HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

redwoolf

710 karma · joined May 24, 2011

submissionscomments
redwoolf··on UEFA slams FIFA's 'unprecedented, unjustifiable' Balogun decision
Then perhaps it’s the offsides rule that needs revision. Do you think the spirit of the rule is captured by foot position analysis? If two players bodies are in alignment and the attackers leg is just beyond the leg of the defender, does that really matter? The rule was designed to stop attackers from sitting deep between the defenders and the goalie.
redwoolf··on UEFA slams FIFA's 'unprecedented, unjustifiable' Balogun decision
The on the pitch call was not a red card. VAR told the ref to go to the monitors to review and then the red card was given. If the on the pitch call stood, which was the right call, then we wouldn't be having the conversation.

The level of scrutiny we place on foot position when determining offsides with VAR is an example of the letter of the law vs the spirit of the law. Offsides was not meant to catch players who were half a foot length beyond the last non-goalie defender.

I'm not sure VAR is the net-benefit we think it is.

redwoolf··on 'Uber for nurses' exposes 86K+ medical records, PII via open S3 bucket
This is shameful. S3 buckets have not been public by default for many years. You have to make a choice to make them publicly accessible. And to not have the contents encrypted at rest. I just can’t.

The lack of respect that some companies have for their customers is appalling.

redwoolf··on Avoid ISP Routers (2024)
Can anyone suggest a good modem for DSL Fiber? I have CenturyLink/Quantum.
redwoolf··on Federal employees told to remove pronouns from email signatures by end of day
So I'm going to be that guy. It wasn't until Nixon and his southern strategy that the modern Republican Party became the Party we know today. The coalitions that formed the political parties before then were based more on tradition and geography than on ideology. The Republican Party has been moving ever more rightward (and pulling the Democratic Party along with it) since Reagan. America doesn't even have a Center-Left party anymore as result of this.
redwoolf··on Federal employees told to remove pronouns from email signatures by end of day
I did not know that. Thanks! But it's so rare that people even use honorifics at all these days.
redwoolf··on Federal employees told to remove pronouns from email signatures by end of day
I'm not talking about the 1st amendment. I'm talking about the rhetoric of those on the right in America. They are constantly congratulating themselves on being the champions of freedom. But if someone wants to read a book they don't like, or if someone wants to use a pronoun they disagree with, or if someone wants access to certain medical procedures then they pass laws to restrict those freedoms. It's incredibly hypocritical.
redwoolf··on Federal employees told to remove pronouns from email signatures by end of day
Republicans are the party of personal liberty until they don't like what you're doing.
redwoolf··on Federal employees told to remove pronouns from email signatures by end of day
What is the salutation for they/them pronouns?
redwoolf··on Is the Q source the origin of the Gospels?
I am most definitely over generalizing. I could have been more thoughtful in my word choices to narrow the scope of my comments.
redwoolf··on Is the Q source the origin of the Gospels?
I recognize what you’re saying and you’re right. I’m well aware of different approaches and traditions. And I completely agree that ignoring religious writings across history deprives us of understanding the full range of human experience. I for one am not one of those people. I realize that I’m engaging a bit in the very thing I’m criticizing, but this is a comment on HN not a well thought out and twice revised essay.
redwoolf··on Is the Q source the origin of the Gospels?
You're absolutely right. The thing is that in America, Catholicism isn't the cultural force that it is in other parts of the Americas or in Continental Europe. Protestantism is the brand of Christianity that fights the culture wars here. So for me "Christian" has become a shorthand for "Evangelical Christian." This is somewhat intellectually dishonest and definitely sloppy.
redwoolf··on Is the Q source the origin of the Gospels?
Right, which is probably part of why most Evangelicals think Catholics aren't Christian.

After I finished my BA in English, I considered going for a MA in Catholic Studies because it offered an opportunity to study Philosophy, Theology, and Literature in a way that was fascinating to me, but by that time my faith had withered and died.

redwoolf··on Is the Q source the origin of the Gospels?
You're right. I'm extremely colored by my Evangelical upbringing and the contemptuous American Evangelical community.

