HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

rank0

1,554 karma · joined February 12, 2015

submissionscomments
rank0··on American workers are demanding almost $80k a year to take a new job
Wages are just the price of labor. Our currency is worth less, so employees are demanding more in dollar terms for their labor.

I feel like people misunderstand/misrepresent what the fed officials say about the relationship between wages and inflation. The Fed doesn’t want to create unemployment or directly reduce wages. The ideal scenario is to curb inflation while keeping unemployment as low as possible (which is at a record low atm).

Raising rates restricts the supply of credit, which makes servicing debt more difficult and usually results in layoffs. It’s not like the Fed is conspiring to keep the working class poor from a smokey back room…which I feel has become the narrative being pushed by media outlets nowadays.

rank0··on Moderna CEO made $400M last year–2,435x the median salary of employees
You’re missing the point. No corporations means no goods/services.

Share with me your fairytale about how we’ll all have apples/cars/whatever without free enterprise.

People like you would rather see the world burn than see the presence of the elite, who will always exist.

rank0··on Moderna CEO made $400M last year–2,435x the median salary of employees
Starting a company is not inherent good, but rather a prerequisite for a prosperous economy.

Who do you think maintains supply chains? Who is gonna sell food, energy, and build infrastructure? Entrepreneurship and capitalism for all its ugly tendencies has lifted more people out of poverty than any other system.

Where does this ideology come from that says people will produce goods/services for free? Nobody is going to build homes or drill for oil without a financial inventive.

rank0··on Moderna CEO made $400M last year–2,435x the median salary of employees
He already paid taxes on the compensation! He sold stock that had previously vested and taxes are calculated at the time of vestment.

What's so special about the Moderna employees? They already make much more than the median American income. You're redistributing wealth from the ultra rich to the rich. Even if the USGOV took 100% of that $400M, that'd be a whopping dollar per American.

History is littered with failed "utopian" communist/socialist states. The ultra rich will always be able to avoid taxes legally or illegally. They're not gonna report income that gets taxed at 90%. The math doesn't work out. If we magically take 400M additional taxes from 1000 individuals annually that wouldn't even cover our federal debt obligations.

EDIT:

It's telling that you need to resort to quips about goal posts. I suggest you take a moment to read about history and macroeconomics...your brain must be tired from all these mental gymnastics.

rank0··on Moderna CEO made $400M last year–2,435x the median salary of employees
Did you even read TFA? The 400M came from planned stock sales. How are you gonna distribute that money if not by taking his ownership?

And your suggestion that anything remotely similar happened to the Reagan era corporations is plainly false.

rank0··on Moderna CEO made $400M last year–2,435x the median salary of employees
Very convenient of you to entirely sidestep discussion of the original point: “80% income tax bracket at >$100M”

It’s ridiculous that so many users of this startup accelerator forum want to ban private ownership. I guess I’ll bite…

Why would anyone start/own a company if the government is just gonna liquidate your legal ownership? It would be more lucrative to find the easiest job and do the bare minimum than be CEO under your half baked authoritarian system.

But why is this even a response in the first place to OP? Stick to the topic or else you come off like a religious zealot.

rank0··on Moderna CEO made $400M last year–2,435x the median salary of employees
How much revenue do you expect from such a tax bracket? You should do some napkin math to see if it’ll actually make a difference.

I suspect very few people report income in excess of $100M and an 80% bracket would do very little for society other than a vindictive gesture to placate the masses.

Not saying we should or shouldn’t…but it’s not gonna fix all our problems like people think.

rank0··on Job Corps: free, residential training and education for low-income young adults
Living standards have never been higher in the history of mankind. Go read some history!

I’m not even sure what you’re advocating for, but blind anger at the world is senseless. You want to replace our current society with a new one? That could mean bloody, violent revolution.

What do you even want? What does the world owe you?

rank0··on Job Corps: free, residential training and education for low-income young adults
Take a look in the mirror dude. I called you naive and this was your response:

“this is the only time of the day you actually feel like your existence means anything”

You are gripped by ideology. Don’t train yourself to think everyone is evil and you know best. It isn’t true.

rank0··on Job Corps: free, residential training and education for low-income young adults
This is a hilariously naive take.

