HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

renhanxue

805 karma · joined January 15, 2024

submissionscomments
renhanxue··on What flying was like fifty years ago
In the EU pilot-owners can self-certify their aircraft for unleaded fuel, provided that the engine is unmodified and that its manufacturer has approved the use of Avgas UL 91. Print an AFM supplement page and put on new fuel quality placards and you can release the aircraft to service yourself. EASA has a set of "standard changes and standard repairs" (CS-STAN) that offer simplified procedures for some common modifications and repairs and this is one of them. CS-STANs have been around for about a decade now.

In the US you still need to go and purchase a supplemental type certificate for your specific aircraft type for this, I believe.

GA is a much smaller phenomenon in Europe than it is in the US but that's not because regulators are out to make it more complicated.

renhanxue··on All Aboard the Bureaucracy Train
Probably less than you'd think. Levy is delivering a punchy oneliner here; what the Transit Costs Project research indicates is that what's often missing in countries with high construction costs isn't so much bureaucrats as it is in-house engineering and technical program management resources. A lot of the design and program management work they do needs to be done by someone, but in countries with high construction costs this work mostly tends to be done either by consultants or by the contractors themselves, and that leads to misaligned incentives.

They do get into these things a little bit later in the interview, but the surprisingly simple conclusion is that when an organization is buying something, the people working out the deal need to understand what it is they're buying, or the organization gets ripped off. It sounds simple to the point of being silly when I put it like that, but it's actually true. And this should feel familiar to a lot of people in tech; how many times have you had to use or implement some very stupid system that got purchased because of buzzwords or because the people deciding what to use aren't the people using the system? (Education is particularly plagued by these problems.) What the Transit Costs Project finds is that this is a thing in public works as well: if your civil service has insufficient in-house technical expertise in its field, or if it doesn't trust its own technical expertise, that tends to make costs go up. It's far from the only contributing factor, but it's an important one.

When cost overruns for these types of projects can routinely be measured in billions of dollars, I think it's not that hard to justify hiring a few dozen civil engineers to keep things under control. The "big" civil service Levy talks about doesn't necessarily need to be big in terms of team size, but it needs to have weight.

renhanxue··on All Aboard the Bureaucracy Train
Levy's research group calls this "adversarial legalism" and yes it does seem to be a contributing factor to high construction costs.
renhanxue··on All Aboard the Bureaucracy Train
Many of the countries he compares against are part of the Western world, though? Spain, Portugal, Italy, the Nordics - all of these have significantly lower construction costs than in the US. What unacceptable methods are you thinking of, here?
renhanxue··on Go(lang): Robust generic functions on slices
It's golang, it has a long and proud tradition of being footguns all the way down.
renhanxue··on Stuffit – 30 Years of File Compression
StuffIt is a thing you might be nostalgic about if you used MacOS 7 through 9 or so in the 90's. I'm surprised it still exists, I don't recall using it on OS X at all.
renhanxue··on The business of check cashing
Here in Sweden there are (since last year) no longer any banks that will cash a foreign check, no matter which country of origin, currency or bank. There used to be one that still did it at a quite steep fee, which became relevant for expats trying to cash their covid stimulus checks a couple of years ago, but now there are none. It's just a huge yarn of fraud and manual processing, it's not worth it.

Domestic checks barely exist either, the only way you'll ever see one is if the government owes you money for some reason but you haven't told them what your bank account number is.

renhanxue··on Apple Vision Pro review: magic, until it's not
> just in case this VR stuff takes off

I think the last few years have pretty conclusively proven that there is no VR train to miss. It remains mainly a novelty (with some niche uses) and none of its fundamental issues have been resolved.

renhanxue··on Ingenuity had more computing power than all NASA deep space missions combined
Unfortunately I think this will have less of an impact than many people think. As expensive as the radiation hardened hardware is, it's still series produced stuff that doesn't need reinventing for every mission. Almost all of the costs are in development of the unique scientific instruments each mission needs, and in keeping the mission teams staffed.

