HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

revelio

1,142 karma · joined March 18, 2023

submissionscomments
revelio··on Corporate profits account for almost half the increase in Europe’s inflation
You're talking about wealth, not money. Wealth indeed cannot be created out of thin air and is based on converting inputs into higher value outputs. Money in contrast can be created at will, and is, all the time.
revelio··on Corporate profits account for almost half the increase in Europe’s inflation
Printing money is by definition out of nowhere.

If governments sell bonds to domestic buyers then indeed that doesn't create money, but in practice most bonds are bought by the central bank using printed money.

revelio··on Corporate profits account for almost half the increase in Europe’s inflation
I didn't intend for it to be read as either good or bad. Actually I think it's a good thing. Government employees should not see themselves as independent of politicians.
revelio··on Corporate profits account for almost half the increase in Europe’s inflation
Inflation during the gold standard came from:

1. Debasement of the currency (reducing the gold content of coins)

2. Gold mining

3. Stealing gold from abroad

That's why the Spanish Empire suffered hyperinflation after Cortez, because so much gold was brought back to Spain from the conquered South American tribes.

Yes, money velocity has an impact too but the main thing which can affect that is government intervention (like by printing lots of money and giving it to people who then save it - low velocity - and later start spending it - higher velocity).

revelio··on Corporate profits account for almost half the increase in Europe’s inflation
Apple has lots of competitors and doesn't even have dominant market share.

Google is hard to compete with due to network effects, because they don't often miss tricks, and because they've invested so heavily in core R&D for so many years. The classical story about competition is that a big rich company becomes complacent and stops improving their products, opening a gap for new companies to enter, but Google hasn't really done that, they continue to tweak and try new things (arguments about search quality specifically for precise programmer queries aside).

Amazon retail is hard to compete with because it's not a very good business. They keep margins extremely low for not entirely rational reasons, which is why most of their profit now comes from AWS. AWS meanwhile does have competitors.

revelio··on Corporate profits account for almost half the increase in Europe’s inflation
The sharp rise in inflation predates any kind of energy crisis. Inflation kicked off in 2021.

https://tradingeconomics.com/united-states/core-inflation-ra...

Energy didn't become a major issue until Ukraine was invaded.

Inflation was triggered by all the money printed during COVID getting into the economy once it opened up again.

revelio··on Corporate profits account for almost half the increase in Europe’s inflation
That claim is very specific to how you define market.

Most markets have never had more than 3-5 major competitors in them because beyond that it gets too hard for customers to differentiate between them, too hard to understand all the available brands etc.

But this depends on a lot on where you draw the boundaries of the market. There probably aren't more than 5 good Chinese restaurants within walking distance of where you live even in a city, for example. But over the whole city there are many more. There are only ~4 main cloud providers globally, but if you expand your definition of the market a bit further there are many more.

In practice for price competition to exist you don't seem to need more than 3-5 players. For example Oracle offer a generous free tier in the cloud space.

revelio··on Corporate profits account for almost half the increase in Europe’s inflation
In practice central bankers are unelected politicians. Their mandates are set by politicians, they aren't actually bankers in the normal sense of the term, and what they do is attempt to plan the economy in service of politically set goals. If central bankers were really independent of politics then they would of course have refused to print any money to fund COVID measures like lockdowns on the grounds that they are responsible solely for inflation and employment, so if governments wanted to do that they'd have to pass emergency taxes. Obviously no central banker said that. They were all immediately on board with letting politicians do whatever they wanted.
revelio··on Corporate profits account for almost half the increase in Europe’s inflation
He labelled the cause as government policy, which clearly includes pandemic measures.

Sweden didn't lock down but they did print a ton of money. Compare money supply growth for UK vs Sweden. It's the same and occurred at the same time. Lockdowns weren't the only pandemic spending measures unfortunately. All governments everywhere massively pumped the money supply to pay for "whatever it takes" and now the bill has come due:

https://d3fy651gv2fhd3.cloudfront.net/charts/sweden-money-su...

> Do you really think none of this matters, or do your political leanings tell you it's always the government's fault?

Inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon, however, this basic insight is easy to get confused about because there's a large gap between theory and practice when it comes to this metric.

In theory inflation cannot occur without money printing, because a rise in prices of something like oil or food must be compensated by a fall in prices elsewhere as demand for that less essential thing disappears. People re-allocate their financial decisions towards the thing increasing in prices, businesses compensate by lowering prices to try and increase demand, it balances out.

Several things complicate this simple picture in practice.

One is that government inflation metrics don't include all prices. Indeed they cannot because it's too difficult to collect that data and prices constantly change. Also, governments like to play games with inflation statistics because if you can confuse people about inflation you get to pay for election pledges with money printing and then blame inflation on external factors, and because people tend to vote for whoever promises to spend more without raising taxes it's a quick way to hack democracy. So they usually define inflation only in terms of a small subset of all prices. If you do that then you can obviously have inflation even in the absence of money printing because you're ignoring the prices that fall.

Another problem is that in a sufficiently damaging period of price instability, some goods and services may simply cease being available. Everyone is spending all their money on heating their homes and other businesses go bankrupt as a consequence. At this point the price of the thing effectively goes to infinity, it just can't be obtained at any price, but that ruins the calculations and so governments do substitutions within the basket of prices, asserting that X is a substitute for Y even if in reality X is quite different (e.g. different kinds of meat). There are lots of hacks like these in how the stats are calculated.

Yet another problem is that money printing is somewhat circular in a fractional reserve system with very low reserve ratios and there are lots of feedback loops. If the government prints lots of money, then gives it to people whilst simultaneously banning the spending of it then it will appear they printed lots of money without causing inflation. When they stop banning the spending of it, that will show up as inflation even if the money printing has stopped. This is what's happening now, as governments shovelled money into people's pockets during lockdowns but there was nothing open to spend it on.

Nonetheless, we usually think of inflation has being caused by money printing because most of the time prices aren't being affected by wars or oil cartels and when that does occur, the prices which rise are being compensated by other prices that are falling or disappearing (which is a loss of wealth). It may just not be obvious.

revelio··on Declassified U.S. report on origins of Covid-19 virus [pdf]
Feel free to write your own analysis of the original question!
revelio··on The rule says, “No vehicles in the park”
Yes, but the goal of curious conversation requires a diversity of views, otherwise there's nothing to be curious about. In turn that would greatly benefit from a more classical approach to rules of debate in which speakers aren't blamed for the behavior of listeners or responders regardless of what they said. Otherwise you can't be too curious, in case someone flips out about the dangerousness of that idea, and then you get blamed for starting a flamewar.

I really don't think HN does the best possible job of living up to this ideal as a consequence and you see this in the wide range of important topics that the site has largely failed to debate. For example, a common complaint on lab leak stories is that just a few years ago this site was routinely suppressing people who were attempting to engage in curious conversation about SARS-CoV-2 origins.

revelio··on Declassified U.S. report on origins of Covid-19 virus [pdf]
It doesn't ascribe words to anyone. For the rest, yes, that's what political analysis is. Do you find all political commentary illegitimate or just the stuff you don't like?

"Putting words in someone's mouth" is different. It means ascribing a quote to them that they didn't actually say. It doesn't cover all speculation about what people think.

revelio··on Declassified U.S. report on origins of Covid-19 virus [pdf]
No words are ascribed to anyone, so you're off base there. It's just an attempt to analyze the behavior of a group of people by seeking underlying themes and rationales, like millions of other such explanations out there.
revelio··on The rule says, “No vehicles in the park”
Getting moderated typically results in a post being made invisible to most site readers, which voids the effort put into writing it. Of course it imposes cost on the person being moderated, that's the purpose of moderation and bans in the first place.

Quite beyond the quiz instructions, the rest of the psychology on display in this thread is fascinating. Having clear rules makes things harder because other people will follow them. That sounds like the kind of outcome you fear only if you don't really want there to be rules, but only cultural homogeneity. Which is a stated anti-goal of the site.

revelio··on Declassified U.S. report on origins of Covid-19 virus [pdf]
> What incentive do people on the left have to deny the obvious conclusion that it came from the lab?

