HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

rbarooah

1,972 karma · joined May 31, 2008

submissionscomments
rbarooah··on US sues Apple and publishers over e-book prices
This implies that Amazon had a monopoly position. This is further illustrated by the fact that they did delist MacMillan's paper books in retribution.

Without Apple providing an alternative, Amazon controlled prices within the ebook market.

rbarooah··on US sues Apple and publishers over e-book prices
The app store is clearly nothing to do with any kind of monopoly, however much people would like the government to force Apple to make it what they want.

However, I agree that antitrust oversight would be harmful for the Apple, and indirectly for the industry as a whole.

rbarooah··on US sues Apple and publishers over e-book prices
If so, that seems like just as unwise strategy now as it was for Microsoft. I think it's pretty unlikely.
rbarooah··on Dear DoJ: You Need To Sue Apple Again
What exactly are you comparing to an unrestrained, pre-breakup AT&T? I'm not aware of any modern equivalent.
rbarooah··on If Google's Really Proud Of Google+, It Should Share Some Real User Figures
Ok, but that definition still renders the numbers meaningless - it's just a box you happen to see forever onwards if you've ever said yes to one of their prominent enticements to find out what Google+ is.

If they told us how many Google+ members use those results, and how often they are picked in comparison to the non+ results, that would tell us something that justifies using that definition.

As it stands, the numbers only tell us how many people clicked through a very prominent ad.

rbarooah··on If Google's Really Proud Of Google+, It Should Share Some Real User Figures
Sure, but by their definition someone who visits Google+ once and then never does anything with Google except search for the rest of time still counts as an active Google+ user.

Those people simply aren't engaged in any kind of social layer, and yet Google is reporting them as if they are.

It might not be correct to measure Google+ as if it were a direct equivalent to Facebook, but that doesn't make the numbers they are releasing any less misleading.

rbarooah··on What would Steve Jobs think about Project Glass (Google Glasses)
He'd ask whether it would help you to get a girlfriend, or whether it would just creep her out.

Based on this:

http://37signals.com/svn/posts/52-steve-jobs-just-put-it-in-...

rbarooah··on US sues Apple and publishers over e-book prices
Well we don't know whether there was what actually amounts to collusion, but assuming there was it might have been required to break Amazon's leverage over the bookseller which was artificially depressing prices.

That wouldn't make it less illegal, but it would be a reasons why it was necessary to restore the market as a pricing mechanism.

rbarooah··on US sues Apple and publishers over e-book prices
I'd say it could a good thing because it facilitates price competition between actual producers, where the feedback from the market can more directly affect the quality of actual books rather than just who gets to sell them.
rbarooah··on Dear DoJ: You Need To Sue Apple Again
When was the last time you saw anyone on HN directly insult someone else here in such a mean and insidious way?

You wrote that edit just to try to hurt and undermine me.

I think this is the first time I've seen anything like it here, and it has a really unpleasant schoolyard bully vibe to it.

rbarooah··on Dear DoJ: You Need To Sue Apple Again
These things are irrelevant to the definition of a monopoly.
rbarooah··on Dear DoJ: You Need To Sue Apple Again
Being the market leader doesn't give you a monopoly in any market, and certainly not in a young and growing one.
rbarooah··on US sues Apple and publishers over e-book prices
Isn't the agency model exactly what enables new entrants to publishing (whether publishing houses or self-publishers) to operate on a level playing field with established publishers?

It seems to me to be the best thing that's happened to the book industry for decades.

rbarooah··on Dear DoJ: You Need To Sue Apple Again
Accustomed to any of the countless apps and services that only exist on the iPad? Ready to do without them?

Severing business or consumer relationships with anyone but a totally incompetent supplier or commodity service involves a trade-off. Some benefits you are accustomed to may not be present, but others which are more desirable presumably exist. Understanding this is part of being responsible for how you spend your money and it applies universally.

Are you arguing that consumers should be protected from having to understand and exercise this responsibility by the government?

rbarooah··on Dear DoJ: You Need To Sue Apple Again
A monopoly is more than just having the largest market share. There has to be no viable competition. With Google and Amazon in the game that's clearly untenable.
rbarooah··on Dear DoJ: You Need To Sue Apple Again
In the days before the consumer internet, there were online services like Compuserve, Prodigy, and AOL. They did demand a cut from developers based on different features they provided.

They were driven out of business through competition from the open internet.

If the current situation is analogous, then over time we can expect open app stores to drive the closed ones out of business. No need to involve the government.

rbarooah··on Dear DoJ: You Need To Sue Apple Again
You said it wasn't easy to buy an alternative, and you used switching away from Windows during Microsoft's dominance as your example.

It was true that moving to the competition was hard during the Windows era because there weren't good alternatives. That's a strawman because there actually are good alternatives now, and your comments indicate that you know this.

Oversight exists to prevent abuse of monopolies, not to regulate companies just because they are successful.

rbarooah··on Dear DoJ: You Need To Sue Apple Again
A consumer could simply buy an alternative, but that is seldom as simple as it at first blush may seem. "Just use something other than Winodws" a million apologist would rant. That's why large companies get constant oversight."

