HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

rafterydj

580 karma · joined December 10, 2020

submissionscomments
rafterydj··on Unpowered SSDs slowly lose data
Interesting statement. I suppose you could argue that long term archival storage is communication with a long tailed, sometimes ill-defined window for receiving the message. Few people write books they don't want anyone to read.
rafterydj··on Steam Machine
Good question
rafterydj··on Steam Machine
I 100% see the Framework Desktop and Steam Machine less as competitors and more as separate flavors of the same form factor: Steam Machine for the lower priced, casual plug-n-play gaming use case, and Framework Desktop for the higher priced, professional use case.

Seeing as the Steam Machine feels like a way to get traction for SteamOS just as much as it is a venture for selling hardware, a partnership between them selling Framework laptops/desktops verified for SteamOS seems like exactly the type of thing Valve would want.

rafterydj··on AOL to be sold to Bending Spoons for $1.5B
Any recommendations on registrars?
rafterydj··on Sora might have a 'pervert' problem on its hands
This seems like you are not fully thinking this through, either intentionally or not. Benefit of the doubt, I will add to your question about why you should care with more questions: what if it's someone you know? what if they want to then sell the generated content? what if it was your political enemies? what if it was your boss? what if it was someone who was stalking you or made you feel unsafe?
rafterydj··on You did no fact checking, and I must scream
Just yesterday, there was a post that made me angry in the same vein: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45609942

Not only was the article slop, but the author kept responding to comments/criticisms with MORE slop. I must scream.

rafterydj··on Show HN: We priced basic needs in work hours (global ranking and CSVs)
What is this? The formatting of this article is horrendous, the writing style follows common AI output (read: slop), often to the point of being nonsensical, and the citations are questionable at best.

For example, they never actually state WHAT their basic needs are - despite it being the crux of their article and referencing a consumer's "basket" 18 times, they never state what goods they are comparing!

They cite bizarre data like linking to a CSV of "their" OECD, then utilize it to rattle off a number of stats that don't correlate with each other. The charts don't look right either.

The website is drowning in banner ads - despite being a .org TLD - and looks so sloppy that a high schooler could make a more coherent and convincing report, despite being written by "(name) Economic & Pricing Investigator | Content Reviewed by CFA (name)".

This is frankly trash, and any valuable insight is impossible to distinguish against the backdrop of sloppy garbage. We should be posting higher quality articles than this.

rafterydj··on Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violations in Las Vegas
This is why I use the phrase "sucking all the oxygen out of the room" where the proverbial oxygen is funding:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_High-Speed_Rail#Hyp...

Musk literally admitted he wanted to block progress on new rail projects, and the Hyperloop was his PR project to do so. Snake oil.

There are many people who want new train infrastructure. Musk is not one of them.

rafterydj··on Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violations in Las Vegas
everybody knew and voiced their knowledge before, during, and after the Vegas tunnel that Boring Co and the Hyperloop were just bad concepts. You didn't need to waste money to try it, because it's not new tech. It's a tunnel. It's a solution to traffic. It's for riders, not drivers. But instead of calling it a train and therefore being _lame_, you slap a fresh coat of paint on it with _self driving cars_ and _insane_ promises you could never deliver on.

Calling out snake oil, for being snake oil, and lamenting that it sucks all the oxygen out of the room for _real_ , _serious_ technology and progress? That's a good thing.

rafterydj··on Qwen3-Omni: Native Omni AI model for text, image and video
I agree the market is niche atm, but I can't help but disagree with your outlook long term. Self hosted models don't have the problems ChatGPT subscribers are facing with models seemingly performing worse over time, they don't need to worry about usage quotas, they don't need to worry about getting locked out of their services, etc.

All of these things have a dark side, though; but it's likely unnecessary for me to elaborate on that.

rafterydj··on The treasury is expanding the Patriot Act to attack Bitcoin self custody
In that case the obvious move from the 5$ wrench perspective is to hit you with it until you tell them where the private key is kept, because you would need to have it somewhere.
rafterydj··on How RSS beat Microsoft
I've had this same idea! Of course, it remains an idea never taken out of the garage. Are you delivering broadsheet, or formatting a printable file for users to print at home?
rafterydj··on Chicago has the most lead pipes in the nation
Could you link a real source instead of ChatGPT, please?
rafterydj··on MIT Study Finds AI Use Reprograms the Brain, Leading to Cognitive Decline
I feel like I'm taking crazy pills or misunderstanding you. Shouldn't it matter that they are using 70mb of RAM more or less totally wastefully? Maybe not a deal breaker for Brave, sure, but waste is waste.

I understand the world is about compromises, but all the gains of essentially every computer program ever could be summed up by accumulation of small optimizations. Likewise, the accumulation of small wastes kills legacy projects more than anything else.

rafterydj··on An LLM is a lossy encyclopedia
"Given a detailed list of symptoms" is sure holding a lot of weight in that statement. There's way too much information that doctors tacitly understand from interactions with patients that you really cannot rely on those patients supplying in a "detailed list". Could it diagnose correctly, some of the time? Sure. But the false positive rate would be huge given LLMs suggestible nature. See the half dozen news stories covering AI induced psychosis for reference.

Regardless, it's diagnostic capability is distinct from the dangers it presents, which is what the parent comment was mentioning.

rafterydj··on What is going on right now?
That sounds horrendously inefficient, no?

Is creating a giant wobbly world of unreliable AIs all talking to each other in effort to get their own tasks accomplished, is that leaving us much better off than humans doing everything themselves?