Huh, isn't that kind of obvious?

A big part of left wing ideology is progressivism, which is an exaltation of progress. The exact definition of progress changes over time, but the idea is at heart about having the most intelligent and specialized people being granted power to re-organize society for the greater good, as they see it. It is explicitly against the public making their own decisions in a decentralized way (neither via markets nor politicians), because it's assumed they're too stupid to do so with good outcomes.

Core to this worldview is the belief that there are such people as neutral experts, wise intellectuals, morally uncorrupted regulators and so on. You have to believe these people exist and in large numbers, otherwise the core progressivist project falls apart because who would be in charge of society? So the left are very keen on regulators, NGOs and especially "scientists", by which they don't mean corporate scientists but academics and government lab workers. They see in such people the core of the progressive project. Motivated by the greater good rather than self-centered profit, they deploy their superior skill and wisdom to make the world better.

So COVID comes along and it appears at first to be the perfect vehicle for validating the progressive project. Nature attacks, and who will defeat it? Not politicians or ordinary people! It will be the scientists and public health officials - but they say they can only do it if they're awarded total power over our lives, if politicians and markets are disposed of entirely and if we're all forced to act in concert (so we get collectivism as well as progressivism). Ideal!

The lab leak conspiracy turns this progressive dream into a nightmare. Suddenly the experts, the public health officials etc aren't the heroes of the story anymore, they're the villains. It turns a story about the virtues of progressive power into a story about how supposedly intelligent people killed millions through a foolish, careless and ultimately useless pursuit of abstract "progress" without regard to risks. And if they lied and covered up that then what else might they be lying about? How can anyone defend these people as superior leaders when they behave this way?

So depending on whether or not it came from a lab, the conclusions can switch from total validation of left wing goals to total repudiation. Of course they will never accept that it came from a lab leak.

revelio··on Declassified U.S. report on origins of Covid-19 virus [pdf]
That's the explanation they came up with for why they were lying, but these people are self-admitted liars so why would you believe their lies any further?

If you are in charge of government and worried about mask availability, the right thing to do is pass laws seizing mask supplies. This is easy because they were almost all being imported from China anyway.

The worst possible thing to do would be to assert with 100% confidence that for scientific reasons masks don't work to the entire population including healthcare workers, and then later invert your position over night. Anyone who thinks this is a reasonable way to manage material logistics is clearly far too stupid to be in charge of anything, let alone critical government functions.

revelio··on The rule says, “No vehicles in the park”
That's a fairly culturally specific interpretation of common sense. Where I live it would for sure also include e-bikes and scooters, quite possibly regular bikes too (this is assuming "park" here means something on the ground and not e.g. a roof park where there might be weight limits).

The HN approach makes things simpler for moderators in much the same way that being a monarchy makes lawmaking simpler for the king, but writing down rules isn't about making the enforcer's life easier, it's about making the subject's lives easier. They're more numerous, so their needs should have at least some weight.

Independent of that argument, precise written rules and a process for updating them are valuable for several reasons:

1. Whilst people might still get mad, they get mad at the written rules and not at the interpreter of them. This takes a lot of the heat out of the situation because a document can be improved easily relative to improving a person, so discussions about bad outcomes become de-personalized and more constructive.

2. The act of writing down rules forces mental clarity. Contradictions and unhelpful biases that may not be obvious when free-floating in one's head can become apparent immediately when trying to write it all down.

3. Because the rules are clear, violations are less likely to happen to begin with. People who aren't on-board with the values of the community stay away.

The generic HN prohibition against "flamewars" is a good example of a rule that could use a rigorous clarification. It doesn't work to assume the intent or definitions are obvious, because flamewar is a purely online concept that doesn't have any clear analogy to the physical world. Actually it's the opposite: in physical debates there's a general understanding that anyone who turns up and takes part will engage in emotional self-control. If they lose it and start getting angry or raising their voice, they're the ones expected to leave, regardless of what argument the other side was making at the time. HN's approach inverts this standard social convention and blames the person who remains calm for the behavior of angry respondents!

