HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

quietplatypus

65 karma · joined April 16, 2015

submissionscomments
quietplatypus··on I no longer understand my PhD dissertation
And a lot of it comes from trying to sound smart instead of readable.

Sorry, but if I was this guy's advisor, I'd keep his ass in school until he took away his pretentious "it is obvious from ___ that"'s.

Ph. D education just isn't what it used to be.

quietplatypus··on Jobs that are disappearing thanks to robots
Nice cult-like thinking there buddy. Hope your startup works out! I too wish I could enslave myself to something harder than most others (and throw a bunch of my employees under the bus in the process, making it a net loss), obviously the only way forward is back. I'm just a little bit more in touch with this annoying 'reality' thing :)
quietplatypus··on Jobs that are disappearing thanks to robots
Pretty much this, and I argue that it is because of motivations like his that we end up with companies purely meant to flout regulations to make money for themselves, like Zenefits, than anything that is of real value.
quietplatypus··on The truth about sex robots
We just need artificial wombs at this point. No seriously. Why tie the survival of the species to fickle personal factors?
quietplatypus··on Jobs that are disappearing thanks to robots
1. It's good that such boring, backbreaking labor is being automated away.

2. It's bad that we're still in the middle ages when it comes to this thing where if you don't slave yourself enough to something, you starve because no money.

quietplatypus··on The Surprisingly Innovative Future of Wood
Haven't people (e.g. Japanese) been doing this for thousands of years?
quietplatypus··on A Programming Language with Deterministic Multithreading
Why do we need a language to enforce this discipline of threading? Can't we just take away the lessons?

- explicitly label shared data and control flow - group together where the top threads are spawned

quietplatypus··on GCC: Improve on memory cost in coloring pass of register allocator
Ah, this explains it! I was thinking about the loop as presented and it seemed to boil down to "do your data flow correctly" but the situation is more subtle.
quietplatypus··on GCC: Improve on memory cost in coloring pass of register allocator
I've no idea about the specifics either, but I've done a little bit of compiler optimization in the JIT setting. What you say sounds right, and I'm filing it in the same mental bin as "when you're looking at which parts of the state + variables depend on others, you're most of the time better off reasoning from the initial state and input variables, instead of trying to do clever tricks of also reasoning backward from the output variables and combining them, resulting in worse approximations"

Or maybe it's something else that has to do with loops the way they are written.

quietplatypus··on I have no idea what I’m doing but I’m a programmer
Also, it's like, "What books?"

Programming any nontrivial piece of software not covered in a tutorial is not going to be in a book. Or it should be?

But there are cooking recipes where as long as you have the tools and ingredients, you can follow the steps and learn/generalize from that and you're cookin'. Same for just about any non-joke topic on wikihow.

Call me when there's a book on exactly (I mean not just talking in useless generalities) how to build and maintain a particular modern machine learning / robotics control / operating system.

There just isn't, because a) they are that complex and b) our culture discourages actual education when it comes to programming. Hell, even auto mechanics, maintenance programmers of the physical realm, get Haynes manuals for all the vehicles they might plausibly work on, which is a goldmine of material for knowledge development.

Right now, it's just so much more efficient to actually run the damn code and let the computer collect your data. I feel like software engineers of the future should write down everything they know about the programs they are working on, or at least all the steps of development and maintenance, so it's easier to get their internal theory.

quietplatypus··on I have no idea what I’m doing but I’m a programmer
I went through phases. At first I'd go on an on about having the most awesome process out of all the companies so as to make programming awesome software into an assembly line, then declare any programs written in Java or C/C++ to unmanageable untelligble dreck, to declaring assembly the best language because it gave you the most control.

These days I'm in a phase where I am curious about improving the development process in simple (but high impact) ways that do not interfere much but nonetheless are hard to voice because of their social unacceptability, like not comparing developers quantitatively and changing the culture from "works on my machine, push!" to "test your damn shit!"

quietplatypus··on I have no idea what I’m doing but I’m a programmer
That would be about my reading of this article as well, at least my most charitable reading. Peter Naur's "Programming as Theory Building", while not getting some important points right, is right enough to set anyone on the right track.
quietplatypus··on On Becoming an Individual in an Age of Distraction
BTW, can you imagine if Aristotle et al were listened to in their time, how different things would be?
quietplatypus··on On Becoming an Individual in an Age of Distraction
Hmm I think I am agreeing with you on the preconditions; I did say that the system, through literacy has sowed the seeds of its own destruction.

