HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

rhelmer

658 karma · joined May 14, 2010

submissionscomments
rhelmer··on The likely end of DownThemAll
Good points, and I'll respond to the "sunk cost" bit by adding that backwards compatibility is a double-edged sword. My favorite pet example of this is MS versus Apple - the former has historically cared deeply about being backwards compatible, while the latter has gone through several hardware and software architecture changes that have required total rewrites from third-party developers.

The situation with Firefox is a little trickier, staying backwards-compatible for web content has always been an important goal, but anything living inside the browser chrome does not get the same assurances.

Right now extensions live somewhere between these two worlds, and we've had over a decade of experience with them so I think it's time to carve out their own space, with dependable APIs that are more stable than the internal browser APIs, but faster-moving and more privileged than the web.

rhelmer··on The likely end of DownThemAll
First, see https://billmccloskey.wordpress.com/2015/08/21/firefox-add-o...

1. these ideas are being announced far in advance of any actual changes

2. firefox devs (see link above) actively want to support current popular extensions, by adding to the Web Extension APIs

In fact, you can participate in this discussion with Mozilla devs more directly: https://webextensions.uservoice.com/forums/315663-webextensi...

Nobody working on Firefox wants to take away your most useful extensions, become a "clone" of Chrome (or any other browser) or otherwise has ulterior motives. The goals is really about improving performance and security and making add-ons easier to write and port between browsers.

rhelmer··on Hackpad source code
Looks like there's an OSX client in https://github.com/dropbox/hackpad/tree/master/client/osx
rhelmer··on Warning after security experts hack Tesla car
Thought experiments are fun, but I am coming to a different conclusion. I agree that it changes the risk analysis, but I don't think that it's necessarily for the worse. Performance doesn't necessarily improve under pressure, and extreme risk aversion can cause some funny side effects - for instance working around known bugs rather than risk correcting them.

Is there any data to support the "only possible result" that you conclude? Or, maybe examples of high-quality software that doesn't have any kind of high-frequency automatic update mechanism?

rhelmer··on Warning after security experts hack Tesla car
> It could be argued that the existence of an OTA mechanism incentivizes lower quality (RTM patches)

Is there any evidence of this? I think of automatic updates more like a safety net, or a seat belt.

Does the presence of those things change how acrobats or drivers perform?

rhelmer··on How We Deploy Python Code
I've used fpm to make rpm and deb packages that simply include a virtualenv, it works ok.

One of the significant tradeoffs to this approach is you lose the carefully-crafted tree-of-dependencies that the distros favor, so it makes the package pretty much automatically unacceptable to package maintainers.

However, being able to have install instructions that amount to "yum/apt-get install <package>" is pretty great.

I am hoping for an app/container convergence at some point, but we might need to drop the fine-grained dependency dream and have them be more self-contained, like Mac OS X apps.

rhelmer··on Chromium unconditionally downloads binary blob
Can you please cite where you read that proprietary blobs are used? IIRC the Pocket client is open-source, and so is the Hello client (it's basically a webapp that uses WebRTC)
rhelmer··on Nasty Lockup Issue Still Being Investigated for Linux 3.18
Reversible debugging might help more here than snapshots, since it allows you to record a failure and then debug it: http://rr-project.org/
rhelmer··on Mozilla, Virtual Reality, and the Dawn of the Metaverse?
The site in question is not hosted by Mozilla, but embeds video hosted by vid.ly, which air.mozilla.com also uses.

You certainly don't have to go out of your way on my account! If you'd like help with crashes or anything else, let me know or file a bug.

Nobody has been able to reproduce the problem you hit with the video, although I appreciate knowing about it. It's pretty difficult to test arbitrary sites with different sets of addons and other local config, so I certainly appreciate if you don't have time/desire to dig in further.

rhelmer··on Mozilla, Virtual Reality, and the Dawn of the Metaverse?
I filed https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1097572 to track the issue you're seeing with the JS player - I think it's vid.ly not air.mozilla.org that's not working, but it's worth looking into.

Can you send me more info on your crashes? I work on crash collection and reporting. If you put about:crashes in the address bar and hit enter, you can click on some of the crashes there and send the links to me.

Is this the Ubuntu Firefox build or did you download it from Mozilla? (they do their own builds)

rhelmer··on Celebrating 10 Years of Firefox
Profile manager UI is still around and used to be easier to get to (there's a command-line option for it now), but it was too easy to accidentally remove profiles and also confusing for people who got into it accidentally.

Profilist is relatively new and doesn't allow profile deletion, but to me still seems like the kind of feature that's great as an add-on but not used by so many people and confusing to less power-users.

rhelmer··on California’s strawberry industry is hooked on dangerous pesticides
Certain organic pesticides, which generally take less time to break down in the environment than synthetic and so tend to need larger doses, are allowed on certified organic farms. Also there's a chance of things like E. coli from contact with manure (commonly used as a fertilizer, although it's supposed to be aged and/or treated as part of the organic certification in the US), or just from bacteria normally present in soil.

So, make sure you wash fruits and vegetables before eating, whether grown on organic-certified farms or not!

(EDIT - s/more time/less time/)

rhelmer··on Don't run 'strings' on untrusted files
I wonder if there'd be less friction to porting a BSD - FreeBSD already uses clang to build the kernel+userland, for instance.
rhelmer··on Firefox OS Shows Continued Global Growth
Mozilla can't provide base images without licensing proprietary software (for the RIL primarily, although there may be others depending on the hardware).

Also the focus for Mozilla right now is on providing new low-end hardware and optimizing for that. It's possible to build and flash onto your own hardware, people on the XDA forums have done it.

Testing web apps in the simulator (or just with the responsive design tool) is totally doable right now, but it's hard to get an idea of performance without actually testing on a target device.

rhelmer··on Mozilla Unveils $33 Intex Cloud FX Smartphone
Here is the Mozilla blog on the subject:

https://blog.mozilla.org/blog/2014/08/25/first-firefox-os-sm...

The phone is for sale on snapdeal.com but I am not sure that it's available outside of India right now.

rhelmer··on Mozilla Unveils $33 Intex Cloud FX Smartphone
Apps are built using web technologies like HTML5 and JS - this doesn't mean the phone is "always-connected", the review is incorrect on this point.

Some apps are offline, some are only online, many are both. This is just like other popular smartphone platforms.

rhelmer··on Mozilla to sell '$25' Firefox OS smartphones in India
FirefoxOS has lower resource requirements than Android - for example this $25 device has only 128MB of RAM. FxOS (an it's app ecosystem) is still very young (1.3 just came out, and the first release came out at the end of 2012). I'm positive that we'll continue to see dramatic performance improvements as well as feature parity with the dominant platforms, along with the app ecosystem continuing to mature.

On the app developer side, making apps requires no specialized development environments or knowing anything beyond web technologies (HTML/JS/CSS), which dramatically lowers the bar for making apps.

I'm not sure what counts as "truly remarkable", personally I am pretty impressed by games like Cut the Rope on my FirefoxOS phone. I also carry and regularly use an outdated Android device that has very similar specs, and it's not particularly responsive. More apps are available, but the average quality is not very high.

rhelmer··on Mozilla to sell '$25' Firefox OS smartphones in India
I wouldn't call FirefoxOS a "thin client" (if that's what you meant) - it has a concept of "packaged apps" in which the app and all its assets are packaged and downloaded to the phone, and loaded from there. The built-in "certified" apps (like Phone, Music, Calendar and so on) don't require loading anything from the network at all, for instance.

You can think of FirefoxOS apps the same way conceptually you'd think of them on Android/iOS, except they are always written in open web technologies (HTML/JS/CSS).

App developers do have the option to provide "hosted" apps to the store (which is basically a regular web page but without browser chrome), however even in this case writing HTML5 apps that work offline is totally doable using existing cross-browser standards.

rhelmer··on Mozilla to sell '$25' Firefox OS smartphones in India
Where do you see $70? The article talks about current phones that you can buy right now at that price - those are different from the new $25 phones (which will be sold in India in "the next few months" also according to the article):

"The current handsets, which are sold via eBay, retail at £59.99 in the UK, or $69.99 in the US."

rhelmer··on IRS misses XP deadline, pays Microsoft millions for patches
I think the most important factor is that Microsoft puts a ton of effort into backwards compatibility, to make sure that it is always easier/less risk to upgrade Windows (and Office) than to switch to something else.