Except that you know this is a strawman, since you regularly argue that the competition is strong:

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3822163

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3823863

rbarooah··on Dear DoJ: You Need To Sue Apple Again
This blog has a strangely contradictory nature. The tagline is "Nature does not like or grant monopolies. Monopolies Fail", and yet the piece is all about how government needs to intervene.
rbarooah··on Dear DoJ: You Need To Sue Apple Again
Nobody gets locked into a 2 year contract forcing them to do anything with Apple.

iPads are not sold on contract. iPhones come with a contract, but the contract doesn't force you to keep using the device - just the wireless service.

You can sell the phone and buy a different one to use with the same contract if you don't like it.

rbarooah··on Dear DoJ: You Need To Sue Apple Again
Apple is quickly enjoying a dominant position in mobile devices that Microsoft once enjoyed with desktop computers.

This can't be true while Android is the dominant mobile OS, and Amazon is the dominant eBook reader.

rbarooah··on Google (as a company) is more popular than Facebook, Twitter, and even Apple
You didn't address any of the points I made, and that's a straw man definition of ad-hominem. Ad-hominem is not specifically about tarnishing reputations, or unrelated attacks, although these can be part of it.

If you look at a real definition:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ad_hominem

You'll see that it conforms to what I said in my previous comment.

You have clearly indicated that you think the position of Apple users is less valid because of their loyalty to the company. That is ad-hominem - attacking the position by pointing out a characteristic of the person rather than the position, and is a fallacy designed to mislead the audience.

You also think that negative positions about Google are more prevalent amongst Apple users. On that point we have agreed from the beginning, but I haven't argued against that so repeatedly defending it is just another straw-man.

[edit: You added 'go away troll' to your comment after I posted this. That doesn't make your argument seem very strong.]

rbarooah··on US sues Apple and publishers over e-book prices
It does look strong. I wonder what Apple is holding out for, or whether there is actually a defense.
rbarooah··on Google (as a company) is more popular than Facebook, Twitter, and even Apple
Thanks for clarifying.

I have recently had the experiences of meeting more than one person (not super-technical engineers, but tech-literate IT people) who were very negative about even the idea of owning Apple products, but also without prompting made statements like "I hate what Google is becoming", and "everyone used to like them but now they're evil". So I can assure you the sentiments aren't limited to such a small community.

Even if this were not so, complex criticisms of a technology business would reasonably be expected to originate within a skilled technical community with a demonstrated preference for an alternative. So if these critiques did happen to be limited to this community, this would still be no reason to conclude that they do not reflect Google's behavior.

Your statements like: And the reason is clear: since 2008 Android has represented the biggest single threat to Apple's increasing dominance. are clearly an ad-hominem because you are implying that their criticisms stem from loyalty to Apple as a company, as opposed to them actually reasoning that Google's products and strategies have become counter to their specific values.

I'd say it's just as reasonable to suggest that Android amongst other things has caused Google itself to change its values, and it is this change of values that people are calling out.

Saying things like "none of this speaks to the legitimacy of.." and "Some of it is deserved.." does nothing to mitigate the ad-hominem.

If the criticism is legitimate, or the statements are deserved, then it doesn't matter what phone someone has in their pocket.

rbarooah··on US sues Apple and publishers over e-book prices
Right - basically the argument is that publishers cooperated with Apple to raise prices, and prices actually did go up. Which raises a red-flag of anti-competitiveness.

The counterargument is that this took place at a time when prices were artificially lowered because of Amazon's leverage over the publishers. When competition was restored, prices returned to a level set by the market.

rbarooah··on US sues Apple and publishers over e-book prices
If they lose, it's not obvious how this would hurt Apple aside from the fine. Wouldn't they just adopt the wholesale model for books leaving the publishers high and dry?

Presumably the only way Amazon was able to force the wholesale model in the first place was to threaten to stop selling paper books from those who wouldn't accept it.

rbarooah··on What can you do with an Android application with no permissions?
To follow up - the OP shows that the permissions are far from clear and visible.

Would people reasonably expect that the contents of their SD card and a list of all their purchases could be silently uploaded by an app they'd given no permissions to?

If not, this is clearly not delivering control to the user.

rbarooah··on Google (as a company) is more popular than Facebook, Twitter, and even Apple
I nowhere summarily dismiss it. I say that the correlation is not exclusive to Apple owners and is just a reflection of their opinions.

What I dismiss is the claim that this pattern is somehow unique to Apple users commenting on Google vs say Android users commenting on Apple. That's what makes it an ad-hominem.

Do you actually support this claim?

rbarooah··on What can you do with an Android application with no permissions?
Accepting your framing of the selling point, the OP clearly shows that it is not being delivered on.
rbarooah··on Google (as a company) is more popular than Facebook, Twitter, and even Apple
In that case you've successfully invalidated the parent poster's claim that posts critical of Google are only made by iPhone owners.

Either way shows the parent post to be a baseless ad-hominem.

← PreviousPage 3 of 30Next →