HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

racional

872 karma · joined April 17, 2024

submissionscomments
racional··on Wildlife Protections Take a Back Seat to SpaceX's Ambitions
Both, obviously.

There's no way one can say the company doesn't also have agency in the matter.

racional··on Russian space agency head: Moscow has proof America DID go to the moon
Previous discussion of essentially the same article:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40901790

racional··on Wildlife Protections Take a Back Seat to SpaceX's Ambitions
https://archive.is/2o77k
racional··on Russia Finally Admits US Landed on Moon
But it is significant that according to a recent poll, only 31 percent of Russian adults accepted that U.S. astronauts landed on the moon in the last century.

Meaning we have here a population that is so used to being propagandized that it propagandizes itself without even being told to.

racional··on VPN ban is strangling communication in Myanmar
But you didn't reference just that one comment.

You specifically took the trouble to make it look like this was something that keeps happening all the time, via the carefully chosen phrasing:

every time someone promotes 'ethical journalism' here,

That's where things started to get weird in this thread.

The democractic russian government ...

Before they got weirder still.

racional··on VPN ban is strangling communication in Myanmar
Why does it feel like every time someone promotes 'ethical journalism' here, it's always state backed propaganda?

A quick keyword search on the phrase easily refutes the supposition you're making here.

Not only that, people use propaganda terms like 'authoritarian regime'.

Probably because it would seem to be a reasonable enough description of the system of government in that country since 1962.

Meanwhile the weirdly exaggerated language you're using here seems to be in itself quite propagandistic.

racional··on Russia Claims Breakthrough With ATACMS
NATO was never, ever, ever going to start a land war against Russia.

The idea that it would have even the slightest interest in doing so is just absolutely fucking absurd.

It's just pure scare imagery that the Russian deep state puts out -- to feed its internal narratives ("The West out to encircle us, only the Russian state can protect you"), and to confuse and mollify external opposition to its blatantly aggressive actions against neighboring states.

racional··on Russia Claims Breakthrough With ATACMS
If instead we listened to what they were actually saying about the expansion of NATO toward their borders this conflict could have been avoided.

Actually the West did listen, and as a result took the crucial step of formally denying the NATO memberships requests of Ukraine and Georgia in 2008.

But Russia invaded anyway -- because all this NATO noise was never the real reason they sought to pacify Ukraine in the first place.

racional··on OpenAI Wants New York Times to Show How Original Its Copyrighted Articles Are
It's not an exact analogy, but I think it captures the basic moral point of what's at issue here.

It's perfectly obvious what OpenAI did - and it knows perfectly well how limited its horizons will be if it can't build its empire on the basis of stolen material.

That's why it's now hissing and spitting like a cornered animal.

racional··on The Soviet Union's Monster Mi-6 Helicopter Airliner
I'm quite fond of Crimea.

Very fond, I'm sure.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1939_German_ultimatum_to_Lithu...

Many Ukrainian cities as well

And the German soldiers were always so fond of Paris.

racional··on The impact of Orwell's "Homage to Catalonia" on Noam Chomsky's path to anarchism
The so-called "Khmer Rouge"

My bad - Angka Loeu it seems you'd prefer we say.

racional··on Google rejected me and now I'm building a search engine
I'd recommend programmers with anxiety to avoid whiteboarding interviews [1] or at the very least let it be known ahead of time that you get stage fright.

Unfortunately acknowledging that you are in any substantive way human is a huge turnoff to these companies.

And approaching them with the suggestion that the interview process should have at least some resemblance to a 2-way street will be seen as a huge red flag, and a sure giveaway as to what an incorrigibly self-entitled primadonna you must be for even brokering that suggestion, as well.

racional··on OpenAI Wants New York Times to Show How Original Its Copyrighted Articles Are
It's called a "burdensome discovery request" and will likely be rejected outright or curtailed greatly in scope.

To the extent that it's interesting it's because (on top of brazenly stealing everyone's copyrighted material in the first place) it simply showcases just how thuggish and antidemocratic the brain trust behind this company truly is.

In a nutshell this is like a thief breaking into your house, stealing all your underwear and jewelry -- and then going to the judge to compel you to produce receipts to prove that it's all yours. And certificates of origin to prove they aren't all counterfeits.

racional··on The Soviet Union's Monster Mi-6 Helicopter Airliner
Mutin/Agutin

Whoever the Russian deep state manages to run up the flagpole after Putin croaks -- we know you'll still be here.

Echoing his latest catchphrases, defending his every move.

racional··on A Bugatti car, a first lady and the fake stories aimed at Americans
But now the situation is worse, a hot proxy war.

The thing is -- the response you're retroactively advocating here (aggressive brinkmanship) would have been by definition a major gamble. And it does seem that you're basically assuming that the "dice" would have turned up your way.

Whereas most likely the US/UK mindset was: "Yeah, it could go our way, if we went that route. Or it could trigger a nuclear escalation, either as an intentional response from their side -- or a purely accidental one. The odds for this are quite high -- at a bare minimum 10 percent, according to our analysts, though some say the risk is far higher."

The current situation has a recurring risk of escalation also, of course -- though objectively a far lower one.

I don't think they were thinking about a long-term proxy war at the time (as they generally thought Ukraine would be simply overrun if not defended). But we can be very sure they were thinking about the categorically more important issue of avoiding response that could trigger a nuclear escalation -- especially in very short term.

racional··on A Bugatti car, a first lady and the fake stories aimed at Americans
Yeah, poor kids.