The thread you linked to (from 2015!) is a good example of this. The original post is something about pi and the Bible. It's phrased calmly, isn't obviously in bad faith and is at least somewhat interesting yet is flagkilled, then you threaten to ban the user for conducting "religious flamewars". That user quite reasonably asks what it is that makes his post a rule violation and gives several possibilities e.g. is all discussion of religion banned? But you reply that it would be "soul destroying" to answer his question that specifically! He wasn't asking for a mechanical algorithm but getting more specific than "religious flamewar" and "spirit of the place" doesn't seem like an unreasonable request.

revelio··on Turning Joe Rogan down was the right thing to do
If they're ignorant then Hotez should be able to destroy them on air, with ease, shouldn't he?

The actual fear here is not that these guys are ignorant idiots but rather that they will in fact make many correct points that aren't easy to refute at all, and that Hotez - a completely discredited person who has said many untrue things - would end up losing the debate comprehensively. Which is why he has now backpedalled. It should be an easy $100k+ win for a charity of his choice but he can't do it.

revelio··on Turning Joe Rogan down was the right thing to do
Hotez doesn't do that. He has a long track record of saying things, on video, that contradict prior things he's said, also on video. The reason he won't debate anyone is that he'd immediately be hung by his own words.

Here's a video showing Hotez in action:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sj6-QDVYbv8

revelio··on How AI can distort human beliefs
Authors. There are two. One is a psychologist from Berkeley. The other is another AI ethics grifter (article affiliation claims she's in the school of computer science at Dublin but her website says she studies human behavior and AI ethics, so not CS research).

Isn't psychology the field that's notorious for generating tons of non-replicable claims that are nonetheless swallowed whole by everyone within it, often for decades at a time? Pop psych books are a giant misinformation industry that nobody within the academy cares to tackle. Hard to imagine a group of people less qualified to talk about a misinformation problem than the ones who have systematically filled our culture with misleading memes and fraudulent studies, without remorse and without any attempt to fix things. They need to remove the plank from their eye before trying to remove the mote from ChatGPT's.

revelio··on How AI can distort human beliefs
They chose Claude because if you're going for a friendly human sounding personality, a first name (which is how people address each other) sounds much better. How many people refer to each other by their last names in normal casual conversation, outside of maybe the military? Even ChatGPT in its heavily neutered state isn't silly enough to claim the Anthropic devs are trying to subconsciously oppress women via name choice.

This constant witchhunt for sexism and racism is really tiring, btw. It's long ago blown past boy-crying-wolf territory. You should know that many of us now assume that any claim of sexism or racism is automatically false, just another attempt to dig up virtue truffles from already wrecked land. It makes the accuser look bad and worth avoiding, whilst having no effect on the reputation of the supposed guilty party.

revelio··on 53% of parents say climate change affects their decision to have more kids
Please prove that it's human actions that cause coastal erosion, because I'm pretty sure coastlines have always been moving and shifting in response to erosion. That's how beaches are made, isn't it?

Also, even if that were to be true which I doubt, so what? They were supposed to sink beneath the waters as they rapidly rise due to melting polar ice. That was the doom scenario that was used to motivate people, but it hasn't happened. In a rational world that should cause us to toss out the other predictions made by such "experts", not try to retcon what was said to fit whatever actually happens. Especially because a change like "maybe a beach migrates northward a bit in some islands, others grow a bit, others shrink a bit" is nowhere near important enough to make disruptive changes to the lives of everyone on the planet.

revelio··on GCC Adopts a Code of Conduct
No CoC is as clear as law is generally expected to be.
revelio··on GCC Adopts a Code of Conduct
They could, but their justification had to be "I don't like you". The CoC process is designed to enable exclusion via opaque committees who justify their decisions by reference to vague and subjective criteria. It makes the people doing it feel better by allowing them to pretend everyone signed up for whatever random thing they decided today, and thus shield themselves from criticism.
revelio··on 53% of parents say climate change affects their decision to have more kids
Yes, but that's not what I said. Sea levels do rise globally at a slow rate, but it can also be offset by the land itself rising and falling (isostatic rebound), by minor changes to instruments (because the actual changes we're talking about are tiny), temperature changes affecting the volume of the ocean etc.

