HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

pwinnski

8,760 karma · joined June 28, 2016

submissionscomments
pwinnski··on Accenture would cut 19,000 jobs
Accenture handles immigration paperwork so large companies don't have to, among other things.
pwinnski··on Women are less likely to buy electric vehicles than men
You don't know me nor the men I've talked to. I have had deep meaningful conversations about fears and vulnerability with many men, and they almost never involved physical safety. Conversations about shame, and emotional pain, and fear of failure and being perceived as weak, yes. About being attacked on the street, almost never.

You doubt, and you suspect, and you believe. More than three-quarters of rapes and sexual assaults are not reported[0]. Violent crimes involving injury, or murder, are reported by the medical personnel involved. When you rely on one set of statistics to negate widespread fears, and ignore all reports or statistics that support them, you don't end up with a clear view of things.

The experiences I describe are 100% normal in suburbs all around America. It's not just once or twice, and I'm not the only man to have noticed this.

If you don't want condescension, base your opinions on facts rather than counter-factual beliefs and feelings. I'm linking to statistics and reports, and you're parroting stereotypical generalizations countered by comments from women on this very page.

I am taking your statements at face value, but at this point it is starting to honestly feel like you're trolling, so carry on.

0. https://www.statista.com/statistics/251934/usa--percentage-o...

pwinnski··on Why buying furniture is so miserable
Like many things, this seems to reflect a difference in philosophy. Personal story:

I grew up poor, living on the cheapest possible option for everything, and no option at all for many things. Then I wasn't poor anymore. So I would spend time researching the absolute best toaster oven, say, reasoning that paying more would mean not having to worry about a toaster oven again in my life.

Later still, I got married to someone who grew up in Hong Kong, a city famously filled with tiny living spaces and street markets filled with goods from right across the border in China. Her philosophy, shaped by her upbringing, is that things are generally disposable. She will happily buy a $20 toaster oven from Walmart[0], and do so again whenever she decides it needs to be replaced. At $20 every three years, it would take several decades before she spent more than I did, and in the meantime maybe she has decided she wants different colors, or uses a toaster oven much less and doesn't even need one anymore.

While I look and see waste and a deleterious effect on the environment, she see flexibility and cost savings.

Back to the furniture: part of me wants to see if Ethan Allen is still making high-quality long-lasting furniture here in the USA, and buying a new couch there whatever it costs. Another part is on board with my wife's approach, which is pick the style of couch she wants, buy it cheaply, and just know it's going to need to be replaced in five years, but that's okay, because she'll want a different style then.

0. Literally, $19.96! https://www.walmart.com/ip/Mainstays-4-Slice-Toaster-Oven-Bl...

pwinnski··on Microsoft Loop Preview
Absolutely! I don't know of any company offering bundles in which every product is consider the best in its class, and even bundles that start with credible claims seem to quickly fall behind in quality.
pwinnski··on Women are less likely to buy electric vehicles than men
> I'd suspect that men and women have similar safety concerns, but men are just more likely to lie about it on surveys.

Talk to more women, I'd say.

I have been scared in my life, and I have known many men I would describe as being generally-fearful people, but I have never met any man who spent as much of their life considering physical safety as one of their highest priorities every single day of their lives, and I have talked to many women who describe that feeling in different words.

I think it's good to acknowledge that men can be, and sometimes are, scared. But I think you do a disservice to both men and women when you look at "violent crime" stats (skewed heavily by gang activity most of us will never encounter regardless of gender) and believe that men and women are generally equally concerned about safety. That flies in the face of the experiences of nearly everyone, I think.

Put another way: there are some neighborhoods in which I would not like to walk alone at night, but I have never once worried about being attacked while walking for exercise in a tony suburb in the afternoon. Any time I've encountered a woman while doing so, they would cross the street, be holding keys in their hands, or both. I don't think I'm a scary-looking guy, but as an unknown man they encountered, even in a tony suburb in the afternoon, concern for their safety prompted them to take action.

