HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

qnleigh

2,052 karma · joined March 12, 2023

submissionscomments
qnleigh··on How I use LLMs to learn complex topics
Well everyone needs some downtime, and then I think it's important to acknowledge that there is a range of quality within the category of "educational entertainment." You can learn a lot of interesting things from 3BlueOneBrown and Veritasium, even though neither compares to working through a textbook.
qnleigh··on How I use LLMs to learn complex topics
100% agree. They are not good teachers. Nevertheless I've been using LLMs more and more to learn complex topics, but my learning is always anchored in something else:

- Getting through textbooks and lecture notes. LLMs have gotten very good at answering basic questions on quite advanced material (e.g. representation theory and quantum field theory). By asking a very specific question or even giving the LLM a screenshot, I can get unstuck a lot faster.

- Learning e.g. new python packages. Instead of hunting for examples on Stack Exchange, now I ask an LLM to write a minimal working example and then build off of that. By writing most of the remaining code myself and only using the LLM to answer questions, I've been able to learn new packages significantly faster.

In both cases, the LLM isn't providing the curriculum or guiding what I learn. The textbooks, papers and coding tasks are. But now I can pick these things up much more efficiently.

qnleigh··on Artificial Intelligence used to design new viruses
What you say would make sense if phages designed from scratch with generative AI were the only solution to antibiotic resistance. That's obviously not the case.
qnleigh··on Artificial Intelligence used to design new viruses
This specific study sounds relatively benign, but generative models for DNA sequences sounds like an incredibly dangerous technology to develop. If someone were to reproduce their study while including animal viruses in the training data, what would it be capable of? And what about after a few years of progress?

Their phages have only 5400 base pairs, but the hepatitis virus has around 3000, and ebola only had ~19,000. That doesn't mean making a novel lethal virus is easy, but if anyone pulls it off, it would make Covid look like a picnic.

qnleigh··on Ten advances in mathematics and theoretical computer science
Found some discussion here [1] from someone who actually worked on a few of these problems.

[1] https://x.com/henryquantum/status/2083623695436623915?s=20

qnleigh··on Ten advances in mathematics and theoretical computer science
Can anyone comment on the significance of any of these results for their respective fields? Or what impact they might have? Presumably none are quite at the level of the Jacobian conjecture, but some of the results on group theory and sphere packing sound pretty important at first glance.
qnleigh··on Gemini Robotics 2 brings whole body intelligence to robots
Wow, I know what my next nightmare will be about.
qnleigh··on Our position on open-weights models
I'm not talking about what the AI labs are saying and it. I don't know what they have been saying and I don't care. I care whether LLMs a few generations from now will be about to bring these dangerous capabilities to the masses. Right now, given the progress of open and closed-source models, it seems inevitable.
qnleigh··on Our position on open-weights models
So many commenters are asserting this but no one is giving an argument or references. Cults have been able to make sarin. The DNA sequence for smallpox is pubicly available. Where are you getting your confidence that LLM-assisted bioweapons are of no concern?
qnleigh··on Our position on open-weights models
If you are optimistic about this given your expertise, I am very glad to hear it. As someone scientific but with little background in biology, I've been concerned about the bioweapons angle for a long time (and not because AI companies tell me to worry about it). Can you please explain a bit more about why you are not concerned? Between standard bioweapons like sarin and gain-of-function research on viruses, it's not obviously implausible to me that LLMs a few generations from now won't be able to guide a determined layperson through the steps needed to make something very destructive.
qnleigh··on Our position on open-weights models
I'm dismayed that I had to scroll past so many cynical cheap shots to find a comment that actually addresses the core point. I have yet to hear a single compelling plan for how we will prevent bioweapon development or massive hacking campaigns. For those who are skeptical of Dario's motives here, it's not enough to call out apparent hypocrisy, you need to suggest an alternative plan that addresses these concerns.
qnleigh··on GPT-5.6 used a prompt to close a 30-year gap in convex optimization
I have absolutely no problem with people disliking or fearing AI. It's energy consumption, effects on education and potential for displacing good jobs are all quite disturbing. But "stochastic parrot" means that "all it does is randomly repeat things that it has seen before without understanding them." It's infuriating to see this written about an instance of an AI solving an open math probably. Do you think the models are just randomly repeating facts until they accidentally emit a proof? If so, then how do they synthesize that knowledge into something logically coherent?

Alternatively, if you think that even Maxwell was a stochastic parrot, then presumably almost every human who has ever lived was also a stochastic parrot except a few rare examples like Einstein. Not sure what definition you are using but it seems too broad to be useful.

qnleigh··on GPT-5.6 used a prompt to close a 30-year gap in convex optimization
I won't touch creativity, but if this and other results like it do not demonstrate intelligence, what does? How was it able to solve problems that specialist mathematicians have tried and failed to solve for years?
qnleigh··on $100 AI Music Video: Claude Fable 5 vs. GPT-5.6 Sol
These are funny the first time you see them, but I guarantee if you watch a few you will start picking up how similar they all are and it will all start to feel like slop.
qnleigh··on $100 AI Music Video: Claude Fable 5 vs. GPT-5.6 Sol
I would love to see an example of this! Can you link anything?
qnleigh··on $100 AI Music Video: Claude Fable 5 vs. GPT-5.6 Sol
Art is kind of unique though, because it inherits a lot of it's value from scarcity, both of the art itself and of the rare talent that can make quality art. If an artistic style or product becomes too common, it tends to lose its luster.

