HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

racional

872 karma · joined April 17, 2024

submissionscomments
racional··on Far-left extremists likely behind France rail sabotage, interior minister says
So what is your working proposal to end "this shit" -- this evil war propped up by Goebbelsian machinations, per your insinuation -- then?

Specifically which of Ukraine's regions are you willing to hand over (in terms of granting permanent recognized sovereignty) to Russia in order to make that happen?

Because that's the name of the game, here.

racional··on Book details overlooked contributions of women and people of colour to maths
Reviewed also in the NYT:

https://www.nytimes.com/2024/07/24/books/review/the-secret-l...

https://archive.md/VEwpC

racional··on Russia's stocks of Soviet-era weaponry are running out
Also the mayors of Ukrainian cities who approve naming streets after "heroes" of OUN.

Then try writing letters to them, perhaps? I'm sure they'll be happy to hear from you.

racional··on Oscar Zariski was one of the founders of modern algebraic geometry
It’s not condescending it’s reality

Sounds more like you're (uncritically) accepting the narratives put out by various sources in regard to events of the time.

I think better choices could have been made

That's very different from what you said initially.

You didn't say that the Ukrainians "decided" not to negotiate for a cease fire (meaning, to accept Putin's demands for recognized sovereignty over the occupied regions).

What you said (twice, for emphasis) was that they "were told not to".

As if they are simply incapable of making such decisions for themselves, and just do what their Western handlers tell them to do.

racional··on Russia's stocks of Soviet-era weaponry are running out
Certain people in Ukraine valorize and whitewash that history.

But "Ukraine" as a country does not. And none of this stupidity is any way relevant to the current (very much Nazi-like) invasion by Russia that you are continually apologizing for. Whose true causes you know perfectly well, and are continually attempting to distract attention away from with finger-pointing tactics such as these.

That is the cardinal error you are making here.

racional··on Ties between Google's Project Nimbus and Israel's military
That's not the implication here.
racional··on How did Facebook intercept their competitor's encrypted mobile app traffic?
It's important to note that the "Guy" was not just with the IDF, but with Unit 8200.

Otherwise you'd be essentially saying "Hey look out, the guy who ran this op was an Israeli" (because nearly every male Israeli serves in the IDF).

racional··on Oscar Zariski was one of the founders of modern algebraic geometry
And they were told then not to negotiate for peace because they didn't have to

This is a rather condescending attitude which assumes the Ukrainians have no agency over their situation, and are just doing what their Western puppet masters tell them to do.

I was looking to move to Ukraine in 2020 because I think it's a lovely country and Lviv is a lovely city. Very cheap where I could exist cheaply and spend my time reading books. BTW it'd be an even nicer city if it were governed by Poland.

Please don't, as you plainly don't respect the country or the people living there.

If you'd prefer to live under Polish administration, try Wrocław.

racional··on Russia's stocks of Soviet-era weaponry are running out
And rightly so -- as far as the current conflict is concerned, it's a red herring.
racional··on Oscar Zariski was one of the founders of modern algebraic geometry
I think peace could have been bought at the cost of neutrality, so sovereignty yes.

It's possible of course, but it's also speculative, and the window for that option is long since closed -- once Putin grabbed the Crimea and then the LNR/DNR, the "neutrality" bid fell from the table.

In any case he's been quite consistent about maintaining whatever regions he's currently occupying (and likely then some, according to the most recent formulations).

So if we're to buy peace now by just giving him what he wants -- that (or some approximation thereof) is what he'll be demanding. In any case it seems extremely unlikely he'd accept a neutrality-only bid by this point.

racional··on Russia's stocks of Soviet-era weaponry are running out
As the set of my irrational russophobia is empty, the intersection of its relevance and the current conflict is also empty.
racional··on Göttingen was one of the most productive centers of mathematics (2019)
He was similarly evil of course. But he was a totally different creature (and came to and held power in ways very different) from that other guy.

That said, one can certainly imagine a NS movement that left the Jews alone and concentrated its wrath the other usual suspects. It might not have achieved quite the fiery intensity, or had quite the degree of hypnotic effect that it had on so many people that it did without the singular choice of a primary "hate object" that it made

Resonating as it did with centuries of psychic undercurrents in regard to the position of the Jewish minority in European society.

racional··on Göttingen was one of the most productive centers of mathematics (2019)
Not quite true in regard to border closures. It certainly became much more difficult to move around or out of Occupied Europe, but significant numbers of people managed to do so (via for example Portugal, Turkey and Vichy Africa).
racional··on Oscar Zariski was one of the founders of modern algebraic geometry
Instead of using Ukraine to give Russia a bloody nose we should have again fermented divisions between Russia and China.

Your reading of what's driving Western support for Ukraine is completely wrong here. They're not simply doing it to "give Russia a bloody nose" for its own sake. They certainly don't mind if that's what Russia gets out of it. But that's not the key objective in itself.

