HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

rocketflumes

42 karma · joined July 22, 2018

submissionscomments
rocketflumes··on South Korea to give $490 allowance to reclusive youths to help them leave house
I love this idea in principle, but when our school ran something similar to connect grad students who didn't have the opportunity to socialize due to covid remote work, I got a feeling some of them just showed up for the free coffee (we did free coffee chats instead of meals) and just weren't that interested in the social aspect.
rocketflumes··on Basics of Concrete Barriers (2000)
saw a fascinating video on this topic awhile ago:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w6CKltZfToY

rocketflumes··on In defense of flat earthers (2020)
This series on YouTube has some fairly easy arguments on the Earth being a sphere w/o using any math:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_bHqBy92iGM

rocketflumes··on Open Problems in Robotics
I think OP meant "teleoperation" - controlling a robot from afar
rocketflumes··on Please Pay for Your News
On the issue of bias - I'm not confident that paid news is necessarily less biased than news that relies on clicks and ads. Two potential issues:

1) A news agency might be further incentived to publish biased, "echo-chamber" type of news if they are more effective at convincing readers to pay.

2) Detailed news with in-depth research and thorough analysis is expensive to produce, so news agencies that produce such material, if they were to rely on subscriptions, need to charge appropriately expensive fees. This means only a select group of people can afford this news. To generate more revenue, such a quality news sources are incentived to cater content to this limited audience set. Over time this can make quality news inaccessible and even irrelevant to most of the public.

rocketflumes··on We're Incentivizing Bad Science
I can't comment on China and other fields, but in the US for AI and robotics, in which I do research / publish in, there is definitely a growing trend of an over-emphasis on novelty research that disregards reproducibility in favor of "wow" factors and fancy demo videos. A lot of highly cited research papers/labs tend to be the most heavily promoted ones (on Twitter, in the press, etc), and they're not necessarily impactful/useful for the rest of the field.
rocketflumes··on U.S. senators want social media users to be able to take their data with them
won't big players like FB benefit from this? It seems more likely that people would port data from smaller networks to bigger ones than the other way around.
rocketflumes··on Congress votes to make open government data the default in the United States
data.gov is great but it seems like the most recent activities/updates were prior to 2016...
rocketflumes··on No Phd, No Problem: New Schemes Teach the Masses to Build AI
A PhD is not only about solving some specific problem. It is more about learning how to solve problems, and more importantly, choosing what problems to solve.

Having a PhD should mean that the person is capable of making consistent progress in ill-defined problems without much external support. Of course not all PhDs can do this, and you don't need a PhD to gain these skills, but they correlate strongly enough that it makes sense to just filter some jobs by whether or not someone has a PhD.

rocketflumes··on How China Systematically Pries Technology from U.S. Companies
I understand that the scope and scale of the technology transfer agreements may be unreasonable, but surely these foreign companies aren't "forced" to oblige? I'm not sure if it's on China that many companies find it more profitable to have access to the Chinese market than to hold on to their IPs.
rocketflumes··on An Introduction to Mathematical Optimal Control Theory [pdf]
for more on that subject - check out this recent RL and OCT survey by Ben Recht, also from UC Berkeley: https://arxiv.org/abs/1806.09460