“My value system would create a utopia and everyone is evil because the world doesn’t subscribe to my nebulous beliefs”

Real unique idea!

rank0··on The OpenTF Manifesto
Any reason why you don’t like cloudFormation or the SDKs?
rank0··on The OpenTF Manifesto
I actually love the weaponization of OSS. It eats away at the technical gap between proprietary systems and their FOSS equivalents. See elasticsearch + openAI (although open models are still quite far behind)
rank0··on Children of alumni no longer have admissions edge at Carnegie Mellon, Pitt
The OECD definition says this:

"Information is also presented for gross household disposable income including social transfers in kind, such as health or education provided for free or at reduced prices by governments and not-for-profit organisations."

See: https://data.oecd.org/hha/household-disposable-income.htm

rank0··on Children of alumni no longer have admissions edge at Carnegie Mellon, Pitt
> return to a much higher upper marginal tax rate (there's no evidence that the reductions which started with Reagan have benefitted most Americans in any way). > reduce military spending (American's socialism) by at least 50%.

This is not even a remotely serious proposal. There is no scenario where both parties agree to cut the military budget in HALF! Have you looked at the actual budget numbers? We're going to have a 2023 budget deficit of $1.5T. Even if we could, in the midst of the the Ukrainian invasion and rising tension over Taiwain, cut military spending by 50%, that's only a ~$400B reduction of our annual deficit. Do you seriously expect to extract an additional >$1T from income tax in the top bracket? Basic napkin math should tell you this isn't possible.

Also lol at "America's socialism". How do you explain the fact that SS,medicare,medicaid absolutely dwarf military spending?

> take the money from these two actions and use it on infrastructure and social support.

Complete non-statement. What specifically are we going to do with you imaginary tax revenue?

> ...Wealth redistribution schemes consist of taking money in taxes from people with more money and (in some way) giving it to or spending it on people with less.

I don't know how to help you understand this. I suggest reading this - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pensions_in_France. Here's some quotes:

"This minimum pension (Allocation de Solidarité aux Personnes Agées in French) is the first level of the first pillar of the French pension system. The ASPA is a monthly benefit paid to low-income seniors, whether or not they are former employees. It is not a retirement pension: it is financed by the State, not by social contributions."

"The mandatory state pension is an unfunded contributory pension based on the redistribution of contributions from those working to those in retirement."

"The mandatory occupational pension is a defined contribution scheme that is mainly based on redistribution"

The French pension system is a direct transfer of wealth from workers/citizens to beneficiaries. The US equivalent is social security.

> In terms of income (even adjusted for PPP), sure. But as I tried to explain, that's a silly way to measure wealth, at least if it is the only way you use. As an American, I am forced to spend more of that increased wealth on things that would be free-at-point-of-service or just cheaper in Europe.

Your understanding is incorrect and the cost of living (including government subsidies to healthcare) is included in the OECD statistics:

"This indicator [Household Disposable Income] also takes account of social transfers in kind 'such as health or education provided for free or at reduced prices by governments and not-for-profit organisations.'"

---

I do not believe you are arguing in good faith. Your argument basically boils down to "Ignore all the economic data because it doesn't tell the whole story". If you reject the OECD data, corporate financial reports, and national statistics, the least you can do is offer some other data to compare.

Go play with this neat little tool - https://data.oecd.org/hha/household-disposable-income.htm

The US beats the EU on almost every indicator including household income, net worth, debt, and savings.

rank0··on Children of alumni no longer have admissions edge at Carnegie Mellon, Pitt
I meant literally legal. My point being this practice is legal so universities may accept whoever they want.
rank0··on Children of alumni no longer have admissions edge at Carnegie Mellon, Pitt
My argument is that the university is free to conduct admissions as it sees fit within the bounds of the law.

A preference for family members of alums is totally legal. Are you suggesting that the federal government should dictate admission procedures?

rank0··on Children of alumni no longer have admissions edge at Carnegie Mellon, Pitt
That's a typo its supposed to be "Unsheltered Homeless".

I don't think you're understanding the broader point. Look at the economic data. The PPP median household income and PPP net wealth is much higher in the US. Yes, the income/wealth distribution curve is skewed to the right here...

But the majority of Americans are wealthier than the majority of Europeans! A random sample of both populations would yield wealthier individuals on the US side.

Equal distribution by itself is a silly goal. The goal should be increase the net income/wealth as much as possible for as many people as possible.

