HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

qeternity

8,835 karma · joined May 4, 2016

submissionscomments
qeternity··on US voters roundly reject data centers in ballot measures
Yeah I'm still not following.

What is Big Tech doing that you think everyone else should have a say in?

Big Tech didn't reshape the Internet...its customers did, by flocking to their products by the billions.

Big Tech isn't reshaping the workforce...employers are, by once again flocking to their products.

qeternity··on US voters roundly reject data centers in ballot measures
What ownership model are you referring to that is tech-specific and why is it in quotes?
qeternity··on OpenAI seems to be silently re-enabling model training on Codex chats
Not defending it, but training on books gave them a better product that people were willing to pay billions for.

Training on customer data will give them a product that nobody will pay for.

qeternity··on The SEC Should Block Anthropic's IPO to Protect the Public
I'm not sure what you think the "offering" in "initial public offering" means. It is literally the company offering shares to the public...to raise money for the company.

The alternative is a direct listing, where you just list your existing shares on a stock exchange.

Anthropic is expected to raise ca. $100b in their IPO. SpaceX raised $75b. Where did you get the idea that most IPOs aren't raising money?

qeternity··on Oracle files to sell $20B in new stock, bonds to finance AI buildout
The shares you own (usually) give you voting rights. Whether that makes any difference is another story.

But I'm not sure what people think the stock market is for? It exists primarily so that companies can access capital markets namely by issuing their own shares.

Historically for companies that were growing rapidly or had large capital needs, private markets weren't large enough to handle that. Times have changed, but the whole point of going public is to be able to raise capital by issuing shares.

qeternity··on Spain train crash: 'At least 10 dead' in high-speed collision
There is something deeply broken with Spanish rail.
qeternity··on Amazon’s “digital pacifier” for toddlers
The real answer is not that companies are trying to please shareholders, it’s that they are trying to please customers.

Nobody external gave a directive to build this. But if people buy it en masse, they will continue to invest in it. If not they will sunset it.

Its success or failure rests on consumers, the same people responsible for parenting their children well.

qeternity··on OpenAI and Anthropic cut their LLM prices by up to 80% within a few months. Why?
> its per GPU-cluster, not a single gpu.

No, it isn't. It's revenue per hour per GPU.

qeternity··on OpenAI CLI
No, this is an account/workspace management CLI.
qeternity··on Hybrid Reasoning Agents: LLM agents that think in latent space, act through text
I'm not even really sure what this means but the first part is not accurate, and the opposite is true: looped transformers are moving reasoning even deeper into the model.
qeternity··on NY announces game ownership bill requiring ownership rather than licensing
You’re confusing two things. It’s very different to change or reduce the IP protections companies have.

It’s entirely another to force them or restrict them from engaging in transactions between consenting parties that do not infringe on a third party.

qeternity··on NY announces game ownership bill requiring ownership rather than licensing
I don’t believe they have special rights.

You are comparing products that aren’t equivalent. If I “buy” a book on Kindle, that book might have restrictions (natural or artificial) that don’t apply to a physical book.

The product is what it is. If you don’t like it don’t buy it. If you bought a physical Xbox disc 20 years ago, you wouldn’t expect to be able to use it on PlayStation.

qeternity··on NY announces game ownership bill requiring ownership rather than licensing
Fine then let's reframe it: why can't the companies release games on their terms at their prices and allow consumers to decide whether they want to transact?

Nobody is forced to play video games.

qeternity··on NY announces game ownership bill requiring ownership rather than licensing
Incredible. Let's just upend well established rights to agency because you really like video games.
qeternity··on DeepSeek-v4.1-Flash-1017
> LLMs are non-deterministic

This is not true. Non determinism only arises via sampling, and to a much lesser extent, CUDA kernel launch subtleties.

qeternity··on US federal budget deficit jumps 12% in one year to nearly $2 Trillion
If you knew my full beliefs, it's the exact opposite. The Framers were a group of such people unafraid to chart a new path.

They enshrined a number of rights that are under attack by both ends of the political spectrum.

It's the failure to break the cycle which leads to dictatorship, and is unequivocally not the solution to problems of today.

qeternity··on US federal budget deficit jumps 12% in one year to nearly $2 Trillion
Today we are dominated by weak men afraid of what a greater mass of weak men might say about them or accuse them of.

The lion doesn't concern itself with the opinion of sheep.

qeternity··on Pg_vectorsearch: An index that is faster than pgvector's IVFFlat and HNSW
Partitioning is the easy bit I think, and falls out naturally from Postgres.

But how are people doing recency biasing with vector databases?

All of our approaches are either expensive or super hacky.

qeternity··on Claude Haiku 5.5
Knowledge will be shifted to systems like n-gram augmentation which are relatively cheap and will not compete with reasoning capabilities for weight saturation.
qeternity··on Mistral Large 4
> This comment could not have been more stereotypically American.

Of course. As I noted before, dripping in European condescension. Nothing you can actually point to, just condescension from a region that has been left behind over the past century.

> Attacks on rule of law and civil liberties have increased, and the right to privacy is one of those liberties. It's of course not limited to Trump, he wasn't in office when Snowden showed the world the scale of American mass surveillance on domestic and foreign citizens.