An app is still useful even when it's cheap for anyone to make it. But art that anyone can make for cheap becomes, by definition, slop.

qnleigh··on $100 AI Music Video: Claude Fable 5 vs. GPT-5.6 Sol
I would really love to see examples of creatives using modern AI/LLMs to make quality art, and it feels like this should be happening, but I can't think of any examples yet. Maybe there's so much low-effort slop that the good works are lost in the noise. Or maybe most artists don't use AI on principle.

I would love to see examples if anyone has any. I saw a few things on r/AIVideos that I sort of liked, but I wouldn't go as far as to call them quality art.

qnleigh··on A metallurgist's doubts about self-replicating probes
I would also think that self-replicating probes would work more like living things. He seems to be imagining that we make probes like modern machines, and then find ways to let them build themselves. But nature found much easier solutions.
qnleigh··on The shingles vaccine may reduce the risk of dementia
Why on earth wouldn't you need to look at the P value? You give good arguments for the soundness is the methodology, but you still need to look at the results and their statistical significance.

Their P value is 0.02, which is good but certainly not definitive. Also the effect is kind of small, 3.5% reduction in diagnoses.

qnleigh··on China sentences official to death for taking $325M in bribes
> he was described as the most corrupt official in Chinese history... Heshen is remembered as one of the richest men in history... His total property was... reputed to be equivalent to the imperial revenue of the Qing government for 12 years.

Damn

qnleigh··on AI's Affordability Crisis
I think the concept of "AGI-complete" was interesting but had been falsified. LLMs have jagged intelligence, meaning that they are good at some things while being counterintuitively bad at other things that seem much easier. Especially given that a lot of software engineering can be trained via RL, it's entirely plausible that they will get extremely good at that while lagging in other things.
qnleigh··on I used Claude Code to get a second opinion on my MRI
Totally agree. I'm a scientist, and like most scientists I have some specialized skills that most of my colleages don't. AI has empowered them to learn and build things that they might have otherwise needed me for. But there have been quite a few cases where it led them very far down a wrong path. This has started happening way more often in the last few months.*

We've known since the beginning that AIs confidently say incorrect things. But now that they can speak confidently about very complex topics, and mostly say correct things, we are letting our guard down and lots of subtle falsehoods are slipping through.

*In one case, I was able to put things back on track because the AI suggested my colleague talk to me; somehow it figured out we were co-workers.

qnleigh··on Previewing GPT‑5.6 Sol: a next-generation model
Last I heard, Cerebras chips were entire wafers and would be extremely expensive. How could OpenAI possibly have enough of these to serve a popular model at scale?
qnleigh··on How physicists track and trap the elusive neutrino
I used to think this was the explanation, but I was told by a particle physicist that this is actually not correct. Unfortunately I don't remember the correct argument (and I'm not sure I understood fully it in the first place)
qnleigh··on OpenAI unveils its first custom chip, built by Broadcom
I haven't read any of these papers, but given the environmental impact of LLMs in 2026, it seems like Timnit Gebru has been thoroughly vindicated...
qnleigh··on AI's Affordability Crisis
The estimate that AI companies need to replace 27% of jobs to service their debt is interesting. But at least Anthropic and Meta seem to have their eyes on replacing software engineers.

There are ~1.6M software engineers on the US [0], earning a bit under 150k/year on average [1]. If AI companies captured all of that spend, that amounts to about 250B/year. The article assumed that they need around 300B/year to keep up with their debt.

At least based on Meta's recent behavior, forcing 30-50% of developers to switch to data labeling, it looks like that is actually their game plan.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Software_engineering_demograph...

[1] https://www.indeed.com/career/software-engineer/salaries

qnleigh··on Hyundai buys Boston Dynamics
> Atlas would need to learn new factory tasks in a day or two and reach 99.9% reliability before it could be truly useful on the floor

Progress in robotics has been impressive, but is there any evidence that we are approaching this point? How many days are needed to teach a robot a task at even 90% reliability? Given that most companies are still only showing of demos, that number looks to be way more than 2...

qnleigh··on A robot is sprinting towards you. Do you want it running on Claude or Grok?
Yeah it's sort of alarming when you think about hooking up models to take action in the real world and telling them it's just a game. Several scifi stories have it as a plot twist that humans think they are playing a game but are killing actual people. I'm not sure if the same twist shows up for AIs but it seems like an increasingly real possibility.
qnleigh··on Ice water drowning survival of young patient (2025)
That is incredible. 2.5 hours underwater, 1.5 hours of CPR. They were instructed not to start rewarming him until he could be given more comprehensive treatment at a hospital. They list 'death' as a differential diagnosis...

He didn't come out unscathed though. They describe his progress:

> At 6-month follow-up, he was giving short commands, standing without support, riding a tricycle, eating soft foods, and relearning simple tasks. Peripheral neuromuscular weakness continued to improve.

which is quite limited for an 8-year old, but remarkable considering the circumstances.

qnleigh··on Apple's weird anti-nausea dots cured my car sickness
What is the origin of this trick? It seems like the kind of thing that might have been discovered in academia but overlooked for years.
← PreviousPage 3 of 17Next →