You don't have to believe me, and I can't convince you. But if you ever listen to women, read women, or even believe the comments you see on this page from women, you might just understand life a little more.

pwinnski··on Women are less likely to buy electric vehicles than men
Context matters, and in this case the context includes several references you glossed over, the category under which this was published, and oh yeah, the fact that one of the prime selling points for EVs is helping the environment by eliminating combustion engines.
pwinnski··on Women are less likely to buy electric vehicles than men
You may not feel safe, but "safer" is a comparison word, and I'm not sure on what basis you claim to feel as unsafe as a woman would in the same situation.
pwinnski··on Women are less likely to buy electric vehicles than men
Moving the goalposts from sexual harassment to violent crime doesn't change reality. I don't know any men who fear violent crime every time they step foot out of the house, unless they are actively involved in a lifestyle that tends to violent crime. Most women I know fear sexual harassment and worse every time they step foot out of the house.
pwinnski··on Women are less likely to buy electric vehicles than men
Which is great! You only had to exert a bunch of extra effort, and it sounds like you've enjoyed the results.

Now read some stories from women who've also made that extra effort and then some, having more experience and knowledge than the mechanics trying to rip them off, and still being given the runaround more often than not.

A shady mechanic will be shady to some degree to everyone to the degree they think they can get away with it. No amount of self-education on the part of women lets them escape the shadiness.

pwinnski··on Women are less likely to buy electric vehicles than men
Why would "economics" be the sole, or driving, factor, without anybody in the room to say "Hey, roughly 50% of the potential market is not going to use any charging location they deem unsafe, and in fact if we don't work hard to provide a lot of safe charging locations, the entire market size is going to be constrained?"

The women described are making rational choices here. Safety is paramount. The market isn't currently for them, and the people who have created the status quo have done so foolishly, because there weren't enough women in the room when these decisions were made.

pwinnski··on Home Prices Fell in February for First Time in 11 Years
In one sense, you're clearly correct. Most people living rough aren't doing so because there are no homes available for them to live in, so given that our kids aren't generally homeless, clearly they're living with parents, or roommates, or something.

Fannie Mae says, for example, that we are lacking 3.8 million homes for people to live in[0]. That's a serious undersupply! Build more houses! The NYTimes is on the case, too[1].

Conversion of homes into rental units is definitely a big part of the problem, but there are numbers on that, too. Turns out there are more vacant homes than Fannie Mae said the undersupply is, 17 million by one reckoning[2]! Not all of those are vacant due to landlords being involved, but a lot are.

0. https://www.fanniemae.com/research-and-insights/perspectives...

1. https://www.nytimes.com/2021/02/26/upshot/where-have-all-the...

2. https://ggwash.org/view/73234/vacant-houses-wont-solve-our-h...

pwinnski··on Home Prices Fell in February for First Time in 11 Years
Oof, so many things wrong with this tweet, starting with the fact that the chart doesn't address the claim of the the image to which he's responding.

The claim is that all of those things could be afford on a single income. The chart doesn't look at individual income, but uses "family income" in both cases, hand-waving away protests by saying two-income homes were already common in 1953. That is debatable, and the tweet offers no evidence or basis for comparison, but again, does not address the claim of the original image, which involves a single income.

Smugly pre-declaring that you've made a case you haven't made, and gently mocking people trying to point out your error, it's not a good look.

pwinnski··on Microsoft Loop Preview
The market shifted toward more FPS games because of Doom, yes. But also, modern FPS games don't copy Doom slavishly.

Initially browsers were, in fact, copies of Mosaic, but over time they've branched out somewhat.

This seems note-for-note to be a copy of Notion, not just conceptually. It's a product designed so a sales team can tell customers: you can cancel your Notion contract and just add this low-cost option to your existing Office 365 subscription!

pwinnski··on Microsoft Loop Preview
Right, so instead of competing on quality, the established player can put out a vastly inferior product that ticks enough checkboxes and rely on the cost savings and easy of bundling to gain market share, pushing the superior competitor who actually delivers a quality product out.

From a game theory perspective, I get why companies do this. The level of management signing these POs don't rely on Notion or Slack the way the people who work for them do.

But this unquestionably makes everything worse. It eliminates real competition on merits and quality, replacing it with market leverage. It's anti-competitive. And Microsoft knows all about being anticompetitive.

pwinnski··on Unchecked corporate pricing power is a factor in US inflation
If you're selling luxury goods, then sure, exercise your imaginary "moral imperative" all you want.

When you're selling something people need to survive, like food or medicine, your moral imperative runs in the other direction, and profiteering at the expense of deep need is immoral in the extreme, especially if there are factors preventing competition so you have a captive market, like increased corporate concentration or a government-enforced monopoly.

pwinnski··on Google was beloved as an employer for years. Then it laid off thousands by email
At Google, developers were the product, not overhead. As such, they were supported lavishly, with meals and massages, at a level not previously seen, at least not in career available to people who weren't fifth-generation Ivy grads. And the pay, total comp is still trumpeted here at HN as among the highest around.

Sure, a lot of people saw those perks as being aimed a particular demographic: young people without attachments who were willing to spend nearly 168 hours each week on site. And a lot of us saw the selection of perks as those most likely to attract that demographic.

But people who joined Google didn't often leave for reasons related to Google, and I'm not sure there's a better way to describe that than "beloved." Low turnover tells the story.

pwinnski··on Unchecked corporate pricing power is a factor in US inflation
The "explanation" confuses correlation with causation. It is true that during the pandemic, with two stimulus checks from Trump and one from Biden, average savings increased, and many companies saw that as an excuse to raise prices to try to drain that savings. But that savings was not evenly distributed, and the timeline doesn't quite work. It's a word-association fallacy.
pwinnski··on Unchecked corporate pricing power is a factor in US inflation
If you consider "motive, means, and opportunity" then your question seems to be, essentially, "the motive should have been there in 2019, why now?" and the answer is that the means have become stronger through increased corporate concentration, and the opportunity is greater because the pandemic and political climate provides an excuse.

Not that shame was a huge pressure in 2019, but it's even less of one now.

Some percentage of people, even here on this very site, will argue with these conclusions, and say it's the pandemic, or wage pressure, or anything but pricing power, and that percentage of people is higher today than it has been in the past.

The pandemic and political environment provides an excuse that wasn't handy in 2019. The political environment provides cover. The naked greed has always been there (the motive), but the means and opportunity are stronger today than before.

pwinnski··on Altstore: Home for apps that push the boundaries of iOS
> So copyright infringement. Really a poor argument against Apples policies.

>> A poor argument? To me, as a final user, it's the greatest one.

>> I agree, regulators shouldn't exist.

So you don't want regulators, even though regulators are the only possible way things like the copyright infringement tools you like might be made mainstream. Got it.

pwinnski··on Altstore: Home for apps that push the boundaries of iOS
> Netflix had insanely good revenue when they started out and there wasn’t much competition.

I'm really curious about when you think this was, and what you mean. They started out shipping DVDs at a loss and took a very long time to become profitable--or to start the streaming service we know today.

pwinnski··on Meta Layoffs
Closed offices > cubicles > open desks, the treatment like cattle began once we stopped having closed offices.
pwinnski··on Supreme Court asked to strike down immunity for police who brutally beat student
Lets expand the judiciary, then. We can shrink the TSA to offset.
pwinnski··on GPTs Are GPTs: An Early Look at the Labor Market Impact Potential of LLMs
I had an extended back-and-forth in which I asked ChatGPT how to undo mistakenly marking a message as junk in Messages on iOS.

It gave me a 7-step answer that was completely wrong. Then I said no, you can't do that, it apologized and gave me an 8-step answer that was completely wrong. When I pointed out in this case there is no "Junk" folder in iOS Messages, it apologized for the confusion and gave me another 8-step answer that was completely wrong. When I pointed out why that one wouldn't work, it gave up and said recovery was impossible and that I would need to contact the sender to re-send, and be more careful when marking messages as junk. This was still wrong, as recovery is possible, just not by any of the means it described.

So yeah, I have been super-impressed by the quality of output from these LLMs, but I cannot imagine actually relying on one for anything where correctness matters.

Giving me a nice list of Korean shoegaze bands, sure. Its step-by-step for how to become a better volleyball player will be great for my daughter, and was better than the answer to the same question from Google. But correctness? No.

pwinnski··on Amazon to lay off 9,000 more workers after earlier cuts
Yes!

Whether there are 250k open positions at suitably-high levels is less clear, but there are more than twice that many open positions.

Of course, people used to making $300k+ might balk at positions offering half that or even less, but they're out there.

pwinnski··on Lance Reddick, star of 'The Wire' and the 'John Wick' franchise, dead at 60
He was the only good part of that show, but he was really good.
pwinnski··on Rupert Murdoch Lies at the Heart of Democracy's Destruction Worldwide
The difference is that thanks to court documents, we know the truth in this case, and we know that they knew the truth even while lying.

What you are describing is not true, and any and all court documents do and would demonstrate that. Whether you are aware of the truth or not isn't clear to me, so I don't know whether you are knowingly lying, like the Fox News hosts in this case, or ignorantly spreading false information.

pwinnski··on US Air Force MQ-9 camera footage: Russian Su-27 Black Sea intercept
I refer to Tesla's practice of releasing videos after Tesla crashes in an attempt to discredit the drivers involved, which came as quite a surprise to the drivers, who didn't realize that the cameras on the car they bought would rat them out.
pwinnski··on US Air Force MQ-9 camera footage: Russian Su-27 Black Sea intercept
I certainly did not have "The US military pulls a Musk, releasing footage to prove the other party is lying or mistaken" on my bingo card for 2023.
pwinnski··on First Republic Bank Executives Sold $12M in Stock in Months Before Crash
Okay, looking at David Lichtman, Senior Executive Vice President and Chief Credit Officer, let's see.

https://finance.yahoo.com/screener/insider/LICHTMAN%20DAVID%....

In 2023: Sold $917k on Jan 19, $594k on Feb 17, and $1.966 million on Mar 6.

But maybe that's normal! Let's see.

In 2022: Sold $326k on Nov 15, and $2.151 million on Dec 14.

Huh. Sold nothing at all before November, but $5.628 million from Dec, 2022 to Mar, 2023. That's... I wish we could go back farther, but there were no sales at all in 2021, at last as far back as the records go, which is at least May, 2021.

So from May 2021 to November 2022, no sales at all, then $326,000, then from December 2022 to March 2023, right before the crash, $5,628,000.

Lucky timing on the part of that Chief Credit Officer of a failing bank, right?

How about James H. Herbert, II, Founder and Executive Chairman? Honestly, he looks pretty safe. Sales on a semi-regular basis for similar amounts. 40k shares in 2021, 55k in 2022, 35k in 2023, not too suspicious.

Even less suspicious is Rick Osterloh, Senior Vice President of Devices & Services at Google, who was appoint to the board in September 2022 and bought $148k of shares in March 2023, days before the failure. Ouch!

pwinnski··on Who Blew Up Nord Stream? Investigators Focus on Mysterious Passengers on a Yacht
That is a fascinating definition of propaganda. So if I'm involved in state and want to ensure that the free press in my country spreads my message, all I need to do is ensure that there's no direct private coordination between my department and theirs? If I hold a press conference in which I state the party line, and new outlets reports on that press conference with no pushback, and then editorialists around the world write think-pieces that assume what I said at that press conference as truth, that's not propaganda unless I made some phone calls in the meantime? Amazing.

I don't assume Hersh is Russian, that would be bizarre. I haven't said Russia is making him do it, or that he's avoiding saying anything negative about Russia out of fear or as a result of blackmail, or anything like that. I have offered no conspiracy at all. I think it quite possible that Hersh just has a Russia-shaped blind spot. Having been witness to so much US malfeasance over so long a period of time, he might just assume that everything he see must be appropriately struck with the same hammer.

Perhaps his single unnamed source is a Russian plant, or perhaps it's an anti-American plant, or perhaps it's someone who misinterpreted things he witnessed, or who knows? I don't have any particular theories about that, either. I just think it's probably important to consider all the players, not just one. It's probably important to consider important and deeply-relevant public facts when forming or accepting a theory. That's all. Otherwise you might accidentally find yourself spreading propaganda, possibly without even realizing it.

I genuinely don't see what any party really gains from the destruction. It was already an unused pipeline for which there are alternatives, so the destruction seems symbolic more than anything. That facts since then have shifted slightly in the US' favor doesn't seem to have much to do with the pipeline destruction, things were already shifting that way.

I'd probably go with 50/50 NATO/Russia, but it's still not clear why, or how we'd ever find out absent a confession in a few decades.

← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →