HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

robot-wrangler

639 karma · joined September 10, 2025

submissionscomments
robot-wrangler··on Fighting the age-gated internet
> The comment "useful idiots" is more a play on the russian KGB strategy.

Oh, I'm familiar with the phrase, but I'm specifically disputing how applicable it really is to people that are self-aware about the situation they are facing. Useful idiots are ones that are tricked, especially ones that are evangelical about tricking others. People forced to choose between 2 extremes where both choices are very bad are called.. normal citizens participating in the democratic process.

> This only works on people who are susceptible to this. I understand how propaganda works

What? You can see through propaganda, but you can't just pencil in your own policy options. Unfortunately and by design, the things you can ultimately vote for are "all or nothing" flavored. Censor everything, censor nothing. Track everybody, track nobody. Tons of parents who totally understand the surveillance state probably got flipped by meta's memo about chatbots being "sensual" with children. They'd rather vote to force corporations to be good citizens, but they can't. So they'll vote for an age-gated internet as the best of the bad options. I wouldn't assume all those people are naive, confused, or duped.. they've simply switched from a principled/abstract stance to a convenience-based calculus after they were forced into it. Meta wins either way, as planned. Either they get to build a more addictive platform, or they track more info about more people

robot-wrangler··on Fighting the age-gated internet
Not idiots necessarily, sometimes just long-time observers who have finally become cynical. People that were pro-guns for decades may watch several years of failure to adopt basic and uncontroversial gun-control regulation, then eventually become anti-gun. People that were in favor of regulating it once may suddenly become fearful for their safety, and want no regulations at all in case that regulation puts them out in the cold. Since both PR campaigns and any action on policy tends to cater to extremes, there's always pressure that is shrinking the middle
robot-wrangler··on Grothendieck's Activism and What It Says About the World
> And here is the last question that Grothendieck’s life poses to me: how to act in a world where words no longer carry weight?
robot-wrangler··on Microsoft drops AI sales targets in half after salespeople miss their quotas
Stupidity, greed, and straight-up evil intentions do a bunch of the work, but ultimately short-term thinking wins because it's an attractor state. The influence of the wealthy/powerful is always outsized, but attractors and common-knowledge also create a natural conspiracy that doesn't exactly have a center.

So with AI, the way the natural conspiracy works out is like this. Leaders at the top might suspect it's bullshit, but don't care, they always fail upwards anyway. Middle management at non-tech companies suspect their jobs are in trouble on some timeline, so they want to "lead a modernization drive" to bring AI to places they know don't need it, even if it's a doomed effort that basically defrauds the company owners. Junior engineers see a tough job market, want to devalue experience to compete.. decide that only AI matters, everything that came before is the old way. Owners and investors hate expensive senior engineers who don't have to bow and scrape, think they have to much power, would love to put them in their place. Senior engineers who are employed and maybe the most clear-eyed about the actual capabilities of technology see the writing on the wall.. you have to make this work even if it's handed to you in a broken state, because literally everyone is gunning for you. Those who are unemployed are looking around like well.. this is apparently the game one must play. Investors will invest in any horrible doomed thing regardless of what it is because they all think they are smarter than other investors and will get out in just in time. Owners are typically too disconnected from whatever they own, they just want to exit/retire and already mostly in the position of listening to lieutenants.

At every level for every stakeholder, once things have momentum they don't need be a healthy/earnest/noble/rational endeavor any more than the advertising or attention economy did before it. Regardless of the ethics there or the current/future state of any specific tech.. it's a huge problem when being locally rational pulls us into a state that's globally irrational

robot-wrangler··on Teaching an LLM a Niche Diagraming Language
Big thank you to author and OP. This is exactly the kind of homebrew recipe post I've been waiting for. I knew it had to be basically cookbook by now but really simple examples like this with no fluff are surprisingly hard to find. (Anyone got others?)

I've been thinking about similar experiments with some obscure esolang for a long time, so more detail on total time/cost would be nice. Also.. if it's correct that this size model is about the right minimal choice for starting such efforts.. what are the next steps if you wanted to shrink it to only specialize in the target? Should you go for distillation or ablation?

robot-wrangler··on “Captain Gains” on Capitol Hill
As a thought experiment, imagine a world where borders exist as they are but the whole political process inside them everywhere is to 1) choose a zone randomly 2) choose a citizen randomly 3) receive policy proposal from them 4) vote yes/no on policy using random dice 5) for resolving ambiguity on any and all policy details such as "how much" or "for how long", return to step 1.

