HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

richardfeynman

467 karma · joined September 16, 2011

submissionscomments
richardfeynman··on Israeli group claims it’s using back channels to censor “inflammatory” content
At the beginning of 1945 the allies had most of germany occupied. The nazis didn't surrender, and the allies killed countless german civilians until they did. Who was responsible for their deaths? The allies or the nazis?

Also, reporters without borders is not at all reputable. Here is one of countless rebuttals to their position: https://www.camera.org/article/using-journalists-lives-as-cu...

richardfeynman··on Israeli group claims it’s using back channels to censor “inflammatory” content
haha
richardfeynman··on Israeli group claims it’s using back channels to censor “inflammatory” content
It is absolutely 100% mainstream, repeated in almost every speech by Israeli politicians at a ratio of maybe 100:1 that the war goals are what I stated versus what you concocted. I understand it's tough for you to know this since you don't speak hebrew and may not follow Israeli media, but I can assure you--assure you as someone who has followed this topic for 20 years, criticized the Israeli government for 20 years, marched with free palestine-- that you're dead wrong in your assessment.

Also, not sure how much of an expert you are in the Genocide convention, but Israel allows free speech and like the United States it does not prosecute legislators for saying wild things.

There is a massive gulf between your confidence and knowledge.

richardfeynman··on Israeli group claims it’s using back channels to censor “inflammatory” content
I'm kind of tired of showing people evidence of rape, but yes, all the evidence does exist, and at some point you will see it. You can even find it today if you search around carefully.
richardfeynman··on Israeli group claims it’s using back channels to censor “inflammatory” content
Hey Paul, I just want to clarify that you are an idol of mine and I hugely respect your thinking. I've read your essays for decades. I think there may be an imbalance between your knowledge and confidence when it comes to these matters, but I still highly respect you and I know you're more philosemite than antisemite. Thanks for inspiring me for decades.
richardfeynman··on Israeli group claims it’s using back channels to censor “inflammatory” content
The declared aim is to make Gaza unlivable? Really? Israel has stated hundreds if not thousands of times that he declared aim is to (1) destroy hamas's ability to wage war; (2) return the hostages; and (3) prevent such an attack from recurring.

Yes, there have been particular government officials who've said they want to make Gaza unlivable, just as there are crazies in the US congress and senate who say things like we should nuke the middle east.

In terms of the earth going around the sun, the point I was trying to make is that at first glance it does look like the sun goes around the earth, just as at first glance it looks like Israel is trying to reduce Gaza to rubble, but after careful observation and adherence to scientific thinking we learn that the earth goes around the sun -- and that Israel is not carpet bombing gaza.

richardfeynman··on Israeli group claims it’s using back channels to censor “inflammatory” content
With regard to the evidence for sexual violence, can I ask you what would be an acceptable form of evidence for you that doesn't include watching a video of a girl getting raped?

Also, with regard to the beheadings, I know this is uncomfortable, but it's worth looking into a bit more than you have. There is lots of evidence that would pass muster in any court.

richardfeynman··on Israeli group claims it’s using back channels to censor “inflammatory” content
It's hard to believe that the earth goes around the sun!

Yes, there is lots of destruction. Yes, that's regrettable. No, that doesn't mean Israel is carpet bombing.

richardfeynman··on Israeli group claims it’s using back channels to censor “inflammatory” content
Friend, Israel has a shitty party in power and a shitty prime minister in power, but that doesn't mean it's not a liberal democratic state. It's pretty obvious that you don't know much about Israel. Do you know that the kibbutzim that were attacked on october 7 were full of people who used to go to Gaza to drive gazans to Israeli hospitals? I myself have donated to gazans and marched with palestinians for decades. I will not stand silent as people who know much less than they think they do make overconfident statements maligning Israel.
richardfeynman··on Israeli group claims it’s using back channels to censor “inflammatory” content
The UN is unfortunately not a credible source when it comes to this issue. Hostages have been held at UN employees' houses; the UN failed to condemn the October 7 attack for months; and they denied that rape occurred for months.

While you rely on authorities, I'll do what enlightenment thinkers do. Ask questions like "how" and "what is their method."

richardfeynman··on Israeli group claims it’s using back channels to censor “inflammatory” content
Of course target selection matters, as does the existence of checks and balances associated with each strike. There is lots of destruction because Hamas built its military infrastructure in and under urban environments.

Maybe this is semantics to you, but to me carpet bombing implies indiscriminate bombing, which is the opposite of what Israel has done, despite its having dropped many bombs.

richardfeynman··on Israeli group claims it’s using back channels to censor “inflammatory” content
Nobody is asking you to be a domain expert. When it comes to almost any other issue, people ask how and demand evidence. But when it comes to Hamas's claims of a certain number of dead, nobody seems to ask "How do they calculate it? Are they looking at morgue data? Are they doing photographs of mass burial sites, as Ukraine did? What is their method?"

So people are asking you to be scientific and critical rather than to uncritically repeat the claims of a belligerent in combat.

Finally, I'm not sure if you're saying this facetiously or if you genuinely don't know what Israel is capable of, or the lengths its gone to to reduce civilian harm but Israel is not doing indiscriminate mass slaughter. That's what Hamas did on October 7.

richardfeynman··on Israeli group claims it’s using back channels to censor “inflammatory” content
Can you name a country that doesn't allow news censorship by their military during combat? The same exact thing happens with US journalists embedded with the US military. It's obvious operational security. I'm guessing you don't speak hebrew, but Israeli journalists are even more critical of their government than American journalists.
richardfeynman··on Israeli group claims it’s using back channels to censor “inflammatory” content
Carpet bombing is what the allies did to Dresden. Carpet bombing is indiscriminate. For every bomb that israel drops there is a lawyer approving it. There is lots of damage, particularly in the north (which Israel did its best to evacuate before bombing), because Hamas had built military infrastructure virtually everywhere: under schools, UN buildings, under residential houses, hospitals, etc.

I'm not trying to say there has been little damage to Gaza. There's been lots. But that doesn't mean it's been carpet bombed. There's lots of damage because there was lots of military infrastructure.

richardfeynman··on Israeli group claims it’s using back channels to censor “inflammatory” content
Great - I'll rely on scientific thinking -- nullius in verba -- and ask questions I'd ask anyone else about how they gather their data, how they know what they claim to know, etc. You believe in the church when it says the sun revolves around the earth.
richardfeynman··on Israeli group claims it’s using back channels to censor “inflammatory” content
The blame for kids dying lies on Hamas for (1) recruiting child soldiers; (2) building weapons factories in children's bedrooms; (3) building terror tunnels under schools; (4) preventing civilians from evacuating from the north... I could go on.

Not sure if you're a Hebrew reader, but you don't know what you're talking about with regard to journalism in Israel. Have you ever read Gideon Levy? There is tons of criticism of the government and its conduct in this war in Israeli media.

Sorry these facts make you ill. Get better soon!

richardfeynman··on Israeli group claims it’s using back channels to censor “inflammatory” content
That's like saying America isn't a liberal democratic state because of Trump and the republican party. Israel is a liberal democracy, far more liberal than America, and there were hundreds of thousands of people who marched against Netanyahu.
richardfeynman··on Israeli group claims it’s using back channels to censor “inflammatory” content
"I believe there is very little reason to assume the numbers are not accurate."

How are the numbers generated?

richardfeynman··on Israeli group claims it’s using back channels to censor “inflammatory” content
So confident yet so wrong.

- Israel has not carpet bombed gaza. They've used a higher portion of smart bombs than any other military in history and use F16s to guide their dumb bombs. Israel has dropped more than 25,000 bombs, and according to the high estimates fewer than 25,000 palestinians have been killed, meaning each bomb kills less than one person. Israel also establishes humanitarian corridors, drops leaflets, sends evacuation warnings, allows in aid, establishes safe zones, and much more.

- Nobody knows how many Palestinian journalists have been murdered. Gaza does not have a free press. What we do know is that many militants posing as journalists have been killed. See: https://www.camera.org/article/using-journalists-lives-as-cu...

- You're upset that Israel imprisons minors like these guys? https://www.wionews.com/world/are-hamas-resorted-to-training... Save some of your outrage for Hamas using child soldiers. Also, plenty of other countries, including the United States, imprison minors.

- I can see you've been listening to lots of Norman Finkelstein? Israel does not just wake up one day and say "let's mow the lawn" - each time they bomb gaza it's been in response to something like a suicide bomb or stabbing, which has happened for decades in Israel.

- I see you think you're familiar with the Hannibal directive. Can you link me to the text of this directive? The principles are tactical rather than strategic and followed by many other militaries, including the US.

richardfeynman··on Israeli group claims it’s using back channels to censor “inflammatory” content
Hi keefle, thanks for taking the time to write this in such a reasonable, friendly way. I appreciate that. I notice you still didn't answer the question of how the Gaza Health Ministry gets their data. Do you have confidence in their methods? Are they going into North Gaza (now controlled by Israel) and looking at dead bodies?

1. No it wasn't, despite the link PG shared. See: https://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-28688179 . This won't surprise you but the Gaza Health Ministry also put out false data during COVID.

2. The American government's position has shifted over time from outright denial of the Health Ministry numbers to "we don't know, but we do know there are too many deaths." Let's see how it continues to shift as the conflict evolves.

4. Remember the context. You asked for an instance of the Gaza Health Ministry lying and I provided one. Are you now saying the 500 dead figure was accurate? Because if so, you're wrong that the matter is unsettled. While the exact estimates vary from as few as a dozen KIA to ~300 KIA, the entire open source intelligence community, all western intelligence agencies, and most publications agree the initial death toll was wrong. Also--not to be pedantic--but the NYT retracted their early coverage of the al Ahli hospital incident; the piece you link to was widely panned by open source intelligence experts; and it doesn't actually question the incident -- it just calls into question one particular piece of evidence.

5. I don't think you're following the narrative. Israel has said that the total death toll may be roughly 30% lower than what the Gaza Health Ministry asserts, but they also argue the list is NOT accurate. The list says almost everyone dead are women and kids, whereas Israel claims that roughly 8,000 militants have been killed and 1,000 captured.

richardfeynman··on Israeli group claims it’s using back channels to censor “inflammatory” content
I'll answer your question, but first I'll ask you a question: Do you know how the Gaza Health Ministry generates their death toll? What do you think of their methods? My guess is you don't know but you trust it because you see these numbers repeated in the media (just like China's COVID death toll).

If you ask me how Israel calculates its death toll the answer is pretty simple: they use archaeologists, forensic medical teams, and more

One of the most obvious examples of a prior discrepancy was the Health Ministry claiming that ~500 innocent civilians died when Israel bombed al Ahli hospital. Of course, we later discovered the hospital wasn't bombed, the parking lot was, the bomb wasn't dropped by Israel but was rather an errant rocket from Hamas, and that far fewer people died. In other words, a series of lies. The Health Ministry never corrected the death toll and kept adding from that.

Beyond this, here's one of many analyses casting shade on the Health Ministry's statistics: https://twitter.com/Aizenberg55/status/1744381711993946209

You can google around for dozens more. As I said to the prior commenter, I'd rather not have a debate here about whether the numbers are accurate (not because I'm not confident but rather because of the famous XKCD) and I simply mean to point out that Paul Graham has one standard for China's COVID death toll and a completely different standard for Hamas's Health ministry figures.

richardfeynman··on Israeli group claims it’s using back channels to censor “inflammatory” content
Yes, of course there is reason to suspect Hamas is untrustworthy. I'm not trying to argue one should take Israel's word at face value (of course you should subject it to scrutiny as well), but yes, Israel, a liberal democratic state with a free press, strong left-wing movement, and the second biggest tech sector out of silicon valley, is far more trustworthy than Hamas, a repressive, fundamentalist, authoritarian regime with no free press. This doesn't mean they always tell the truth, but there is no equivalence between them and Hamas.

In terms of specific reasons to doubt the Gaza Health Ministry numbers specifically, I could go on forever about that, but I don't see the point of doing so on HN. It's not a tech-related question.

richardfeynman··on Israeli group claims it’s using back channels to censor “inflammatory” content
It was certainly interesting to see Paul Graham, famous for his skepticism of China's COVID numbers, immediately embrace the Gaza Ministry of Health's death toll, without understanding how they themselves generate it.
richardfeynman··on Autonomous Agents and Agent Simulations
These agents, even in their embryonic form, are so powerful. The world is about to change. I'm convinced we're at the beginning of a massive exponential.
richardfeynman··on Scaffolded LLMs as natural language computers
I agree that there are still differences between humans and AI, and vision is one of them. Humans also remember across conversations, ChatGPT doesn't. We have longer context windows. We think in our downtime, unprompted. We take input from 5 senses, today's chatGPT only takes input from text.

But--and this is a big but--the set of things that people can do better than computers has shrunk significantly over the past five months. Today, thanks to GPT4, AI can get a B in a Quantum Computing class, generate engaging stories, know that the color yellow is closer to orange than blue (despite never having seen color!), answer emotionally laden questions with the sort of facility that IMO is better than most humans, write code, rhyme, and much more. All of this stuff was unthinkable before. I personally thought it would be centuries until this stuff was possible. I was very wrong.

Several developments in Deep Learning, like the Transformers paper (https://arxiv.org/abs/1706.03762), set off this growth, as did big data and increased computing power. The insight of particular humans, like Ilya Sutskever, played a role as well. But taken together, I actually don't understand how one can argue that we aren't at the beginning of a massive exponential.

Of course there are things humans can still do better than AI, but the number of things is shrinking rapidly, while the number of things computers can do better than humans is growing rapidly.

I argue that we are indeed at the beginning of an exponential, and we'll see both new classes of products and faster development time.

richardfeynman··on Show HN: Docalysis – AI chat with your documents
This is great. I used it to help me understand the Transformers paper, which I would not have been able to understand without it.
richardfeynman··on Text to Cartoon: How we created a cartoon from a prompt using ChatGPT and more
A step-by-step guide to how we created a basic kid's cartoon using a mix of AI tools including ChatGPT, resemble.AI, Stable Diffusion, Controlnet, Img2Img and more. The cartoon isn't perfect and this is just meant to be a proof of concept.
richardfeynman··on When did SVB insiders begin to realize they were in trouble?
Thanks for this, this is a fair critique!
richardfeynman··on When did SVB insiders begin to realize they were in trouble?
Did you read the article? From the article: "One thing to keep in mind is both Ms. Izurieta’s and Mr. Becker’s 10B5-1 plans were adopted just a month prior to the sales occurring, and these transactions appear to be one-time in nature. They’re arguably open market sales masquerading as 10B5-1 transactions."
richardfeynman··on Show HN: I “wrote” a kid's book with ChatGPT and Midjourney
Hey Obaid, I built something similar, https://storybird.ai/. Want to chat?
← PreviousPage 7 of 9Next →