But it seems like we're on a path that makes this less and less likely, whereas the introduction of technology and so forth should have done the opposite, were we not "ethically bankrupt" as a species.

Baudrillard can be said to have identified the problems. and that more than makes up for his defeatism.

The rest of your reply is basically, now that we dont have salt mines worked by kids, everything is awesome and you cant complain.

If you really do recognize that we have the systemic problems I was talking about, perhaps we actually agree and I'm only saying things arent getting better fast enough.

Which is a real danger. There's only so much resources one can devote to not being a complete tool, and these are running down, quickly.

quietplatypus··on On Becoming an Individual in an Age of Distraction
Developing tech in small groups, making multiple versions of the same social media apps / manual labor explotation apps lol, while all thinking they will make it big, while sucking up to VC's. You could not have picked a worse example.

I'd say universities and government are actually the only institutiona left where one can really do the work you are talking about, and even that is with significant capitulation to the economy in order to continue existing.

We have a new religioua dogma now: capitalism, make more money than the next guy, everything is exchangeable, what you cannot pay for doesnt exist.

quietplatypus··on The strange non-transitivity of random variables (2014)
Not even true in that case, because races often come down to luck with pit stops and how aggressive other drivers are in protecting their space. If you can't pass the dude without rear ending him, you're not going to pass him, doesn't matter how better your "single-racer" driving skills or faster your car is on paper.

Even in footraces, the competitors still have influence on each other with drafting and late starting and whatnot.

quietplatypus··on The strange non-transitivity of random variables (2014)
Uhh, what if I told you that like most people with common sense and who realize that the initial conditions of a tournament are fixed in advance and that the ranking at the end only applies for that tournament and there are many other factors that influence who wins and loses in each match, I take tennis rankings with a grain of salt?

Hell I can even accept that player A > B > C > A if each has different skills and specialities that they bring to the table, without trapping myself and others into declaring it's some "paradoxical nonsense". Do we say rock < paper < scissors < rock and declare it's the end of mathematics?

quietplatypus··on Why Are Projects Always Behind Schedule?
if it's a long tailed distribution knowing the expected value isn't going to tell you anything you can count on
quietplatypus··on The strange non-transitivity of random variables (2014)
this isnt paradoxical at all, it's just you are looking at only 2 dice at a time not the full joint probability of a < b < c. i can come up with similarly retarded "paradoxical conclusions" if i took enough samples of different tiny slices of things.

dude is just trying to sound smart with yet another "counterintuitive probability post"

quietplatypus··on Intrinsic Motivation Doesn't Exist, Researcher Says (2005)
Is this just the lame philosophical trivia game where if you can name the thing that motivates you, by definition it's not intrinsic?

Booooooooooooooooooooooring.

quietplatypus··on We can't see our culture very well, because we see with it
Do you think either culture can make a case for itself being superior? I have witnessed firsthand the abuse and corruption that stems from Asian "family-first, materialistic" approach and honestly believe the American way stands a far better chance of creating someone who has self respect while still being able to function in groups.
quietplatypus··on A Way to Detect Bias
Isn't this not as meaningful as the mean, because the minimum doesnt really tell you about true capability? I can also easily construct an institution that satisfies your parameters, the minimums of two groups match, as in they have a token member at C for every group, but the characteristic performance of all members is different?

This in my eyes amounts to a simplification that is neat mathematically, but removes most of the useful information. I admit though that if the minimums did not match very well, that is an obvious sign of bias.

Edit: I suppose what I'm essentially saying is, what if minimums do match, then we cannot rule out bias.

quietplatypus··on A Way to Detect Bias
Very interesting! Seems like I don't understand probability as well as I think I do, since I bought the argument till I ran into this comment.

So, what are the effects of variance in different evaluation contexts, and do we have a meaningful way to measure bias if we take variance into account?

