HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

robot-wrangler

639 karma · joined September 10, 2025

submissionscomments
robot-wrangler··on A Theory of Deep Learning
> The Borges/Lavoisier stuff is a tell.

Nah, the softer stuff seems like valuable outreach / good science communication for people that aren't up for the math. Including probably lots of software engineers who are sick of dumb debates in forums, and starting to dip into the real literature and listen to better authorities. More people should do this really, since it's the only way to see past the marketing and hype from fully entrenched AI boosters or detractors. Neither of those groups is big on critical thinking, and they dominate most conversation.

Time/effort coming from experts who want to make things accessible is a gift! The paper is linked elsewhere in the thread if you want no-frills.

robot-wrangler··on Knitting bullshit
If there's anything more tragic than wealth without taste, it is technique without vision
robot-wrangler··on Google Chrome silently installs a 4 GB AI model on your device without consent
Can't observe the future, so learn from the past.. or use common sense. You don't react to a stranger or a mysterious camera in your household by saying, wow ok, let's see if anything bad happens.
robot-wrangler··on I'm scared about biological computing
> skeptical that the author has actually looked into the details.

Nevermind the experiment.. same deal for a lot of people who are only interested enough to offer opinions about consciousness and theory-of-mind without doing any of the boring background reading.

The bottom line in TFA is maybe just about unapologetic carbon-chauvinism. But although OP has "been in the AI space since ChatGPT first dropped" and "bothered by this for months", they don't seem aware of terms or the usual problems with this position. Your average non-technical scifi reader has a more nuanced take than AI bros puffing up blogs for linked-in traffic

robot-wrangler··on Google Chrome silently installs a 4 GB AI model on your device without consent
If someone puts a camera and a microphone on devices that don't need them, then it's a) pushing up the price of goods for everyone with features that mainly serve corporate, b) there are bad actors out there even if you think corporate is a good one, c) no reason to think corporate is a good actor.

Shipping an AI model with a browser is starting to look like sticking cameras on ALL glasses, not just smart glasses, regardless of whether anyone wants that. Saying this is fine and not unusual is clearly motivated reasoning and just normalizes the surveillance state. It's very obvious the way this ends. Browser-based models will eventually be using your computer at the edge to save corporate money in the cloud while they do ever more expensive and invasive stuff to profile you.

robot-wrangler··on Young sons of U.S. marshal ride horseback from Oklahoma to New York (2018)
> The boys’ father agreed to their cross-country ride and helped them plan the route. Abernathy postulated a few rules before they set out: They could not travel more than 50 miles in one day

I've done very long distance pack-horsing in wild places and these are indeed the big problems. There's this thing like the tyranny of the rocket equations.. a horse can't carry what it needs to drink, so you almost have to follow rivers or know exactly where they are and when you'll hit them. I came from long-distance cycling too where I would think nothing much of 100 miles on a good day even on trails, carrying food and water no problem. Not going to happen with horses on long solo trips without logistical support.. you can push limits for days without consequence but not for weeks

robot-wrangler··on Middle schooler finds coin from Troy in Berlin
Yeah the wild thing about the southwest is the open-air museum aspect of it, not the layers on layers. For petroglyphs, the southwest has so many that date to the high middles ages (~1100 AD) you can stumble on them by accident as a hiker. AFAIK the oldest in the area are still thought to be these ones[0], about 9000 years ago. (Always controversial to date rocks I guess, but the oldest North American mummy should be easier and is about the same.[1])

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Winnemucca_Lake [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spirit_Cave_mummy#Dating

robot-wrangler··on FSF trying to contact Google about spammer sending 10k+ mails from Gmail account
> How much customer support resources should someone reasonably expect

