HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

racional

872 karma · joined April 17, 2024

submissionscomments
racional··on Human history in the very long run (2021)
But that wasn't what you said.
racional··on Human history in the very long run (2021)
That no one who has read Marx can have significant criticisms of his work.
racional··on Human history in the very long run (2021)
I've encountered zero people with criticisms of Marx who have read what he's written.

So you're a fundamentalist, basically.

racional··on Dr. Ruth Westheimer, America's pioneering sex therapist, dies at 96
Hasbara literally means "explain"

Like Pravda means "truth" - things just aren't always what they seem.

racional··on Russian Missile Attack Levels Children's Hospital
And yet the idea that Russia has or ever had some rational reason to be threatened by any of this noise, or that it any other substantive way led to the invasions of 2014 or 2022 -- is still entirely fake. It's just another form of this basically:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dead_cat_strategy

‘Jeez, mate, there’s a dead Banderist on the table!’ is what your footnote salad amounts to.

racional··on The Phantoms Haunting History
Monotheism is one of the big contributions to culture by Judaism.

Presumably you mean Abrahamic monotheism -- as monotheism throughout the world has had multiple sources of origin, generally predating Judaism (and Yahwism).

But Yahwism itself most likely arose out of the Canaanite pantheon (and its monotheism).

So really is the latter -- the mighty Canaanite religion -- that we should be thanking for this great gift to the world that has been Abrahamic monotheism.

racional··on Never ask a candidate to rate themselves out of 10
The main point is - it's a intrinsically a footgun question (a stealth behavioral question that also happens to have no rationally correct answer).

Quite plainly there's no rational reason for someone to suspect that in this particular case of a standard boilerplate HR question ("How do you rate yourself?") that they should expect your secret trapdoor answer ("4 or below") should apply rather than the usual, automatic "7-9 is the only right answer").

I'll take your word that it wasn't intended as a joke. But it was intentionally oblique and slippery. All that you accomplish with a "filter" like this is to flush a lot of otherwise potentially perfectly decent candidates. And if they were to find out after the fact that this was where they "failed" your interview (after taking a whole day off work, driving down there, and going through all the other interview rituals) -- they'd be perfectly justified in applying whatever 4-letter words came to their mind in regard to that company and its vaunted "culture".

racional··on Microsoft cutting crucial link to Gaza, Palestinians say
These are fair points, and I appreciate the thoughtful, holistic response. We may disagree on interpretive aspects, particularly as to the motives of certain parties, and the extent to which the current operation differs from "war as usual" (whatever that may mean) or even other major IDF campaigns.

But beyond that I think we can spare ourselves further predictable iteration (which would only veer further from the original topic of the thread, and change nothing about what's happening on the ground in any case).

racional··on GE Aerospace Successfully Develops and Tests New Hypersonic Dual-Mode Ramjet
The figure I've seen for Russia's spend is 40% of its budget, not its GDP. More like about 10 percent of GDP.

Still an insane amount, for a war that has been obviously insane from the very beginning. But a different number, in any case.

racional··on Microsoft cutting crucial link to Gaza, Palestinians say
Yes, one notices there's been lots of shooting and bombing going on. The question is whether the current Israeli government rationally believes it will improve its overall security position in conducting the operation in the way it is doing (the usual intended outcome of a "war"). Or whether it has other goals in mind. As its numerous (quite nauseating) statements about the long-term fate it in has in mind for both the territory in question and the "animals" who inhabit it consistently indicate:

https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/security-aviation/2024-0...

It has long since abandoned any pretense of freeing the hostages as a primary goal, in any case.

racional··on Microsoft cutting crucial link to Gaza, Palestinians say
The sophistry resides in the gap between the current government's stated reasons for conducting the operation in the way that it has -- and its actual, inner reasons.

I am but the messenger.

racional··on Europe's new heavy-lift rocket, Ariane 6, made its inaugural flight
That's what I mean by backward-looking. Putin is so obsessed with his perceived stature and "correcting" past humiliations that he's willing to create a completely fictional crisis and drive his country into a never-ending meatgrinder war just to prove some abstract geopolitical point.
racional··on Europe's new heavy-lift rocket, Ariane 6, made its inaugural flight
And Germany once thought it "needed" to regain its colonies, and France once thought its very survival would be threatened if it didn't hold onto Algeria, and so on.
racional··on Europe's new heavy-lift rocket, Ariane 6, made its inaugural flight
Beats me, it wasn't my post.

The main thing is that Russia needs to pull its troops out of all of Ukraine; return those 20,000 abducted kids; set and adhere to a timetable for paying full reparations; and re-affirm its commitment to respecting the inviolable sovereignty of all of its neighbors, permanently and irrevocably.

After that we can dissect past NATO transgressions, and fix all the poorly thought / ahistorical comments on HN.

racional··on Mountain View-based Intuit to lay off 1,800 as part of an AI-focused reorg
Indeed, it seems the calculated coldness of the carefully chosen phrasing was precisely the point.
racional··on Europe's new heavy-lift rocket, Ariane 6, made its inaugural flight
The point is it was never going to launch an attack on that certain very large country to the East. All the rhetorical moaning and puffing of its current incredibly thin-skinned and backward-looking regime notwithstanding.
racional··on [dead]
For some reason, you're saying things here that you know not to be true.