My initial reactions:

- It seems the higher the variance, the better examples you can trot out to say you are not biased against that particular group. since youll always find a member of that group who does amazing.

- If distributions of performance are multimodal, its even harder to conclude stuff because different institutions might cut off different modes when selecting the bar.

- Modeling the sources of variance may lead to insight into any actual bias.

quietplatypus··on Effective Learning Strategies for Programmers
Also, I find that being able to read code is super important. The faster you can read code and get it, the faster you understand new ways of doing things that actually are backed up under the hood by things that run.

This kills the incompetence.

quietplatypus··on Effective Learning Strategies for Programmers
That's especially true about the 10x programmer---I don't see people talking about how they saw a 10x programmer doing <X>, and how that factored into the 10x, I just see admiration, envy, disdain, etc.
quietplatypus··on Epistemic learned helplessness (2013)
Guy makes a shitload of basic philosophical errors, like most rationality training people. They are all centered around conflating logic with reality and ignring computational costs. If you cant connect a theory with reality that is rooted in specific, observable, actionable things, without requiring strong AI with a O(1) time complexity of synthesizing respinses, the theory is a nonstarter. If he was more aware of this, he would never get close to buying into claptrap like pascal's wager or mugger. So what if you believe in god or not? What does doing that or not actually get you?

It's amazing how many of these "rationalists" are using the concept as an emotional band aid against their resentment and other uncomfortable feelings.

And its not about compartmentalization. Ideas vary in their usefulness or actionableness. Sure, it takes instinct to distinguish them. But that is what "rationalists" are scared to death of, there being things like instinct and unconscious processing that, honed right, is often much superior to their laborious, droning but logical attempts to count every outcome, but requires faith in oneself.

It's really just a huge inferiority complex that they have. They are so insecure that they need universe-circumscribing systems of Bayesian logic to do anything. The truly rstional thingg to do is to put down the fucking rationality handbook, stop running the fucking expected value computations, go outside, live life, dare for the world to correct you, and get stronger or die trying. Thats it.

quietplatypus··on Forecasting is a talent – luckily it can be learned
They make it sound simple: apply a rational, scientific mindset to life. Talk about easier said than done. Most of us sink into easy-to-reach reactions that are only good for the simplest situations, and sometimes not even then, and often come with emotion or resentment. Still, the former mindset is a nice ideal to shoot for.
quietplatypus··on The cure for procrastination? Forgive yourself
What you said resonates with a lot of Nietzsche's thought, a core theme of which was it is better to experience the overcoming, the removal of an obstacle under your own power, than to have the obstacle removed for you. Nietzsche's take: the former makes you a master, the latter, a slave. I agree: that this is a universal human desire, and I'd rather be moving under my own power than having to take from others for everything I do.

Solving procrastination has become a sort of my own personal overcoming. Self-motivation is one of the core problems of life that everyone has to solve, I feel. Forgiving myself is just one of the tactics in my arsenal.

For me, I see the ideal of me doing anything I set my mind to, easily, without loss of energy or "motivation" (in fact transcending these concepts), and that is so tantalizing, and I am so naturally not good at that, it becomes a great target of Overcoming for me, and has an effect of having a constant but large reduction in procrastination.

quietplatypus··on Let’s Play War: Could war games replace the real thing?
One of the interesting ideas from this article is how simulations can map out how a war is going to turn out _badly_ for the people who wish to engage in it, such as Vietnam. Of course, the wargamers' advice was not heeded in the case of Vietnam, but this strikes me as probably one of the best ways in how war games could "replace the real thing", because a computer simulated it, and turns out the war is a terrible idea.

This leads to the other interesting idea from Buckminster Fuller: that Earth is a (ONE) spaceship, and we need to quit acting like each nation is on a different ship...

quietplatypus··on N3uro: A marketplace for brainwaves of people thinking about things
Great scam. Riffing off of this, there's probably a marketplace for a whole bunch of stuff, incl. urine/blood/faecal/saliva samples correlated with diet/exercise logs, handwriting, etc.

Never underestimate the modern idiot's tendency to ascribe any personality trait some sort of scientific-sounding, "quantifiable" entity.

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →