HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

reaperman

5,485 karma · joined March 28, 2023

submissionscomments
reaperman··on Gustav Klimt's Obsession with Gold
> it’s simple enough in Unreal Engine

The color of physical metallic gold is outside of sRGB color space. Maybe you could get close enough to fool people with some of the best modern HDR's (I don't know), but for most of the history of modern computing it didn't matter how good you were at digital animation -- no display could display the color "gold" even if you could mathematically compute the right color.

reaperman··on Map with public fruit trees
Indeed. But it is difficult to find a house near work that is not already part of an HOA.
reaperman··on Amazon employees are 'rage applying' for new jobs after RTO mandate
$100M just isn't that much money though. That's maybe the compensation for 200-300 truly good-to-excellent engineers? RTO mandate seems likely to lose that many good to great engineers. $100M is 0.017% of amazon's revenue. At my income level that's equivalent to me telling the woman who cleans my house that she's done here because I found someone else who charges $1/month less.

I could see that potentially being one part of the overall calculus, but certainly have difficulty seeing it be a rational "driving reason" of all this RTO.

reaperman··on the US Has Low Prices for Most Prescription Drugs
A generic for Lisdexamfetamine was recently released this year but it is still expensive. Its debut also triggered the end of the manufacturer coupon for low income individuals without insurance so many people now pay more for the generic than they paid for the brand name drug.

I'd say more importantly, while many prescriptions are cheap, they're still gated behind a >$100 doctor visit. Just getting basic antibiotics for strep or fluconazole for yeast infections can be too expensive, not because of the price of the pills but because of the price for a doctor to write a prescription.

http://redboxrx.com , etc. helps with this but the costs are still not great compared to ordering internationally through Indian "pharmacies".

reaperman··on GM electric vehicles can now access Tesla Superchargers
As of this year, it's a 100% tariff on Chinese EV's, not 25%.

https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases...

reaperman··on GM electric vehicles can now access Tesla Superchargers
More subsidies than the $7,500 per vehicle subsidy that the US government gives for our EV vehicles?
reaperman··on GM electric vehicles can now access Tesla Superchargers
> Traditional US car manufacturers are absolutely incompetent and will not survive competition with Chinese manufacturers

Oh they won't have any trouble. They may lose international market share but the US government will keep raising tariffs ad infinitum to protect the US automakers no matter how far behind they get, or how expensive the vehicles get. We already are giving them 100% tariffs against BYD/etc. You might think that's absurd but the steel industry has received tariffs up to 266% against Chinese steel, so there's a lot of headroom left to continue to price out international competition.

There's really no pressure for the US automakers to do better or innovate or actually compete.

reaperman··on OpenAI's $150B valuation hinges on upending corporate structure, sources
We can’t, only other YC alums.
reaperman··on He's Known as 'Ivan the Troll.' His 3D-Printed Guns Have Gone Viral.
> Glock 19, already quite close to the Platonic ideal

In some ways I agree with you. But we still see true innovation and leaps of improvement in this space. The Laugo Arms Alien handgun is one such leap of innovation, and is much better than a Glock 19. First produced just 5 years ago, Laugo Arms took a "blank slate" approach to designing a new handgun and it is genuinely very different from the designs of the last 50 years of handguns. The primary benefit of the design changes is a massively reduced recoil; this was designed to be the world's best competition shooting gun, but the innovations could also benefit guns designed for other purposes.

I’m only saying that maybe we are not quite as close to the platonic ideal as you’d imagine - not invalidating your overall point at all.

reaperman··on Would you trust AI to scan your genitals for STIs?
Snark isn’t helpful, and is against HN guidelines. It’s actually a pretty big dodge from Delano. Trans women who are post-surgery may be VERY poorly served by these AI solutions and will likely need a very easy “escape hatch” option to get timely human review.

Delano should have said they’re going to provide that escape hatch with fast response times.

reaperman··on The Texas Billionaire Who Has Greenpeace USA on the Verge of Bankruptcy
This submission should be flagged then. Paywalled articles with no workarounds are not allowed per the HN FAQ.
reaperman··on Cruise ships chopped in half are a license to print money
The EU is 1.5 million square miles of land area. The continental US is 3.1 million square miles of land area. Continental Europe incl. non-EU countries is over 4 million square miles of land area.
reaperman··on We should train AI in space [pdf]
I mean, okay…if SpaceX launch prices were lowered from the current $100 million per Falcon Heavy price down to $1 million per Starship launch I guess 5 Starship launches could be enough for a 40MW compute unit in space.

If SpaceX can really pull that off, my math above would look a lot different.

reaperman··on We should train AI in space [pdf]
> Launch can get to <$5m/Starship

What are you basing this on? Just the GPU’s to utilize 40MW will weigh nearly 100 metric tons (40MW / 700W * 1.7kg). Thats an entire Starship payload just for the GPU’s and absolutely nothing else.

Starship launches currently are $100 million and after adding in solar panels and radiator panels and radiation shielding you’ll need several of those Starship launches per single “40MW compute unit”.

How do you get this down to “<$5 million”?

reaperman··on We should train AI in space [pdf]
Not for “$5 million in launch costs” per 40MW compute unit. Sure, many things are possible with enough money, but their “Table 1” is a pretty bald-faced lie. Just the weight of 40MW’s worth of H100 GPU’s alone would be $200 million in launch costs on a Falcon Heavy. That’s before you even add on launch costs for solar panels or “magic” not-invented-yet radiator panels.

The first question isn’t whether it’s “possible” with enough money, it’s whether it could ever be within even an order of magnitude of “profitable”. The second question is why would you trust a company who provides these kinds of estimates with no reasonable explanation for these obvious massive discrepancies?

reaperman··on We should train AI in space [pdf]
Note: In my napkin math I forgot they could maybe use both the front and the back of the panel so it would be “merely” the area of one pentagon. I’ve edited that.

But the launch cost would remain the same as my original estimate because it was based on weight per “effective radiator area” of current best-practice space materials.

reaperman··on We should train AI in space [pdf]
I’d think so but maybe they could orient the radiative panels with just their edge facing the sun, so there’s very little area of the flat radiators exposed to insolation.
reaperman··on We should train AI in space [pdf]
Edit: Apparently while SpaceX launches currently cost $100 million, some people expect them to offer Starship launches for $1-4 million sometime in the future. If SpaceX really can reduce their launch prices by 99% then things might actually be napkin-math economically feasible.

———————-

There’s really no such thing as active cooling in space. You can move the heat from the component to the radiators with pumped water but ultimately the only way to get rid of heat in space is passively radiating it away.

And it’s very inefficient at removing heat unless there’s a large temperature differential. If the radiator heats up to 70C it can dissipate 785 watts per square meter of area facing into space. I guess assuming you have a front and also a back of a panel both radiating equally that could be 1570W per square meter of panel material. You can check it yourself with this equation: https://courses.lumenlearning.com/suny-physics/chapter/14-7-....

So for this “1 gigawatt” project you’d need 0.6 million square meters of double-sided radiators. Which is about the area of the Pentagon, or a quarter the area of Monaco. It would weigh around 6000 metric tons, which is the weight of half the trash produced in NYC in a day. This would require up to 300 Falcon Heavy launches for a total launch cost of $30 billion.

They say the launch cost for one 40MW unit (including radiators! and solar panels! and radiation shielding!) will be $5 million. That’s pretty laughable as just 25 of these 40MW units = 1GW. And 1/25 of $30 billion is … well over $1 billion.

Somehow, I estimate that JUST THE COOLING RADIATORS will cost >$1 billion to put into space. But they estimate they can put the whole everything in space for less than 0.5% of a very reasonable estimate.

EDIT: Actually, just launching enough H100’s to consume 40MW would cost at least $200 million. One H100 uses 700W so you’d need 57,000 of them to consume 40MW. Each H100 weighs 1.7kg so thats a total of 97 metric tons of H100’s. The falcon heavy can launch between 20-64 metric tons so you’ll need two launches at $100 million per launch.

reaperman··on We should train AI in space [pdf]
From the wikipedia article on SSO’s that I linked above:

> the dawn/dusk SSO orbit, where the local mean solar time of passage for equatorial latitudes is around sunrise or sunset, so that the satellite rides the terminator between day and night. Riding the terminator is useful for active radar satellites, as the satellites' solar panels can always see the Sun, without being shadowed by the Earth.

reaperman··on We should train AI in space [pdf]
They specify on that page a LEO-SSO (Low Earth Orbit Sun Synchronous Orbit).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sun-synchronous_orbit

reaperman··on We should train AI in space [pdf]
> Table 1: Cost comparison of a single 40MW cluster operated for 10 years in space vs on land…

> Cooling (water usage): Land: 1.7m tons vs. Space: None

They completely ignore the cost of 40MW of radiative cooling in the “Cost comparison” table. Then they have a section saying “we’re inventing something to dissipate gigawatts of energy into space.”