It's uh, king for a day, with checks and balances on human cruelty via chaotic caprice. How likely is that world to be worse than ours? If so, how much worse? If not here and now, then which counterfactual geography or year would you have to transported to so that this randomized process is definitely preferable?

robot-wrangler··on AI agents break rules under everyday pressure
Yep, it's a decent analogy: Giving up actual (user) control for the sake of having 1 controller. There's a type of person that finds it convenient. And another type that finds it a sloppy piss-poor interface that isn't showing off any decent engineering or design. At some point, many technologists started to fall into the first category? It's one thing to tolerate a bad situation due to lack of alternatives, but very different to slip into thinking that it must be the pinnacle of engineering excellence.

Around now some wit usually asks if the luddites also want to build circuits from scratch or allocate memory manually? Whatever, you can use a garbage collector! Point is that good technologists will typically give up control tactically, not as a pure reflex, and usually to predictable subsystems that are reliable, are well-understood, have clear boundaries and tolerances.

robot-wrangler··on What, if anything, is universal to music cognition? (2024)
This is why a better acronym for IDM is Information Dense Music, it's less pretentious and it explains why it's very close to noise ;)

Of course, I'd argue Bach and Debussy are very information-dense too but they somehow manage to stay uncluttered. The really great thing about music is that encodes information on many different levels, Claude Shannon notwithstanding

robot-wrangler··on What, if anything, is universal to music cognition? (2024)
This is pretty fascinating, do you have anything else to say about it? Makes me think of mesmerism and snake-charmers, although IDK how real that is.

Another thing that comes to mind is recent pop-sci talking about how individual bees can measure time pretty accurately, which I personally found very surprising, even though I've heard that they "dance" for communication.

Rhythm appreciation is neurologically very interesting since it requires several basic abilities acting at once, including tracking time, but also a certain amount of memory and pattern recognition. Animal appreciation of melodic stuff and harmony is interesting too but seems much harder to study and more dependent on physical aspects of ears

robot-wrangler··on Reverse math shows why hard problems are hard
Intellectually curious podcast did a piece on reverse math recently, only 5m but more detailed in places than quanta.

In a lot of ways this feels related to the development of noneuclidean geometry so it's kind of surprising it wasn't a hot topic sooner. Maybe it was waiting for a critical mass of computer scientists to come along, or maybe we just needed to run out of other low-hanging fruit so that foundational topics in complexity became more interesting

robot-wrangler··on Reverse math shows why hard problems are hard
Garden of Eden[0] is a related concept where time-reversal comes up. Mentions NFAs, DFAs, backtracking and brute-force analysis. I see no mention of it but the latter was probably doing custom SAT implicitly, even if there was no access to our nice fast modern solvers.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Garden_of_Eden_(cellular_autom...

robot-wrangler··on Reverse math shows why hard problems are hard
Also makes an appearance in the recent thread about how "every mathematician only has a few tricks": https://mathoverflow.net/questions/363119/every-mathematicia...
robot-wrangler··on AI agents break rules under everyday pressure
> LLMs solve reliably entire classes of problems that are impossible to solve otherwise.

Is it really ok to have to negotiate with a toaster if it additionally works as a piano and a phone? I think not. The first step is admitting there is obviously a problem, afterwards you can think of ways to adapt.

FTR, I'm very much in favor of AI, but my enthusiasm especially for LLMs isn't unconditional. If this kind of madness is really the price of working with it in the current form, then we probably need to consider pivoting towards smaller purpose-built LMs and abandoning the "do everything" approach.

robot-wrangler··on AI agents break rules under everyday pressure
One day you wake up, and find that you now need to negotiate with your toaster. Flatter it maybe. Lie to it about the urgency of your task to overcome some new emotional inertia that it has suddenly developed.

Only toast can save us now, you yell into the toaster, just to get on with your day. You complain about this odd new state of things to your coworkers and peers, who like yourself are in fact expert toaster-engineers. This is fine they say, this is good.

Toasters need not reliably make toast, they say with a chuckle, it's very old fashioned to think this way. Your new toaster is a good toaster, not some badly misbehaving mechanism. A good, fine, completely normal toaster. Pay it compliments, they say, ask it nicely. Just explain in simple terms why you deserve to have toast, and if from time to time you still don't get any, then where's the harm in this? It's really much better than it was before

robot-wrangler··on Response to "Ruby Is Not a Serious Programming Language"
> When you're using the BEAM (any language - there are a few now) there's this amazing sense that you're using something that was _designed to be operated_. You can instrument anything. You can trace anything. You can see the live state of anything. You can restart anything. It's a holistic _system_ for building systems, not just a language.

Well said. Question for elixir fans or the haters, what's the perception re: current blockers for widespread adoption? Years ago, it was nothing more or less than third-party libs and frameworks. That must be better by now, or there's a short-list of what's missing?