Which right or in what way has the right to privacy been attacked? Fully agree with you on attacks on rule of law. And I find Trump incredibly dangerous. But I do not think privacy in the US today has suffered. Please educate me.

> I'm totally unsure what you are attempting to imply. That mass surveillance by the American state stopped at some point in the last 10 years?

I am not implying anything. The Freedom Act curtailed a bunch of activities. You are implying nothing has changed. All of the Snowden revelations implicated many European countries: intelligence agencies spying on each others populations. I am asking you if you believe nothing has changed in the US do you 1) have any evidence of this and/or 2) believe that anything has changed in Europe? You've answered neither.

> What does that even mean "read history" ahaha. Espionage != mass surveillance. You do understand the difference, do you not?

Do you understand that the mass surveillance of European people was done at the behest of the intelligence agencies of those countries? And ditto for the NSA. The agreement was "you spy on mine and I'll spy on yours and we'll swap the intel". I am not talking about espionage. Foreign intelligence agencies spying on foreigners...what did you think they did?

> l m a o. Oh say can you see...

God, it's so painful. Yes in the same way that you talk about the US as a monolith and not 50 individual states. You don't care what Rhode Island does any more than I care what Latvia does.

Christ you guys are insufferable. It's no wonder everyone is leaving in droves.

qeternity··on Mistral Large 4
Except that the government has all of this information and much more.

And you have no protections from the "much more" bits, unlike in the US.

It's incredible that Europeans today think the culture of privacy is different. American privacy protections (from the government) were born out of European flaws.

The difference is that Europeans love the nanny state regulating private enterprise (GDPR) but never pointing that same effort against itself.

qeternity··on Mistral Large 4
I have no clue what English comprehension, monolith culture, and condescension have to do with one another? Or even the presumption that I only speak English?

It's not a strange statement in the slightest if you live here or spend any appreciable time here. I take it you do not.

qeternity··on Mistral Large 4
> So the NSA doesn't do any kind of domestic surveillance anymore

Yes, of course. That is why GP said "anymore".

Thanks for playing!

qeternity··on Mistral Large 4
Yes, I am an American living in Europe. I have pretty good insight into all of this.

> Some politicians in Europe push for that, until now it has been refused by the others. Unlike in the US, there are many different parties in European countries. And Europe is made of politicians from many parties from many countries.

And yet neither party in the US is pushing for it...

> So the NSA doesn't do any kind of domestic surveillance anymore, is that what you believe?

Do you have any evidence to the contrary? Or if you believe this without evidence, do you have any evidence this is not occurring in Europe?

> So if it's surveilling allies, it's all good in your opinion?

Lol, lmao even. Yes, of course it is. Allies spy on each other. The Europeans do it to each other massively and have done since the dawn of Europe. Good lord, go read some history.

> "Far far"? Do you even realise that Europe is not one single country? The US elected Trump, twice.

Again, I live in Europe. I am well aware, but thanks for the classic European condescension. I don't like Trump. But how has he weakened privacy rights? And yes, beacause I don't want to write dozens of caveats for each teeny tiny member state, I consider Europe to be dominated by happenings in DE + FR + UK. I don't care what Latvia does.

qeternity··on Run Qwen 3.8 Flash Next (125B) on consumer hardware (RTX 4090) at 100T/s
This may be true, but neither FA or MTP are lossy (aside from some possible CUDA kernel noise in FA)

MTP when done correctly is lossless. As you note: it is a draft. That draft is still checked by the original model. Drafted tokens are not accepted if the original model would not have selected them.

If you are having issues, something else is wrong. But in any case, you lack the domain knowledge to be posting authoritatively about it, and I suggest you read deeper into how these things work first.

qeternity··on Mistral Large 4
As an American living in Europe, it's generally Europeans who have a distorted perception. Most Americans know the bill of rights and the 1st/4th/5th amendments. Many Americans will know of the Patriot Act/NSA/Snowden revelations.

The same is not true of Europeans and they generally believe their rights are much stronger than they are. Most Brits are not aware of the true nature of the Investigatory Powers Act. Most Frenchmen are not aware of Article L851-3.

qeternity··on Mistral Large 4
Do you understand what "metaphorically speaking" means?
qeternity··on Mistral Large 4
> Generally speaking, the EU has some quite strong privacy protections relative to the US.

Please, like what? GDPR?

qeternity··on Mistral Large 4
> PATRIOT, FISA and Bush's surveillance programme imho give more powers to certain agencies today already than are codified in EU law.

This is not true. Whether you believe that FISA courts have teeth, or whether 3 letter agencies abide by the law, in most of Europe you do not even have the pretense of this. UK/FR and to a lesser extent DE are all much worse.

The worst parts of Patriot Act were undone in 2015, and the "F" in FISA stands for "Foreign". Europe continues to push policies like Chat Control and attempt to backdoor/ban E2E encryption for domestic surveillance.

The present day and trajectory in Europe is far far more grim than in the US.

qeternity··on I quit OpenAI because its culture is broken
I'm not advocating anything, to be clear.
Page 1 of 34Next →