Better yet, if you have an application that does exactly what you want, why would you (or an AI representing you) want to do anything other than use that application? Sure you could execute this binary and get what you want, OR you could reach to the AI-net and make some other AI do it from scratch every time. With inherently less reliable results.

rafterydj··on A guide to Gen AI / LLM vibecoding for expert programmers
But who _wants_ a program to be alive? To be super clear, I love the tech behind LLMs and other transformers. But when discussing regular, run of the mill software projects that don't require AI capabilities - do you really need to have the understanding of the transcendental nature of LLMs to do that job well?
rafterydj··on Vibe Debugging: Enterprises' Up and Coming Nightmare
Hah! Especially seeing the same articles, and pro/con discussions feels like a form of the preceding lines: _"There's only one subject on HN for Christ's sake. _Tips For Agentic AI Use_,_Gemini CLI_, _Building X with Claude_, they're the same thing!"_
rafterydj··on A guide to Gen AI / LLM vibecoding for expert programmers
Not to be rude, but what about understanding the "transcendental nature" of LLMs allows people to build more, faster, or with better maintainability than a "hardened industry titan"?
rafterydj··on Building AI products in the probabilistic era
That's all well and good to ask as a what if, but in terms of practical applications, the vast majority of the time you want to trade the other way around whenever possible - you want your system to work reliably. That's the cornerstone of any project that wants to be useful for others.
rafterydj··on AI doesn't lighten the burden of mastery
I don't really disagree with you about handwriting CRUD apps. But I'm not sure that having an off-the-shelf solution, from AI output or not, that would spin up CRUD interfaces would _actually_ erase software as an industry.

To me it's similar to saying that there's no need for lawmakers after we get the basics covered. Clearly it's absurd, because humans will always want to expand on (or subtract from) what's already there.

rafterydj··on AI doesn't lighten the burden of mastery
Thanks for adding the link!
rafterydj··on AI doesn't lighten the burden of mastery
I mean that's basically all high level programming languages are, right?

I would argue that as an industry we love high level programming languages, because they allow you to understand what you are writing, much easier than looking at assembly code. Excellent for the vast majority of needs.

But then people go right on and build complicated frameworks and libraries with those languages, and very quickly the complexity (albeit presented much better for reading) comes back into a project.

rafterydj··on AI doesn't lighten the burden of mastery
Interesting. Would you mind elaborating a bit on your workflow? In my work I go back and forth between the "stock" GUIs, and copy-pasting into a separated terminal for model prompts. I hate the vibe code-y agent menu in things like Cursor, I'm always afraid integrated models will make changes that I miss because it really only works with checking "allow all changes" fairly quickly.
rafterydj··on AI doesn't lighten the burden of mastery
Counterpoint: a cabinet has always been a cabinet and nobody expects it to be anything but a cabinet. Rarely are software projects as repeatable and alike to each other as cabinets are.

Software is codified rules and complexity, which is entirely aribtrary, and builds off of itself in an infinite number of ways. That makes it much more difficult to turn into factory output cabinetry.

I think more people should read "No Silver Bullet" because I hear this argument a lot and I'm not sure it holds. There _are_ niches in software that are artisanal craft, that have been majorly replaced (like custom website designers and stock WordPress templates), but the vast majority of the industry relies on cases where turning software into templates isn't possible, or isn't as efficient, or conflicts with business logic.

rafterydj··on Mastercard deflects blame for NSFW games being taken down
Hard disagree on every point. Just because implementations aren't always perfect does not mean you should not have public services.

I know a librarian who spends an inordinate amount of time helping the elderly and tech illiterate members of the public with creating emails, because they're necessary. However, you can't create emails anywhere without a phone number these days - a post office option would fix that.

Email already gets enormous amounts of spam, and the only reason most don't see it is because private service providers like Google expend resources filtering them out. Why would a business not be able to charge for premium filter services on an email they don't host? Not to mention that private email services send you ads.

To be clear, I'm not saying we should shut down Gmail tomorrow, but having a free public email service option would allow many people to use internet infrastructure they don't have. It's an accessibility problem that should be addressed in the public's interest as well as shareholders.

rafterydj··on U.S. bombs Iranian nuclear sites
"flippantly tossing words around devalues them and debases the conversation." Agreed- and that's exactly what you are doing with the word, "no."

Soldiers are murdering an entire population- or as many of them as they can, seemingly- for political purposes that desire that population to simply not exist anymore. To say that is _not_ a genocide devalues the meaning of the word.

rafterydj··on The Illusion of Thinking: Strengths and limitations of reasoning models [pdf]
well that's not a very convincing argument. That's just a failure to recognize when the use of a tool- base64 decoder- is needed, not a reasoning problem at all, right?
rafterydj··on Ask HN: What is the best LLM for consumer grade hardware?
I understand that the core similarities are there, but I disagree. The comparisons have been around since I started browsing HN years ago. The moderation on this site, for one, emphasizes constructive conversation and discussion in a way that most subreddits can only dream of.

It also helps that the target audience has been filtered with that moderation, so over time this site (on average) skews more technical and informed.

rafterydj··on Interviewing a software engineer who prepared with AI
Firstly, what we call a suit is a highly varied outfit of clothes that are designed to look good on a male silhouette. Deriving from that, yes, the suit is aesthetically better- to disagree is to discount both the entire field of custom tailoring and also the rest of wider society surrounding tech.

Most people off the street would agree that a suit is more dignified, and it's not without reason. Wearing a suit indicates a level of discipline, effort, and intention about the way that you look that simply wearing a t shirt with jeans does not.

To contrast, the historical reason for the t shirt / jeans combo is practicality and convenience; tech as an industry got away with it at first, because techies were not interfacing with clients directly or simply because they're working class.

You can argue about the elitism and class differences surrounding suits versus t shirts and jeans, but I think it's a bit ridiculous to say that suits aren't aesthetically better just because of the media image for hacker types.

← PreviousPage 5 of 6Next →