On the flip side: "fermenting divisions between Russia and China" is just fantasy, as at the moment U.S. is really quite inept in regard to such influence. It has no clue how to do that effectively (and any efforts it did take in that direction would most likely be moot and/or backfire).

I should note that I lament the cost of these conflicts to human lives on both sides and wish smarter populations governed by astute politicians would have found ways to successfully avoid war, perhaps at the cost of a multipolar world which we’re likely to get anyway.

Okay, multipolar world, whatever.

But what it really comes down to is this: the only way to have "avoided war" (after 2014) would have been to simply give Russia what it wanted -- recognized sovereignty over significant chunks of territory (most likely at least as much as it's sitting on now), combined with permanent limits on Ukraine's own sovereignty (in terms of its ability to enter treaties).

If you think this would have been (or still would be) an astute course of action -- you might as well come out an say so.

racional··on Russia's stocks of Soviet-era weaponry are running out
Perhaps you should consider doing the same, at moments when all you can think of offering in response to an evident Russian war crime (demolishing memorials on territory is illegally occupying) is to cite the completely non-analogous situation of the Ukrainians demolishing memorials (for whatever reason) on their own territory.

It's just such an obviously insipid and vacuous comparison. It's difficult to see why you went down this track, other than as an excuse to thrown down more of your favorite scare imagery and talking points.

racional··on Things I said as a manager part 2: Hiring is emotional
I had been talking to the candidate for months

This is in itself a huge red flag about not just Figma's hiring process, but its entire decision culture internally.

There's absolutely no reason for a "process" to drag on this long, unless it's for a C-level position with a corresponding equity stake.

The high of finding the right person makes it all worth it.

Not if the best people stop applying or referring their friends to you, once word gets out as to what's in store for them.

racional··on Russia's stocks of Soviet-era weaponry are running out
Well, of course.

It was yet another "Bandera, Bandera" thread.

So nothing emerging from it would have relevance to anything.

As you knew when you started it.

racional··on France high-speed rail traffic disrupted by 'malicious acts' on Olympic ceremony
I doubt their goal is to be universally reviled, so what's their real objective?

Believe it or not -- their initial goal was simply to gain respect.

They actually thought the Ukraine invasion would be a walkthrough, and that of course Western countries would whine and moan about of a -- but ultimately they would respect Russia for its audacity and boldness, that Russia would emerge with greatly enhanced stature over its historic rivals, and a new era of Russian gravitas and self-assuredness would begin.

So yes - it was all definitely quite strategic, in theory. But things didn't go as they planned of course, so now they're fighting like a cornered animal.

Except now the fight isn't for "respect", and it certainly isn't about Ukraine -- but rather their own physical and political survival.

racional··on Russia's stocks of Soviet-era weaponry are running out
The guy's an idiot, and a loose cannon. It doesn't matter how much he "evolved" or changed his tune once he started facing the natural consequences for whatever he shitposted earlier.

What matters here is that you seem to happy to hold him up a credible, interesting useful and inspiring source of information.

You couldn't disprove the fact that ...

I don't dispute any of it. There's no need to because it's simply not relevant to the current situation.

racional··on Russia's stocks of Soviet-era weaponry are running out
I don't think you rationally believe that this history has any substantive relevance to the current conflict.
racional··on Russia's stocks of Soviet-era weaponry are running out
(to the tg channel of Ukrainian politician, who is in exile in Spain and has survived an assassination attempt).

About that "politician", Andrij Shariy whom you are citing as some kind of a credible figure, if not a martyr of sorts -- from WP:

   In a 2010 article, "Blue Rust. Dictatorship of Sodomites"[4] Shariy expressed an opinion that due to death sentences for same-sex and adultery relationships in Iran after the Islamic revolution the situation with prostitution, pedophilia, and rape in Iran was much better than in Ukraine.”[79]: 46–47, 57 [81] In the summer of 2020, journalist Sergei Ivanov posted screenshots of Anatoly Shariy's publications from 2010 in which he showed understanding for the extermination of homosexuals and Roma in gas chambers during the Third Reich.[82][83]
No credible information has emerged about the alleged attempts on his life. However he is under investigation by the SBU for inciting nationalist hatred.
racional··on Russia's stocks of Soviet-era weaponry are running out
Which part are you disputing?

The idea that any of these stupid monuments have anything to do with the actual reasons the 2014/2022 invasions were launched.

Or that Putin actually cares about Nazis. Or that you actually care.

Or that any of this stuff has any relevance as a topic, next to the reality of the current war itself.

It's all just dumb propaganda.

racional··on United States discloses nuclear warhead numbers; restores nuclear transparency
For Russians of Putin's generation, the domination over Central and Eastern Europe was normalcy and they want it back.