That being said, even if we did find Q or something like it, would it change much about our understanding of that time in history?

redwoolf··on Is the Q Source the Origin of the Gospels?
Worse, Assemblies of God (speaking in tongues).
redwoolf··on The End of Private Libraries?
Many years in the future, after global warming wrecks our world, when humanity rebuilds civilization, they will be glad for folks like this person. Without physical books there will be no way to reconstruct our time and tell our story. Digital media will be useless to future generations if there’s a blip in continuity.
redwoolf··on OpenAI as we knew it is dead
Totally agree.

I think with the suburban explosion and rise of the personal automobile we’ve seen individualism trump collectivism. I don’t think we’ll ever see a new deal or social security like initiative in America until the power structures in our society are changed fundamentally.

redwoolf··on OpenAI as we knew it is dead
And breaking a promise, siphoning money from a nonprofit, and making billions in the process.
redwoolf··on OpenAI as we knew it is dead
The public has no stomach for collective action anymore. All for one and one for all? Nah, man, what’s yours is mine and what’s mine is mine.
redwoolf··on OpenAI as we knew it is dead
One does not need to know someone personally to assess their character based on their public actions.
redwoolf··on OpenAI as we knew it is dead
Did you read the article? The hubris and avarice required here doesn’t develop overnight.
redwoolf··on OpenAI as we knew it is dead
And the downvotes to prove my point
redwoolf··on OpenAI as we knew it is dead
[flagged]
redwoolf··on Alternatives to Google Products – Updated
Okay, but why is Aptoide on there[1]? If you're on Android, you've already lost the war with Google. Don't talk to me about custom ROMs. Those are only feasible for the technologically savvy.

[1] https://en.aptoide.com

redwoolf··on Causing environmental damage should be a criminal offence
Yeah, maybe. I don't disagree with the sentiment, but who is prosecuted for the crime? In US law, there is the concept of corporate personhood, but a corporation has yet to be tried for a crime. And even if it were tried and convicted, how do you sufficiently punish a corporation. You can't put it in jail. Fines don't seem to deter corporations as they're happy to either pay them or settle out of court and move one with business as usual.

If it is to be treated as a crime and we choose to prosecute the people responsible, how do we determine how widely or narrowly to distribute the responsibility? To the CEO of the company or the board? To the management that oversaw the environment damage? Or to the individual workers who were told to perform the actions leading to the environmental damage?

But as we've seen time and again "the shit rolls down hill." Blame will move from the CEO who will claim they knew nothing and will land on the field workers. And while these workers do bear responsibility for complying with directives that caused environmental damage, the power structures in corporations (at least in America with at-will employment and relatively few extant unions) make prosecuting such workers for these crimes an unjust outcome. Their burden of responsibility must be mitigated by the choices they were forced to make between feeding their families and performing a possibly harmful action. Not to mention the fact that such people would in many cases be acting in ignorance of the ramifications of such actions.

Environmental damage is a serious concern, but the way we have positioned private entities in our society makes it nearly impossible to affect any change in their behavior. Adding criminal penalties for such behavior includes the risk that the wrong people are charged and punished while those who bear ultimate responsibility jump from the burning plane in their golden parachutes.

redwoolf··on I disapprove of what you say, but will defend to the death your right to say it
I’m not a fucking troll
redwoolf··on I disapprove of what you say, but will defend to the death your right to say it
Nice try. I have nothing to contribute to this world.
redwoolf··on I disapprove of what you say, but will defend to the death your right to say it
Why the fuck does a simple question get downvoted? Jesus Christ!
redwoolf··on I disapprove of what you say, but will defend to the death your right to say it
Nanny-fascism because of crackdowns on racist riots?
redwoolf··on I disapprove of what you say, but will defend to the death your right to say it
Never mind. I’m wrong about everything as usual.

How the fuck do I delete my account?

Page 1 of 4Next →