About both Haaretz's circulation, and Levy.

racional··on Journalism's trust problem is about money, not politics
That doesn't at all jibe with my extensive observation of both Americans and non-Americans. But hey, it's your life and you can keep on forming beliefs about the world based on crude (and frankly rather trite) stereotypes like this, as suits your fancy.
racional··on The War on Estonian Forests (2022)
[Troll farms, recent German scandals etc]

I'd continue further with you here, but you seem to be very, very confused about some very basic things. We were talking about (empty) claims of KGB influence back in the 1980s. Not modern troll farms or German scandals in the past decade. The latter have absolutely no bearing of any kind on the former.

But various journalist do make educated guesses on this without the "we did it" explicit proof.

At least in principle (when they are not being grossly irresponsible) they attempt to draw inferences from boring things like, you know, actual substantiated facts (from multiple sources), or at least interviews with people claiming direct knowledge of such. Not -- as we have with the assertions you are strenuously defending -- wild-hair speculation about "could have" happened, in the complete absence of any hard facts or direct evidence of any kind.

racional··on The Impact of the Kaspersky Ban
The black sea a very strategic location that is 90% Russian.

Between 55-80 percent of the people in these regions identify as Ukrainian, according to the most recent census.

They may also speak Russian (to some degree), but that doesn't mean they consider themselves to be ethnically "Russian", or are desperate to be reunited with the Motherland.

It just means that Ukraine is a bilingual country.

You may want to take a serious look at what sources you are pulling such obviously misleading figures from.

And in particular: at who is presenting these misleading narratives to you, and why.

racional··on The Impact of the Kaspersky Ban
At this stage, a MAP [Membership Action Plan] offer would be seen not as a technical step along a long road toward membership, but as throwing down the strategic gauntlet.

You understand that in fact the MAPs to Ukraine and Georgia were never issued -- and hence, that this "strategic gauntlet" (which according you is what really started the war) was never "thrown" -- right?

racional··on Julian Assange has reached a plea deal with the U.S., allowing him to go free
The US was the first to violate the agreement, unfortunately.

How, specifically? Facts only, please.

There are hawks in the US that don't care about Ukraine being neutral because they want to squeeze Russia.

That doesn't mean they are a dominant contingent or that this is a key driver of current policy.

racional··on Journalism's trust problem is about money, not politics
You are, apparently.

Whether this is a useful way of looking at the world or not is up to you.

But in any case: no, they're definitely and obviously not the same.

Just because someone's view of a particular situation isn't exactly as diabolically dark and sinister as yours -- doesn't mean they see it as all rainbows and unicorns, either.

racional··on The War on Estonian Forests (2022)
Are you the kind of person who doesn't understand the difference between "tries to influence" and the obviously much stronger "pretty strongly influenced" claim the above commenter was making?

Or who thinks: "Okay, so we've been hearing a lot about the FSB and attempted election meddling. So if someone on the internet makes a spurious claim about an amazingly successful operation the KGB supposedly pulled off back in the 80s -- heck, why not just believe that also? Even though apparently nothing has been ever been written about it; and in fact what they're saying runs counter to direct observation of events at the time."

You certainly sound like that kind of person.

racional··on The War on Estonian Forests (2022)
The anti nuclear power movement in Europe was also pretty strongly influenced by Soviet info ops.

Citation needed, especially for the "pretty strongly" part.

racional··on Journalism's trust problem is about money, not politics
People generally think journalists are trustworthy.

That is ironically, in itself, a gross distortion of what I'm saying here.

racional··on Russia Finally Admits US Landed on Moon
Yeah, he gets that way sometimes.
racional··on Never ask a candidate to rate themselves out of 10
You're weirdly (and inaccurately) splitting hairs here. Per the Oxford Learner's dictionary:

The practice of playing tricks on somebody, or giving them very unpleasant things to do, sometimes as a condition for entering a fraternity or sorority.

So it can also be a "barrier to entry". The fact that Intel isn't technically a fraternity or sorority but is basically acting like one (in regard to this team's interview process) is but a small side detail here.

We also have, from Wiktionary:

To oppress or harass by forcing to do hard and unnecessary work.

Like requiring them to discern and accommodate the interviewer's oblique sense of humor as a condition for entry, for example.

racional··on Journalism's trust problem is about money, not politics
Not what one would a representative data sample from which to draw broad, sweeping conclusions about the entire industry. As opposed to the particular news outlets you were speaking with, for which it would have more validity.

It's kind of like saying: "Lawyers? I've dealt with them twice -- and let me tell you, they're all a bunch of lying scumbags who ..."

But interesting data points, nonetheless.

racional··on Never ask a candidate to rate themselves out of 10
Then it's a straight-up hazing question.

And not only that -- it betrays the mathematical (and everyday practical) ignorance of the people who apparently think of themselves as wily and clever for asking it.

It doesn't matter how weird and fuggly that particular language is. The only obvious, intuitive and reasonable way to approach the "How do you rate yourself?" question is always in relative terms, compared to the pool of candidates applying for the job (or perhaps compared to other engineers at the company).

Which either way means a fricken bell curve, obviously and by definition. For which 5 is the median, and the only acceptable answers are "7,8,9".

But instead someone on your time decided they had to be cute and turn it into a "Guess the punchline to the snarky joke question I came up with this morning" question.

This is Intel's idea of culture, apparently.

← PreviousPage 4 of 19Next →