But you're an adult (per your bio), and are choosing to fall for fascist propaganda.

The only difference is that its colors are red and blue, rather than blue and gold.

racional··on The Soviet Union's Monster Mi-6 Helicopter Airliner
They should go to Putin and sign some ceasefire or peace treaty with him if they don't like it. Why come to me. I am not Putin and I didn't even vote for him.

And yet - when someone corners you on the internet you run to stand behind him, like a big papa.

So in that sense, you very much are "voting" for him.

racional··on The impact of Orwell's "Homage to Catalonia" on Noam Chomsky's path to anarchism
The article describes the allegations of such support -- alongside their debunking.

That's why it has the word "Allegations" in the title.

racional··on The impact of Orwell's "Homage to Catalonia" on Noam Chomsky's path to anarchism
The US began arming and supporting Pol Pot in 1979

This allegation floats up from time to time, but lacks veracity.

Of course Kissinger would have loved for the US to have done so -- but that doesn't mean it actually happened.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allegations_of_United_States_s...

racional··on A Bugatti car, a first lady and the fake stories aimed at Americans
Why would you assume that?

Because in the vast majority of cases, when someone posts some version of "The US/West could have prevented this war if they wanted to" (or "It could have ended with the March 2022 negotiations") that's exactly what they mean (territorial concessions), either tacitly or explicitly.

But of course I'll take your word that this wasn't the sense you were intending.

As to what you're now saying:

For one that doesn't like a diplomatic solution, but an overtly military one.

More importantly, the Budapest Memorandum doesn't establish that the US has any "commitments" to come to the aid of any of the 3 countries (BY, UA, KZ) should they come under attack (and Russia would never have signed it if it did). It merely asks that the signatory powers respect the newly established sovereign status of these countries; to refrain from using force or economic coercion against them; and to not nuke them, please. And that the signing powers will consult each other in situations that pertain to these commitments.

That's why the language was specifically chosen to read "Security Assurances" and not "Guarantees". The latter implies a commitment to some kind of a military response, like NATO's Article 5. But the former does not.

You can still maintain the position that the US/UK should have done something different in 2014 or 2022 -- but the simple fact is, there was no commitment expressed in the Budapest Memorandum which required them to do so. And this is probably the main reason they ultimately did not.

This, and a perfectly reasonable desire not to stumble into a direct and intrinsically risky confrontation with their main nuclear rival. Or a protracted / large-scale conflict of any kind with no clear signal of public support.

racional··on The Soviet Union's Monster Mi-6 Helicopter Airliner
Hey, can you point to some live instances for these fun quotes ("The masters will be back!", "We can show it again!")? Particularly from anyone public and notable? Original Russian is fine; no need to translate.
racional··on A Bugatti car, a first lady and the fake stories aimed at Americans
Are you saying Mariupol is not being rebuild?

The point is you're sharing a link to an obvious propaganda piece, put out by the same folks who destroyed Mariupol in the first place.

Like it's some great revelation that explains everything.

racional··on A Bugatti car, a first lady and the fake stories aimed at Americans
The Ukrainians have actual Nazis.

It has its share of fashy types, but very few "actual Nazis" in fact.

Meanwhile the U.S., Canada, every European country, and Russia of course all have a solid contingent of the exact same kinds of folks -- probably in greater proportion than Ukraine.

And no, that isn’t “propaganda.”

It is a masterpiece of propaganda -- in the sense that the Nazi issue is wildly, ridiculously distorted and overblown as applies to Ukraine. And has precisely zero bearing on why the war came about and what should be done about it.

Yet for some reason, it's literally the very first item on your list when you think of why the U.S. should ditch Ukraine and let Putin have his merry way with it.

racional··on A Bugatti car, a first lady and the fake stories aimed at Americans
It could have been stopped diplomatically

By agreeing to Russia's demands for a "friendly" regime to be installed in Kyiv, and that Russia be allowed to annex whatever regions of Ukraine it set its fancy on.

Would you have been in favor of such a "solution"?

racional··on A Bugatti car, a first lady and the fake stories aimed at Americans
The USSR lost in Afghanistan, to a US armed Taliban.

The Taliban did not emerge until 5 years after the USSR left the country.

If you can't get that right, why should we be interestedin any other analysis of the situation you may have?

See how Mariupol is being rebuilt

See also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Potemkin_village

racional··on Tripping on Xenon Gas (2023)
It doesn't matter what I think.

I'm not the one trying to scare everyone about Azov's "role in Maidan" when in fact it did not exist at the time.

racional··on The Origins of Yiddish (2014)
Paul Wexler's thesis is that the Eastern dialects of Yiddish actually independently descend from early Jewish Slavic languages (e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Knaanic_language), and the Western dialects are derived from the Eastern ones,

"... a hypothesis that has been widely rejected by other Yiddish and Germanic linguists and geneticists", says his WP bio.

racional··on Tripping on Xenon Gas (2023)
The point is that with all of your concern about these momentous events, and all your "research" -- you're clearly hallucinating about the key players involved.

Does this fact not bother you?

racional··on ID verification service for TikTok, Uber, X exposed driver licenses
Citation needed. Otherwise, it's a smear.

Again: 100 percent, you said.

racional··on Julian Assange has reached a plea deal with the U.S., allowing him to go free
US fighter jets flying formations around Lviv in 2016 was a clearly offensive move

Given that Ukraine was already quite openly invaded by Russia in 2014 -- these were, by definition, defensive moves.

← PreviousPage 5 of 19Next →