2,303 karma · joined May 9, 2009
Go Julian, go.
Secrets exist for many purposes, but their primary impact on history is to permit groups of people to organize in order to persecute other less organized groups of people. Ultimately, it was the combination of industrialization and secrets that made it possible for nation states to directly the cause the death of 160 million people in the 20th century. In these situations, the ability of individuals to influence the course of events is essentially nil. That's why you and I have not stopped the millions of murders in Darfur, the same as our parents did not stop them in Rwanda 17 years ago, and so on.
In this context, it really is not reasonable to argue that we would all be much safer if nobody was revealing the secrets of those who have too many secrets.
On the second point, the airline industry is notorious for cases where the whole industry quickly follows the changes initially tested by a single airline. That's an important part of the process through which we end up with air fuel surcharges and checked baggage fees. My point is that it's pretty fair to assume based on this subtle change in the fine print at one airline, that in a couple of years being stranded due to bad flying weather is going to be a substantially worse experience than it already is.
Through posts it links to all of the other good econ blogs: Krugman, Mankiw, as well as good articles in FT, NYTimes, Economist, etc.
Economic texts are notoriously boring, blogs are a good solution to that problem
http://www.gabrielweinberg.com/blog/2010/05/twitter-rt-test-...
Wasn't the CTO of Facebook just saying less than a week ago that : "users have complete control over their data, and as long as [the] user gives an application explicit consent, Facebook doesn't get in the way of the user using their data in your applications beyond basic protections like selling data to ad networks and other sleazy data collectors?" [1]
I sure hope I'm missing something here.
Obscure, but that's kind of the point with this sort of app
On a sidenote: You can definitely resolve the speed issues people are talking / complaining about by pre-computing and storing everything, instead of doing it on the fly
Which is why it's better to work on something truly innovative and disruptive that has the potential to become one of those key technologies. Elon Musk type stuff, rather than think X for Y to get buzzword soup and series A projects.
That said, if I really wanted to spend money on Textmate, yes, I would prefer to pay 50 bucks rather than either $4 or $8 monthly. At a $1 or $2 a month, I would probably be indifferent. To some element there's an issue of how long the purchaser will actually use the tool vs. how long they estimate they'll use it.
I agree with you 100% that we develop countermeasures because we know that these recurring monthly plans are dangerous. My sense is that we develop the countermeasures exactly because the monthly plans are so effective at separating us from our money, and that the countermeasures only partly offset the tendency. Of course, for you may have an outright aversion to the monthly plans, just as I have excessive frugality, but overall my sense is that for most people monthly plans go over better than upfront charges in most situations.
Think about 40 bucks a month for an alarm system, or 60 bucks for the gym. That's roughly 5-7k over a ten year time span, and even if you adjust for time value of money and the user having the cancellation option, at the end of the day it's ridiculously easier to get people to make a monthly payment for those sorts of services than it would be to get a one-time upfront multi-thousand dollar payment.
To them, working is a subset of having a job. They couldn't imagine themselves choosing to not have a job before retirement, and they assume that you look at it the same way.
The bottom line is that one of the hardest things in the world is looking at things from the other person's point of view. The truth is that it's something that all of us have to actively work on.
EDIT: This is the panel I was talking about ... http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1405320
I find myself often forgetting how dysfunctional a lot of organizations are, only to be spectacularly reminded of it, again and again. And there are people at those organizations who know they aren't going to be able to overhaul hiring, but they have a budget, and they have a problem, and there are not a lot of great options. Those are the target customers for something like this, not Google and Foursquare and AirBnB.
One approach to getting started would be to provide resume screening services to employers. I'm sure there are a bunch of service businesses like that today, but if you solve the problem like it is an NLP problem rather than an HR problem, that could be a differentiator.
At a large enough enterprise, I'm sure there are people who are applying for a bunch of different positions over an extended period of time, and just being able to solve that problem intelligently for that one enterprise is something that must be useful for some big firm out there. So I don't think you need to have a bunch of employers on the system to get started.
But that doesn't address the real challenge, which seems to be that your service provides clear benefits to the employer, but not for the employee. The employer gets better candidates, more efficiently, and almost every business that's hiring acknowledges that they have trouble finding enough good candidates.
What about the potential employee? Why would they want to participate in this sort of system vs. the status quo? That seems like the challenge to me, more than legal issues, or the employer side of the equation.
There is definitely terrific potential here, exactly because hiring is currently so inefficient: it'll be really interesting see how this idea develops.
Give Tesla a few years
http://chla.library.cornell.edu/cgi/t/text/pageviewer-idx?c=...
This is also the sort of thing where if one leader did it (Google, Twitter, etc.), it could basically force the others to follow.