HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

riemannzeta

447 karma · joined May 29, 2008

submissionscomments
riemannzeta··on Scientists Learn How Genes Can Jump Between Species
It is truly amazing how similar this is to the descolada in Orson Scott Card's Speaker for the Dead

Quite a visionary that man.

riemannzeta··on TvOS for Developers
https://developer.apple.com/library/prerelease/tvos/document...
riemannzeta··on TvOS for Developers
They've got webviews. But what about browsers?

And will apple bluetooth keyboards connect?

riemannzeta··on Birth of the Moralizing Gods
what do you mean by "more successful"?
riemannzeta··on Birth of the Moralizing Gods
I agree. The Ashley Madison leak is a great example! It's almost like we have become our own super ego.
riemannzeta··on Birth of the Moralizing Gods
The question of whether specialization requires hierarchies is kind of the question that Coase sought to answer in the Nature of the Firm. To make a long story short, Coase thought the answer was "no" so long as it was more efficient for the specialists to contract with consumers of their services on a open market than it was for them to work together in a firm under managers. I think Coase's answer seems more obvious now thanks to the Internet. Back when he published it was pretty counterintuitive for a lot of people.

These days, I think hierarchy is required only where private information needs to be shared with the specialists in a carefully choreagraphed way. If we don't have to worry about who knows what when, then the specialists can synch up and deliver to customers just fine without managers. But if there's some super important private information that can only be shared in sequence with particular specialists in order to maximize a good result, then no hierarchy is a mess.

In other words, human hierarchy now is almost entirely derived from the architecture of private information.

riemannzeta··on Birth of the Moralizing Gods
Great question. What if it's something like the Internet itself -- i.e., the potential that somebody will capture and share a private act in a way that will become completely public and forever.
riemannzeta··on Birth of the Moralizing Gods
I find it pleasing that their theory is consistent with Julian Jaynes's theory about the origin of consciousness. One could view this even as an extension of Jaynes's theory. First, we became conscious, then self-conscious. Consciousness was a prerequisite to any form of society. Self-consciousness was a prerequisite to a moralistic society. The details of the form of deity seem to me a proxy for the underlying question about how the brain was evolving over this period.

Although the article notes that this fact is in dispute, at least to me it seems striking that there do not appear to have been any large-scale wholly atheistic or agnostic civilizations in history until recently. To continue the thought about the biological substrate for consciousness and self-consciousness, I wonder what that implies about whether or how are brains have evolved in the recent past? Is there some allele or set of alleles that express for pro-social tendencies that are required for pluralistic, capitalistic, atheistic/agnostic civilizations?

riemannzeta··on A metabolic master switch underlying human obesity
Another thanks. Probably the most value I've gotten out of 23andme to date
riemannzeta··on US Patent 9085897: Space elevator
Heinlein had a similar idea, which he described in The Moon is a Harsh Mistress

http://www.quora.com/How-feasible-would-the-catapults-from-t...

riemannzeta··on Presumption of stupidity
Despite the flaws in the rational model of economics and the efficient market hypothesis more generally, I have always been fond of the more humble, observant posture it gives us in considering others' behavior. The flaws in the rational model are well-known. But as a presumption, it certainly works better than its opposite.
riemannzeta··on Ask HN: Books with a high signal to noise ratio?
Great question. Reminds me of what Samuel Johnson had to say about Paradise Lost ("great, but nobody ever wished it was longer")

My $0.02:

Andy Groves - High Output Management fits your bill

Most Seneca

Robert Frost poems (but maybe S/N is TOO high for comfortable consumption here)

riemannzeta··on Apple's Cash Dilemma
Your question effectively answers my question.
riemannzeta··on Apple's Cash Dilemma
It seems like such a no-brainer for IRS policymakers to offer Apple (and companies like it) a tax holiday on foreign cash reserves. Smart for US, smart for them. What countervailing political forces hold that back? Is it simply that the US feels like it shouldn't have to negotiate how much a company like Apple should pay in tax?
riemannzeta··on Ask HN: What are the greatest discoveries in the last few years?
CRISPR, blockchain, and direct connection between brain and lymphatics system are way bigger, but this was a big one for economics and political science:

Zero-Determinant Strategies in Iterated Prisoners' Dilemma http://www.pnas.org/content/109/26/10409.full.pdf

riemannzeta··on Consciousness Began When the Gods Stopped Speaking
I have seen this called "chunking" by folks who study learning http://smile.amazon.com/Mind-Numbers-Science-Flunked-Algebra...
riemannzeta··on Consciousness Began When the Gods Stopped Speaking
Just about everything I've read about this book has gotten it wrong in the particulars. Jaynes's is a nuanced argument, with many caveats and exceptions. It may be impossible to do justice to it with a summary.

Anybody interested should just read Part I of the book. Parts II and III are where he starts to run off the rails a bit.

Although not a neuroscientist, my understanding is that a quite a few of his observations in Part I have been reproduced, along with a few of his speculative hypotheses.