In that particular city and beach, you can see that tides went down between 2000-2005, then remained more or less stable until 2015, then went up a bit and stabilized at a new level. CO2 levels meanwhile go up very steadily. This data clearly doesn't indicate something CO2 driven given the various trends including declines that have happened within the time since the gauge opened in 1995. These look like natural changes, which are expected because especially when zoomed into these tiny differences everything is always changing.

In either case, South Florida just this year had "once in 100 year" floods

If they happen every 100 years then why is human CO2 emissions to blame? Even climatologists don't claim there was much CO2 impact in 1920 or 1820.

revelio··on 53% of parents say climate change affects their decision to have more kids
Your last link is about Tebunginako. That island was already identified in 1991 as suffering from ordinary coastal erosion and sandbank migration:

https://spccfpstore1.blob.core.windows.net/digitallibrary-do...

Although there is erosion near Tebunginako village centre, there is an accreting area north of the village centre where trees are systematically being planted to reclaim the accreted area. This situation implies the natural northward migration of a sand bulge along the beach

The article presents this as a narrative about climate change because that creates clicks, but it's misinformation. The fact that most of the Tuvalu islands have grown over the past 40 years shows that climate change is not sinking the Pacific Islands, even if some very small ones do disappear or move due to natural forces.

From a quick look, your other links aren't more reliable unfortunately. These sorts of islands are prone to erosion and movement of the coastline, which would occur regardless of whether humanity was here or not.

revelio··on 53% of parents say climate change affects their decision to have more kids
Neither claim is correct, both are intended to denigrate him (an electrical engineer is someone who does electrics for buildings or grids, not someone who works on CPU design and you know it). And they're both about the author of one of the links, not about the actual subject in question, which is pretty much the definition of ad hominem.

> If the "data" is genuinely interesting then I'm happy to leave it to the experts to analyse it.

The "data" is the government's own data and if you delegate to people who have a clear profit motive to exaggerate/lie about what it says, and a track record of doing so, then you're going to continue to believe things that aren't true. In which case you should let the rest of us get on with actual analysis and debate instead of trying to kick up mud about the people doing it.

revelio··on 53% of parents say climate change affects their decision to have more kids
Miami Beach tide gauge readings haven't changed since the year that study was published.

https://psmsl.org/data/obtaining/rlr.monthly.plots/1858.png

Also, do you really find that study credible? "tide-induced events increased by more than 400%" in one single year? Sea level rise is a slow and steady process, but these guys are claiming it tripled in the span of a single year. That hasn't been reported anywhere else.

revelio··on 53% of parents say climate change affects their decision to have more kids
The supposed flooding of low lying Pacific islands have been one of the primary emotional stories told by environmentalists, governments and the UN for decades. The poor innocent islanders having their homes destroyed by massive sea level rises created directly by rapacious westerners in their gas guzzling cars.

The falsification of these claims is therefore no mere "factoid" or "little gotcha". It means all the people and institutions who made these claims were wrong and wrong whilst asserting 100% confidence in what they were saying. It is not just a falsification of a scientific hypothesis but the falsification of their self-proclaimed expertise too.

Now think about how many other "gotchas" are lurking out there in the science. Because for sure this isn't the only one.

In reality there is no evidence for "massive disruptions costing trillions of dollars". None. Zero. It's a fiction that's been made up out of whole cloth and now way too many people just can't let it go.

revelio··on 53% of parents say climate change affects their decision to have more kids
You packed two bits of ad hominem misinformation into one sentence there, bravo! He once used a pseudonym like so many of us on this forum still do, but has gone by Tony Heller for many years now. And he wasn't an electrical engineer, he was a microchip verification engineer who worked at IBM.

Now do you have anything to say about the actual data, which is what's interesting here?

← PreviousPage 3 of 26Next →