2,750 karma · joined February 2, 2011
This is what over-the-air TV program looks like these days. What percentage of its broadcast time consists of quality TV shows? (Don't forget to factor in all the ads.) How much of it would you watch, honestly?
Right now, we have unparalleled levels of global surveillance and media centralization plays a key role in it.
In the past TV channels and publishers competed with one another. Right now every large website is an unchallenged emperor of its niche. The emperor dies and we get a new one, but it's hardly a free market system.
Finally, there are phenomena like Twitter/Reddit hate mobs. The principle is not entirely new, but the scale, pettiness and randomness are unparalleled.
What does require some explanation in the order of events. At some point television had decent TV programs. People still stream and torrent them. They are classics. Than the overall quality declined. Only then cable sort of "stepped in", became more prominent and got good content. (In the process, however, news programs became what they are right now.)
Interestingly, the shift to streaming is quite different.
Also, centralization is objectively there. Google, Twitter, Facebook. It was obvious where this was going years ago, but instead of warning us, technologist sung odes to Web 2.0. Great. Now, Web 3.0 is shitty phone apps.
it also smacks of elitism when you complain endlessly about what the masses want
When you don't complain about things simply because masses want them it's groupthink.
This isn't censorship of the type that is illegal or not allowed.
Neither is posting something offensive. Have you thought about that? Yes, GitHub owns the servers. If you haven't notices already, someone owns every single piece of the Internet.
people are choosing to die on some pretty ridiculous hills.
If you just ignore it, censorship and selective enforcement becomes a socially acceptable practice through sheer repetition and groupthink.
Anecdotally, most desktops I used lived much longer than most servers I worked woth. I know a Compaq desktop that worked as a server for 11 years. Still does. One hardware failure in that entire time. (Power supply.) Could be a result of lower workload, but still...
What you describe is a hack for lacking isolation/security/permissions/package management in the operating system. Seriously, if there was a sensible way of isolating apps and handling dependencies, it would be perfectly sensible to implement a lot of the current web "apps" as real applications.
Not to mention that the web sets its own expectations. If everyone uses stupid modal popups, your clients will expect you to use stupid modal popups.
The problem with making everything subscription-based is that it changes the dynamic of the website. A lot.
An interesting experiment would be to allow people to pay not just for themselves, but for a few others as well. I.e. you've seen something good, you pay to get rid of ads for that item and it removes ads for N other people as well. Sure, there will be free-riders. That's the point. I postulate that those free-riders would be the people would otherwise not use the platform at all.
Attribution. Mechanical attacks are easier to attribute than something that can be done from across the world over the Internet.
"Yeah it sucks, but it is what it is."
This attitude might work with some other things, but the automotive industry will have to deal with security in a reasonable fashion. This is potentially life-and-death stuff and consumers actually have choice here. Not everyone understands the full implication of someone tracking their cellphone or hacking their email, but everyone can imagine what will happen if your car will get out of your control.
There is little genuine need to send commands from low-importance networks to high-importance networks. Yes, you would have to live without single uber-control touchscreen, but it's not really that big of a limitation: you simply need separate controls for low-importance and high-importance things.
"Are we sure what is being simulated here is cognitive? It seems to me merely mechanical."
This is analogous to asking "are you sure this is done by humans rather than animals?" The question makes sense and is valid. To answer it with "humans are merely animals" would not address the subject at hand and, again, would have specific connotations.
I see that this kind of semantic acrobatics is extremely common in discussions of AI on HN.
Funny, but that blog had a "pitch" for Twitting toilet somewhere as well. It seems Microsoft combined both jokes into a single real-life product.
Human language is not based on set theory. There is a huge difference in connotations here.
In other words, we will start thinking about people as if they are mere things. Complex things, but things nevertheless.
It matters a lot. Typically, there is a gateway (in body or chassis controller) between the two (or three) buses. It puts some messages from the controller bus onto infotainment bus, but not the other way around. It's done specifically to prevent infotainment systems interfering with workings of the car.
If Jeep has everything running on the same bus, it's incredibly stupid.
The noteworthy part of this is being able to bridge the gap between the two CAN networks, and it's not explained in any way.
Does Jeep Cherokee have separate buses for high-speed controller and low-speed infotainment CAN? (That's the usual setup.) What controller acts as the gateway between them? Is it read-write (which would be incredibly dumb) or did they actually hack that controller after hacking infotainment?
I had shown similar articles/research papers to my friends working in automotive. They pointed out several factual mistakes and said it's generic fluff with no meaningful technical details. (See the questions above.)
If realistically exploitable, these vulnerabilities are serious stuff. Hackers/journalists need to get their shit together and communicate these findings in an appropriate way. 99.9% of automotive engineers do not go to Black Hat conference.
Problem is, most automotive engineers are clueless about security and most "hackers" are clueless about automotive hardware, software and protocols. There is no dialog.
I wish articles like these posted at least some specifics. A lot of these hacks in the past were completely impractical. Yes, yes, they had shown some interesting possibilities, but it was disingenuous to present them as real-life attacks (which many media outlets did).