In my experience, the main benefit of reading the book was in gaining a more precise definition of consciousness. We tend to have many different things in mind when we talk about consciousness. :-) Jaynes gets very precise about what he means by "consciousness" before he introduces his theory. Within the scope of his narrow definition, I find compelling his argument that consciousness developed after and as a result of language.

Also, for those who are also familiar with and fans of Tim Gallwey's The Inner Game of Tennis you should note that Gallwey first published a few years before Jaynes.

riemannzeta··on The tensor renaissance in data science
Although not a small amount of effort, it really helps to learn geometric algebra notation:

http://www.amazon.com/Geometric-Algebra-Physicists-Chris-Dor...

Once you get an intuitive grasp of bivectors, it's not hard to "see" tensors as a linear map of bivector into bivector.

riemannzeta··on Why Hasn’t the World Been Destroyed in a Nuclear War Yet?
Another explanation offered by Schelling is that nuclear is generically different, basically ickier than other explosives.

http://www.nobelprize.org/nobel_prizes/economic-sciences/lau...

Fukushima is kind of reinforcing that sense of ickiness to the long-term detriment of nuclear as an alternative energy source, which is unfortunate because to me at least it appears to be the most viable.

riemannzeta··on Why Hasn’t the World Been Destroyed in a Nuclear War Yet?
Glad you brought up Schelling. He gave a fairly compelling answer to the question posed in this article in his Nobel acceptance speech 10 years ago.

http://www.nobelprize.org/nobel_prizes/economic-sciences/lau...

riemannzeta··on The Slow Death of the University
The author would have benefitted from a bit of historical knowledge of the university as an institution. The English were making the same sort of complaints about Scottish universities in the 18th Century, and it's pretty clear from our perspective now where more of the insights emerged in that period.

While he may find it distasteful, the first university in Bologna appears to have formed around a core faculty who decided to start charging students for their lectures.

riemannzeta··on When You Lose Weight, Where Does It Go?
on closer inspection, this version is not nearly as good (and hence probably independent)
riemannzeta··on When You Lose Weight, Where Does It Go?
This appears to have been copied without attribution from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4pkSLKucVbM
riemannzeta··on Killing the Golden Goose? The changing nature of corporate research, 1980-2007 [pdf]
Yup. Compare that to MIT endowment's annual return. And guess where (a big chunk of) the MIT endowment gets invested (indirectly through VC funds)? The same startups that their alumni are founding.
riemannzeta··on Killing the Golden Goose? The changing nature of corporate research, 1980-2007 [pdf]
Universities are to organizations as cockroaches are to organisms. They're ridiculously inefficient and bureaucratic; but they're also the only form of organization likely to be around in 10,000 years.
riemannzeta··on Killing the Golden Goose? The changing nature of corporate research, 1980-2007 [pdf]
Irony alert! Note their conclusion:

" It may well be that other organizations -- smaller firms and universities -- are making up the shortfall in investment in research. According to this interpretation, what is happening is a reallocation of research from large corporate labs to more efficient cient organizations."

The suggestion that universities might be more efficient than private corporations at anything is almost comic.

But this isn't an error. There is actually something quite profound at work. It is indeed the case that "smaller firms and universities" are more efficient at commercializing new technology than most large corporations. But it's not the smaller firms and universities independently; it's the smaller firms and universities together as one super-entity.

In Silicon Valley, the grad students quit and found a startup. Their advisor joins the Board. The university creates the IP. The startup commercializes it.

The puzzle for me ten years ago was this: Where is the licensing revenue for the universities? If they're creating the IP, then how come they're not getting anything back?

The answer is that they are, but in the form of alumni donations. :-D

riemannzeta··on Killing the Golden Goose? The changing nature of corporate research, 1980-2007 [pdf]
Breaking from page 17 to 18:

"Finding that European firms display similar reductions in investment in science as American firms is not consistent with the idea that specific regulatory changes in American institutions drive the results of this paper."

This is a clever way to get at what effect SOX and Bayh-Dole have had on private large-enterprise investment in science, but the evidence and argument are a bit opaque. What counts as a "European" vs. "US" firm? Most corporations are global at the scale of interest to this argument. US regulations might still have had an effect, even on "European" firms.

Logically the best they can argue here is that the evidence is consistent with their hypothesis, not that the evidence is inconsistent with an alternative hypothesis that SOX and Bayh-Dole had an effect.

riemannzeta··on What Developing Acute Schizophrenia Feels Like
Sounds like hypomania triggered by the stress. You may be a mild case of bipolar. Definitely avoid marijuana.
riemannzeta··on What Developing Acute Schizophrenia Feels Like
I too found this interesting. I wonder also whether this particular individual was misdiagnosed as schizophrenic. Sounds pretty similar to a bipolar episode of mania, and marijuana is a documented trigger for bipolar mania.
riemannzeta··on Craig Gentry named MacArthur Fellow for work on fully homomorphic encryption
Ex patent lawyer. A very select crew.
← PreviousPage 5 of 6Next →