HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

raiflip

254 karma · joined August 11, 2017

submissionscomments
raiflip··on The Blockchain Is Bigger Than Any Bubble
"Nope! Starting from a position of only having BTC (because you've already got rid of the USD you had, and you immediately convert any USD you receive into BTC), what is the advantage of buying USD to spend instead of spending your BTC directly?"

Based on a false premise. Under no scenario will people only have BTC. With regards to what people will be paid in, insofar as people are planning to spend money, they'll want it paid in USD.

raiflip··on The Blockchain Is Bigger Than Any Bubble
Yep that is exactly my point. Hence USD would stay in circulation and bitcoin would not.
raiflip··on The Blockchain Is Bigger Than Any Bubble
"Like I said, you can't eat bits of currency. I would spend the deflationary currency but I would be more hesitant to spend it. I would buy stuff that I really want or need. People aren't going to starve to death or go homeless because they want to hold on to their deflationary currency. That's not reality."

Yes but if you had the choice between spending a deflationary currency or inflationary, which would you spend? Unless you want to outlaw USD in general, because USD is decreasing in value you have an incentive to spend it.

"You are seeing the situation for what it is now, not for what it will be in the future. Crypto is gaining more acceptance world wide. Yes, currently people prefer to be paid with USD or similar but in the future it could be possible that people prefer crypto. Also there are lots of businesses and services that directly or indirectly accept crypto. I disagree with your last sentence. Like all things, bitcoin started as an experiment but it will go on to change the world similar to how the internet changed the world. Entire industries will be disrupted as a result. I have been in crypto since 2011 and to even be having this discussion today already shows me that the experiment has been a monumental success. In 2011, I would have never even imagined that bitcoin would reach 10k per coin."

I want to engage with you but I don't see an argument here. You are only asserting that "this is the way things are, but they will change!" without saying why.

raiflip··on The Blockchain Is Bigger Than Any Bubble
Deflation means the value of the currency is increasing. It does not mean the amount of units of that currency is increasing.
raiflip··on The Blockchain Is Bigger Than Any Bubble
They are not socialist in nature. Socialism is a system in which workers own the means of production instead of capital holders. I mean this in the friendliest way possible, you are not using the word socialism correctly.

If you have a currency that is increasing in value, and one decreasing, which do you choose to spend? You would not "use" deflationary currency, only hold onto it.

Yes the economy will restructure. People will spend USD and keep Bitcoin in their pocket. People will want to be paid in USD because they can use it to buy stuff. Bitcoin is and will stay relegated to an interesting experiment people invest in, and only use if they need its anonymity.

raiflip··on The Blockchain Is Bigger Than Any Bubble
That's a good point, but for the case of illegal online activity bitcoin currently has a kind of anonymity guarantee that no other system does, and is as such an apples to oranges comparison. If the USD had the same anonymity guarantee you'd see those people making the same choice everyone else is: hold onto bitcoin and spend USD.
raiflip··on The Blockchain Is Bigger Than Any Bubble
See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gresham%27s_law. If given the choice between holding bitcoin and USD people will hold bitcoin, but they will still want to buy stuff. People then have an incentive to use USD to buy stuff, and since USD is used to buy stuff they will want to have USD on hand to buy stuff when they want to. Hence Gresham's Law.
raiflip··on The Blockchain Is Bigger Than Any Bubble
What you are describing is an ancient economic law known as Gresham's law: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gresham%27s_law . It states that bad money drives out good because people hold onto good and spend bad. Bad is really normative saying more valuable is good and less is bad. So deflationary (up in value is good) and inflationary is bad (down in value).

Frankly your argument is incoherent. If something is bad for the economy its bad for individuals. If the economy goes down most people starve.

You also seem to argue that people hold onto more of a currency than another that currency "wins" but the currency that "wins" is the one in circulation. If by "win" we mean the currency that survives, then the one that survives is the one in circulation. Again this is all eco 101.

raiflip··on The Blockchain Is Bigger Than Any Bubble
Is it obvious? That is the kind of arrogance people accuse tech people of having.