> I certainly don't think that the economic system in the USA is better than those found in the EU, even though there are some metrics where you might make that case. But mostly what the USA has a lot of that the EU has much less of is economic churn - businesses constantly starting and almost all of them failing, followed by more businesses starting etc. This gives the impression of very prosperous, active economy, but I would question whether we really do much better out of this model than the EU does with their much less entrepeneurial systems.

This is an insane take. The technological innovation that comes out of the US blows Europe out of the water. Where is all the European competition? Just look at the financial statements of the largest EU and US corporations. The data is plain as day!

> The people who earn the most in our system are not the people who do difficult or unpleasant work, and it just seems preposterous to me to suggest that there is a link here.

You're wrong. Any meaningful tax revenue for wealth distribution would have to come from people in the upper quintiles. These are lawyers, doctors, engineers, oil rig workers, underwater welders, etc.

You still haven't suggested any actual policy change. I'm guessing you have a nebulous idea of "take it from the billionaires". There is no way in hell we can create a wealth tax that generates a $1T+ in annual tax revenue. There aren't enough billionaires to sustain such a tax and they absolutely have the means to legally evade taxes or jet off to anywhere in the world. Also, we already have the estate tax!

> This is not an example of what I think you're claiming it is an example of. Defaulting on pension obligations is about a failure to honor past labor contracts, not income/wealth redistribution.

Dude. Its literally a government run wealth distribution scheme. It's the basis for most citizen's retirement. The government isn't paying out what they had promised.

> Same way we can afford a war whenever "we decide" to fight one. Same way we can "choose" to spend more than the next 10 top military spenders combined. We are a rich country, and we could choose to place substantially more emphasis on the quality of life of all our people. But we "choose" to do otherwise.

We cannot afford infinite wars. Our military spending is dwarfed by our spending on social programs. Go read the federal budget for fucks sake. The majority of our budget is social security, medicare/medicaid.

Go read history and international news. How can you hear about the current events in Europe and claim that economic conditions are good? The region is unstable and full of young governments. The region cannot create its own energy, which kneecaps its own heavily industrial economy. The region is entirely dependent on the US/China and is just now decoupling from Russia. Macron is ranting about the lack of European Sovereignty. Inflation is much worse in the EU. The continent will definitely stabilize, and its not the end of Europe...but they've sustained significant economic damage.

I don't give a fuck about nationality. I don't think America or Americans are superior. Europe is our most powerful ally and I wish prosperity for the entire region. I just hate this constant populist rhetoric that the US needs to adopt undefined mythical tax/spending systems to achieve some fantasy utopia.

Please name the policy changes required to solve poverty in America. You'll be a hero.

rank0··on Children of alumni no longer have admissions edge at Carnegie Mellon, Pitt
I don’t know much about Denmark but it sounds like a great place!

I’d be concerned that policy in Denmark wouldn’t work in the US due to the enormous differences in size, culture, geography, etc.

That’s why I think it really only makes sense to compare G20 countries or entire regions like US:EU

rank0··on Children of alumni no longer have admissions edge at Carnegie Mellon, Pitt
Glad we could find common ground! I’m not claiming that life in America is inherently better…just pointing out that things are pretty fucking good all considered.

I’m not in favor of a wealth tax though I frankly still don’t see any evidence that it improves society. Our edge as a nation comes from our insane technological and economic output. Squeezing the private sector too hard can drive away that innovation.

At some point in the future our economic machine eventually falters and we’ll loose reserve currency status. That’ll mean a massive drop in US living standards across the board…so I hope it happens way after we’re dead.

rank0··on Children of alumni no longer have admissions edge at Carnegie Mellon, Pitt
There’s a lot of great things about the French economy. There’s also plenty of areas where they lag behind the US.

The French labor force participation rate is ~74% compared to ~62% in America.

The French homeless rate is 3x the US rate.

France just defaulted on its national pension obligations a few months ago.

What policy exactly should we copy from France? If we’re still arguing about wealth redistribution policies I want a clearly articulated example of a superior system. I don’t see where it is in France but please lmk if I’m missing something.

rank0··on Children of alumni no longer have admissions edge at Carnegie Mellon, Pitt
Me too! Unfortunately the only way to do that at tech is to aggressively expand student body size.

> I much preferred the persona of giving everyone a chance and weeding out people out so that they could give kids without stellar resumes a chance.

