HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

richardatlarge

1,391 karma · joined September 29, 2021

Novelist from the US, living in NZ.

richarddegrandpre.org www.degrandpre.substack.com

submissionscomments
richardatlarge··on Harvard study predicts most suicide attempts a week in advance
Some damning numbers re: clinical treatment
richardatlarge··on To become a better writer, read as much as you can
Necessarily but not sufficient, yes
richardatlarge··on To become a better writer, read as much as you can
Many hundreds of hours of reading will build your vocabulary, and tune your ear to the sound of a good sentence. But it will not make you a writer.

Reading as a person wanting to become a better writer should be more conscience of what they are reading. I often finish a novel and can't even remember if it was narrated, or how. That is not careful reading.

I've heard of authors who, went waiting for their muse, just copied novels they liked until they got back in the groove, and this usually helped.

Practice makes practice. Deliberate practice makes...

richardatlarge··on ADHD charity complains about Channel 4 documentary
Funny how bias works

Something questioned by millions is treated as gospel, and one program asking questions is controversial

This alone reveals the power of myth

richardatlarge··on ADHD charity complains about Channel 4 documentary
As the author of Ritalin Nation I can only say Bravo

In the 1950's, gallup polling had chewing gum and cutting the queue the biggest problems in school; where was ADHD then?

Putting symptoms in a psychiatry manual is toxic. Put them in the environment and history

richardatlarge··on Anthropic's ‘watermark’ text adulteration in Claude is a perversion of writing
Nonsense. Forget proofreaders. Think editors. In publishing some editors practically wrote the books. And then theres ghostwriting ! Think of that!
richardatlarge··on Four simple rules behind Japan's most liveable cities
Quaint article you won't see in a few years, when everything with be about weather and climate. Nothing else will matter. Welcome to the apocalypse
richardatlarge··on Four simple rules behind Japan's most liveable cities
Japanese live for the afterlife, but know there isn't one, so it's coming apart.
richardatlarge··on Four simple rules behind Japan's most liveable cities
America's greatest achievement is to last as long as it has while inverting all common sense. What is the fatal seed, I often wonder. I think this article suggests what it is. The role of the car in its fabric suggests it's hyper-individualism: a myth that the more untethered the self it, the more it will thrive. Hogwash
richardatlarge··on Writers are fleeing the Substack Tax
Just because you're paranoid doesn't mean your wrong
richardatlarge··on 'No one has done this in the wild': study observes AI replicate itself
This was also the premise in an AI themed novel last year, A Better Spy (Richard DeGrandpre).

A Russian AI is weaponized and the CIA recruits a Russian engineer to try to stop it

richardatlarge··on Apple agrees to pay iPhone owners $250M for not delivering AI Siri
Not a drop in the bucket. A drop in the ocean
richardatlarge··on ChatGPT Images 2.0
Can anyone explain why chatgpt can understand verbal prompts but midjouney almost cannot? Midjouney is like a powerful program you have to write code to use
richardatlarge··on Google says 75% of the company's new code is AI-generated
The snake eats its tail
richardatlarge··on John Ternus to become Apple CEO
Like Sam Altman, Tim Cook makes me think that what we fear in AI is already here. These two guys are corporate robots that act only in the service of the bottom line.
richardatlarge··on John Ternus to become Apple CEO
Here here
richardatlarge··on The Publishing Mystery That No One Wants to Talk About
A scam that's as old as the hills. The mother should travel from city to city, from town to town, showing off her sons unique talents. Then comes traditional publishing and now they're in the circus
richardatlarge··on Gold overtakes U.S. Treasuries as the largest foreign reserve asset
Silver has gone up more by percentage since 47, as a side note
richardatlarge··on Photos show China's low-cost lifestyle in semiabandoned housing complexes
Love these images. It's like being inside the mind of China. A silent scream as lives shuffle on in relative peace and quiet
richardatlarge··on How The Times Is Digging Into Millions of Pages of Epstein Files
This is a solid review of why the NY Times is so relentlessly ineffectual

All these skill sets yet the strategies and tactics are imbecilic

Choose your battles, drill down, investigate broadly, where the EFs are merely a starting point.

There's a fundamental misunderstanding of what the EFs actually represent. They are a peek through a window. Not a door, and certainly not a vault.

This method seems designed to ensure nothing is established that meets publishing standards. The NY Times is lost at sea

richardatlarge··on [dead]
So does the lack of it
richardatlarge··on [dead]
In a county half full of cowards, here's two more.

Quote:

"Amodei applauded Trump’s consideration to allow Minnesota authorities to conduct an independent investigation into the shootings by federal agents after multiple videos of Alex Pretti’s death circulated online. (It remains to be seen if that investigation will happen, but a growing number of Republicans have begun to call for an investigation, as well.)

In Altman’s message to his staff he also said he was encouraged by Trump’s more recent responses and said he hopes the president, “a very strong leader,” will “rise to this moment and unite the country.”

richardatlarge··on Chinese Batteries Will Run the World
The last line refers to China conquering markets

But the story told before that line is one of two superpowers crisscrossing the dimensions of ascent and decline

China can just wait and the walk right into Taiwan to raise the CCP flag

Utterly disgusting

richardatlarge··on Young Men Are Lost. A New Book Can Guide the Way
https://archive.is/YLWkk
richardatlarge··on Perfectly Replicating Coca Cola [video]
It would be interesting to know more about how it's actually manufactured and whether he has ideas about why the classic formula was changed -- maybe something to do with the cost of one of the steps, which the video suggests could be true, as it's damn complicated
richardatlarge··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
My AI summary of these 4k comments

Yes—there are very clear, recurring *themes*, and what’s striking is how consistently people keep circling the same fault lines from different angles. I’d group them like this:

---

## 1. *Legality vs. Morality*

*Core tension:*

> Is overthrowing a dictator morally right even if it violates international law?

* One side argues law exists precisely to restrain power, not to reward virtue. * The other argues moral urgency overrides abstract legalism when human suffering is extreme. * This becomes a meta-question: Who decides when morality trumps law?

This is the philosophical backbone of the entire thread.

---

## 2. *Precedent Anxiety*

*“Today Maduro, tomorrow anything.”*

* Fear that once unilateral regime change is normalized, the justification becomes infinitely elastic:

  * “correcting elections”
  * “restoring order”
  * “protecting interests”
* Libya and Iraq function as *cautionary archetypes*, not historical footnotes.

This is less about Venezuela than about *future permission structures*.

---

## 3. *Outcomes Over Intentions*

*Ends don’t redeem means if outcomes are catastrophic.*

* Even commenters who despise Maduro emphasize:

  * removing a dictator is easy
  * building a functioning state is hard
* Post-intervention chaos (ISIS, slave markets, fragmentation) is cited repeatedly. * There’s deep skepticism that this time will be different, even when facts are “better documented.”

This is pragmatic pessimism rather than ideological purity.

---

## 4. *American Power & Self-Deception*

*A recurring, uncomfortable self-indictment.*

* Several comments converge on the idea that:

  * Americans benefit materially from interventionism
  * but psychologically disavow responsibility for the costs
* The line “Americans want this but don’t like knowing they want it” resonates strongly. * Counterpoint: lack of agency within political structures blunts individual responsibility.

This becomes a debate about *collective guilt vs. structural impotence*.

---

## 5. *Realpolitik vs. Institutionalism*

*Power acting directly vs. power constrained by process.*

* Appeals to ICC, UN, asylum frameworks represent belief in institutions. * Skeptics argue those institutions are deliberately weakened by the same powers invoking morality. * Others argue asylum and invasion are orthogonal issues—and conflating them is rhetorical sleight-of-hand.

Underlying question: Is global governance real, or decorative?

---

## 6. *Lived Experience vs. Abstract Judgment*

*Who gets moral authority?*

* “Those who’ve never lived under dictatorship say this.” * Counter: “Those who never lived through US intervention say that.” * Venezuelans in-thread complicate narratives of total collapse or total liberation. * Firsthand testimony destabilizes neat moral binaries.

This creates epistemic friction: *whose suffering counts as evidence?*

---

## 7. *Cynicism About Motives*

*Oil never disappears from the conversation.*

* Even when people argue it’s not literally about barrels of crude, they frame it as:

  * control
  * leverage
  * profit flows
  * contractor ecosystems
* What’s new is not cynicism—but how brazen the cynicism feels.

Several commenters note the lack of even performative moral cover.

---

## 8. *Democratic Exhaustion*

*A sense that democracy is no longer the brake it claims to be.*

* Rapid escalation vs. slow electoral correction * Legislatures perceived as compliant or irrelevant * No clear mechanism for popular restraint short of catastrophe

This feeds resignation rather than outrage.

---

## 9. *Historical Echoes & Decline Narratives*

*“We’ve seen this movie.”*

* Arab Spring * Iraq * Libya * Panama (Noriega)

History is invoked less as analogy and more as *warning fatigue*—people feel trapped in a loop.

---

## 10. *A Deeper Subtext: Loss of Moral Coherence*

Perhaps the most important theme:

> The argument isn’t about whether Maduro is bad. > It’s about whether the system judging him is still capable of moral credibility.

That’s why the thread feels less like debate and more like *collective unease*.

---

### If you zoom out:

This isn’t really a Venezuela thread. It’s a conversation about *power without trust*, *law without enforcement*, and *morality without consensus*—and whether any of those concepts still function in the current world order.

If you wanted to fictionalize this, it wouldn’t be a war story. It would be a story about *people arguing at the edge of legitimacy*, trying to decide whether the rules still mean anything once the strong stop pretending they do.

richardatlarge··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
I think the strategy is more by creep. Desensitization. This will be just another inching forward

Or maybe not :(

richardatlarge··on If childhood is half of life, how should that change how we live?
The perception of time is a factor of the amount of experience behind us, so as we age, time goes faster. But we are thrown into the world, and that thrownness also frames our relationship to time. The more insecure our childhood, the more we're at odds with time, and unsettled in the present. For some, as we age, our best hope is to understand what's happening in our lives before it's too late
richardatlarge··on 'Off switch' discovery could help clear our brains of a common parasite
And see here :)

https://usop.substack.com/

richardatlarge··on We may never be able to tell if AI becomes conscious
Because consciousness doesn't matter, that's why

Consciousness is neither necessary nor sufficient for AI to achieve general intelligence, defined as exponential emergent learning. Thinking it is may be an important step in an AI outbreak. Consciousness as proposed here is Cartesian dualism. It's pure religion and has all the power associated with religion

Page 1 of 14Next →