The whole point is we DON'T want people to just hold onto a currency. If everyone stops spending their USD and just saves them, the economy will collapse. Think about all the businesses that will go under because no one is buying anything. I could go on but really this is economics 101.

raiflip··on The Blockchain Is Bigger Than Any Bubble
The reason Bitcoin will never be a replacement for a Central Bank based currency like the USD is the fact that it is in permanent deflation.
raiflip··on What's worked in Computer Science (2015)
Cool, thanks! Checking it out.
raiflip··on What's worked in Computer Science (2015)
As much as FP has made my life easier, have to disagree with you on OO. Any language/paradigm is capable of producing bad code. In my first job a high up manager brought in Clojure to a department filled with Java and OO acolytes. While the language was amazing, the Clojure code base was filled with gigantic let statements simulating imperative code, functional spaghetti, and given the lack of a good IDE difficult to debug (had to throw exceptions just to see variable values... shudders). The point is not that FP is bad, just that any tool in unskilled hands can produce bad code.

Not sure what it is like for the industry at large, but from what I've seen a dominant paradigm in Java is to separate out model classes that are basically just structs with Service or Workflow classes that manipulate the data. It's questionable how much of that is still OO (at least when I started learning it the narrative was to put your code where your data is. POJOs are the opposite of that). Given say having a high level service that calls low level services and external system while returning a result produces code thats very easy to trace and provides solid abstraction to the calling code. Also if you've read Uncle Bob's data structure vs. Object dichotomy you'll see how Objects are objectively better in some scenarios, and OO languages give you powerful tools for objects.

That said 100% agree with you on horrible inheritance hierarchies. What I think would be best is some course on how to combine OO and FP paradigms to get the best of both worlds (though tbh it'd probably be 90% FP with some OO).

raiflip··on What's worked in Computer Science (2015)
I'm confused as to why he doesn't put functional programming as a yes. He writes "Functional languages are still quite niche, but functional programming ideas are now mainstream, at least for the HN/reddit/twitter crowd."

While purely Functional languages are definitely not mainstream, as he puts functional programming ideas are pretty mainstream. At the same time major OO languages like java have incorporated functional programming ideas, so arguably even Java is not purely Object Oriented anymore. It seems to me by his criteria that would also put OO as a no too.

If he comes from OO languages I think this is a bias because it is easy to take OO for granted and put strict requirements on foreign Functional Programming before accepting it as successful. However it seems to me the only criteria that should be needed to call either paradigm successful is if their ideas are are mainstream, which is true for both languages.

Basically if Function Programming ideas have gained currency then it should be regarded as successful.

raiflip··on Bitcoin Mining Now Consuming More Electricity Than Many Countries
I think he pins it to future price instead of current price because of the time lag between the decision to mine for bitcoin and the time you actually get the coin. If you think bitcoin is going to crash by the time you start making a profit then even if it is worth a lot now you're not going to mine.
raiflip··on Effective Programs: 10 Years of Clojure
I think the mistake he's making is in that while his hierarchy is correct in that one bug from a category further up is far worse than any bug in a category below it, if you have many more bugs from lower categories they can start to become problems on the scale of a few bugs higher up the chain. Constantly dealing with typos is a great example because one or two would not be a big deal, but they can add up to significant mental effort and time loss.
raiflip··on Effective Programs: 10 Years of Clojure
Honestly I've never understood this argument that choosing types is too complicated. Most often I've seen it come from people without much experience in statically typed languages and imagine that having to determine the type will be difficult.

After becoming familiar with the code base or library, particularly with modern IDE's it's rarely taken more than 10 seconds to choose a type. When reading another person's code, it does take some time to map out the relationship between the classes, but unless your code is in one giant file/function/object you're going to have to figure that out anyway.

raiflip··on Satoshi was wrong
That article is pretty bad. Even at this point in the article it is clear he does not understand why a small amount of inflation is good. For example he says:

"According to popular thinking, in response to a high rate of inflation, consumers will speed up their expenditure on goods at present, which should boost economic growth.

So why then is a rate of inflation of 10% or higher regarded by experts as a bad thing?"