I know that in the corporate world there are still very many business applications that are mission-critical and very special-purpose (sometimes custom) that were not written in a cross-platform way, and may not be maintained anymore - I would be shocked to find out that it was not this way in the government too.

rhelmer··on Brendan Eich
Brendan was the CEO of Mozilla Corporation, which is a subsidiary of the non-profit Mozilla Foundation:

https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/foundation/moco/

rhelmer··on PostgreSQL Columnar Store for Analytic Workloads
Very cool! Thanks for contributing this.
rhelmer··on PostgreSQL Columnar Store for Analytic Workloads
Don't you still need to purchase citus DB to use this?
rhelmer··on Mozilla and Epic Preview Unreal Engine 4 Running in Firefox
The new UI (Australis) has landed on the Firefox Aurora channel, if you'd like to check it out for yourself: https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/channel/#aurora
rhelmer··on Mozilla and Epic Preview Unreal Engine 4 Running in Firefox
There is a link in this blog post to one from late last year that describes the first commercial game powered by asm.js being launched: https://blog.mozilla.org/blog/2013/12/12/first-3d-commercial...
rhelmer··on 2014 Goals
A lot of non-technical people use Firefox - somebody had to introduce them. If it was just about IE not being good and tabs, why not Opera?

Mozilla had (and still has) a lot of people spreading the word - the Spread Firefox campaign was very popular, as was the crowdfunded New York Times ad: https://blog.mozilla.org/press/2004/12/mozilla-foundation-pl...

rhelmer··on 2014 Goals
It's already been addressed that individual teams at Mozilla have more specific goals with more actionable metrics, but in Mozilla's case I disagree that engineers cannot sign up users. Firefox didn't have a sales team to get its current marketshare.

We do it in person for friends and family, we do it through discussion and diagnosing problems on hackernews and twitter etc.

Source: I work in Mozilla engineering and I help people out online and offline with Firefox all the time, clear up misconceptions people have etc.

rhelmer··on Firefox OS 1.3
I don't know the state of hardware support for random low-end phones is, but Mozilla just announced that a $25 phone with Spreadtrum that is in the works: https://blog.mozilla.org/blog/2014/02/23/firefox-os-unleashe...

Right now the least expensive phone you can buy right now that FirefoxOS definitely works on (that I am aware of) is the ZTE Open.

There isn't any official effort from Mozilla to port to existing devices that I know of, but there is a porting guide if you want to get your hands dirty: https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/Firefox_OS/Porting

I know that existing Android ROM hacking communities have made some progress too, but I personally use a phone that explicitly supports FirefoxOS (Geeksphone Keon) which I am pretty happy with. I'll probably switch to the new reference device (the Flame) once it is available, although I'm really interested in the $25 Spreadtrum model too.

rhelmer··on $25 Smartphones on Firefox OS to Rock MWC
The underlying rendering engine (Gecko, FirefoxOS "Boots to Gecko" hence the codename is "B2G") is the same - all apps (including the Browser app on the phone) are written in HTML5/JS/CSS: https://wiki.mozilla.org/B2G

B2G is different than Desktop Firefox in some ways, for instance it uses multiple processes (this is being worked on for Desktop, it's already in use for plugins for instance) and supports some new APIs to access the hardware on the phone that you'd expect: https://wiki.mozilla.org/WebAPI

rhelmer··on $25 Smartphones on Firefox OS to Rock MWC
Fennec is not the core of FirefoxOS, no. Gecko is the core of both, but Fennec provides an Android UI. Fennec's requirements are more tied to what the underlying Android version supports.

FirefoxOS is in fact working on requiring even less memory - there is a project underway to support devices with 128MiB: https://wiki.mozilla.org/FirefoxOS/Tarako

← PreviousPage 4 of 6Next →