HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

rbarooah

1,972 karma · joined May 31, 2008

submissionscomments
rbarooah··on Sergey Brin's Clarification On Guardian article
I'm glad he wasn't attacking Facebook and Apple in the way it was portrayed.

I think a key issue here is that powerful incumbent corporations have always challenged the economic freedoms of smaller players and individuals operating in their space.

In the heyday that Brin refers to, those powerful corporations hadn't yet emerged. Now they have. The biggest challenge to starting a new eBay today is eBay. The biggest challenge to starting a new Google today is Google.

Going forward, what matters is the extent that a platform economically empowers its participants to create additional value. Ideological openness is just one dimension in that.

Facebook, Apple, and Google all do empower their participants in different ways and with different tradeoffs, as do startups like Square and Kickstarter.

rbarooah··on Julian Assange Starts Talk Show On Russian TV
One reason for the downvotes may be that you basically just called him names, rather than making a reasoned point.
rbarooah··on IPhone Will Fail in a Late, Defensive Move (2007)
I wasn't aware that the palm brought any touch features that weren't in the Newton.
rbarooah··on IKamasutra: Apple Hates Brunettes
I do now understand what you mean as far as a legal precedent is concerned, but if a ruling were based on the idea that Apple had a monopoly then by definition it wouldn't apply to anyone else.

[edit: removed point about Apple not having a monopoly]

rbarooah··on IKamasutra: Apple Hates Brunettes
The legal damage would be the fact that each design decision they made around the store would be under court scrutiny.

But so far, you haven't explained why this should be done given that Android offers what you ask for. What's wrong with letting people decide for themselves?

rbarooah··on IKamasutra: Apple Hates Brunettes
It sounds like you are saying that you want Apple to be forced to do what Google has already done. Doesn't this mean the the precedent has already been set but Google?

That leads back to the original question: Why is it so important for Apple to be forced to operate like Android when people are free to just buy an Android phone if they want that kind of environment?

What's wrong with Android in your opinion?

rbarooah··on IKamasutra: Apple Hates Brunettes
I'm not sure I see how a successful suit against Apple would have any such effect.

Google would simply say "we're open already", and become the dominant platform while Apple was reeling from the legal damage.

rbarooah··on IKamasutra: Apple Hates Brunettes
Are you agreeing that Android isn't open either?

If so, how would suing Apple (successfully) have any effect other than to cede the market to Google?

rbarooah··on IKamasutra: Apple Hates Brunettes
That wasn't advocacy.

I really wanted to know why the original commenter was talking about suing Apple, instead of just buying an Android phone.

rbarooah··on IKamasutra: Apple Hates Brunettes
I don't think I've ever advocated Android, but I am interested in why it doesn't live up to the promise of being open.

When I see comments like the parent's the logic seems to be: "Android isn't properly open, so let's sue Apple."

rbarooah··on IKamasutra: Apple Hates Brunettes
Why not just buy an android phone?
rbarooah··on IKamasutra: Apple Hates Brunettes
The fact that this happened on both the App store, and Google Play almost simultaneously raises the suspicion that one of the less reputable competitors lodged some kind of complaint.
rbarooah··on Sergey Brin: Facebook and Apple a threat to Internet freedom
I didn't say anything about removing Google. That's a bit of a strawman.

We're not talking about marginal websites that, by your reasoning are dependent on Google for survival.

We're talking about businesses that have accumulated large amounts of valuable data such as FaceBook. The value of being searchable through Google is clearly not enough to persuade them to provide access to their data.

Integration is worth more to Google than it is to Facebook. When this situation arises in business, often the one who values the resource more makes a deal that involves paying money to the one who has the resource they want.

rbarooah··on Sergey Brin: Facebook and Apple a threat to Internet freedom
I suggest they acknowledge that business realities are driving them to do the same thing but that it would be better for everyone if they could find a way to cooperate.

Painting themselves as somehow superior while they engage in the same behavior doesn't seem likely to engender trust.

rbarooah··on Sergey Brin: Facebook and Apple a threat to Internet freedom
Now that they've shown everyone how valuable data is, probably the only thing they can do is to start to pay for it and take a hit to profitability.
rbarooah··on Sergey Brin: Facebook and Apple a threat to Internet freedom
It's only 'under lock and key' if you are Google.

For Google it is very much about selling ads. That's their business.

The data is obviously worth a lot of money to Google, and yet they want it to be given to them for free.

That seems like an unrealistic expectation now that the market understands how valuable data is.

rbarooah··on Sergey Brin: Facebook and Apple a threat to Internet freedom
That doesn't make it any less hypocritical when they attacking others for doing it.

If they think it's a problem they should stop doing it themselves.

rbarooah··on Sergey Brin: Facebook and Apple a threat to Internet freedom
I don't need data to back up a commonly held observation - people are influenced by those who they have to answer to. Are you really disputing that?

As for the idea that they can and will act as they want - that's obviously not true. For example, what if they decided to sue the other Android licensees as they threatened to do before the acquisition?

Do you think the person who decided to do that would have a great future once the acquisition was completed?

rbarooah··on Google’s Sergey Brin: China, SOPA, Facebook Threaten the ‘Open Web’
If this data is so valuable, and Google makes enormous revenue out of it, why shouldn't they pay for it?
rbarooah··on Sergey Brin: Facebook and Apple a threat to Internet freedom
Brin acknowledges that the data is valuable. It belongs to other people. Google makes enormous revenue from it. Perhaps it's time for them to start paying for it.
rbarooah··on Sergey Brin: Facebook and Apple a threat to Internet freedom
All they seem to be being "accused" of is not giving data for free to Google to sell advertising against.
rbarooah··on Sergey Brin: Facebook and Apple a threat to Internet freedom
That's a red herring. Google could easily have asked them to desist from this policy while the acquisition was closing. Executives at Motorola know who their new boss is going to be and are acting accordingly.
rbarooah··on Sergey Brin: Facebook and Apple a threat to Internet freedom
It is on topic - Google has the exact same openness issues that these other companies have, and yet Brin fails to mention this.
rbarooah··on How I lost access to my Google account today
Sure but iDisk was little more than a generic WebDAV service, so you could easily replace it with a service from another provider with the money saved.
rbarooah··on [dead]
Thankfully Apples 'action' isn't true.

All that's happened is that they released a new style Airport Utility, with a simpler UI that doesn't support IPv6 yet.

They are still supplying a version with IPv6 support, and presumably a point release will add it to the new style utility soon enough.

rbarooah··on Oracle thinks you can copyright a programming language, Google disagrees
That assumes that the extra money is distributed. That doesn't seem to be happening.
rbarooah··on Oracle thinks you can copyright a programming language, Google disagrees
That's going to be a problem as we approach a world where basic human needs are easily met.
rbarooah··on US sues Apple and publishers over e-book prices
You do have the right to tell the retailer what price they must sell your product. It's called a contract. The retailer doesn't have to accept it.

Without Apple, the publishers had no meaningful alternative ebook store so Amazon always had the upper hand in contract negotiations, even going so far as to threaten to delist their paper books if they didn't accept the terms.

rbarooah··on US sues Apple and publishers over e-book prices
You might be in favor of dropping DRM, but that would in no way provide publishers with comparable access to the Kindle customers.

Kindle customers buy titles using 1-click from their devices or from the Amazon website. How does just 'dropping the DRM' compete with that distribution channel?

rbarooah··on US sues Apple and publishers over e-book prices
Sure, but $9.99 and even lower are still options which do in fact get used. Apple didn't set prices, they provided publishers with a range of options that included the old price point.
← PreviousPage 2 of 30Next →