According to this line of thinking if a little bit of something is good, then more of it should be good, right? I think we can all see the faultiness in this logic. What he doesn't get is after inflation reaches a certain point, people start expecting their money to be not worth as much in the very short term, leading to increase in buying, leading to higher inflation, and so on. This spiral is how economies like Zimbabwe end up with crazy inflation. However at a low rate, around 2% and a little higher, people do not immediately expect their money to be worth less in the short term, and therefore the economy does not enter this spiral.

The rest of the article goes into some decently complex economics. Suffice to say his core argument - that inflation hurts wealth creators because it decreases the value of said wealth- does not hold water unless said wealth creators are putting all their money in places with interest rates less than inflation. This means no investment in their or a business, but just parking the money in a bank. Anybody with that kind of money will know to put large amounts of money in inflation-protecting assets. Because risk of an investment is generally the amount of interest you get above and beyond inflation, parking money in assets growing at the rate of inflation is generally very safe.

raiflip··on Wall Street Banks Warn Downturn Is Coming
"Innovation in a specific area slows or stops all the time" Yes, but the general pace of innovation in the entire economy including areas that are slowing down or starting up is pretty consistent. One thing I'd like to make clear is I'm not just talking about 1950-2010 growth rate, I'm talking Industrial Revolution (around 1800 depending on where you are) to now. Ever since society realized we could build machines fueled by energy to increase productivity we've been growing at roughly a 2% pace. Even if it isn't immediately clear where the new productivity gains will come from (although I'd argue there are plenty of promising areas) I think it's more likely than not going to continue.

some possible areas - AI, 3d printing, falling renewable energy prices, continued marginal gains from computers, quantum network communication, longer term - quantum computers, expansion of VR, driverless cars, etc. Point being there are a lot of promising areas on the horizon.

raiflip··on Wall Street Banks Warn Downturn Is Coming
Problem is interest rates are still very close to the 0 bounds. Even a few years ago interest rates could simply not go any/much lower. Since we had the same problem when interest rates could not go any lower, I don't think its interest rates themselves thats the problem. Instead the problem is a global excess of savings vs. demand resulting in a situation where interest rates decrease and there's more money then there are things to invest in.
raiflip··on Wall Street Banks Warn Downturn Is Coming
If there was ever a point where our current run of innovation starting with the Industrial Revolution were to slow down or stop, then you are correct. However arguing that it's not proven to be sustainable because the fact that it hasn't collapsed in ~80 years only proves that its sustainable for 80 years is makes proving it sustainable impossible. Absent a better theory with better predictions Keynesianism is still the most successful economic theory. Moreover the scenario where innovation stops or slows down is a fairly unlikely scenario and if we're going to have a public policy debate I don't think it's wise to count on it.
raiflip··on Wall Street Banks Warn Downturn Is Coming
The business cycle may look perfectly cyclic to the point where it appears predictable, but a closer look at the data shows that it is not. Exhibit 7 is not a great way to show the data because the compressed x axis gives the optical illusion that the cycles occur within the same amount of time and that each cycle's shape is roughly the same. For example, the two right after 1980 look similar, but their shape does not match any other cycle (particularly the 2008 recession).

Likewise the three around 1960 to before 1980 all look different. The expansion after 1960 is unusually long and even though it dips at one point before 1970 does not go negative until after.

With that classification we already have 4 categories of recessions (3 between 1960 and 1980, and one for two recessions after 1980). The reason is prior to the 1980s recessions were generally driven by political events or changes in government policy exogenous to the private sector. According to this link: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_recessions_in_the_Unit... the 1961 is because of FR interest rate move, 1969- government tightens budget and interest rates go up 1973- Stagflation starting with OPEC tightening oil supply

You'll notice all of those are caused by events outside the control of the private sector or in other words the cause of someone's deliberate policy rather than an event of the system. Economic policy cannot predict these nor should it try to predict human behavior. Which brings up the point again that they are not predictable because I don't think anyone would say they can predict the behavior of an individual or a conglomerate like OPEC with great certainty.

That said post 1980 many of the recessions are caused by financial crisis that are endogenous to the private sector, so that is worth looking at. But the claim that the business cycle from 1945 to 2009 is predictable does not hold up.

← PreviousPage 4 of 4