fargo doesn't seem better to me.

I'll look into the Capital One option, thank you!

pwinnski··on Apple introduces Apple Pay Later
That seems to give the same 2% I already get with my Apple card, but only 1% immediately, and the other 1% when it's paid, making it not as good as my Apple card's 2% immediately.
pwinnski··on Apple introduces Apple Pay Later
I have the same one! I use it for Amazon only.
pwinnski··on Apple introduces Apple Pay Later
Fidelity and Citi match Apple's 2%, okay.
pwinnski··on Apple introduces Apple Pay Later
Q. what is the best general-purpose cashback credit card?

A. As an AI language model, I cannot recommend a specific financial product, but I can provide some information on what to look for when choosing a cashback credit card.

[Information on what to look for: Cashback, signup bonuses, annual fees, redemption options, and credit score requirements.]

It's possible Bing's AI does better, but I don't use the Edge browser, so I don't know.

pwinnski··on Apple introduces Apple Pay Later
Brave throwaway, you underestimate the knowledge you possess! You should be proud of your knowledge and gladly share it, rather than mock those unwilling to expend the effort you've expended to earn such knowledge.

Search results are plagued with spam to the point of uselessness, and this is precisely the sort of information I would not trust from an LLM because their sources are, as I said, plagued with spam and I don't want to chase hallucinated results.

In fact, for all that it's a trivial question, this is at least the fourth time I've asked it, and the first time I've gotten real answers--although not from you.

Perhaps the issue is that you don't seen to realize I've never gotten less than 2% from my Apple Card, and I get 3% back from Apple purchases? (Since I just bought an iPad Air + accessories for my daughter's birthday, that alone saved me more than $50!)

The Fidelity card you mention seems to require a Fidelity account, but that's okay, since I have one. However, the terms then seem identical to my experience with the Apple card.

I got my Apple card before Chase updated my cards from them to be tappable, and basically I use the Apple card for Apple Pay (2%) and purchases/subscriptions from Apple (3%), a Chase Amazon card for purchases from Amazon (5%), and a Chase Sapphire physical card (2% or 5%, depending on category) when a physical card is required (rarely these days, but at Walmart for one). It's not clear to me how Fidelity is any better than Apple card in this scenario.

pwinnski··on Apple introduces Apple Pay Later
That is shocking to me, and you'd be doing everybody else a favor if you let the store know about it, so that guy can be terminated or at least retrained. I've never had an experience anything like that, and I know that's not the norm at Apple stores. Wow!
pwinnski··on Apple introduces Apple Pay Later
That didn't seem to have anything do with it being an Apple card, though?
pwinnski··on Apple introduces Apple Pay Later
People keep saying things like this, and rarely offer up the name of any better card when asked.

Apple Card offers 2% cash back on all Apple Pay purchases, which... exactly matches my no-fee card from Chase. Except I have to choose how to use the 2% from Chase when it eventually is available, while I can spend Apple's 2% the next day via Apple pay. I threw the metal card in a drawer when it arrived, so if your goal is tell people not to use the physical card, then sure, I'm with you. But I don't think that's the primary use of the card.

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →