HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

richardjordan

2,110 karma · joined March 20, 2012

physicist by education, hacker by choice, entrepreneur by compulsion

...and I use my real name because I stand by what I say. Doesn't mean I'm always right. Doesn't mean I won't change my mind or disagree with myself ten minutes later. But I'm okay with that.

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/richardjordan; my proof: https://keybase.io/richardjordan/sigs/GYNnuU1A-m6G3OTnz1QUilvgFcAy5PmckanOKFqhqnw ]

submissionscomments
richardjordan··on The Criminalization of Everyday Life
We live in an era of delicate balance between global overpopulation and resource depletion. We have exceeded the carrying capacity of the planet, we are at peak supply rates for oil and other essential resources. We're rendering things less habitable and global climate change - coupled with water table depletion and topsoil burnout - threatens to crash food crops in some key regions.

It's not a conspiracy. People who know things - and when you have wealth you have the ability to know things - tend to see that we have a period of incredibly instability coming involving a lot of dying and misery. In such a situation having a tight control of the masses and a control of resources in the hands of a tiny elite benefits that elite in ways that times of abundance make seem unnecessary.

richardjordan··on The Criminalization of Everyday Life
As someone broadly in political agreement with much on the left I never understand the obsession with rolling in Islamophobia with these things. At the end of the day religious movements are broadly intolerant, aboslutist and objectionable in nature. It's not a bad thing to fear the increase in power of religious totalitarians. They have a lot in common with many of the others you want to attack.

Even the most mainstream of Islamic voices tend to espouse positions on women's rights, sexual identity and tolerance which would be pilloried and decried if they came from our typical WASPy overlords.

richardjordan··on Simulations back up theory that Universe is a hologram
Of course this isn't helpful to the layman who thinks of holograms as things they get on a card in a cereal box.
richardjordan··on South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies
if that's what you suspect then you're grossly ignorant of world affairs for the second half of the 20th century
richardjordan··on South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies
Two people who have been heads of state of their respective countries are Obama and Mandela. Seems mentionable to me.
richardjordan··on South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies
An unfortunate turn of phrase, but it's not about pacifist white washing... his release from prison was into a society where apartheid had yet to be removed and he advocated that in many circumstances people need to use force to defend themselves against oppression for most of his life. The point is that it takes a certain obtuseness to focus on that when his crowning achievement was avoiding a bloodbath on transition away from South Africa, choosing instead a path of peace and reconciliation.

Also your flame-baiting attack on liberals is very confused - the key criticism by conservatives against liberals on this topic, for years, was their support for a terrorist who advocated violence, thereby themselves supporting violence. The truth is nuanced, but not to such a degree that it's incomprehensible to ordinary people.

richardjordan··on South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies
because typically they were coming here to raise money spent on placing bombs in parades of WWII veterans and in hospitals
richardjordan··on South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies
He's one of the most important world figures of the second half of the 20th century. Pretty legitimate news topic given the other non-tech topics that get plugged into this feed nowadays.
richardjordan··on South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies
but it also hasn't been the bloodbath many who lived there expected it to become on the fall of apartheid - and Mandela bears a huge portion of the credit for this
richardjordan··on South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies
His peaceful assumption of power and non-violent transition of government are his lasting legacies. His violent struggle which resulted in his imprisonment became his advocacy for peaceful transformation. As the movement became focused on peaceful resistance it gained moral weight against the brutal violence perpetrated by the South African government.

Emphasizing the non-peaceful roots, and the fact that there was much violence in the struggle against the oppression of apartheid is to ignore his own words on the topic and to only tell half a story.

richardjordan··on South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies
I still remember sitting in front of the tv for hours, the day he was released. The long, extended coverage of his exit from prison, delayed as he spent his time saying goodbye to inmates and captors alike.
richardjordan··on Why Do Brits Accept Surveillance?
Really? Not in my experience. I lived in Texas a few years and every job seemed to require drug testing and often credit checks. I always wondered why folks just didn't say fuck you but once I'd lived there a while I learned that in those parts of the country where people like to talk about freedom and independence they sure like to accept their obedient roles when it comes to companies telling them to jump.
richardjordan··on Why Do Brits Accept Surveillance?
I've never heard this in my life. I don't know a single Brit who finds the term offensive. Unless you're talking the. Brit Awarss. Now there's some bollocks.
richardjordan··on Why Do Brits Accept Surveillance?
I think to the contrary that Brits, an Europeans in general are vastly more sensitive to the threat of nazi-style or communist-like government - and corporate - oppression than Americans who are, by and large, complacent on this topic despite all the anti-government rhetoric you hear. As a result governments can't get away with as much because people watch closely. Combine this with the greater sense that the government runs the provision of critical services like healthcare and people have a better relationship with their government so fight over what matters, and there tends to be a good sense of what that is. Also the British political system is far more responsive to the electorate than is the US system which famously has less churn among elected officials than the old soviet politburo. This means that the electorate has more confidence in its ability to effect change.
richardjordan··on Why Do Brits Accept Surveillance?
In much of the US atheists are forbidden from holding many electe offices. This is not true in the UK. Fretting over the Lords Spiritual and their lately ceremonial role is to misunderstand the nature of political power and the lack thereof vested in the House of Lords, and in particular the non-party-political members.
richardjordan··on Why Do Brits Accept Surveillance?
On Her Majesty's Secret Service is a movie. OHMS (On Her Majesty's Service) meaning government business is a thing. And indeed a formality of language based on tradition. The former was a joke on the latter. It is most certainly not a real thing beyond the movie.
richardjordan··on My dad unexpectedly uses my Linux laptop to get real work done
Thanks for sharing. I know my comment adds little but I wanted to throw out there a nod of appreciation for a story like this.
richardjordan··on Entangled toy universe shows time may be an illusion
gotta love agreement :-)
richardjordan··on Entangled toy universe shows time may be an illusion
Agreed. Taking "ancient wisdom" too seriously and seeing it through a modern scientific lens is pretty much always too big-a-stretch to make.

Plus there's a difference between talking about psychological perception of time, as most religious texts do, and time as a measure of the evolution of physical systems in the scientific sense. Not the same thing.

richardjordan··on Entangled toy universe shows time may be an illusion
Right. But most people don't read math and reporters don't write it.
richardjordan··on Entangled toy universe shows time may be an illusion
No they have proof in math. He is clearly saying it's not a proof to explain to the layman interviewing him that he shouldn't go and write some stupid headline like "physicists prove that time is just an illusion".
richardjordan··on Entangled toy universe shows time may be an illusion
The problem is consistency with your approach. I am referring to theories that are consistent enough with each other to have useful predictive power. As you get bigger disconnects between theories their predictive power falls away.
richardjordan··on Entangled toy universe shows time may be an illusion
You're not comparing apples to apples when you compare ancient "theories" and modern scientific theory. Predicting that the sun will come up tomorrow, and why the sun will come up tomorrow are two very different levels of detail and granularity. The latter will have far more predictive power than the former.

No ancient theories had anything like the predictive power of modern theories, so were far less powerful. So when we talk about how the ancients had theories for this - we're talking orders of magnitude less complexity.

An analogy: when we were kids my brother took part in a guess the weight of the cake. The answer was 1.010 kg. My brother had guessed 1.005 kg and another boy had guessed 1.04 kg. They tried give it to the other kid - well his difference was "3 different" whereas my brother's was "5 different". Obviously anyone with a brain could see there was an order of magnitude difference in the precision of the two predictions.

Ancient theories are like that. Orders of magnitude less precise and therefore less predictive than modern theories. The differences tend to lead to dramatic differences in outcome making them fail to interweave in ways that are useful for us in the modern world - this is why, after all, we moved to the modern theories and they led to everything we have today.

Ancient theories didn't tend to connect in philosophically logical ways as do modern theories - this is reflected in their lack of predictive power. So when I say that the problems with tying theories together that modern physicists have are vast in our minds, but really amount to splitting hairs when we compare them to the differences between theories that preceded them, this is why.

richardjordan··on Entangled toy universe shows time may be an illusion
Those ancient theories are not philosophically and logically consistent. It's why we had the scientific revolution and the enlightenment in the first place. Because there were holes in those accounts. The degree to which Physicists are talking about inconsistencies are tiny compared to the huge holes in theories than the very primitive and simplistic ideas of the ancients.

As to your ending comment. That's the point. Without studying physics you're not going to understand the degree to which it already all plugs together very well. We would have no electronics nor satellites without an incredible level of agreement between theories and experiment supporting a tightly interconnected set of theories - they weren't going to happen with any pre-scientific revolution worldviews.

richardjordan··on Entangled toy universe shows time may be an illusion
This is one of those cases where the poetic language used to try to explain complex phenomena to lay persons is unhelpful. It doesn't really mean illusion in any sense consistent with what people might imagine that to mean.

Indeed it's not really that revelatory. "Experiment agrees with what we already pretty much know" would have been less interesting.

richardjordan··on Entangled toy universe shows time may be an illusion
You either believe in natural or supernatural explanations for the universe. If you accept the latter then the discussion is moot. If you're a scientist your approach is the first.

It is difficult, perhaps impossible, to come up with a philosophically sound logically consistant explanation for natural phenomenon which isn't unified and connected at a fundamental level. Two incompatible sets of natural explanations are vastly less likely than one unless we're falling back on superstition again.

Hence on some level there will be a unified way of approaching and talking about physical phenomena. Now, is that underlying consistent theory achievable? Well that's a different question. If the unified explanation for all natural things, at its heart, relies on physics we just don't have access to - either it's too small scale for us to ever probe, or too large scale, or no longer manifested at this point in the universe's life (there are examples of this I could describe but that'd make this post too long) - then of course we would not ever get to a satisfactory scientific account which is unified.

But efforts to get there tend to reveal other interesting things so are worthwhile even if we never achieve the final goal.

Plus because it's so specialized and inaccessible to the layman, the degree to which there's already tremendous consistency and unification in our theories of the underlying nature of things is dramatically underappreciated by most people.

richardjordan··on Redecentralize: Quietly, some geeks are decentralizing the net again
Exactly. With a well laid out webpage of text I can scan fairly quickly and get the gist - and also figure out how much time to spend on it or wherever to defer it etc. video only I tend to skip.
richardjordan··on Terrorism is not about Terror
What nonsense. The KKK are directly linked to countless acts of physical intimidation, violence and murder perpetrated against the targets of their prejudice.

Military units socialize over dinner, doesn't make them less lethal. I'm sure Al Qaeda members break the bread together from time to time, doesn't stop them being terrorists.

richardjordan··on Nreduce online incubator shuts down
I'm interested in that too if there's an attempt to redo this again with some changes. My email is just username at pretty much any email provider.
richardjordan··on Why We Hate Infographics
I loved the post but I agree that the energy infographic was a bad example to use because it's one of my favourite infographics. I have referred to versions of it often and find it very good at expressing some of the points I want to study or talk about.
← PreviousPage 3 of 19Next →