Zero. OTOH, since I'm sure they are training on emails and archiving/profiling everything forever even if we delete messages.. those constant threats to become a paying customer before hitting some arbitrary small quota are still villainous

robot-wrangler··on The local LLM ecosystem doesn’t need Ollama
Thanks, did not know any of this.
robot-wrangler··on The buns in McDonald's Japan's burger photos are all slightly askew
No idea why we're discussing burgers or the man, but pretty funny to learn the phrase goes back to freaking BCE
robot-wrangler··on The dangers of California's legislation to censor 3D printing
I'd guess the bring-back-DRM lobbyists are all automotive interests, whether it's OEM or the existing after-market people. Replacing mirror housings and stuff even for cheap cars has got to be one of the highest margin businesses out there, and lux cars? Insane
robot-wrangler··on The dangers of California's legislation to censor 3D printing
Quite a page. Featuring the work of ted k and a toy pop-gun that's un-toyed
robot-wrangler··on Picasso’s Guernica (Gigapixel)
I'm not a fan of AI "art" at all, but this particular attack does leave something to be desired.

Beyond aesthetic judgements of good/bad or intentional stance re: communication with others, there is such a thing as "process art" which could also be described as communication with oneself, or as kind of being locked into conversation with the medium, or with the universe. People will get distracted here and want to fight about whether Pollack is good, but I think that's missing the point. It just happens to be a very direct way of engaging with the dialectic tension of order / chaos that's incompressible, irreducible, and completely without substitute.. and that's just one of many dialectics you could explore.

Another self-communicative aspect of art is about exploring the limits and mastery of technique, where the details and result per se don't matter much. You can see this with a bunch of dorks building useless programming languages and doing amazing stuff with them, or see it with a smith at a forge. Someone will say this is about being a technician or a craftsman, but I'd say no, those activities typically have a practical purpose. Especially if you're doing this for the joy of it without even caring whether you're actively learning something you can apply elsewhere, then it's probably art.

robot-wrangler··on I wrote to Flock's privacy contact to opt out of their domestic spying program
> They were saying "don't write to us, talk to the people who own the cameras and ask them to delete the data".

The response to this should just be, "Yes, very well, please divulge a complete list of your customers, their contact information, and information about camera locations so I will be able to pursue this per instructions".

When that obviously doesn't work either then we can all agree the law as written is completely useless, and feel great about rewriting it in a way that's calculated for maximum damage to both the vendor and their customers, and collateral damage to the whole panopticon. Or, just spitballing here, we can just skip to the punchline here and do all that anyway

robot-wrangler··on The Future of Everything Is Lies, I Guess: Safety
> it has to be understandable in market terms

I like economics and math too, but the whole discussion of markets is a terrible starting place for deriving results in ethics/psychology. If you insist though, notice that unions will happen unless some other organization is working to prevent them. What do you suppose this means? People are aligned with each other exactly because they've noticed their coworkers are not corporations or governments.

Although the two are entangled, politics is a more relevant framing than economics here. If people weren't broadly aligned on basic stuff, then autocrats, theocrats, kleptocrats and so on would simply not be interested in dismantling democracies. They make that effort because they must.

robot-wrangler··on The Future of Everything Is Lies, I Guess: Safety
Couldn't read the next sentence before wading in, huh?
robot-wrangler··on The Future of Everything Is Lies, I Guess: Safety
You can tell that broad alignment between people is natural just by looking at the effort that corporations and governments make to undermine it. Alignment between people is perhaps not a state of nature, but it really is a pretty normal consequence of a fairly small amount of education and of middle-class existence that is left to itself (i.e. without brain-washing and deliberately working to create out-groups). If you're eating enough and have a few brain cells to rub together, then you definitely want that for your neighbors too because it promotes stability.
robot-wrangler··on Uncharted island soon to appear on nautical charts
Or something darker.. R'yleh where dead Cthulu lies dreaming is out there near Point Nemo too ;)
robot-wrangler··on Should capitalism be a choice?
The premise is something I think about too. Image someone who has interests and expectations that are naturally in line with a completely ascetic lifestyle, where they do not aim to collect wealth, are prepared to own nothing, to have no children / dependents, and basically just to live a simple life of service. What viable options are there today for even that saint-like person to opt out?