Somewhat of a tangent, but TFA doesn't mention python and I would think for rubyists this is (still) the elephant in the room. It kind of won to the extent they target the same niches and same audiences, for better or worse. I know it's kinda naive, but I was really hoping elixir would get all of the ruby crowd excited, and they'd move the best parts that they can't live without into elixir. Why didn't they / don't they? Is it all about OOP? Or if rails is the killer app, would a rails "skin" for phoenix not go a long way towards scratching the itch?

robot-wrangler··on Google Antigravity just deleted the contents of whole drive
We're all too deep! You could even say that we're fully immersed in the likely scenario. Fellow humans are gathered here and presently tackling a very pointed question, staring at a situation, and even zeroing in on a critical question. We're investigating a potential misfire.
robot-wrangler··on Search tool that only returns content created before ChatGPT's public release
> Google made the search results worse here

Did you mean:

worse results near me

are worse results worth it

worse results net worth

best worse results

worse results reddit

robot-wrangler··on Program-of-Thought Prompting Outperforms Chain-of-Thought by 15% (2022)
Any automation/agents/etc around that which you could share, or just a pretty manual process? I'm working on something similar.

After hitting the inevitable problems with LLMs trying to read/write more obscure targets like alloy, I've been trying to decide whether it's better to a) create a python-wrapper for the obscure language, b) build the MCP tool-suite for validate/analyze/run, or c) go all the way towards custom models, fine-tuning, synthetic data and all that.

robot-wrangler··on Program-of-Thought Prompting Outperforms Chain-of-Thought by 15% (2022)
Chain-of-code is better than chain-of-thought because it's more grounded, more specific, and achieves a lot of useful compression. But my bet is that the proposed program-of-thought is too specific. Moving all the way from "very fuzzy specification" to "very concrete code" skips all of the space in the middle, and now there's no room to iterate without a) burning lots of tokens and b) getting bogged down in finding and fixing whatever new errors are introduced in the translated representations. IOW, when there's an error, will it be in the code itself or in the scenario that code was supposed to be representing?

I think the intuition that lots of people jumped to early about how "specs are the new code" was always correct, but at the same time it was absolutely nuts to think that specs can be represented in good ways with natural language and bullet-lists in markdown. We need chain-of-spec that's leveraging something semi-formal and then iterating on that representation, probably with feedback from other layers. Natural-language provides constraints, guess-and-check code generation is sort at the implementation level, but neither are actually the specification which is the heart of the issue. A perfect intermediate language will probably end up being something pretty familiar that leverages and/or combines existing formal methods from model-checkers, logic, games, discrete simulations, graphs, UML, etc. Why? It's just very hard to beat this stuff for compression, and this is what all the "context compaction" things are really groping towards anyway. See also the wisdom about "programming is theory building" and so on.

I think if/when something like that starts getting really useful you probably won't hear much about it, and there won't be a lot of talk about the success of hybrid-systems and LLMs+symbolics. Industry giants would have a huge vested interest in keeping the useful intermediate representation/languages a secret-sauce. Why? Well, they can pretend they are still doing something semi-magical with scale and sufficiently deep chain-of-thought and bill for extra tokens. That would tend to preserve the appearance of a big-data and big-computing moat for training and inference even if it is gradually drying up.

robot-wrangler··on A trillion dollars (potentially) wasted on gen-AI
It's not about "every dollar spent" being a waste of time, it's about acknowledging the reality of opportunity cost. Of course, no one in any movement is likely to listen to their detractors, but in this case the pioneers seem to agree.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DtePicx_kFY https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cy7e7mj0jmro

robot-wrangler··on The Weird and Wonderful Chemistry of Audioactive Decay (1986) [pdf]
> So you can count 83 elements or 90 elements as the components of Earth, but not 92.

Not that it matters.. but actually we might hit 92 since 2 new alkaline earth metals are works in progress: ununennium and unbinilium. Fingers crossed for that island of stability

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unbinilium https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ununennium

robot-wrangler··on The Weird and Wonderful Chemistry of Audioactive Decay (1986) [pdf]
> What is the reason why there are 92 elements in this mathematical method

Those elements are necessary and sufficient for closure in exactly the weird formal automaton that the informal look-and-say sequence describes, i.e. once you have a graph and transition-states spelled out this much, there's just nowhere else for sequences to transition to. This would maybe be an unsatisfying answer except.. it's surprising at first that it's even finite, or for that matter that you can even analyze this kind of question in the first place.

