1,028 karma · joined February 18, 2010
Said any group that has implemented certifications to make entry into their discipline more difficult to newcomers. "Craftsmanship certification" is something I wouldn't be shocked to see becoming a business in the next 10 years.
Especially when they want to write things in MSWord that you have to end up getting into your application.
It wasn't a heavily utilized feature so we deprecated it. Maybe if the community says there's a big need for this we'll bring it back?
You can try to make parallels to the record industry at its worse, but those people at least receive advances.
And with journal publishing, it's not some random niche. This is where "new knowledge" becomes validated. You're not hearing talking heads on television mentioning some new thing mentioned in a first year college textbook – instead you hear "a new study published in the New England Journal of Medicine."
Scholars need to and are adopting ways to take scholarly communication into their own hands. A sociology journal called Sociological Science, with an editorial board out of Stanford and Cornell has recently made a buzz by taking the process into their own hands: http://www.gsb.stanford.edu/news/headlines/group-sociologist...
(Full disclosure: this is a problem my startup works on)
At this point I'm left wondering:
1. Is the typeset version that much of a value add? Do people not realize how relatively easy it is to do these things on apart from publishing houses?
2. Is reading a single column version all that bad? We do it on the internet every day.
Many of the commenters here are replying with things like, "Dude, you don't understand the meaning of the term 'viable'." I can say that I've worked with plenty of developers who think of MVP as "the minimum amount of shit I need to build to ship this thing" rather than "this is the minimum that needs to be developed to make something that someone would be happy to use."
With all that said, I think changing the term to "Minimum Desirable Product" would be something that helps get everyone involved with a software product on the same page.
What can a small startup do to bring attention to our solution?
Apps like Scholastica (http://scholasticahq.com/) allow anyone to start their own peer reviewed journal and manage its content. Very soon, they'll even be able to publish open access (http://blog.scholasticahq.com/post/21917547765/open-access-p...). Full disclosure: I'm working on this application.
• Improve the scholarly publishing process for all involved by improving usability
• Eliminate the need to install software on your own server
• Automatic data backups to which also lessens the need for IT Staff
• Not focus solely on the sciences
• Give reviewers better incentives and public recognition for being good reviewers
• Create a global pool of reviewers across a variety of disciplines
• Give scholars a place regardless of discipline where they can share ideas
I encourage you to take the tour on our website (http://www.scholasticahq.com/tour) to see more of these differences for yourself.