So the cost comparison is entirely misleading, and that critical lie by omission makes it very hard to take them at face value about literally anything else.

reaperman··on The Texas Billionaire Who Has Greenpeace USA on the Verge of Bankruptcy
Is there a workaround for the paywall?
reaperman··on Dynamicland 2024
I assume this hasn't been "released" yet, but still thought I'd ask if the source code for the operating system (or "computing environment", in Dynamicland-speak) is available anywhere and also if there yet exists any DIY hardware guides for building your own to play with at my own location (far from the Oakland/Berkeley Dynamicland facility).

I believe the FAQ confirms that this is not possible at the moment:

> Where can I get Realtalk?

>> At present, Realtalk exists in Dynamicland spaces and in the spaces of our collaborators, where we can carefully grow and tend in-person communities of practice. In the short term, additional spaces will be started by people who have contributed significantly to an existing space and have internalized the culture and its values. Long term, we intend to distribute the ideas in the form of kits+games which will guide communities through building their own computing environments that they fully understand and control. Long long term, computing may be built into all infrastructure as electric light is today. This would also require an extensive network of educational support.

reaperman··on Intel Honesty
> a market dominated by industry giants from the 60s

The thing is, the SpaceX moment occurred because of a rare opportunity where the industry incumbents were insulated from any competition or need for innovation for ~30 years. Some domestic industries still operate in an environment somewhat like this (e.g. the steel industry), but still face modernized global competition (albeit whose effects are kept at bay via import tariffs reaching as high as 266%).

The semiconductor industry... while there are magnificent barriers to entry and not "enough" competition, they have absolutely not been wholly insulated from innovation or competition. And innovation in fabrication is driven at a very rapid pace! So there aren't huge outsized profits to be found like there was for SpaceX. And even SpaceX needed to invent what was almost an entirely new industry (Starlink) to become truly profitable.

And even trying to pull a "SpaceX" on domestic steel manufacturing would fall flat because you wouldn't capture the global market, and would still be dependent on some (potentially much lower) tariffs to compete against the very modernized factories in China, which are innovative/competitive/efficient, unlike our domestic industry.

SpaceX took advantage of a very rare situation where there truly was no competition or innovation anywhere on the planet for a very long period. I'm not aware of any other industries which are quite as far "behind" today as space launch systems were in 2010. But if anyone else is, please mention those industries here!

reaperman··on Bypassing airport security via SQL injection
I'll take that bet. How long of a time window? 1 year, 2 years?
reaperman··on Breaking down a record-setting day on the Texas grid
> You don't really have the option of draining the water if you happen to be on a short vacation at the time.

I know this sounds like I’m just arguing for the sake of arguing, and maybe I am … but everywhere i’ve lived that gets to -40 there’s been an incredible neighborly energy. This is a situation where I would 100% just call a neighbor to flush my pipes, even if I don’t typically get along with that neighbor.

There’s something about places where you have to shovel 1 foot of snow twice a day just to park your car in the driveway that leads to people just giving a helping hand whenever it might make a difference.

Idk, YMMV but the only place I’ve seen people pipes freeze and burst was in Texas. And that includes living places where school doesn’t shut down during a blizzard and -40 temps.

And yes, these places definitely can be very noticeably racist but even then people would still absolutely do this for a neighbor.

reaperman··on Accident Forgiveness
I ran up a $4,000 bill with like a week of TPU time bc I didn’t realize that they kept running after the attached CPU turned off (unlike GPU offerings).

GCP also waived the whole thing - even refunding the $4k they had already pulled from my payment method.

reaperman··on Breaking down a record-setting day on the Texas grid
Everywhere I’ve lived where it actually does get to -40, none of the pipes burst if you lose power for extended periods. First, they’re buried well below the frost line, and secondly, there’s usually an pressurized air inlet nozzle somewhere so you can open a faucet and blow all the water out if you’ll be gone for a long time.

Fun fact, -40 is the same in F and C so it’s fine to omit the units for once!

reaperman··on Mushroom edibles are making people sick. Scientists still don't know why
We do know why! (Terrible headline...)

These weren't psilocin/psilocybin edibles made from natural psychedelic mushrooms. These chocolates contained synthetic tryptamines[0] (related chemicals to psilocin/psilocybin) such as 4-AcO-DMT, with poor quality control of doses/concentrations.

This is a direct result of patchwork prohibition laws. If psilocin/psilocybin were legal nationwide and well-regulated, it could be provided in a variety of forms with high purity, real quality control guarantees, and accessible independent third-party testing.

0: https://arstechnica.com/science/2024/07/illegal-drug-found-i...

reaperman··on HID Remapper
Completely agree.
← PreviousPage 6 of 34Next →