Until Putin expires, or his lights grow sufficiently dim. At which point they'll be worrying simply about their political and physical survival.

racional··on Ties between Google's Project Nimbus and Israel's military
Again, it is not the simple fact of a dominant majority that make a country an ethnostate; it is this plus legally codified structures of dominance. The article on the subject is under 'ethnocracy' not 'ethnostate':

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethnocracy

There may be other countries in the region which satisfy this definition also, or fall on the spectrum; I do not single out Israel for criticism in this regard. The topic only came up in regard to the events 1947-1948, specifically the UNPPP -- and why the indigenous populace were not exactly celebrating this proposal or its likely consequences (which are of course now their day-to-day reality).

In regard to those consequences, specifically: the creation of an ethnostate on a large portion of their ancestral homeland; dominated by foreigners, and intrinsically and permanently hostile to their well-being and their right of self-determination.

Which they naturally opposed, as any self-respecting people would.

racional··on The Right Way to Quickly End the War in Ukraine
The war is evil and stupid and we all know who is to blame.

However, missiles are not raining down "daily" on Kyiv, and certainly not on Lviv (which has seen relatively few missile strikes in fact).

Or anywhere else, except places very close to the front.

Are they trying to be cartoon villains?

Believe it or not they imagine themselves to be worldly statesmen, and are doing what they are doing as means of finally achieving Augenhöhe (eye-to-eye respect) from their Western counterparts, in fact. "They get to bomb hospitals by mistake or otherwise in the course of their military adventures, so why can't we?" is their basic line of reasoning.

racional··on Ties between Google's Project Nimbus and Israel's military
That a country having a "dominant group" is something that would form an ethnostate?

Of course the fact of one group being dominant is not sufficient; there need to be deeply structural (legal) mechanisms in place for that group to maintain its dominance, which has certainly been the case with Israel since its very founding.

You may consult the definitions in Wikipedia as to "ethnostate" and "ethnic group" for further detail if you wish.

Which ethnicity would that refer to in your opinion?

The one referred to in Sections 1, 5, 6 and 7 (and whose language is given preferential treatment in Section 4) of the Nation State Bill.

racional··on Ties between Google's Project Nimbus and Israel's military
A 10 minute walk through Israel ...

"But the dominant group in Israel has internal diversity; therefore it can't be the dominant group" -- is that the counterargument, here?

racional··on United States discloses nuclear warhead numbers; restores nuclear transparency
Claims, without making a substantive argument.

Mearsheimer initially comes across as concerned, serious and intelligent. But when we stop to unpack what he's actually saying -- he emerges as a prime example of someone way too ideologically biased and beholden to broken narratives to be taken seriously.

racional··on United States discloses nuclear warhead numbers; restores nuclear transparency
Hacker News, 1939:

Armies don't just charge out because Hitler has his "dream", and certainly not sustaining the sort of punishment that the Germans have had to undergo in Poland. We can see from the response to Ernst Röhm that the military actually supports the Führer to a significant extent; if it was unpopular then Hitler would have been rolled by now. You aren't trying to understand the German motivation; this is unhelpful straw-manning and caricaturing.

And othering the Germans with irrational motivations is stupid. As a culture we've passed up too many opportunities to calm the situation down because of a Germanophobic attitude out of the US. Years of unhinged rhetoric from 1930 onwards turned out to be unhelpful in de-escalating a dangerous situation.

And I note you didn't link to speeches by Hitler. That'd be wise, it is rare to see a Anglo-American media outlet accurately representing even Anglo-American politicians. Not as a partisan thing, but as a blanket failure. It is better to go to the source material.

If we entertain multiple theories though, the "Hitler is just crazy!" theory fits, but so does the "gee, it is pretty easy to see why they'd be scared of France and Britain, look at what France and Britain did to them at the first opportunity" theory. Especially since it has been a factor in conversation for decades. People have been pointing out that the Treaty of Versailles was raising tension with Germany since the end of the Great War.

If the Treaty of Versailles wasn't involved in German Rearmament it does seem likely that nobody would be talking about the Treaty of Versailles.

But to argue that Germany isn't acting with reference to the Treaty of Versailles is just displaying a void of strategic empathy. What they've been doing makes a lot of sense through the lens of a group of people panicking as France and Britain keeps tightening the noose on them.

racional··on United States discloses nuclear warhead numbers; restores nuclear transparency
It was more the "cutesy" (and fact-indifferent) way they were arguing their position (rather than the basic proposition what they were arguing) that suggested to me that something was off here. As confirmed by their subsequent posts. I'll withdraw the pro-Russia insinuation if you like (as whichever side, if any they may favor seems irrelevant in this context).

I've personally yet to encounter anybody who holds (or read any arguments in favor of the view) that Russia is outright winning this conflict in any tactical or operational sense, beyond perhaps a very marginal measure - without it becoming immediately clear that the person making them had major gaps in their knowledge, and/or strong biases (as revealed by reciting standard narratives as to the supposed causes of the war). Or without it emerging (as with the sibling commenter) that they just don't seem to give a fuck either way.

But this is of course a different topic.

← PreviousPage 2 of 19Next →