FWIW, idk when you got out but I graduated in 2018 and the professor’s love for low GPAs was still around in full force.

rank0··on Children of alumni no longer have admissions edge at Carnegie Mellon, Pitt
Yes I agree with that! It makes no sense to compare Beverly Hills to the state of Oklahoma.
rank0··on Children of alumni no longer have admissions edge at Carnegie Mellon, Pitt
I appreciate the response!

> By contrast, social democratic societies in Europe have lower median (PPP) income, but higher income redistribution means that far fewer people face such struggles.

The idea that EU citizens do not face poverty is simply false. The EU sheltered homelessness rate is very close to the US, both under 0.2% which is phenomenal honestly…

Poverty rate statistics are quite tricky to decipher. But all the data I can find says that there isn’t an outsized difference between the regions. Rates in US states vary as much as EU member countries with plenty of states from both regions exceeding or below US/EU averages.

I’m not trying to be a blind patriot stereotype or even claim that the US is “better” than other portions of the world.

My only point is that objectively speaking, living standards in America are PHENOMENAL. We should not “redistribute wealth like other western nations” because I can’t think of any G20 nations that have a clearly preferable economic system.

Also to your point about Rawls, if you go too far with redistribution you remove the incentive for people to do difficult or unpleasant work. We’ve witnessed this countless times over the past century in all the failed socialist/communist societies. In a less extreme example we just witnessed France default on its pension obligations!

Nobody is going to work for free. The US spends more money than any other nation on social welfare programs. It’s inefficient and unsustainable. How can we honestly consider expanding wealth distribution programs when we can’t even afford what we have now?

If you can think of a particular nation’s system we should emulate I’d love to hear the argument with an open mind. I honest to god cannot think of any.

rank0··on Children of alumni no longer have admissions edge at Carnegie Mellon, Pitt
Lol. The US is hundreds of times larger than those countries. It does t even have to be about the US…

Do you really think it’s reasonable to compare Luxembourg with its 600k population to a country like Germany which has 84M citizens?

rank0··on Children of alumni no longer have admissions edge at Carnegie Mellon, Pitt
Median (not average) PPP income is highest in the US. See: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Median_income

While it’s true our income inequality is larger, the fact still remains that the median American makes more money than the median European (or any other comparable region).

Ask yourself: Is it better for everyone to be richer and have high inequality? Or is it better for everyone to be poorer but more equal?

EDIT: Switzerland is a good point. They are a prosperous and highly educated society! It’s just tough to compare in my mind because the US or EU is hundreds of times larger.

rank0··on Children of alumni no longer have admissions edge at Carnegie Mellon, Pitt
I concede that maybe it’s not the way “things ought to be”

But what’s your legal argument for why this practice should be prohibited?

rank0··on Children of alumni no longer have admissions edge at Carnegie Mellon, Pitt
There’s not a scarcity of education. Anyone is free to attend community college with guaranteed transfer to a larger state university provided they meet their GPA requirements.

EDIT: I do agree with you about employers overvaluing credentials though. Ultimately that’s not something you can unilaterally remove in a free society.

rank0··on Children of alumni no longer have admissions edge at Carnegie Mellon, Pitt
The people receiving athletic scholarships to elite universities have accomplished something amazing. It requires extreme dedication, teamwork, sacrifice, and an understanding of competition/iterative improvement.

Applicants who are equally successful in other pursuits also get credit as they should. An elite artist/musician, community leader, or committed activists are valuable to society and universities should be free to encourage extracurricular excellence in their student body. They are also free to not hold those values and admit purely on test scores + gpa if they like.

rank0··on Children of alumni no longer have admissions edge at Carnegie Mellon, Pitt
I have a hard time defining my own stance on this point.

For example, my alma mater GAtech allows for automatic admissions of my immediate relatives provided they reach some bar like 3.5 gpa + 1400 SAT (math+reading).

Do you think this should be illegal? It’s quite clearly an attempt to create an enduring GT community. It’s also clearly not the same as racially discriminatory admissions.

I do see the argument that it’s unfair…but should it be full blown illegal? “Non-legacy” isn’t a protected class in America unlike race,sex,religion, etc.

rank0··on Children of alumni no longer have admissions edge at Carnegie Mellon, Pitt
Is your argument that we should not have elite universities in the US? Seriously?
← PreviousPage 4 of 22Next →