Historically you could join the military and maybe actually participate in something like exploration instead of murder. You could dedicate your life to the academy / ivory tower even as a normal person, just a quiet life dedicated to study, without being one of the top minds in a crowded competitive publish/perish scene that's just another version of the attention economy. Or maybe you could just fuck off to be a shepherd, or maybe join a monastery even as a non-believer because I bet they'd let you work in a garden or something.

People in the US today who plan to become cops/teachers/firemen/nurses/clerics will effectively have to be prepared to own nothing, save nothing, have difficulty supporting a family, etc.. and before all that austerity they still must play this ugly little game of permission and predation with loans every step of the way.

robot-wrangler··on Show HN: Pardonned.com – A searchable database of US Pardons
https://apnews.com/article/us-capitol-attack-14c73ee280c256a...
robot-wrangler··on How We Broke Top AI Agent Benchmarks: And What Comes Next
> evaluation was not designed to resist a system that optimizes for the score rather than the task.

Welcome to benchmarks in general, but especially reasoning. Robustness and sensitivity research says nothing is robust, everything is sensitive, feels like every paper says "yeah we made a new benchmark that shuffles the order of multiple choice options in the question set and found a 40% drop in model performance"

robot-wrangler··on Show HN: Pardonned.com – A searchable database of US Pardons
> main charge in the case was overstatement of real estate values to secure loans > The banks not only did not lose money from the transactions but in fact happily made money, and they had no complaint about the deals

The first part is either a crime, or it is not, regardless of the second? Suppose I falsely say I am worth millions, and then actually win the lottery. It being true later doesn't change whether it was lie originally.

robot-wrangler··on Top laptops to use with FreeBSD
I'm sure it will be a great comfort to the last person left who knows what a jail is
robot-wrangler··on I still prefer MCP over skills
> clearly don't understand either deeply

No appetite for that. The MCP vs Skills debate has gradually become just a proxy war for the camps of AI skeptics vs AI boosters. Both sides view it as another chance to decide about more magic vs less, in absolute terms, without doing the work of thinking about anything situational. Nuance, questions, reasoning from first principles, focusing on purely engineering considerations is simply not welcome. The extreme factions do tend to agree that it might be a good idea to attack the middle though! There's no changing this stuff, so when it becomes tiresome it's time to just leave the HN comment section.

robot-wrangler··on Tree Calculus
My friend this ain't memes or celebrity news, it's theoretical computer science. You'll get out of it roughly what you're ready to put into it. If you're short on time, the grammar is like 5 characters and the proof of the halting problem isn't much bigger. If you don't already know why that is interesting though you really might have to read a bit to find out
robot-wrangler··on Top laptops to use with FreeBSD
Wow, searched this thread for docker hoping to realize I was behind the times and thinking surely it must work by now. It's so crazy that the BSDs have a reputation for stable, implying sysadmins and servers, then it won't support the one thing that every server needs. VMs running linux is the preferred path of least resistance then? Honestly you'd have to work hard to find a better way to alienate your target audience.
robot-wrangler··on Tree Calculus
https://github.com/barry-jay-personal/tree-calculus/blob/mas...
robot-wrangler··on Just 'English with Hanzi'
> I think most of the claims about grammar are false.

This part about "forced the English plural We [..] injecting mandatory number-specificity where context once sufficed" really struck me. Sounds cool for poetry to be ambiguous about this, but really now, how is an advanced society handling the practical matters of writing contracts and keeping records without it

robot-wrangler··on The threat is comfortable drift toward not understanding what you're doing
Another threat is that you can find tons of papers pointing out how neural AI still struggles handling simple logical negation. Who cares right, we use tools for symbolics, yada yada. Except what's really the plan? Are we going to attempt parallel formalized representations of every piece of input context just to flag the difference between please DONT delete my files and please DO? This is all super boring though and nothing bad happened lately, so back to perusing latest AGI benchmarks..
robot-wrangler··on Google's 200M-parameter time-series foundation model with 16k context
Maybe because useful time-series modeling is usually really about causal modeling? My understanding is that mediated causality in particular is still very difficult, where adding extra hops in the middle takes CoT performance from like 90% to 10%.
← PreviousPage 2 of 8Next →