For example NASA's Lucy mission that launched in 2021 had a just under $1 billion budget, in which $560m was spacecraft development and $280m was for keeping a mission team staffed for 12 years. The launch on an Atlas V was $150m. What's $250k for a radiation hardened CPU in that? It's not even peanut crumbs. And as expensive as the launch was, even if SpaceX and other new launch companies drive it down by 90%, the budget for this mission would still be about a billion dollars.

Heck, even if you started series production of probes and their instruments and as such were able to amortize the development costs over a bunch of spacecraft, the fact remains that if you wanna go somewhere interesting it's gonna take years and you're gonna have to have a staff of mission specialists on retainer for most of that time. You can't disrupt away the fact that space is really big, at least not until someone discovers some new physics.

renhanxue··on Harnessing heat from wastewater
To my knowledge there's no really effective way of converting low grade waste heat into electricity. Basically all heat-based electricity generation today relies on being able to boil water into steam to spin a turbine. But with heat pumps and district heating, you can recover useful amounts of energy even from quite small thermal gradients. That's why things like room temperature sewage and waste heat from data centers can be useful to these systems even though they couldn't be used to generate electricity.

Also, if you rely on local heat pumps, you still need to take the energy from somewhere. Taking it from the air is fine in warmer climates, but in colder climates the efficiency of air-source heat pumps starts to become an issue when it gets colder. You can extract heat from deep underground, but that doesn't universally work in densely populated areas because the ground doesn't contain infinite amounts of energy and it's possible to extract more than it can sustain. So, in cold climates there's definitely a use case for distributing heat using water pipes, with or without local heat pumps in every building (see the sibling comment about 5th generation district heating systems).

renhanxue··on Harnessing heat from wastewater
It's not a new technology, though. The Vancouver system mentioned in the article has been in operation since 2010, which may be a short time in infrastructure terms, but similar systems that extract waste heat from sewage have been in commercial operation since at least the mid-1980's. The system in Vancouver is now being expanded to 9 MW of power output, but there's a similar one in Stockholm that first opened in 1986 that now has an output of 225 MW. That one uses treated wastewater though, while the one in Vancouver operates on raw sewage that hasn't hit the treatment plant yet.

District heating is at a different scale in northern Europe and especially in Scandinavia. The systems in North America are (with a few exceptions) typically local to a campus, a neighborhood or a small downtown area, serving maybe a hundred buildings with maybe tens of kilometers of pipes. The public heating utility in Stockholm alone serves 800,000 people, has over 3000 km of pipes and generates over 8,000 GWh of heat energy in a typical year. It's kind of the default way of heating most buildings, here. The main exception is single family homes where past eras of cheap electricity often made people prefer other heating methods.

Such systems don't have to be huge to be useful, but the bigger they are, the more opportunities you have to move heat from places that don't want it (data centers, industry in general, etc) to places that do.

renhanxue··on Harnessing heat from wastewater
But district heating is a distribution mechanism, not a heat generation mechanism. Cogeneration plants are one way to power it, but you can also use waste heat from industrial processes, very large scale heat pumps, or burning household waste. All of these are in common use in places where district heating is common. The public district heating utility in Stockholm claims to have the world's largest heat pump installation, which has the capacity to extract 225 MW of heat from treated sewage, in the process generating both heat that's sent into the district heating network, cooling that's sent into the district cooling network, and finally a small amount of electric power by releasing the treated water into a lake via a turbine. This facility opened in 1986. The utility also has various other facilities, both cogeneration plants that burn biofuel (mostly byproducts from the lumber industry) or household waste, as well as other heat pumps that extract energy from seawater.

District heating/district cooling has three advantages: you can change the heat source centrally without having to refit every single dwelling, there are economies of scale in the heat generation, and you can take advantage of heat or cooling that's just in the wrong place and transport it to where it's needed.

← PreviousPage 4 of 4