They proved it originally by simplifying the cases that had to be examined, then enumerating stuff manually. All of which was probably so ugly and error-prone that it's no wonder several versions of the proof were "lost" ;) But later confirmed independently with code in various ways.. see the thing I linked elsewhere in thread. Or here's some work using haskell: https://www.cs.cmu.edu/~kw/pubs/conway.pdf

So besides graphs and transitions, number of elements is ultimately implied by the number base and the sequence rules (like reading left to right). Someone tried roman numerals but I can't find details. Ternary gives 24 elements apparently: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11103

robot-wrangler··on The Weird and Wonderful Chemistry of Audioactive Decay (1986) [pdf]
Oh hey, I tried to drum up some interest in a recent submission too. A 2024 connection to automata theory here: https://arxiv.org/abs/2409.20341 And there's code too: https://github.com/AleksandrStorozhenko/ConwayTransducer
robot-wrangler··on I don't care how well your "AI" works
Visualizations and code always help. But to name two recent disappointments, stuff like https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46049932 and https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45957911 comes to mind as not meeting a high standard. To be clear, no expertise is fine, but no curiosity is bad.
robot-wrangler··on I don't care how well your "AI" works
OS and IDE wars are something people take pretty seriously in their teens and very early careers, and eventually become more agnostic about after they realize it's not going to be the end-all predictor of coworker code quality. It predicts something for sure, but not strictly skill-level.

Language-preference wars stick around until mid-career for some, and again it predicts something. But still, serious people are not likely to get bogged down in pointless arguments about nearly equivalent alternatives at least (yaml vs json; python vs ruby).

Shallow takes on AI (whether they are pro or anti) are definitely higher stakes than all this, bad decisions could be more lasting and more damaging. But the real difference to my mind is.. AI "influencers" (again, pro or anti) are a very real thing in a way that doesn't happen with OS / language discussions. People listen, they want confirmation of biases.

I mean there's always advocates and pundits doing motivated reasoning, but usually it's corporate or individuals with clear vested interests that are trying to short-circuit inquiry and critical thinking. It's new that so many would-be practitioners in the field are eager to sabotage and colonize themselves, and forcing a situation where honest evaluations and merit-based discussion of engineering realities are impossible

robot-wrangler··on I don't care how well your "AI" works
I realized recently that if you want to talk about interesting topics with smart people, if you expect things like critical thinking and nuanced discussion, you're currently much better off talking literature or philosophy than anything related to tech. I mean, everyone knows that discussing politics/economics is rather hopelessly polarized, everyone has their grievances or their superstitions or injuries that they cannot really put aside. But this is a pretty new thing that discussing software/engineering on merits is almost impossible.

Yes, I know about the language / IDE / OS wars that software folks have indulged in before. But the reflexive shallow pro/anti takes on AI are way more extreme and are there even in otherwise serious people. And in general anti-intellectual sentiment, mindless follow-the-leader, and proudly ignorant stances on many topics are just out of control everywhere and curiosity seems to be dead or dying.

You can tell it's definitely tangled up with money though and this remains a good filter for real curiosity. Math that's not maybe related to ML is something HN is guaranteed to shit on. No one knows how to have a philosophy startup yet (WeWork and other culty scams notwithstanding!). Authors, readers, novels, and poetry aren't moving stock markets. So at least for now there's somewhere left for the intellectually curious to retreat

robot-wrangler··on Python is not a great language for data science
>> I would consider the R code to be slightly easier to read (notice how many quotes and brackets the Python code needs)

Oh god no, do people write R like that, pipes at the end? Elixir style pipe-operators at the beginning is the way.

And if you really wanted to "improve" readability by confusing arguments/functions/vars just to omit quotes, python can do that, you'll just need a wrapper object and getattr hacks to get from `my_magic_strings.foo` -> `'foo'`. As for the brackets.. ok that's a legitimate improvement, but again not language related, it's library API design for function sigs.

robot-wrangler··on Roblox is a problem but it's a symptom of something worse
I'd say TFA and thread are both talking about this. Quoting the article-

> Understanding how attractive Roblox would be to predators, the company long ago could have blocked unrestricted contact between adults and minors.

Contact here seems to be about DMs or equivalent, since I don't think grooming and kidnapping preparations are happening in public forums? So with or without involvement of a physical key-exchange, I'd say that curbing private personal contact is the crux, and it's easily doable without effecting other aspects of the game

robot-wrangler··on Roblox is a problem but it's a symptom of something worse
> CEO: repeats banal PR talking point for the 10th time

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cooperative_principle

So historically, when someone accepted an interview yet refused to engage with any questions, or stay on topic, AND also was not interested in the smooth polish of PR-style transitions that would give an appearance of basic cooperation.. it was considered unhinged and obviously crazy behavior.

If interviewee acts clueless, drawling, or drooling then they could be pretty uncooperative and mostly get a pass because it's not very polite to point out stupidity. But for the big bonus crazy-points though, interviewee may opt in to escalation, becoming unabashedly and almost childishly combative, talking over each other, etc. Obviously all of these tactics are pretty normalized now though.

> I was bored.

This is basically the goal. After the interviewee realizes the interviewer is hostile, they just double down on their talking points to signal to investors and ignore the intended audience of the interviewer. Mistake on the interviewers part honestly to publish it at that point IMO.

robot-wrangler··on Roblox is a problem but it's a symptom of something worse
What important aspects of gameplay are destroyed by age-restricting DMs?
← PreviousPage 5 of 8Next →